50 Best American Restaurants near Mattituck

“🌮🔥 A Taco Lover’s Dream! I had an incredible experience at this taco spot! The tacos were absolutely amazing — packed with flavor and offered in so many different varieties that it was hard to choose just one (so I didn’t!). Each one was unique and delicious. The spicy margarita was the perfect drink to pair with the food — just the right balance of heat and refreshment. And don’t even get me started on the desserts... they were to die for. Save room, trust me. To top it all off, the owner, Dan, was incredibly welcoming and made the whole experience feel personal and inviting. It’s clear he’s passionate about what he does. This place is a must-visit for any taco lover. I’ll definitely be back!“

“Front counter seats where great ,pastrami hash browns two over easy .Coffee was great ,service well educated.“

“Had lunch today as first time visitors with my family of 5 (3 young kids). We had the best experience! Our waitress was so friendly and attentive! She might be our favorite waitress ever. She gave the kids activities and toys to keep them busy. The food was great and the dessert with candle for my daughter’s 5th birthday put our experience over the top. Brownie sundae was fantastic! We can’t wait to go back. So happy we found this spot.“

“My husband and I had dinner at the Old Mill Inn last night for the first time. The atmosphere was relaxed and casual. The staff courteous and friendly. My white peach margarita was delish and our dinners were amazing. We had the swordfish with in season veges- would highly recommend. We will def go back!“

“We had a large group in to celebrate my mother’s birthday and we had an amazing experience with Windamere. From the initial contact through each stage of planning, the people at Windamere were wonderful and helpful. The day of the party was perfect. The decor was beautiful, the service extremely attentive, and the food was amazing. My mother was very happy with the party, and we wouldn’t have had anything done any differently. We highly recommend the Windamere for your event.“

“My Wife and I live in Nesconset. We Frequent Love Lane throughout The Year. Ammiratis is a place we love ,super food , nice people. We will be back soon …..“

“May 30, 2024. I had a delicious prime rib dinner at lunch. It is so hard these days to. find one that is tender and juicy but this fit the bill. Friendly staff and friendly patrons.“

“Great Place Friendly service warm welcome“

“Good home cooking in a quaint setting. Enjoyed our Autumn trip here. Nice friendly service is always a plus!“

“Amazing food, lovely staff. We have been coming here for 12+ years, celebrating every family occasion and party. It is our second home.“

“Came on the recommendation of Adam at Coffee Pot Cellars. Fabulous lunch! We will definitely be back!“

“Amazing atmosphere. Real and delicious fresh food made to order. Friendly staff and very attentive.“

“Went here for the first time today. Had a truly excellent meal. Corn chowder was amazing, the turkey bacon brie sandwich was the perfect sweet and salty sandwich. My husband had the quesadilla with a side of their homemade buffalo sauce. He loved both. Overall great, quick service and a truly delicious lunch“

“Excellent casual seafood spot! Fresh, delicious and great selection! Service was excellent! Staff were outstanding! Loved this place! Well done, Jerry, Nicole et Al!!“

“Fabulous!! Went to a charity event for Dancing thru the Decades.....the staff, the music, the atmosphere were great....and the food was fantastic!!! Kudos to the Chef!!! Best Chautea Briand mashed potatoes, broccoli rabe ever!! Definitely recommend!!!“

“First time visiting and we look forward to the next! Our server, Andrea was attentive and friendly. My steak was cooked perfectly and exactly what I was looking for. Thank you for a wonderful meal!“

“From the moment you walk in, to the service, drinks, decor and food everything was amazing“

“Last night at Cowfish Restaurant with my family was truly special. The service was amazing from start to finish. Our waitress, Gabby, was absolutely fantastic attentive, friendly, and made us feel so welcome. I had a small issue with my salad and the manager Jason, came right over to the table. He went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. He was professional, accommodating. Thanks to Gabby and Jason, our evening was the best.!!!! We'll definitely be back!“

“Hotel review: Great experience here. Staff was great, rooms were clean. Location is close to a lot of restaurants and activities. Not too far from the wineries. Thank you to the staff who made this a great experience.

Restsurant: Had a pleasant dinner here. Very friendly staff, good drinks.

