50 Best Caterers near Garden City

“My first time here. I had the honey turkey and mozzarella on a ciabatta! Great service and food tasted fresh and tasty. It’s a very big deli with tons of options. Inside was a salad bar, panini and wrap station, breakfast area and lunch buffet. I took off a star because The only issue it’s pricey. But the sandwich didn’t disappoint.“

“The Best venue to have a Wedding! I was married here 14 years ago. I also have been DJing events here for over 25 years. I highly recommend Jericho Terrace for any event. Thank you !“

“Thank you for catering my first holiday meal in GN. Everything was delicious. Turkey was juicy and succulent and went great with the couscous and sausage stuffing with plums. I used the liquid you gave to make it even more moist and have already made blintzes and salad and turkey fried rice with the rest.“

“😍THEY HAVE BEEN A LEADER IN CATERING SERVICES, SINCE LONG BEFORE I FIRST ATTENDED A FUNCTION, AS A TEEN, IN THE 1960'S! STILL WONDERFUL AS OF THE AFFAIR I ATTENDED, THIS PAST SUNDAY, APRIL 13, 2025!“

“Gino was patient and took the time to explain to us all the different packages, in preparation for our wedding. After learning that my fiancé and I are both first responders, Gino extended his support and professionalism to us even more so! We are both looking forward to having him cater the dessert portion of our wedding, in addition to creating an unforgettable experience! Dolce and Gelato is the way to go!! Bravissimi!“

“Marylyn and Juste Hors D'oeuvres recently catered our wedding. From the first contact right to the end of the wedding, Marylyn and her team were wonderful. Marylyn helped us with every detail of the wedding. Rentals, bartenders, staff, flowers... That was such a big help to have one point of contact. And the food...AMAZING!!! The guests raved about everything. My father said that it was the most tender filet mignon he ever had. And, my dad is the steak guy! We cannot thank the staff enough, especially Chef Manny, for their attentive, gracious service to us all. If you are looking for a caterer that delivers 100% every time, you cannot do better than Juste Hors D'Oeuvres!!!“

“I went there for my cousin’s wedding. Beautiful venue. Very spacious and on the lake. Very scenic. The food was delicious. The staff was great and friendly.“

“Great experience food was delicious, staff were friendly. wife was happy 😊 *****“

“We’ve eaten here twice now and both times the service is good. Not to mention I’ve had my share of Chicken Tikka Masala and this spot and swing with the best of em!

If you’re lucky enough to live in the area I would suggest you give Maya a shot.“

“THE Royalton Mansion-- If I could rate them 10 stars I would! The best kept secret on Long Island. The most beautiful venue with such a care for detail with the best bang for your buck with pricing. From the day we had our first meeting with the Royalton they have been fantastic and after my Husband and I walked in the first time we knew it was where we were supposed to be married. Mike T and his entire staff were perfect. Their attention to detail is unmatched. Mike T told me we didn’t need a wedding planner or coordinator with them and he was right. He took his role above and beyond! Every question and pre-wedding concern I had was answered quickly and ever worry I had they calmed my fear. The food was amazing and every aspect of the menu completely customizable. We had so many dietary restrictions and Mike was able to accommodate everyone without any issues. The grounds are beautiful both inside and outside. We planned for our ceremony to be in their beautiful garden but unfortunately mother nature had other plans and the move to inside was still as beautiful. Our family and friends are still raving about how beautiful it was, how amazing the food was and how the staff were phenomenal. Michelle, the bridal attendant was also phenomenal and helped the day run so smoothly! We had an unfortunate incident thar required a guest to be removed from the wedding. The professionalism and approach that Mike T took to handle the situation was perfect to the point that I had no idea of the circumstance and to those involved were blown away on how well it was handled by himself and staff and to ensure all our guests were safe as well. I can not recommend The Royalton enough.“

“we had the absolute best time for our daughters communion. everything was absolutely gorgeous. the food was authentic.. the staff was professional and we can't stop raving on how good of a time we all had! thank you for an unforgettable party!! ❤️“

“Great Food! We are members of the Lakeville Estates Civic Association and we just had our Holiday Party this past Wednesday, which was catered by Tulip Caterers. We have to say that the Hero Sandwiches - all three choices (Italian, American and Vegetarian) were absolutely delicious! We would definitely recommend Tulip Caterers to anyone planing an event or party! Cindy and Jack Benigno“

“I catered two parties recently. One was Italian and the other was a fajita station. Both orders were delicious and plentiful. The orders were on time, hot and fresh. It was a pleasant experience from start to finish. I will definitely be using you in the future. Thank you“

