50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Tuckahoe

“Friendly atmosphere & good food. You can go alone and sit at the bar. You'll always have someone to chat with.“

“I went with a group of friends for my birthday last night. It was AMAZING. The service was great, everyone was so friendly. The place itself was so clean and cute, really cool vibe. The Apps were great, Hush Puppies and Fried Calamari, yum. I did a make-your-own Seafood Boil. OH MY GOD. The New Zealand Mussels, King Crab and Dungeness Crab was out of this world in the Cajun Butter Sauce. I HIGHLY recommend this spot and will be going back.“

“The best around service is grestaff is friendly. Food is out of this world. Highly recommended“

“Food is very fresh and excellent. Our server, Sandy was very friendly and attentive to our needs“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Outstanding Service from Christina!

I had an amazing experience at Captain Loui thanks to Christina. From the moment we were seated, she was friendly, attentive, and professional. She made sure we had everything we needed, checked on us regularly, and provided excellent customer service throughout our meal.
Christina’s positive attitude and attention to detail truly stood out and made our dining experience even better. She was knowledgeable about the menu, patient with our questions, and went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect.
Employees like Christina are the reason customers like myself will keep coming back. She is a tremendous asset to Captain Loui and absolutely deserves recognition for her hard work and dedication. I highly recommend asking for Christina if you visit—she was amazing and definitely deserves a raise!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Thank you, Christina, for making our visit so enjoyable!“

“I went to a family friend’s 70th birthday party they hosted in the Atlantic ballroom. The space was modern and very clean. The food was DELICIOUS!!! And the workers, Yiselle, Estrellita, and Shorty (blonde) made the event so memorable! They paid attention to every detail, whether it was filling our water cups, collecting unused plates and of course they did it all with a warm smile. They were kind, funny and very welcoming. I had a wonderful time! Thank you Yiselle, Estrellita and shorty!!!“

“Great food & awesome service !!!“

“I've been visiting Johnny's for over 30+years. Today I went for a lobster roll which replaced the shrimp roll. last year this lobster was so delicious 😋 couldn't wait till the summer. unfortunately, I was highly disappointed. it is not longer on a garlic bun and now served on a plain hot dog bun :( also flavorless! last yr price was $24 and now up to $28 with no flavor and blah bun. please bring back the recipe from years before. thanks“

“I was there for Mother’s Day (had a reservation). The staff is friendly and very attentive. And the food was delicious. Will definitely try it again.“

“Calamares y cóctel delicioso“

“Oxtails, j*** wings, Rasta pasta es muy bueno. Cabbage, collards, rice and peas are great compliments to the mains..Prices are extremely reasonable and staff makes everyone feel welcome“

“Had lunch at Kee Oyster House today to celebrate a special occasion with my wife. Have been to Kee a few times and have always been impressed with the professionalism of the staff. Customers are treated very well and checked in with often. It was a great meal.“

“Fresh tasting seafood with excellent service in a warm and welcoming environment.“

“The service is great. Everyone is very nice and the food was delicious. Will be returning again. Thank you so much.“

“Drove 4 hours from Syracuse NY just for the stew chicken! Only to eat it in the car before I drove off 🤣 Safe to say, I went back inside for another dish 🤣🤣 5 ⭐️’s #ThaAuthor“

“Es un lindo lugar para compartir con la familia, los empleados son muy atentos y amable, la comida muy buena y llega a la mesa aún caliente 🔥, lo recomiendo 💯.“

“Amazing atmosphere, excellent service, great wine selection. The food is delicious, despite the small kitchen. It feels like a neighborhood spot that people from around the world have heard about — regulars and adventurers coming together for a great glass of wine and a sensuous vibe.

Harlem and France continue the special relationship they’ve had for 100 years with a spot like this.“

“Sat at the bar with my fiancé. We had a few Apps and drinks and enjoyed our favorite singer Johnny. After leaving
A generous 25% tip we discovered they had added 18% to the bill and never told us of this new policy. It’ll be awhile before we go back!“

“The best lobster roll around!!! Delicious shrimp cocktail!! Can’t go wrong….Super easy curbside pick up“

“Pleasantly surprised by how amazing this restaurant. I have passed it a millions times and never thought much about it. A coworker mentioned they had a good happy hour so I checked out their menu and decided we would try for dinner instead. From the minute you open the door you know it’s going to be good. Beautifully decorated, dimly lit, romantic & clean. We opted for the surf and turf and the swordfish - never imagined how generous the portions would be. The dishes were simple yet perfectly flavored. Our waiter Drini was kind and informative.
We will def be back!“

“I always come to this restaurant and they always have a variety of food the service is always immaculate Robert serves me during the night and he gives great vibration to your food Christine is the loveliest she always over extends and does her very best to please she has always served me depending her shift and I recently have gotten to know a new waitress Maria who is always lovely and kind when serving me she is very attentive and servicing a place to enjoy at all hours“

