Jamaican Restaurants near Hicksville, NY

“My family and I have been going to Uncle Don’s Kitchen for the past 4 years. One and only best Jamaica restaurant located in Hicksville. The staff is friendly and personal with every customer. They make you feel welcomed and appreciates customers. The food is perfectly portioned and tastes flavorful and fresh. They do make a very unique chicken with Mac and Cheese that I ask for all the time since my kids love them. The stew chicken, jerk chicken and fried chicken with rice and peas are on point. I love their escovitch snapper with rice and peas and one of the best I had. We will always be repeat customers.“

“Stopped here on a Sunday night as they were about to close they were pretty much out of everything. Kerry Ann was kind enough to make us some fresh fried fish and chicken topped it off with some extras. Super amazing customer service. Their coconut drops and peanut cake reminded me so much of back home, jamaica. Overall I had a great experience and will definitely stop by if I'm ever in the area.“

“We recently visited the area for six days and ate here four of those six days 😂(would’ve been all six had we found it earlier!) Amazing food, great people, and loved their fresh hibiscus tea! Cannot beat the $7.99 lunch price either! 🤩 Highly recommend!“

“Excellent & professional service. Your warm welcome and generous accommodations were greatly appreciated. Highly recommend. Authentic & delicious food. The atmosphere & ambiance were exceptional. Special acknowledgement to the owner & my dear friend, Naala & her professional & courteous staff, Shari, Jermaine, Nick & the entire Dunns River Lounge Staff in Rockville Centre, NY“

“I’m new to the area…. And If you’re looking for a meal that hits every note of flavor and comfort, the oxtail and fresh roti here are an absolute must. The oxtail is cooked to perfection—tender, fall-off-the-bone, and seasoned with rich spices that soak into every bite. The gravy is bold, hearty, and full of depth, perfect for scooping up with their freshly made roti. Speaking of the roti, it’s soft, warm, and flaky, the ideal partner to the savory oxtail. Together, it’s the kind of dish that feels like home—authentic, flavorful, and made with care. Hands down, some of the best oxtail and roti I’ve ever had!“

“de best food... i travel all the way from PA to come get this wonderful food. taste better than Grandmother food :)“

“I’ve just had my third meal at Tony Mac’s in as many days, and again I was not disappointed!??? For lunch I had the curry goat which comes well-seasoned with rice and peas, steamed veggies and plantain. To drink I had a number 5 Sea Moss drink called “The Mac Body Heat” to wake up the body made of - Sea Moss, wheat germ, oats, peanuts, pumpkin seeds, roots and something called tigerbone! ???The waitress noted to me on the way out “Look after your wife tonight, the next day you might be getting a welcome visitor from the Creator!Great meal and the medium was mighty big for the money -$25 for the meal and drink! Highly recommended for great food, Garnett Silk music while you wait and the baby maker shake!!!!?????????Honey I’m home!????“

“Sundays after church....My go to favorite is their curry goat 😋. I also like their, jerk chicken. Always order a large plate, I get two sometimes three depending how hungry I am.
The reason I minus 1 star is due to service & quantity of food a time I went in the evening for the first time on a Friday. My large plate was not equal to what I normally would receive when I went on Sundays. I didn't make a fuss about it because the server was already in a mood. It wasn't worth it and I was already tired. I know to just stick to my Sundays.“

“Just moved out to LI from Brooklyn & was looking for good Jamaican food. Out of all the places I’ve been to, this is the best. I usually get the jerk chicken, jerk pork, or beef patties. Ox tail is also very flavorful. Good customer service and portion sizes. Now a regular spot for me“

“This place has a good vibe and was clean. The service was excellent and the food was ok. I expected a little more for a Jamaica restaurant and wish I could have tasted the salmon but they were all out. They were getting a lot of pick up orders so I guess they definitely are doing something right.“

“We visited on Valentine’s Day and it was such a great time! The food was amazing!! I ordered the lobster and shrimp and my husband ordered the oxtail Rasta pasta.

The oxtails were falling off the bone 🍖!! So good… and the sauce!!! WOW! Blown away!

The service was great, very hospitable. Courteous service from start to finish!

So glad we dined here! All the way from Brooklyn!“

“Best tasting Caribbean Food !!!! ?“

“Idk why all these negative comments and one stars. I come here almost weekly now with my wife. The jerk chicken with oxtail gravy, 4 fried wings chopped and beef patty hits like no others. I have a great experience every week that I’m here“