23 Best Italian Restaurants in New Rochelle

“We had a wonderful meal there - all four entrees were excellent, the service was perfect, and the price is very reasonable. I wasn't expecting such a tasty meal!“

“Go for the reviews - leave shaking your head saying “those reviews were on-point”. The only annoying part, and not worth deducting even 1/4 of a star, is the pushy “ we need your entire order right away because everything is made to order” jargon. They do it to speed you along as you can’t get your apps until you order your main meal. But even with that and not having a reserved table ready on time - this place is 100% worthy of ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️!“

“loved service and food expectacular“

“Fantastic food minus a menu, you feel like you’re at your grandparents house for those of you who are fortunate enough to be Italian“

“Came here for a birthday soirée that was in a private room, the room was lovely and cozy and perfect for the event, the appetizers were great, the food was great the service was less then desirable. The cocktail menu was great and the drinks I actually got were divine but the wait for them and the mood of the server was less then desirable especially for a birthday party, she treated us as if we were a hindrance and we were bothering her by asking her for drinks. Usually, when booking a private party, you get the best of the best as your server if this was their best, it definitely was not good enough.“

“And the waiters were hot and very friendly.“

“The food was so Fresh and Delicious, The Lentil Soup was perfect for the weather Also had an Italian combo sandwich, with Her special homemade hot sauce 😋 will definitely be back THANK YOU LUPE“

“So thankful for finding this gem! Love coming here with my Family. Some of the best Italian cuisine in the area!

All of the appetizers are great. The coconut shrimp, calamari and baked clams are exceptional!

From their specials to the usual dishes you can’t go wrong. Love their penne vodka and all of their chicken dishes are amazing as well!

Did I mention the staff is the best? Thanks for everything guys!“

“The seafood is fresh and tasty! The staff is attentive and the owner is very friendly! Great atmosphere“

“This was my first time entering this pizza shop. My husband works at the hospital, so I caught the train to New Rochelle to meet him but I was very hungry and was craving pizza all day. I googled pizza shop near me and I believe 3 popped up. Well I chose Mario’s shop, and was not disappointed. Something about that pizza sauce was different. It was so delicious and the crunchy crust was everything!!!! My husband told me I made a “good choice” after he swallowed his slices lol. I’m adding this shot to my list for sure. Oh and thank you so much for the seltzer water😉, your customer service was top tier!! 👍🏾“

“What an amazing, hidden treasure! Excellence in dining, experience, and atmosphere. Perfect from start to finish! Looking for a place to have a great experience… this is it!!!“

“Thank you. Guys for showing great hospitality two Maine boys who came down for work. Your staff was very friendly and hospitable,food was great. Thank you too the Lady and Gentleman who served us and recommended our meals. You made our trip back to Bangor, ME better. Thank you for the dessert.“

“This is my favorite restaurant ever I’m so sad I graduated Iona because this was my go to place with my friends. Half off sangria Tuesdays and wine Wednesdays are great deals. The workers are extremely friendly and welcoming and I never had a bad experience here“

“Great food and great view of the Marina. Owner Nick takes time to personally greet you and make you feel like family.“

“It may look like an ordinary deli, but their food is top-notch. Got me a plate with eggplant parm, rice, pasta alla vodka, stuffed chicken, Brussels sprouts . Everything was delicious.

For Jacky, who left a one-star review -

TGTG clearly states that not all stores provide bags and utensils.“

“Great meal tonight, pizza was perfect…. Wings were tasty !!“

“When there last year, the manicotti was great.“

“I've ordered all kinds of weird pizza abominations from them and they've always done a good job and not judged me. 4 stars instead of 5 because one time my boyfriend ordered garlic on his pizza and they gave him SO much garlic on that pizza that it stank up our entire house and gave him garlic breath for 2 straight days. Just an inappropriate amount of garlic.“

“The seafood is fresh and tasty! The staff is attentive and the owner is very friendly! Great atmosphere“

“Afreakinmazing !!! Sal I freaking love y'all !! First we felt like family right when we came in . Second he instantly starts serving us . 3rd but probably #1 the food was insanely delicious . We had a slice each and a stuff something or other chicken Parmesan .. Then dessert was so good it was like inside of a cannoli but a zapple so good . Highly recommend“

“Old reliable; my family has been eating/ordering from here since before they changed their location, so 10+ years. Yes there’s loyalty, but also damn if they don’t know how to make even a simple cheese pie taste good. And that’s what matters in my book, the pizza. Thanks you Alfredo’s.“

“First of all, I absolutely love the waiter, he's the nicest sweetest, most pleasant person ever. Secondly, if you're looking for a place that has fish specifically with fins and scales, this place really has a great variety at amazing prices and very very high quality.“

“Very nice and friendly staff. Store is clean and the restroom very very clean too. I ordered latte with oat milk and falafel pocket and they were so fast. Was too easy to park our car. They have also drive-thru but for me it is more convenient to go to the store and see what they offer.“