“the BEST the BESTTTT chicken & waffles I have ever had! vegan or not! You can tell these ladies put love in every dish they create & I am here for it 🙌 I look forward to trying something new on their unique menu everytime 🤤 in other words, highly recommend 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“We certainly picked the right caterer for our backyard wedding. From the beginning of planning the menu to the event everything was perfect. Danielle was amazing to work with planning the menu to suit our budget. Making adjustments as needed. Joe and Danielle came out the week before to view the site and give advice on how to set things up. The day of the event they were amazing. Came in took charge and handled everything so I could enjoy the day. The food and staff were amazing. I got complements on everything!!!! The event was everything we imagined and more!“

“The food was delicious as always. The wait staff was attentive and efficient with attention to guests needs and desires.“

“Not just southern did a wonderful job for the catering for my business’s fifth anniversary party. Annie was so such pleasure walking me through the whole catering process answered any questions I had with no hesitation was accommodating in any changes or request needed. The food was a hit and everyone enjoyed all the food. Will definitely book for any future events“

“excellent food service and prices can't be beat“

“The most amazing Pretzel Shop ever!!!! The pretzels are so fresh and beyond delicious. All the dips are great, huge fans of the Cinnamon & Pickle Dips!!! Love the owner and all her employees!!!!“

“great food, clean and great service“

“Great bagels and coffee“

“A great neighborhood deli!! Food and catering are delicious! Definitely recommend.“

“Rich catered a party for us that had many food critics in attendance. Everyone was in love with the food so we all had seconds and thirds. Delicious top quality food at very reasonable prices. Definitely can't forget to mention the server that rich sent. Concetta was wonderful, she was like part of the family by the end of the party. We couldn't have asked for a better experience. thank you!!“

“Mary, Kenny and Michael are the best!! They made our son’s Bar Mitzvah such a memorable evening and the time of our lives! They went above and beyond to make sure every detail was perfect which led to an incredible and seamless evening. We, along with our guests, were blown away by the atmosphere, quality of food and the attentive nature of the entire staff. We couldn’t we be happier that we chose Temple Avodah and Kombert to celebrate this special milestone. There’s truly no other place like it!“

“I can't say enough good things about Prime. From the moment I called them to ask them to curate an "Amalfi coast" menu for my daughter's bridal shower, to the moment they finished serving that day, they were amazing. The food was excellent, creative, fresh and beautifully presented. The staff was professional, friendly, dedicated to making the day successful, and just an all around pleasure. I had many many compliments from guests on the deliciousness of the food. Even when there was a snafu in the kitchen (having nothing to do with the staff), the chefs and other staff pivoted like pros and every single thing came off as it needed to. This is a high quality outfit, with extremely delicious food, and just a great group of professionals. Thank you!“

“We had my daughter’s high school graduation party here and it was such a success!! Raj made the party planning process so smooth and easy and we weren’t worried about anything going wrong. He went above and beyond in making everything easier for us in every way. The venue was decorated absolutely beautifully. From the stage setup to the backdrop to the table centerpieces, everything was wonderful. All the guests could not stop commenting upon how gorgeous everything was. The food was also very good! Everyone had such a good time and talked so highly of the event. I can’t recommend Metropolitan Caterers enough; they made our celebration of this event so special!!“

“I recently had the immense pleasure of dining at Tubool and I can honestly say that it was an unforgettable culinary experience that left me absolutely dazzled.The menu was a masterpiece in itself, offering a diverse range of dishes that catered to every palate. Each dish was thoughtfully crafted with a blend of flavors and textures that showcased the culinary expertise of the chefs. The presentation was a work of art, with every plate resembling a canvas that had been painted with exquisite precision.The service was impeccable, with the staff exhibiting a genuine passion for their craft.“

“Wonderful Thanksgiving meal! Thank you !“

“Great place to spend quality time with friends and family.“

“Delicious and healthy food for my dinner party... Was amazing! I will recommend 100%! My guests are still talking about the tasty empanadas. Wow!😀“

“I wish you could put pictures because the picture of this Grand Slam that I got from there today. Yeah, it's where the million words huge will cut meat. Just everything about it.“

“Great breakfast and amazing service“

“Been there for birthday party and now a christening we had a blast food was good . The people that work there were up to par in their service . Service is very important !“

“The blondies can't be beat!“

“Have to give Thomisana's and Tony the manager five stars!!! First of all the professionalism can't be beat when visiting to inquire and to get information. Tony will take care of you and take the time to answer ALL of your questions, as well as give very helpful advice to make your event as special as it can be. He is there every step of the way and works with you if any problems come up on your side. His team is also very professional and had the place decorated beautifully. Now let's get to the food... top notch!! I couldn't believe how good the food was (and ALL the guests loved it). Don't hesitate to use Thomasina's for anything from a repast to an all out party/celebration. Thanks Tony to you and your staff for making everything wonderful!“

