31 Best American Restaurants near Mayfield

“Suggest waffles or sausage gravy or any choice that suits your fancy. This place is the BEST. Excellent. Wish I lived closer...“

“Quality food that taste amazing at affordable prices“

“I prefer my restaurants and food without the bigotry of politics and some assclown giving a recommendation with a stupid red hat.“

“We were blessed to be married here. Cindy did an INCREDIBLE job with literally everything. From decorations, to planning, to cooking. Everything was beyond amazing and more than we could’ve hoped for. We loved working with her and had the wedding of our dreams because of her. We wish we could relive it honestly! What an amazing day🤍“

“Had the best steak panini here ever!!“

“First time here, by far the best stuffed haddock with shrimp and crab with spinach and two sauces ever ! Love the quaintness and historic atmosphere and decor. Very cozy and great service. Rated my favorite 💖“

“Amazing and fresh food! Good portions, friendly. Lunches, specials and soups are delicious 😋“

“I tried them the other day and it so honestly good quality food! Definitely will order again“

“An awesome place with great food and best waitress-Mary Beth!“

“The Hot Dog Hut catering service in Johnstown, NY is top-notch from start to finish. I have used them numerous times and the food is always fresh, hot, and delicious with all the fixings, tasty sides, and plenty of options to please everyone. The staff was friendly, professional, and went above and beyond to make sure our event was a success. Everything was set up beautifully and served right on time. On my last event the attendees couldn’t stop raving about how good the food was. If you want stress-free catering with fantastic flavor, the Hot Dog Hut is the way to go!“

“Hi Sara, My daughter surprised me and brought me a Corned beef and cabbage dinner on the 17 and I was so surprised. I have to say it was perfect meaning the meat was so lean and cooked perfect and of course so were the potatoes and cabbage. I enjoyed it so much, please say hi to the cooks in the kit for me.“

“Went Thursday first time ,heard mixed reviews, was very pleased fish &chips excellent, French onion burger , will be back“

“I’m staying at the hotel and I have to say that the restaurant has excellent food and the atmosphere is decent. Most dinner meals come with a soup or salad (French onion is wonderful) and fresh made rolls. It is a pretty quiet place with a fireplace and lots of tables. Good for large groups or work dinners.“

“Beautiful place to see we love the food“

“Everything. Always good, great service and food.“

“An absolute pleasure having this amazing pub/loft/dining/entertaining gem in Amsterdam! My daughter’s “go to” when celebrating her birthday! This year 2/14 she will be 18 and heading off to college in the fall and you can bet i reserved a table for 12! The staff are so attentive and welcoming, the owner pays attention to detail and has the best menu at great prices! See you Saturday!“

“Hands down best food. Pizza- amazing. Wings- amazing. Then tried the chicken Caesar grilled wrap- amazing! Highly recommend!!“

“Thank you so much to Megan for naking our delicious quiche for Easter breakfast. It’s so perfectly amazing. Thank you to Amanda for buying them for us . I highly recommend. The food is amazing staff is super friendly and helpful .“

“Table was a little small for 10 of us and the room itself was crowded but thats my only complaints. Food portions and price were very reasonable. Service was attentive and gracious for all the demands. ~$40 per person including tip. I recommend reservations for large parties and on busier nights“

“Waitress was great,“

“Fast friendly service, delicious food, generous servings, fair prices“

“Staff is always pleasant and welcoming. My mother and I go there at least once a month and the food is always yummy!“

“Went to Lakeside Tavern for dinner the other day, I ordered the burger and it was delicious. The cocktails and service were also great. The restaurant had great vibes and will definitely be back!“

“Everyone is friendly and amazing people. They all go above and beyond for their customers. Super efficient and awesome food. Love being able to text to order and pick up. They're breakfast was absolutely amazing and I highly recommend the corn fritters. (My first time ever having them was here. )“

“good food definitely great price 2 eggs home fries toast $5. very friendly people great staff. we learned you can put cream of tartar under your tongue and it will get rid of your headache..“

“Recommend the manic mania appetizer it is my favorite! The blue raspberry sprite Boba is amazing. The mac n cheese burger is yummy and the Huncka chunka lava cake ice cream sundae is to die for! A warning that the ice creams are big so make sure to save room! I always leave with a grin and a very full belly. Wonderful people and atmosphere.“

“Thank you for the delicious Haddock stuffed w/crabmeat today absolutely Fabulous❤️Thank you Chef!“

“We have been to Nicolino’s quite a few times now. Every time we have been there, the food has been excellent, and the atmosphere is always lovely. Tonight however, our waitress, Ava, went above and beyond for us. Thank you for being here, Nicolino’s! We will be back.“

“This is my first visit to this particular Ruby Tuesday. I was impressed by the salad bar.Everything was fresh and plentifully stocked. We were a party of six, and everyone enjoyed their meals as well as the salad bar.
I was seriously disgusted with the carpet as my feet were sticking everywhere. Just left me speechless....
This restaurant has a lot of potential. Need some cleaning up and new carpet.“

“This place never disappoints! Every special occasion we are here at the Raindancer celebrating with family and friends! Each time out-of-town friends come to visit, they want to have dinner at The Raindancer. The filet is my favorite but everyone in my family looks forward to the prime rib! Through the years we got to know the owners, and they are such lovely people..“

“I was there recently for work and staying at the hotel. I stopped in to try out the restaurant I will admit I had my doubts. I'm glad two waitress nullified my doubts. The first night I had Gianna it has been more then 15 years since someone has been able to get my order correct without there being a issue. Gianna did it without even breaking a sweet. The last night I was there I was with a friend and we got Samantha ( who trained Gianna ) and again the without breaking a sweat got my order prefect and even convinced me to have dessert that night. I am extremely hard to impress they both did it. I will definitely be coming there just to have awesome food and to see those 2 young ladies. Thank You both for a awesome time it very appreciated.“