25 Best Caribbean Restaurants near Hicksville

“The upcharge of ordering pasta instead of rice as a side results in some sticker shock once it’s time to pay, at which point you feel pressured to just pay it since they’ve already made the plate. Definitely pricier than an average Jamaican takeout spot, and I would’ve liked more transparent pricing upfront, but the food itself was good.“

“A whole vibe!!! From the moment you walk in, you are captivated. The decor, the music and the beautiful staff begin the wonderful experience that's about to occur. The food is exquisite in presentation and taste.i have visited the location in Forest Hills also but the experience in RVC is incomparable. (My daughter works near Forest Hills and frequented the other location but immediately stated she likex RVC just entering the restaurant) Iliana, Chastity, Julie and others, thank you for a great evening. Be back soon and every time I visit NY“

“I picked up food here for the first time and Auntie was so incredibly welcoming. She was happy to let me sample a handful of the dishes they were serving, all of which were delicious.

The oxtail here is just phenomenal. The depth of flavor of the gravy was such a standout. My rice and peas were covered in it and I wish I had more!

The jerk chicken was incredibly tender and the sweet and spicy sauces were a great compliment.

The fresh pine ginger drink is a must have and the homemade coco bread was pillowy soft.

The chef is an absolute pro here when it comes to salinity. The seasoning was spot on for every entree without any lingering saltiness.“

“My Family and I just finished having a late lunch here. The food was sooooo good and the service was great, we appreciate the staff accommodating our large party in such a short notice. The vibe was super chill and Pops was dope, came thru with a few samples 🙏🏾 Thanks again, we will be back next time we are in NYC.“

“TinNel’s Patties in Baldwin is an absolute must! Their patties are consistently fresh, flavorful, and perfectly spiced. The girls working there are always sweet and friendly. A must-try for anyone craving authentic and delicious Jamaican patties. Highly recommend!“

“This is a wonderful restaurant with delicious food and excellent customer service ! I enjoy almost all their meals especially the curry goat, beef patties, wings and their juices are amazing. My favorite is Pineapple Ginger! Love love this place !“

“Wow! Came here for my daughter 40th birthday dinner I called ahead of time told then that I had a large party, we got to the restaurant and were seated right away and the menu said happy birthday Tisha on the menu which was so so great and let me tell you everything we tried delicious the drinks was great waiters were wonderful. I will definitely definitely go back. I’d recommend this place“

“We recently visited the area for six days and ate here four of those six days 😂(would’ve been all six had we found it earlier!) Amazing food, great people, and loved their fresh hibiscus tea! Cannot beat the $7.99 lunch price either! 🤩 Highly recommend!“

“Always a hit! Authentic Jamaican good and the best patties ❤️. Chef Elvis is it truly sweet person and takes pride in his establishment cooks with love.“

“Went to brunch at the barnyard today and it was amazing. The food was great and the drinks and service was phenomenal. I will definitely be making this a regular“

“Had a wonderful time on New Years Eve at Island Soul. The food and service were great. The DJ kept everybody engaged and there was a champagne toast at midnight. It was a great way to bring in the New Year with family & friends. We love this local spot!“

“We catered from Trini Bites for a brunch with friends to celebrate our recent wedding. Working with Renee was an absolute pleasure. From start to finish, she was attentive and responsive. We knew we wanted to cater Trini food as my husband is Trini and I felt the stakes were high to make sure everything went well! And Renee delivered on every front.

The food was an absolute smash hit -- no tray was left untouched or unpolished, and we even sent folks home with to-go containers as they loved the food so much. Particular favorites were the stew chicken, the buss up shot, the mini doubles, and the curry chana and potatoes. Renee made sure that our dietary preferences were met, which was no small feat as we had vegetarians, vegans, kosher-observant (no shellfish), and halal-observant (no pork or pork byproducts) in attendance!

If you've ever been curious Trini food or simply want to serve something different for your party or gathering, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend working with Renee and Trini Bites at all.“

“Coalhouse Express and Market is hands down one of the best spots for authentic Jamaican food in the area. The flavors are bold, rich, and consistent every time you visit. From the perfectly seasoned jerk chicken to the tender oxtail and fresh sides, everything tastes like it’s made with real care and passion.
The staff is welcoming, the service is quick, and the overall vibe makes you feel like you’re getting a true Caribbean experience right here in Baldwin. You can tell they take pride in both their food and their customers.
If you’re looking for high-quality Jamaican cuisine with great portions and unforgettable flavor, this is definitely a place you need to try. Highly recommend!“

