26 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tivoli

“Broadway is our absolute favorite. We moved farther from them and tried the two pizza joints close to our new digs and they are not at all as delicious as a Broadway pie with onions. We'll commute to them - they are worth it!! P.S We were lucky they delivered to us prior to moving and the drivers were always cool. I miss delivery!“

“Great owner and amazing pizza! Was on a trip with my wife to Rhinebeck for a spa weekend at the Mirbeau and we saw that Dave visited Posto and gave a great score, so we had to try it! Pizza was delicious! I definitely think Dave underscored it! Patrick the owner is super friendly and we got talking about all the great pizza in the northeast. Definitely recommend when you’re around Rhinebeck and I’ll be stopping my on my future trips to Albany.“

“The whole wheat Gramma crust alone makes this pizza a cut above but the variety of toppings is such a long list that it’s hard to choose! I enjoy the unusual ones they offer like eggplant and artichokes.The fried dough is a huge pile of fried to perfection bite sized pieces!“

“John was a wonder individual who helped me secure for a large party. He was extremely helpful and the service was fantastic. Came here on New Year Eve and was great full for their hospitality. The food was yummy and out of this world. All pasta, pizza and appetizers were beyond our expectations. Great place with decades long history in operation. It’s a must place to visit when you are in the area.“

“A classic pizza shop and deli that never fails to deliver consistent food with friendly staff. The wait time was minimal and the quality of ingredients on point. The perfect balance. The owners are hands-on and it shows. This is my go to spot when passing through the Rhinebeck area.“

“John at Stone Pony was exceptional! He catered all of our food over the weekend for our retreat. He was always on time with a smile on his face. Super professional and the food was amazing. We had several allergies and dietary restrictions and he accommodated everything. We will definitely be using Stone Pony again if we are ever in the Catskills!“

“We ate at Vincenzo’s while in town this weekend. The owner was working during lunch & wS absolutely lovely. Our food was delicious - with the exception of my dad’s soup which he said tasted like it was from a can. Pizza, calzones & subs were all excellent! Does not serve alcohol & is counter service. Dining area was clean & enjoyable.Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly!“

“Can't speak about the beer, but the cranberry spritz and cranberry mule were delicious! Overall, I was happy with our food. I just wish the service was a bit faster but looked like they were short staffed. Regardless, I'd return.“

“Stopped in last minute for Valentine's Day. And we got a great split pizza that wasn't even on the menu. My half was breaded eggplant, and her side was fresh garlic, onion broccoli. For dessert, we had the chocolate mouse cake and fresh canolis! Our server was so sweet and accommodating and helped us make our decision an easy one!We will definitely be back!“

“My friend Alex is a regular and he got me out of the house for some lunch and he had me try his own menu item! Pesto Wings! Damn were they delicious!!!! I'm sure I'll be back with Alex again. I love this place. The food is great, the service is great, and the owner is awesome and very down to earth guy who is always approachable!“

“Would definitely eat here again. We had garlic knots and cheese pizza. Garlic knots could have use more garlic, but the pizza was perfect - great sauce, perfectly crispy crust, good cheese. Service was perfect once we got it, but it was unclear if we should sit ourselves or not.Vegetarian options: Pizza, pasta, apps and desserts“

“Had to make a pit stop on my way home from Hudson to try this pizza I keep reading about online. The place is so cool. I had a vodka slice and pepperoni and jalapeño, both incredible. Definitely in my personal top 3 slices I’ve ever had. You gotta go here!“

“Overall, my best experience with a Pizza franchise in past few years.Pros: A well maintained nice and clean establishment. Good tasting pizza. Truly professional and courteous behavior all around. A shout out to the manager Jennifer - she and her staff are the best.Cons: None.We were returning from the Catskill mountains after experiencing some pretty decent fall foliage. Enroute, we ordered pizza from the nearest Dominos that the map showed. That happened to be the Dominos franchise at Saugerties, NY.Based on experiences going back at least a couple of decade, our expectations with such pizza places are minimal - grab your pizza and walk out. Most look like sweatshops with very little time or patience for providing any customer experience.So when we walked inside the establishment, we were somewhat pleasantly surprised at seeing a neat and clean place - well lit and surprisingly well-ventilated to not have that overpowering pizza smell through the air. The place looked appealing to sit-n-eat.We asked the manager Jennifer who was checking out our order if we can sit and eat our pizza. Her prompt response - "Of course. Would you like some paper plates and napkins?". She promptly reached out under the counter and got us some paper plates and napkins, and also asked if we needed some red-pepper that were nicely stacked on the desk.As we thanked her and sat down, we noticed her staff not only paying attention to their job but also engaged in occasional light-chats. The whole setup was a welcome change from mostly overworked-employees-sweatshops that we so frequently encounter these days.The restrooms were kept nice and clean. While Jennifer had stepped away, I went up to the counter. The person baking the pizza (I forgot to get his name) quickly came up to the counter asking if I needed any help. It seemed like there was a well-bonded team in place.A very pleasant experience overall. That's how Pizza franchises used to be once upon a time. And that's how they need to be.“

