35 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tivoli

“As a REAL New York City native (unlike 99% of the reviewers), I can tell you hat Broadway is more like an old school NYC slice shop than you would think. From the flavor to the quality to the service...do they make mistakes? Sure. Everyone does. Is their pizza great? Yes it is. So are their dishes. Until recently I had only been a weekender for 40 years. I've been eating here since they opened. It has always been consistent and delicious! The staff are super friendly as are the owners who work on-site every day. The inside is sparse, and no, I don't care what newspaper is on the table (NY Post) or what's on the TV (usually a show like NCIS or Smallville). You don't come here for the media...YOU COME FOR THE FOOD!!!“

“I ordered dinner last night since it was too hot to cook and everything was really good. Their sauce is fantastic! I got a chicken parm sub that was full of chicken and the best chicken parm I've ever had. We always get the vegan pizza for my boyfriend. It's awesome that they have that option(even if it doesn't have vegan cheese.) And they always give a ton of fried dough. They give you plenty of food and it all tastes fresh and amazing 👏“

“I am very particular about pizza and I’ve had a hard time finding good pie in the Hudson Valley. We tried Pizzeria Posto today and I’m happy to say it’s here. Awesome margarita pie with tons of basil and excellent wine!“

“Delicious food, friendly staff and atmosphere. Highly recommended“

“Bob oakes chicken parm the most amazing service in the industry thank you so much
This won't let me click 2 things so i bought take out unfortunately it wasn't correct so I ended up with delivery as it turned out one of the people that worked at the restaurant just so happened to live near me and brought me my corrected dinner no buddy does this above and beyond
God bless you and thank you“

“😀Maria never lets you go home without a large doggie bag. Best in Town. Tip: try the homemade cheesecake“

“Great food and a very friendly staff. Good selection of food and drinks. Great draft beer and generous portions of food.Prices are very reasonable also.“

“Amazing hosts and great food.“

“Cool atmosphere, good coffee and really tasty sandwiches!“

“Stopped in from out of town after the Old Rhinebeck Aerodrome event and was glad we did. The place needs some curb appeal and it’s not a big place but they have seating. We ordered a small thin crust pepperoni and sausage pie ($17 including a bottled drink) and was it was done quickly. Needless to say it was absolutely delicious. I was pleasantly surprised. The staff was friendly and accommodating. I highly recommend it. I would definitely stop in again if I’m ever in the area. (Btw I very seldom do reviews but I had to this time).“

“Excellent food serviced me and my family the Rhinebeck hospital ER. Thank you.“

“Having the best basic pizza establishment in your town should be what our town is most proud of (out of the millions out there). The owner is so nice, prices never raised during Covid when everyone else took the opportunity to gauge, and the pizza is always insanely reliably good.“

“Would definitely stop there when in the area.“

“Me and the wife and kids went To a fancy restaurant called Cjs Italian pizza. The best food I’ve had in a while in a nearly empty dining room with a cozy fire. The waitress Eva was incredibly pretty and friendly and the burger came right as I was done with my salad. Best restaurant in rhinebeck.“

“Just picked up a tossed salad and a chicken parm sub from Tosco’s. The food is delicious and Carlos at the counter is so nice — I highly recommend.“

“I always enjoy their food, absolutely hands down the best quesadilla's around!!! Friendly and affordable with an authentic atmosphere.“

“I was just eating pizza, and it reminded me of something that happened two months ago. There was a pizza place near the hotel where I stayed overnight before taking a fall foliage cruise, so I went there for dinner. The crust of the pizza I ate there was incredibly delicious. I think it was probably the best pizza crust I've ever had. Every time I eat pizza at home now, I think of the taste of that pizza crust. ^^“

“Very clean store, the staff was very polite and on time!“

“The girls at the counter are a pleasure and the pizza delicious and if u haven’t tried the salad bar it’s a must !!“

“Pretty good gluten free pizza crust, and the toppings were delicious. The other pie we ordered didn't come with the add-on we asked for and was very different from what was advertised. It's a very crowded and noisy bar so be prepared for that. There are a few parking spots in their parking lot, otherwise its street parking.“

“We were on a bus tour headed from NC to Vermont. We picked this place off the internet and the tour leader called and they said they could handle our large group. The pizza was excellent and the folks working that lunch (Monday, September 29) could not have been any nicer to us. Wonderful experience plus they had Cheerwine in the cooler which you rarely see that far from NC“

“I always order to go... Angela's is a hit or miss pizza parlor for many years and at times that same history pops up. Food is decent and delivery is hit or miss.
Maybe it is better to pick up the food so you can check to see how it is,but to go and delivery is never the same.“

“I am visiting from out of town and ordered carryout. Everyone was so friendly at pickup. I ordered the Chicken Marsala. It came with a very fresh side salad and large dough wedge. The chicken was fresh and tender, the mushrooms were freshly sliced and the sauce was very tasty. The portions were generous. I would highly recommend this establishment.“

“I love 440 but for some reason my wings are never right. Even after they assured me they are. I trust them so I never open it up before I go to check and then I get home and I’m disappointed. I asked for extra crispy extra wet sticky wings and they are always dry. I walk there so walking back to correct an order when I’m hungry doesn’t seem logical.“

“Best Pizza in Saugerties. Good priced food, Great portions, and nice owners. Been the best Pizza around since they opened.“

“Delicious garlic knots, pizza, beer. Great staff, service. Our go to every time we’re in the area. Excellent!“

“My go to pizza place. Any time I’m in town, I stop in. The five cheese pizza is awesome!“

“The Stone Pony catered multiple meals for my company offsite over the course of 2 days and the food was amazing! People could not stop raving about the food we had, even now that the event is over. They were very communicative, timely, and professional.“

“I used to look forward to eating there. But the last two times I had the worst servers. One never came back to check after she dropped off my food. I had wanted a soda refill and another napkin, had to find her to get my check. Last night I came in and was told the kitchen was about to close so I needed to hurry up (I just sat down at about 9:25 pm). I ordered right away. An ice water and a coke and a meatball parm sub. I was lucky to get my soda with her attitude. No ice water was brought or acknowledged at all. I took a few bites of my food and she asked if I wanted a box. I was really irritated. If they told me to go only I would have been fine. But the way I was handled made me angry. I ate quickly and left. If I choose to get something again , it will be to go. Honestly, Caitlyn is the best server there. She is five stars. The others are not worth a dime.“

“The girls at the counter are a pleasure and the pizza delicious and if u haven’t tried the salad bar it’s a must !!“

“We love the mixed meat and vegetables grandma pizza, it's absolutely delightful.“

“Food is great and amazing customer service 👌🏼 the staff there are respectful all the time.. #PromoteKayla she deserves it“

“Popped in after hair cut. Vinnie and Jeff were friendly, worked well together, got my order quickly, and enjoyed the delightful banter. Clean, well maintained, I’ll be back!“

“Always great food and Awesome service ( and priced reasonable)“

“We've been here a handful of times now, and everything we have tried has been delicious. We especially like the pizza, the chicken bacon wrap, and the chicken parm sub. Service is always fantastic. Happy to have decent pizza place back on our radar!“