“My fiance got us dinner today & I must say it taste very great. We have been looking for a good Jamaican restaurant for some time now. Every cook has slight dif flavor and you can always taste the dif in food. The food was healthy & the overall service provided was very respectful. We also felt full and great after our meal! Looking forward to coming again :)“

“I’m new to the area…. And If you’re looking for a meal that hits every note of flavor and comfort, the oxtail and fresh roti here are an absolute must. The oxtail is cooked to perfection—tender, fall-off-the-bone, and seasoned with rich spices that soak into every bite. The gravy is bold, hearty, and full of depth, perfect for scooping up with their freshly made roti. Speaking of the roti, it’s soft, warm, and flaky, the ideal partner to the savory oxtail. Together, it’s the kind of dish that feels like home—authentic, flavorful, and made with care. Hands down, some of the best oxtail and roti I’ve ever had!“

“Let me tell you something. Lisa and Pete will make sure you have the absolute birthday. Somehow someway they brought out moves I haven’t pulled out in years. The food! They take their time because it is mouth watering. The drinks…. Well the first time I didn’t remember… but the second and third. Let’s just say it’s a good time all the time.“

“This Jamaican spot never misses! I’ve been coming here more often lately, and every visit has been a great experience. The staff is always friendly, welcoming, and happy to make recommendations or let you try something new if you’re unsure what to order.

The food is consistently delicious, the portions are generous, and the prices are honestly hard to beat these days. You get great quality food without feeling like you’re being overcharged. They even have homemade ice cream, which is such a nice bonus!

What really keeps me coming back is the combination of great food, excellent service, and the warm, family-like atmosphere. If you’re looking for authentic Jamaican food with generous portions and friendly people, I definitely recommend giving this place a try. I’ll definitely be back!

FYI. I have tried the jerk chicken, stew chicken and oxtail. All were good :)“

“I arrived to the location recommended by a friend who’s considering this location as a b day rendezvous in the near future.

Parking: there’s parking available in a well lit parking lot directly behind the building. There are lights along the entire plaza outside. No major trash or debris. A small spot which still made us feel safe. There’s an entrance / exit there’s well as the front door. There’s parking directly on the main road. We saw a few spots available in the side streets which was a plus.

Business at 8 pm was busy and rustling. A few seats became available at the bar as the crowd rotated. We were promptly greeted by the bartender. We also made eye contact with a wait staff who also went behind the bar POS. The music was at a moderate volume featuring classic reggae sounds throughout the spot. The bar has about 12 seats. There’s are four tv displaying weekly pronouns and local sports. We ordered wings and fries. Both were bright crisp and hot. An indication that grease is rotated fresh. The panko batter for the wings was tasty.

The restroom is located at the back by the entrance. I did not have an opportunity to check this out. The dining room is bright white and modern. There’s a projector and a tv screen in the area. We are observed the climate control is fair with hot food in hot chafing dishes. There are windows which let light in at sunset.

We discussed future dinner plans with owner Jeff. He provided menu options for large parties. He has digital displays of food and menu plans which was impressive.

We are in the process of setting up dinner. Looking forward to letting you know how the execution is for our large party dinner.“

“Lamb chops to die for . Definitely 10/10“

“Good delicious food especially the jerk chicken the only thing is the price keeps going up and the chicken keeps getting smaller…if yall gonna raise the price it’s cool but keep the same size of the chicken or amount of food“

“Always passed this place when heading to my grandparents. Decided to walk in after visiting them, finally try the food.

For context I am a woman whose life goal is to try food from every country around the world.

I bought the Saltfish, Roti, Ginger Beer, and Oxtail to start out.

This food is so well cooked it’s heavenly. The seasoning is perfect. The oxtail meal is so tender it melts in your mouth. Dipping the Roti into the Oxtail juices? Even better.

I plan on coming back soon to try even more. I have my eyes set on the Goat’s Head and Cow Foot soup. The shop is small and quaint, workers are kind. Only downside is there isn’t much seating inside: so your best bet is to order and bring it home.“

“Came in today for a jerk salad and a side of Mac and cheese . The server innocently rang it up as pasta but they corrected the error with no problem and were very nice about it . Let me say , the jerk salad was DELICIOUS. Definitely worth the money , the chicken was a little spicy , super flavorful and juicy . The mango’s and cucumbers in the salad were fresh. The side of Mac and cheese was the best I have had at any Caribbean restaurant in the entire area and I’ve lived here for over 20 years. Definitely a great experience and I will be coming back for more !!!“

“I did not try the food but will soon. The service was very inviting. The bartenders were great. I enjoyed the music provided by Dj Lennox. 4 Stars right now because I did not order food. I went for the music and a drink. I'm sure the amount of stars will go up after I try some food.“