“This review is for the cafe side only, The space is big, bright, and clean. I had the chicken cutlet focaccia sandwich to go and it didn't disappoint. I forgot to get a picture because it looked too good not to devour immediately. Hope to come back soon for a sit down meal and drink.“

“I got take out from here during a long work day. When I walked in, I was immediately pleasantly greeted. My order was quickly taken. I got “chicken Scallopine A la Maria”. The owners did not mind me replacing the original veal for chicken. The food did not take long. When I opened it, the serving size was incredible! Easily 4 meals for me. The food was delicious and I will absolutely return when back in the area.“

“First, everyone was friendly & professional, excellent service. Second, the pizza was amazing, cooked to perfection and great amount of toppings. Made fresh to order. Love that. Thirdly, absolutely affordable. And don't get me going on the dessert. OMG Yum! Highly Recommend. This is a small business that im proud to support. I can't wait to go back & try more from the menu.Kid-friendliness: Family restaurantWheelchair accessibility: Clear and flat entrance“

“My boyfriend and I love coming here when we get to come out on Saturdays. The sweetest sweetest waitress, a Greek girl. A girl of my country is our favorite waitresss Collia. I hope i'm spelling it right I don't think I am! She is our favorite and we're so happy every time we get her There is Nothing that I've had tht is bad. The burgers are amazing. The pizza is amazing , the salad Dressing is amazing. I love the zings wings ! From the minute you walk in there, it smells delicious and so cozy you get your own personal booth. We have our favorite. It's usually open but when it's not there's always another “

“I’m writing this review simply based off their packaging of my caesar salad. One of my biggest pet peeves is when hot chicken is put on lettuce and then it becomes soggy. Matteo’s packages the chicken separate from the lettuce like GENIUSES. The caesar dressing is also very very yummy.Staff is super friendly and kind! I recommend ordering delivery straight from them. Much much cheaper than DoorDash or UberEats“

“As a local this is the best pizza. Grew up with this family run spot and anytime I'm even close to RH I go for a slice or a pie. The crust makes it as this is not to crisp but you also won't get floppy soft either, offering a great texture. Their sauce is really good as well. Want a cute experience and date night ask the team for the ingredients to make your own pie at home.“

“I spotted this hidden gem from the road. It’s tucked behind things and I’d never noticed it. The place is tiny - takeout only I believe - but magical. The ovens are from another world. The mushroom pizza was unique and wonderful. The young women making the pizzas were charming and seem both good and committed to it.Can’t wait to explore further.“

“The only service I got when I went to the short guy and he ask me if I'm looking for pizza I told Yes I gave him my order what I wanted then 15 minutes later the girl said to me if I was all set when I'm waiting for my pizza they ask me if I order she too much on her cellphone instead helping customers. I give my Service stars to the guy“

“I found this place by accident from a friend. We went in and got a couple slices of pizza. The choices were abundant and I was having a hard time deciding what to try as this was my first time here. I decided on one Sicilian slice pizza which had an abundance of toppings on it, And also a second slice of Buffalo chicken pizza. Both of these slices were out of this world. The service was second to none. We were greeted within one minute of entering the building and served our pizza with in 5 minutes of entry. Both slices that I chose were super flavorful and did not lack toppings at all. I highly recommend this place for the quality of their food Aunt the service of the employee. The place was very clean And spacious inside. I will go back again!Parking: Wide open parking lot right next to the building.There are no marked parking spaces, but the lot is spacious and easily accessible.Wheelchair accessibility: The entrance to the building from the parking lot is wheelchair accessible via a ramp . Very easily accessible.“

