22 Best Italian Restaurants near Rush

“The pizza at Montesano's is excellent. I order on a weekly basis and it's always on point cooked just right. The owner is awesome and very attentive to customers. Located right next to the falls and Lehigh valley trails makes the perfect scenery to stop by and get a pie!“

“Undoubtedly the finest Italian restaurant in New York! The cuisine is simply exquisite, bursting with authentic flavors that transport you to Italy with every bite. Not only is the food exceptional, but the customer service is unparalleled, ensuring every visit is a delightful experience. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, the staff consistently goes above and beyond to make guests feel welcomed and appreciated. It's clear that this establishment is run by a warm and welcoming family who truly care about their patrons' satisfaction. A must visit for anyone craving a taste of Italy in the heart of New York City!“

“Been to the Pizza Shoppe several times in the past month and a half. Let’s start with service. Fast, friendly and fantastic. I got my pizza nice and hot each time and my chocolate chip cookies were to die for. Seriously, maybe the best I have ever had.I have had several different varieties of this Detroit Style Pizza and it is second to none. It is now my go to for Pizza without a doubt.I also love the small pizza shoppe atmosphere not like one these chain pizza shops that has no personality. It was quiet and pleasant to just take a seat and enjoy my pizza. Hoping to try their chicken parmigiana in the near future.I don’t give many 5 star reviews, however this was an easy one to write.Great Job to your team at The Pizza Shoppe.“

“It's a casual restaurant . The food is good , it's good portion size. The long Island ice tea was on point. I got to see the owner of this beautiful fancy restaurant .the price is $$$$ it 17- 20 $ and up. it's more of adult setting. I haven't seen a kids menu or a babystation. But you can bring them at your own risk , I haven't seen no baby or kids restrictions. Its prefer dressy casual format it not mandatory. But above all it good . Recommend this place.Parking: There's free parking only when it's not so buzy.“

“Great local pizza place. Really love their buffalo chicken calzone! Not only is it just spicy enough, but they make some of the biggest calzones around, packed full with juicy buffalo chicken. Their pizzas are also really good. The only thing that sucks is having to drive all the way to Mendon for this terrific food. Very much wish the Victor location was still open!“

“Love that MicGinny's is our kickball team's sponsor. The service was excellent - our server was very good about making sure they spoke to everyone and divided our check accordingly. The atmosphere is lively and very fun with all of the sports on TV. The food is good. The pizza was not my favorite personally, but I am definitely looking forward to exploring the rest of the menu as the season progresses.“

“Came in for the first time after hearing good things. It didn’t disappoint. Food quality and service are what you would hope for from a local sub shop/deli but don’t always get. Seeing Boershead in the case is always a good sign. The staff really cares about serving food that you love. We’ll go again, often.“

“Limoncello has been on my list to try for a while. I was finally in the area and am really glad I went! The restaurant is huge inside, with mutiple rooms and sections. We went on a quiet Wednesday night and were seated in a patio type room. Our server Carolyn was friendly and accommodating. The drink list is extensive, with numerous cocktails, beer, wine, and non alcoholic choices. I had a paloma and my husband and I started with the artichoke french (tasty). For dinner, he got the gnocchi with vodka sauce and peas and I got the Portobello pappardelle. They both came with a small salad, and we got the limoncello dressing at Carolyn's suggestion. The meal was great, I had enough leftover for lunch the next day, and I'd order all of it again. I'm not in East Rochester much but this restaurant is worth a drive.“

“Don’t be fooled by the mall location. Cosimo’s pizza is seriously the best we’ve had in Rochester. Their pizza has great crust that is light, has perfect “pizza oven crunch” and is flavorful. Their sauce and cheese also have great flavor, and toppings are always fresh and cooked perfectly. The calzones are so filling and to die for. I don’t know why it took us so long to realize we could order full pizzas ahead of time but this is our new pizza night in go-to.“