“The food was excellent. Thank you Earl. I will be back.“

“I tried to give this place the benefit of the doubt. The food is awful. Mozzarella sticks were frozen, Cajun fries, a handful of paprika drowned over the top Today beer that's normally $6 was $8 plus a $4 tip, tax and looking for another tip. Bill should have been $20 it's $30. Live with your wn failure. Don't put it on the customers. Pretty bartenders won't cover incompetence.“

“This place is a hidden gem. We were looking for place to make our go to spot. Once my foodie fiance tasted the catfish it was goto spot approved. The service is outstanding as they took very good care of us. The food is very tasty and nicely seasoned. We will be back.“

“I attended a surprise party this Saturday evening. The cuisine was preselected, waiter service was excellent, should receive raises. The table arrangement was very poor. The party was downstairs in one of the private rooms. We were 25 people at one very long table, basically the length of the room, which made it difficult for guests to get around the seated persons at the head of the table on either side. Having two tables would have been a better arrangement, but one long table was not conducive for conversation since we were so far from the other end of the table. The food; not many complaints, I really didn’t have a problem. I didn’t have a lot of food, but it was delicious. The dessert, sorry not very good. Those Famous Crepes(palacinkes) sorry not that great. A lot of crepe and not a lot of filling. The dish was served with fruit, unfortunately this fruit was not in season, so the watermelon although it added color to the dish, upon tasting it, left much to be desired. Why not serve fruit that is in season? No offense to my party hosts who selected my menu for the evening, it didn’t lend itself to the 5 Star Reputation of Dubrovnik’s. I would like to make reservations and splurge on a dinner on my own, I have a feeling I would LOVE the experience! Btw, another plus was the parking!“

“Best fried or steamed fish you will ever have from a store front. And seriously maybe the cheapest. My go to is the fried flounder sandwich, $5 today, sometimes $6 cash for two huge pieces depending upon market price. They give you the tarter and lemon and tons of other condiments and spices to put on yourself, just how you like it, before they neatly wrap it up and bag it for you. I always tip them two bucks. Been coming and thankful for them for the last 25 years when they used to be a block south. There are similar looking joints but none nearly as consistently good as Dyre Fish is. I have tried so many, hoping. It is the oil they dont allow to be used too long and the fresh fish picked up daily at Hunts Point Fish Market. And the prices have barely gone up in all that time.“

“Very good service. Food was very flavorful and had an overall great experience.“

“The food and service was amazing!“

“Top burger spot in NYC

Fast delivery and fresh taste

Must-try signature burgers

Loaded fries with flavor

Value for money

Satisfying burger experience

Consistently great food

Crowd favorite smash burgers“

“we ordered 2 orders of fried catfish, 1 with sweet potatoe fries and 1 with Mac&cheese, and also a side of collards. everything was made FRESH. crispy and delicious fish & fries, super cheesey Mac and the collards we're great! not the first or the last time I will order from here. reasonably priced for fish around here.“

“Prices were reasonable! Food was served quick and was delicious! Valet parking. Staff was pleasant.“

“Got my lobster roll before they close for the season. No problem about The hot sun the afternoon was extremely blustery. I’ve always loved this place even though it is pricey for a clam shack.“

“Great and affordable food. They did my wedding and all events for my family’s gathering. The owner and staff are very personable. Highly recommend it.“

“Go there often & always enjoy the beautiful ambiance & the delicious food! Service usually good as well. Definitely recommend it!“

“Honestly one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in a while. The food was incredible, especially the steak, but what really made the night stand out was the service. Everyone was so welcoming and attentive. The atmosphere was also super comfortable and made it easy to just relax and enjoy dinner. You can tell that Lenny and his staff really care about the experience they give their customers. Definitely a place we’ll be coming back to.“

“We were pleasantly surprised by the food. We asked our waiter if they had fried clams and he looked at us like we were crazy. He said he had no clue what we were talking about. We just chuckled and said it doesn’t matter. When we got our meal to share, we were shocked to see it being delivered in an anchor hocking glass baking dish 😂 The food was really good though 🙃“