“D'Elia's catered our event last weekend and it was a HUGE hit! The food was so fresh and absolutely delicious! Delivered fast and helped me set it up. Highly recommend for your next event. Penne alla vodka was my personal favorite“

“La Florentina, knock me over with a feather! The Owner, a gorgeous lady & soul. I told her, I don't have a credit card today, I do have cash & I love your food I'm seeing. A very big craving for the dishes swept over me, like a tsunami! A delicious tsunami of love cooked into the food. Great ingredients! I can taste them all. Back to Owner & her daughter, another Beauty! I'm beginning again. Hi. I met angels today! Yes I did! They Are Real. Yup! Between the Kindness of the Owner & her daughter, I'm returning from heavenly right now. She told me, she would try to get a food delivery to me & voila! She took some thoughtfulness, kindness & generosity from her heart & soon, my doorbell rings. Yup. I met her daughter next. I didn't know! I called her mom, "My angel!" She smiled & said, "That's my mom." I said, "You're both incredibly lucky & blessed." She smiled again, dazzling & said, "I know I am." Now, here, please note. Yes, she brought me my food. I asked if the next time she was in my hood, if she'd mind dropping me off a menu. She smiled as she left. "No problem!" About 5 bites later, my doorbell rings again. It was Dazzling angel. She has a pizza box & Menu in her hands. She said, "I forgot to bring you our Bread. I'm sorry. Here's our Menu & there are new items on it." Really my speedy brain jumps ahead to? OMG! More deliciousness to chose from?! Holy moly. She handed both to me, I opened pizza box & think I passed out! Face in Bread. Yumm. "No, I'm good. You go on ahead. Thanks tho lol." No! I'm Not suggesting that you have my week, nor my "luck"! No. I'm not saying that La Florentina can, nor should, nor would be capable of doing all this, all the time or even once again. But, holy freakin, try the food here! WoW! Yumm I ordered way too much food, leftovers. Yay! Thank goodness! Chicken in Mushroom Sauce. I'm gonna try including pics, but. Yea, well..... we shall see. Perfect! It's light, while filling. The flavors, partially due to great Ingredient Sourcing, partially cause food is prepared with love & of course, because putting chicken, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms & spinach over penne-Genius! It's Delicious! Bread. Like Focaccia, but more better imo! Besides being as light as air & as delicious as a dream. Yea. It's ok lol. Freakin Delish! Eggplant Rollatini. Spelling? sorry. Eggplant, mine was stuffed with mozzarella cheese & had some chicken stuffed inside too. The red sauce, gravy, tomato sauce-all same thing btw, in American - Italian speak, Outstanding. Is there such a thing as Simple & Complex, concurrently? Now there is! I got so lost in the gravy, I forgot what I was eating! My mind drifted sideways, to Florence, Venice, Rome & other places I've lived in & visited, in Italy. The flavors in this, the taste, that's what did this to me! It tastes like Home, childhood & happiness-all smooshed together! I'm about to cry now. Get it together Jolie! Ok! sorry. Tiramisu-Yup. I said it! OMG! I've been fantasizing about 2 things for a while now. Ok, maybe 4 lol. Hush you plz lol. I ordered 2 pieces! "Of course you did Jolie!" Yup! 1 for now & the other for breakfast! Yup & try it for breakfast, see how good your willpower is sometime, before ya knock it please. Holy moly this is Good. Every flavor Balances. I'm not kidding! It's just perfect is all. Yup. Great Jolie! Now there won't be any left for you anymore. That's ok. I share. Now for easy, but probably my hard fail part. Bringing in the pics! In zero way do my photos here (I hope they come. My pics. Hello lol) represent the incredible foods here. Just a "try" on my part. Overall, I can't Believe it's taken me this long, to find La Florentina! What is wrong with me?! Holy hell Batman?! Thank You Ladies, for making my heart so full, I cried “

“Savona's has several locations. The one I am reviewing is on Morton Blvd. I do occasionally stop in for a quick pie for a last minute dinner option. As all restaurants have lately, the prices have risen quite a bit. The pizza is ok. Like I said...its a last minute option for me. It is not the place I plan to dine in for an evening. There are several other pizza places that I prefer, but I am lazy sometimes and don't want to drive that far...haha“

“Only place around you can still get wings for less than a dollar each and they’re delicious. The pizza ironically is the worst thing about the place. Not very consistent ranging from pretty good to questionable but never inedible. The rest of the menu more than makes up for it though.“