“Best pizza in Rochester in my opinion. They used to be next to movies 10 but are now in a plaza down the road. Love the Ham and Ricotta Pizza they put out for Lunch everyday. Staff is friendly and attentive. If your looking for a place to get pizza stop reading reviews and just order brandani because you won't find anything better.“

“This Rochester original has been here for 80 years. The Bomber was huge(Rochester) and definitely delicious. As was the campi plate. For my first time here I'll be taking the 35 minute drive here again. . Plenty of seating and the atmosphere is welcoming..“

“Lunch on a Fri afternoon was very good. It was leisurely because they were short a server but they let us know before seating us. We enjoyed our Chicken French and Haddock French entrees preceded by a crock of French onion soup and delicious Italian bread that tasted homemade. Will return for dinner in the future.“

“We went on a Thursday night and I was eager to try the Thai food. I was very impressed with the chicken massaman curry which was really YUMMY!!!! It had exactly the right gentle heat and was so flavorful. Their chicken massaman was so much better what other Thai restaurants in Rochester serve. My husband loved the minestrone soup and got a hearty portion of chicken fettuccini for his entree. He loved that too. The waitress was so friendly and checked on us several times to see if we liked the food and if we needed anything else. Overall, the combined Italian with Thai food actually is the best of both worlds. We will be back again!!“

“The food here is amazing! We ordered a chicken French sub and it was delicious! Order food at the counter. Most people pick up take out food. This is a unique Italian market offering limited imported items. There are a few tables inside and outside. They offer many dedicated gluten free options.“

“Hard working crew making sure everyone is happy with their food. I really liked their wing flavours. If you just want some good pizza and no fuss, this is a good spot. I also liked the obvious care they have for the community. Sponsoring teams, hiring students and actually caring. Great to see. Make sure to say hi to Matt.“

“I’m an idiot and put my order in for ASAP instead of 3 hours later when I actually needed it and they remade everything even though it was my fault! Just want to say thank you for that and say they’re the best. Order from them all the time.“

“Came all the way from southern Ulster County NY to see the eclipse and came across this joint. I was welcomed by very nice staff and the service was amazingly quick and easy. The pizza was undoubtedly one of the best that i've had out of town! They also offer a free cookie with 2 slices of pizza on lunch hours and the cookies are so freaking delicious. I 100% recommend this restaurant to all locals and tourists! You guys rock!!“

“So, my niece was looking for a place known for their Prime Rib and was having a hard time. She remembered that years ago she had a good meal at Charley Brown's, so off we went. We found the place packed on a Saturday night. 3 of us chose the Prime Rib and I chose the Turkey Dinner, which was very good (except I didn't care for the stuffing). The others were mixed: 2 thought it was good and the 3rd thought it was mediocre. Therefore, the 4 stars.“

“Great food and service. Ambiance was spoiled by some large garish paintings which seemed out of place in this old restored building. There were no beef entrees! With low ceilings in what was once a house, the noise became a nuisance once most tables were seated.“

“Food was great service was awful. Our waitress never checked on us. I had to find her to pay the bill after sitting there for 20 min after we finished. Our drinks weren't refilled. Never came to see if everything came out OK or to offer dessert.“

“Lucca Kitchen and Cocktails is the best Italian food in the area! the dining room is somehow cozy and modern at the same time, you could take your family there for a hearty wholesome dinner or take a special someone for an upscale romantic evening of dinner and drinks and feel equally at home in both situations. The Chef and Owner, Matt Gervasi, is one of a kind! Always has a smile on his face and is never too busy to say hi, and man can he cook!! the food is top notch, the prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is beautiful and welcoming. I highly recommend you give them a try!!“

“Overall a very nice experience. Our guests enjoyed their meals and the ambiance Service was excellent. Too noisy for us however. I had requested a quiet table when making the reservation but from what I can see there are real no quiet tables based on the layout Nonetheless it was a pleasant meal“