“Gluten free people call early and ask for no crackers. �“

“I rarely write a review but I have been obsessed with Crab Du Jour since they opened in Harlem. My experience here has been delightful from the food to the friendly and attentive staff members who make customers feel right at home. If you are a seafood lover who’s in the mood for mouth-watering authentic Cajun dishes that won't break the bank, look no further than Crab Du Jour in Harlem; just steps away from the hustle and bustle of 125th Street. Their signature boils are an absolute must-try! They offer a variety of options like Crawfish, Shrimp, Snow Crab legs, Dungeness Crabs and Lobster Tail – all cooked to perfection! Each boil comes with potatoes and corn on the cob and your choice of classic garlic butter, lemon pepper, and the original Cajun or Crab du jour special, sauce. I usually add sausage to my boil; Yummy! Looking for something other than boils, there are plenty of choices! They offer dishes like po’ boys sandwiches which come with fried oysters or fried fish filets. My friend really likes the crispy chicken po’boy. They also offer fried shrimp baskets, or crab cake baskets, just to name a few. Regardless of what you choose off the menu here, you can be sure that it will be delicious and flavorful every single time!“

“Fresh fish every time. Everyone friendly. This is the only fish market I go to. The salmon with steam veggies is a must to have. I refer all my friends here and they love it as well. God check it out and see for yourself you won't regret it.“

“we ordered 2 orders of fried catfish, 1 with sweet potatoe fries and 1 with Mac&cheese, and also a side of collards. everything was made FRESH. crispy and delicious fish & fries, super cheesey Mac and the collards we're great! not the first or the last time I will order from here. reasonably priced for fish around here.“

“Great seafood in a fantastic location.“

“Came to this place to happy hour and had a wonderful experience! Non happy hour food was a bit overpriced but all of the food was delicious. Great margaritas as well!

Our waiter, Eury, was incredible and some of the best service I've ever received. He even let us have a second margarita with happy hour price after happy hour had ended. 10/10 experience I highly recommend it to anyone who's looking!“

“I have held several personal & business events at the Sailhouse. Excellent service & food yet again…Owner Sean is extremely accommodating & staff is attentive/professional. Highly recommend for parties or just a night out!“

“what a time capsule of a place! insane prices, hot + fresh food. nothing more i can ask for.

lots of people coming in and out; additionally a ton of ubereats / grubhub orders- but the service is quick! a sweet old korean couple run this spot with two other gentlemen manning the fryer where they fry the fish fresh.

their seafood deluxe combo is solid: fried shrimp, whiting fish (i subbed flounder for $1.75 more), imitation crab sticks, and scallop cakes. you have the option of fries or rice; their veggie rice is nice.

if you’re taking it to go, make sure to ask for some sauces on the side!

i need to try their chicken next time, but everyone that came in got seafood! they take card but cash is preferred.“

“Poke is VERY good! Yummy to my tummy :-)“

“A really nice place for breakfast chicharon... fresh food, big portions and very reasonable price, I also try other plates, all are good,specially jalea, xstuff are friendly, place is a little small but very cozy... I do recommend this place.“

“Came here with my mom, who is very very hard to please, and she left saying this is the best Italian she’s had in her 28 years in New York. Great portion sizes, prices, and very fresh ingredients. Could not recommend this place more!“

“This was one of the worst dining experiences I've ever had. Things were screwed up from beginning to end with absolutely no sense of apology or remorse. We had a 630 reservation, showed up on time, but we weren't seated until almost 7pm. The waiter came to our table for the first time at 720pm. We had researched the menu ahead of time to make sure there were kid friendly options, but since it was Mother's Day, they were operating with a different menu which is totally fine. We asked the waiter if they had any kid friendly food that wasn't on the menu and he said no and that all we can get is what's listed on the menu, so we went ahead and ordered. About 20 mins after we ordered, we saw that the kids at the table next to us were eating chicken fingers and french fries, so we asked the waiter why he didn't tell us about that option. He said that we didn't ask and he got a bit of an attitude about it. Luckily he was able to change our order and the kids got chicken tenders. We waited patiently for an incredibly long time for our food to come out, and at about 830, I got up and asked the waiter for an ETA on the food and he again gave me an attitude like I was ruining his night and he said "soon". The food came out about 2 minutes later, so we were hopefully going to get on with our evening. Upon further inspection, the chicken tenders that they delivered to my daughter were RAW. Not just slightly under cooked, completely raw, pink, cold chicken. We called the waiter over again and he again had an attitude when we sent the food back. Again, not even a hint of an apology to be found. When the chicken came back out, it was completely burnt, but we decided it wasn't worth the time to talk to the waiter about it again. At this point we had been at the restaurant for 2 hours with a 5 and 8 year old kid, so we just wanted to be done and get out. Again, at no point during this experience did a single person offer an apology or even show an ounce of remorse for how terrible the service was. They ruined my wife and mother-in-law's Mother's Day dinner and they should be ashamed to call themselves a restaurant. We are a local family, but we will never go back there again. I will also make it a point to tell everyone I know that Caffe Regatta is a terrible restaurant.“

“The variety isn't the best but I do understand they have to cater to the community. The majority of the staff is pleasant and so is the owner.
There is a sense of community here because they know their regular customers.
There is steaming and fried seafood available however, the fish soup is amazing.“