30 Best Ice Cream Shops near Pittsford

“Our favorite ice cream shop always fun new flavors and the staff are always kind and sweet.“

“Best milk and eggnog there is!“

“Excellent place to get frozen yogurt, whether stopping in or staying to sit and eat.The frozen yogurt menu is diverse and mostly ever-changing, but with returning familiar flavors.The building is quite clean, well-lit, usually very quiet, and not often very busy.The staff are not that friendly but are nice, mostly taking their job somewhat or quite seriously, depending on who is at the register or around the store when visiting.“

“What a neat little spot. The hazelnut gelato was delicious, and the folks behind the counter were polite and jokes around about the ducks outside. The ducks were a little pushy about food, but honestly, the gelato was good enough its hard to blame them ;-) Absolutely perfect end to a savory meal elsewhere in the area!“

“My favorite place to go. Fantastic place to meet new people and stumble upon connections you’d never expect.“

“One Word to describe them is or any experience with them is AMAZING!“

“Amazing ice cream selection! I can get my butter pecan soft serve ice cream always. Absolutely love the favor of it, always hated the crunch of the pecans in the hard ice cream version.“

“I’m obsessed with the honey lavender ice cream! The atmosphere is radiant!“

“Cutest shop around and everything is delicious! Love going on weekends for the breakfast sandwiches!“

“This review is long overdue.

I came here 3 years ago with a guy I had recently started dating (we’re talking maybe two weeks into the relationship). The lady behind the counter took one look at him, and then said to me, “He’s in love- you can see it in his eyes.”

She was absolutely correct! Here we are three years later (and going strong!), and we stop in from time to time for the delicious gelato. Bring your dating prospects with you!“

“Small batches of unique flavors of
Ice creams. I visit at least 2x per month. My favorite is Raspberry truffle chunk. Also they make their waffle cones in house. You need to buy ice cream with the waffle cone. I cannot believe I don’t have a single picture shame on me!! Hint hint they also have hot chocolate in the winter months. Enjoy!!!!

Dietary restrictions: They usually have sorbets (non-dairy) options

Kid-friendliness: They have fun ice cream toppings from sprinkles to gummies“

“the best ice cream cakes and the candy is also delicious!!“

“The best Ice Cream you can find, great service and also great place to go“

“My girlfriend and I, along with her two granddaughters, visited for the first time recently. We were surprised by variety of items on the menu, and everyone LOVED their picks! I must say that the PB BLAST Sundae is the closest thing to a certain Reese’s sundae I used to always get at Friendly’s. Try it and thank me later!“

“The yogurt is delicious. They have 6 to 8 flavors, but you can mix them to create a new flavor. Like a strawberry favor and a cheesecake flavor but you can hit the middle bar and create strawberry cheesecake flavor.
I always get the same flavor, that's the salted pretzel.
When you walk in, they may or may not say hello. Depends on who is working. However, if you ask for help, they will always help you. They have over 20 toppings to choose from. Fun for kids and adults. I'd recommend going. I've been going for years through the different owners.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, wheelchair ♿️ accessible“

“my family and I used to frequent the local Abbotts. They are sadly going away. Yolickity has become our new favorite fro yo place!!! Great seasonal faves as well as our old reliable Choc/van Swirl!!! plus toppings galor!!!“

“Absolutely love Mary and her team in Webster. Loved their yogurt and when it was discontinued, Mary suggested the closest option of non-dairy and loved it. She really cares about her customers!“

“Rochester locals range from snacks to big ice cream, which tastes like ice cream but is smoother and more mellow, sweet but not greasy, with crushed nuts in the middle. There are individual cups, small family buckets, sundae crusts are made on site, and birthday cakes of two sizes. Because it requires freshness, unlike other stores that have many flavors, there are only a few basic flavors, and usually "taste of the day" is launched every day. There are many branches in Luocheng, and the branch in Lakeside Park always has long queues in summer. Seeing the scene of parents bringing their children to patronize, and then happily bring them in the car or sit and eat on the spot, and you can see people walking along the riverside by the lake. Abbott's is not just an ice cream shop, but a place where Luocheng people grow up. The sweet taste is a part of life. If you visit Rome and you are lucky that they are opening in summer, don't miss this experience. When in Rome, do as the Romans do.“

“EVERYTHING! service was great. place was clean. and as usual the chocolate almond was delicious 😋“

“We ordered a set of 6 through Postmates and unfortunately didn’t get our cookie cutter that we ordered. Postmates has put us through if with supplying documentation l, sending a million pictures, etc… only to say our order isn’t eligible for a refund. On a whim I called in to ask about this and the GM was amazing. She just offered us a cookie cutter. Didn’t make it a hassle, was amazingly friendly, and made me feel a lot less crazy about the situation. 10/10 for crumble cookie 0/10 for Postmates ?“

“Best homemade donuts an cinnamon rolls.“

“My boyfriend and I were looking for a dog friendly ice cream place today and saw online that you guys have these adorable little pup cups! The staff was super friendly and very accommodating to our horgi (husky/corgi) Tucker. It was his very first time going out for ice cream! We thank you guys for a fun and memorable experience! 😊🐾 (our human ice cream was exceptional as well 😉)“

“I didn't get a chance to try Purity when we were in Ithaca this summer. Was very happy to try it out near home! Very delicious ice cream flavors, we both tried 3 flavors each in our sundaes. Favorites go to the pumpkin pie, berryblast (i forget the exact name of this one), and banana cream pie.“

“Best milk and eggnog there is!“

“Did a tour with our Girl Scout troop and we had a fantastic time! Would recommend for any groups wanting to learn more about ice cream and entrepreneurship! Lanny was friendly, accommodating and made the tour fun! Not to mention- the ice cream is some of the best in the area!“

“Incredible food will definitely be back“

“Always very good. Cookies are warm and large when picked up. ( only had one cookie that was cold. Totally worth the money. Cute boxes too!“

“The pizza was delicious, fresh, and ready fast! I was impressed with the young staff. They were enthusiastic, attentive, and hard working. My only regret is that I live 4 hours away in Canada!“

“I recently purchased a custom ice cream cake from the Webster NY location. I was blown away by the professionalism of Jenna, the manager and the artistic quality of the cake. I’m one pleased customer, with a very happy birthday girl! Thanks so much!“

“Delicious! And who doesn’t love warm cookies delivered to their doorstep😏“