“Chef’s 724 was amazing! I was there for a bridal shower yesterday and I had a great experience! The food was delicious (The Penne alla Vodka was the best)! The restaurant was clean and staff was kind, courteous, and professional. After the shower, I noticed I had a flat tire and Dave didn’t hesitate to help, he changed it for me! Dave and his staff went above and beyond to make sure we felt safe and taken care of. I highly recommend Chef’s 724 for your next special occasion!!“

“We celebrated my daughter’s Quinceañera in December and I am beyond happy I chose this catering hall for this unforgettable event! A special shout out to Diane and the Maitre D that helped us out every step of that way during the party! They listened to us and accommodated all of our requests. My guests had a wonderful time and the food was delicious! I would highly recommend this venue if you’re looking for a beautiful place to celebrate a Quinceañera or Sweet 16 party!“

“After reading a few low reviews, I felt the need to post that I have been here many times, and never had any issues with either the service or the food quality. This place is like a mini Zabar's with an Italian focus, not a restaurant. While the grocery selection is limited, I have enjoyed many items from the prepared food section, from turkey, to lasagna, to cooked vegetables. Everything tasted fresh and had a nice flavor. There are also pre-made salads, but I prefer the prepared food choices. I plan to continue to shop here.“

“Excellent & professional service. Your warm welcome and generous accommodations were greatly appreciated. Highly recommend. Authentic & delicious food. The atmosphere & ambiance were exceptional. Special acknowledgement to the owner & my dear friend, Naala & her professional & courteous staff, Shari, Jermaine, Nick & the entire Dunns River Lounge Staff in Rockville Centre, NY“

“This place has the best food, period!As good as the food is, nothing compares to their soups. Chicken, Vegetable, Pea, lentil. The soups are the best tasting soup I have ever had. I know that might sound extreme, but it is True!! I hope this review is helpful.“

“First off the service is like no other. The BBQ chicken falls off the bone I travel from Long Island just for this food and I'm never disappointed. Come here and I promise you won't disappointed. My daughter is very picky and she loves the food.“

“The Coral House is a grandiose experience. It emits a unique sense of style and elegance suitable for a wedding. But, it does have a few cracks.
The lighting and overall atmosphere is incredible! When you think of the highlights of a wedding venue, the Coral House should be a strong consideration.
There was a wide selection of food and drink, and the rooftop area for cocktail hour leans in to the New York wedding experience. For some reason, people cannot deny drinking and eating while looking over the gorgeous lake the Coral House rests next to.
I’ll also state, the overall service was great!
Now for the cracks. While the “vibes” are great, there is still a lot of unsightly corners. For example, the rooftop bar broke the level of elegance by letting us see into the dingy corners of that room. A few curtains, some dimmer lights, and maybe some other set dressings would have made the experience just that much tighter. A venue is not just about the view, it is also about the presentation.

Besides those little bits, I think The Coral House deserves to be on the short list of wedding venues.“

“We recently (March 2021) made our wedding with Genadeen at the Sephardic temple. It was beyond expectations. Everything was perfect — It was set up both indoors and outdoors, and as regulations changed, they were adaptive to our needs to be able to keep the wedding safe and per guidelines while also a true wedding party. The food was the best we’ve ever had at a wedding. We visited a lot of places and have been to a lot of weddings but Genadeen wins the prize. Our guests agreed. Finally, the staff are kind, responsive, courteous and friendly. Avi is a wonderful person to work with — incredibly responsive, creative and trustworthy. We were extremely satisfied with the experience of making our wedding with Genadeen. — — — — — — — — — — — — — Genadeen Caterers CJ Studios Nafshenu Orchestra Jerusalem Florist Thank you for making our wedding beautiful, elegant, fun, safe, joyous and awesome. The wedding was beyond our wildest dreams. Thanks to our families and friends for seeing us enter into this new joined, trusting, wonderful chapter of our lives. We’re so glad we got to celebrate with you. May we continue to celebrate together! Miriam and Yair Friedman“

“Thanks Leon for another super awesome event The quality, presentation and abundance of the food was outstanding. The guests are still talking about the lamb and the tuna pizza Can’t wait for the Lederman affair Chaim“

“Lawrence's work speaks for itself! His attention to detail, and his creative eye are a few of the impressive things that blew us away. If you want an event that everyone will remember, HE'S YOUR GUY! Just take a look at the photos we posted on his timeline from an event we worked together 😍🎉 We hope to work with you again very soon, Lawrence!“

“Everything! Daaaalicious!“

“W Kosher catered our wedding this September, and from the very beginning, they showed nothing but professionalism. They were the only kosher caterer who offered us a tasting of all their courses. They also worked with us to build a more custom menu based on what we liked. On the day of, everything went smoothly. Their staff was also professional and attentive, and their food was amazing -- all of our guests were raving about the seared tuna!“

“Love. Love. Love! Recommend for any day of the week and any event that needs catering!!!!!“