Overall, would recommend hotel and restaurant for a weekend getaway.“

“Food is fabulous. Anyone with a gluten allergy or sensitivity this is your place. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable and I love the atmosphere. Can’t wait for our next visit.“

“This was one of the best dining experiences on Long Island! Not only was the food delicious but the service was impeccable. The staff were kind, attentive and informative on all dishes from the menu. This was a 10/10 experience all around. I would highly recommend. I can’t wait to come back again!“

“The food here is so fresh! We came here on a whim after a trip to the beach and ended up eating there every night we were in east Hampton! Such incredible fish and just really well seasoned food! The staff were lovely and the food was really well priced especially for the area which is known for being quite expensive!“

“Delicious food! Cold beer!“

“I want to rate this 3 stars out of 5. The food is amazing but customer service not that great. My family was in from out of state and wanted to get take out and I instantly thought about this place. my fiance got the food and came home and my order was missing the cheese on the burger. So, I unfortunately couldn't eat with my family and neither did my fiance because he had to eat his food while driving 20 minutes back to get my food fixed at the restaurant and then 20 minutes back. However, I would still recommend you guys to other people. I would just suggest checking your order before leaving“

“Great food and atmosphere“

“My fiancé and I ate here for the first time today. Everything was delicious and the staff was very friendly. We will definitely be back“

“Best meal I’ve had in quite some time. Excellent service. Highly recommend“

“Just ate dinner there. Excellent food and service. Cozy, friendly atmosphere. Will definitely go back. Especially liked the Jersey burger with the toot beer barbecue sauce, Applewood bacon, and cheddar on a pretzel roll.“

“The place is awesome, from the food, drinks and overall great atmosphere. A wonderful place to spend a few nights and feel like your away from it all. Staff is great!“

“Went there yesterday with four. Hands down to the chef. The clams were awesome. Excellent broth with sausage and jalapeño. Forget about the chicken eggplant and pot roast. A must go. I would eat there every night.“

“Carla’s is THE BEST! I’ve been going there for a few years now and there’s obvious reasons for why. Over time they have become like family. Sweetest, most honest people you’ll ever meet. Carla’s has literally everything and anything you’ll be looking for!Thank you Carla and Fam !! XOXO“

““I don’t have pictures to post, but John and his mom run an excellent shop. They focus on high-end, organic cannabis products, which I truly appreciate. Many other stores feel inconsistent, but at Carla Kitchen you get top-quality, safe, and reliable cannabis. I care about what I put in my body, and this is the place I trust. Highly recommend if you’re buying weed in Southampton.” John grows his own weed, while the others don’t“

“went with 2 other people, and one of the burgers was undercooked (she asked for no pink and there was a lot of pink). the cheese part of the mac and cheese was pasty, like it was a bechamel sauce with extra flour on instead of a mornay sauce, aka they did the flour butter and milk but added no actual cheese to it. the fries were tasty and the burgers were well seasoned. i wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here again.“

“Omg perfect environment. The food is amazing. I got an amazing egg sandwich. Perfect. Great price. Very filling.“

“Great food service & amazing Dirty martinis!!!“

“Great and abundant food, enthusiastically friendly and efficient service. Welcoming atmosphere.“

“Great place for a delicious steak.“

“I had time to kill and wanted to play some ski ball with my son... i guess i'm a little antiquated, but they did have some ski ball machines... We use the roller coaster simulator which he loved and I wanna miss superman stuffed figure... he's a big fan so“

“Best darn porterhouse steak😋“

“Friendly atmosphere, really good food“

“Amazing food, lovely staff. We have been coming here for 12+ years, celebrating every family occasion and party. It is our second home.“

“5 stars! We are here on vacation and I LOVE small places like this. It’s right on the water and the food was so good! You can always tell by the French fries lol. Tacos had a great kick, quesadilla was great for my 5 year old, cheesesteak egg rolls awesome and our server Sierra was so sweet and hospitable. It’s a gem of a place and we would definitely go back! Just to know, it is not a full bar but we had mimosas and Stella. It hit the spot for us for sure!“

“The All Star Grill is situated under the same roof as the bowling alley, billiards room & arcade.

Each experience is set up in a way where it feels separate. We all really enjoyed the color LED light show, endless pitcher of soda and the burgers were a big hit!

Check out this video I took of the virtual reality arcade game....“

“Good food, good prices. I like the tacos and the steak / cesar salad.“

“good food and nice atmosphere .“

“Everything! Fun family night!“

“Great and fun place! Friendly people and good food“

“Good atmosphere Good food The best margarita & mojito Ask for sangría I loved Guava.“

“Delicious sandwiches and salads. Such nice staff and very clean !“