Restaurants in Oyster Bay

“We just ordered here for the first time and the food was amazing ! The grilled buffalo chicken wrap was delicious! The breaded buffalo chicken wrap and avocado corn salad were huge hits as well.”

“Great fresh food Great service”

“Hands down the best chicken and waffles we’ve ever had! Great service and friendly staff. Definitely recommend. Yum.”

“Went with my fiance before dinner for some drinks and lite bites. Loved the oysters which came with their house made cocktail sauce and vinaigrette - these were $34 for a dozen so not cheap. Recommend sticking to on menu drinks vs create your own. Cindy was great and so accommodating.”

“We actually never went to this location before, but had greatly enjoyed their prior second location in Port Washington. Expectaions were right on point. Food was excellent from appetizer to the main course. Maybe it's weird but I kind of respect even the small things like when a restaraunt offers to chose to serve in house brewed ice tea as opposed to something pre processed. The Brisket from todays specials list was perfect. This restaurant is 45min drive from home and well worth the trip. Thank You, we will be back.”

“This place is a well kept secret. The food is great. We have had pizza, calzones, garlic knots and various pasta dishes. All were excellent. Prices are reasonable, servings are large, staff is friendly, the place is clean and there is plenty of parking. I highly recommend LaBell Pizza!”

“We come from far away to have the liver Viennese. So tasty and great portions”

“I absolutely loved their Burrata Slice. Delicious! My husband loves both the BBQ and Buffalo chicken slices and my kids can’t wait for Pizza Fridays now!! As a long time local I am so happy they made the change and have you in Oyster Bay!”

“Decided to take the 40 min drive from Lindenhurst to Oyster Bay to try out Gimme Burger. Boy are we glad we did! Service was great the burgers were the best we have had ever! My husband never finishes his fries, well not today! Everything cooked without seed oil. The buns were so soft and buttery. My black and white shake was outstanding! My only complaint is that we need one in Lindenhurst! We will be back, soon!”

“Welcomed us in. Atmosphere was welcoming, comfortable, cute and food was absolutely delicious homemade straight up love put into it! We had chicken empanadas and tamales. I wished you shipped. We are regretting not getting any for the 12 hr ride home. Believe me we will be back.”

“We had a party of 14 and everyone loved their meal! Food was delicious and service was fantastic. We will absolutely go back soon!”

“Hands down, one of the finest restaurants on the North Shore. Be sure to make a reservation, as it's intimate. Top notch Chef with a staff to match.”

“Food consistently excellent. Best part, however, is the friendly and attentive service by both the Wait Staff and Management. Management continually walks around to check on each table, address any issues, etc., etc. It's a lovely dining experience and we can't wait to go back!”

“Great place to eat and bring your puppy. Bentley enjoyed a few raw patties and I enjoyed a burger. Great placement! Loved the teddy symbol on the burger. The teddy bear toothpick was nice touch. Quiet and quick. Will be coming back!”

“The absolute best pizza in the surrounding towns. The vegetable sides, heroes, and salads are wonderful too—we especially love the eggplant parm hero and the broccoli rabe with garlic. Just fantastic.

What makes Mario’s in Oyster Bay especially wonderful, though, are the people. Everyone is always warm, friendly, and welcoming. Even when you’re simply picking up an order, there’s a genuine sense of hospitality that somehow makes the already delicious food taste even better. A neighborhood gem.”

“Wonderful people/wonderful coffee!”

“fresh buns and delicious dogs!”

“Good coffee. Good service. The locals seem to love this place as we watched cars and customers come and go in late a.m. way better than you know what. Nice seating and good music (thank god!!).”

“We catered our Easter dinner from Pizza Cucina in Westbury. The food was fabulous, especially the Shrimp Scampi, which is something we have not ordered as yet. The meal was on time and everyone made comments about how good the food was. Thank you for a great Easter dinner?”

“This is a new restaurant opening in Oyster Bay, NY. This is real authentic northern Italian food. Everything was so delicious. Fresh made mozzarella, fresh hand made pasta. The flavors of these dishes really show how much thought and preparation they put into creating food like this and it really shows. I strongly recommend this place. It is a must if you love Italian food!!”

“A must try place whenever you are in Oyster bay. Awesome food and staff! Highly recommended 😊”

“Really nice local bar that serves very good food and drink. They show local games (no satellite) on their 5 tvs. Worth the trip and the parking issues (not much available).”

“Excellent cozy local gem. Great for meeting friends or a light meal. Our new go-to venue. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. A great time no matter the day of the week.”

“Great new family restaurant with fantastic vibes. Televisions everywhere. Great bar. Staff and owners create a family environment. We have been there twice in 1 week and they remembered us when we walked in the door the 2nd time. Rueben spring rolls were a must both trips as was the shepard's pie. Meals are huge! Prices are great.”

“Great times and great vibes!”

“Excellent food, beautifully crafted cocktails, warm , comfortable atmosphere. I highly recommend the coach Meeting House”

“Love it; really exquisite”

“Very good and classic, very nice family run, take-out. Old school as you have to call, no online ordering as of Dec '25. Great Wonton Soup and House Special Fried Rice!”

“Great service and well made açaí bowls and smoothies. Fruit is very fresh. 👍”

“Storefront restaurant with a huge menu. Tough choice what to order.I opted for Panini Italiano, ham cappicola, genoa salami, mortadella, provolone cheese, with sun dried tomatoes, spinach and red onions, very good.My wife chose the Fried Eggplant panini with roasted peppers and feta cheese. her complaint was that the eggplant was dry.”

“Maddie and Stephanie offered me and my friend great service , this is one of the best carvels I been at, from now on I’m always getting my ice cream here 😁😁”