27 Best American Restaurants in Utica

“The food, the Staff and management were all great! I highly recommend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Sincerely one of the best steak sandwiches I’ve ever had in my life. And I’ve had a lot of steak sandwiches.“

“Delicious and unique sandwiches and salads! Love their daily fresh homemade soups and specials!!“

“We went for a Valentine’s dinner the night after Valentine’s Day. It was great. We got the 5 course Valentine Menu. It was phenomenal. I ordered the strip steak- cooked perfectly. My husband ordered the chicken saltimbocca- fantastic. The whole meal was enjoyable and great service.“

“Amazing food! Very friendly! Highly recommend!“

“Coolest beer!! Great people“

“ordered through doordash for lunch. was timely. delicious. got a single classic burger and cheese fries. so tasty and well prepared. the perfect amount of condiments.“

“Absolutely recommend tailor and the cook to anyone awesome staff drinks food amazing We will definitely be back ❤️❤️🍷🍷“

“The Tram is filled with amazingness altogether. if that’s even a word. Whether it be supporting artists of all kinds, out of their passion for art. Or their amazing food and drinks! (best hot chocolate ever, by the way). And kind and hardworking staff! They have created a warm, welcoming, and supportive environment for all. Utica is beyond lucky to have a business like them around!!“

“One of our go-tos!! Great food every time! Can’t go wrong with the duck entree!“

“Subs are great, fresh, and great portions. Excellent customer service! I just found my new lunch spot 😊“

“Eating at Ocean Blue is always a wonderful experience. Only one small issue- it's the first time I ordered a soup, my wife ordered a salad. They came out at the same time as the entree. We would have much preferred having the opportunity to finish our soup and salad prior to being served our entree.“

“Food was out of this world. Always the best. Thank you!“

“Friendly staff and awesome food. Luv this place.“

“I live in NC these days but whenever I’m here a dinner at The Willows is mandatory. Not only is the food exceptional but the staff is great.“

“It’s new building beautifully decorated. And just opened food excellent“

“Love this place. I Never had a bad meal. The staff are pleasant. I go on my 30 minute lunch. I have time to eat and drive back to work. Today I had a tuna sandwich and a bowl of Homemade New England Clam Chowder. The tuna was white albacore (amazing) and the soup was delish. Prices are reasonable. I really didn't want to write this review as I am now afraid they will get busier and I will have to call my orders in but it is well deserved.“

“We made a last minute reservation because we had to change venues for a picky eater. We were celebrating my MIL's birthday. She had the ribeye and loved it. That's all that really mattered. We also ordered the burger, a pizza, chicken francaise and Tuscan chicken. Everything was delicious. We were early so the place wasn't too busy and the service was top notch! The waitress surprised us with a dish of ice cream with a sparkler in it for the birthday girl. It was so awesome! Great service!“

“Good was great, Hot, Fresh..“

“If you have never been to Castlewood Cafe, now is the time! With higher prices and decreasing quality and every popular chain, Castlewood continues to offer their large menu, with same quality products! They have not changed that in this economy! My family chooses Castlewood over all the restaurants in this area! What’s more, the friendly smiles and excellent waiting staff! I strongly recommend this small mom and pop diner that has a menu to satisfy everyone, even the pickiest of eaters!“

“Very good food. My gf and I just started going here. It's our 2nd time. The breakfast is amazing. And very good priced. $12 for a 2 eggs, meat, hasbrowns or home fries and toast. Can't beat that. Best prices in the area. Can deff bring the family there and not empty the pocket like other diners in the area.

Girlfriend is very picky about her food especially her eggs. They've come out perfect over medium eggs both times. Great staff, service is great and very friendly people. Even the cook and dishwasher always have a smile on their faces and actually pay attention to the customers.

9/10/24 UPDATE. Lunch did not disappoint either. Gf got a Rachel (Turkey and Cole Slaw Ruben...by special request) (also at no additional cost and was able to change the rye bread to italian) amazing. And for $11.33 served with a pretty big serving of fries. I got a 1/3lb Daves Burger also amazing. $11.00. I added bacon and cheese for a $13.95 total. With sodas my bill was just under $33. Very affordable for 2 people to eat. Will deff keep coming back.“

“Great food, reasonable prices, and relaxed atmosphere. Will return next time we are in town. Highly recommend!“

“Haven't been to a Denny's in a long time. They've remodeled since the last time I was here. Quiet. Clean. The food was spot on. I love when it's exactly what I'm craving. Runny eggs with toast and bacon. If those eggs aren't just right, it can be a let down. But it wasn't.“

“Good food, especially the Riggies. Service is always great. Nice place for a night cap or playing games with friends!“

“Food was good for me. Service was slow but waitresses were doing a good job keeping everyone informed and plenty to drink. Atmosphere is good just like others just seemed a little more low key than most.

Parking: Parking close is decent. It's shared with other stores thus parking is everywhere. There is enough parking for 2 or 3 CDL truck and trailers also“

“Had a nice meal with my daughter today. Our server, Jason R was fantastic. Start to finish went above and beyond for us. The food was very good as well. Thank you!“