39 Best American Restaurants near Hartville

“I went in the restaurant to try some of the cream pies and wow were they amazing!!! I think the baker was a young woman who was blonde with blue eyes, who I owe my upmost respect to. Can't wait to come back soon for more of the delicious handmade baked goods!!!“

“Good food , nice atmosphere, friendly service. I think that there would be more people eating here if the outside of the building would be fixed up since it is a historical building.“

“Great food and wonderful staff“

“Food was great. Service was better. Appetizers were a good portion size, Burgers and the special of the day rated highly. Bourbon selection was nice too.“

“Wow! Cozy space and great food with friendly service! Don't sleep on the homemade desserts!“

“It’s a relatively small mom & pop shop. I took my 5 kids in and the staff was amazing with us all coming. The food is exceptional. Portions are good, prices are reasonable. They have great choices. I just had to go back with my husband who was also pleasantly surprised that all of his favorites are on the menu. I highly recommend. 5 stars all around

Kid-friendliness: I have 5 kids. 8, 6, 18 months, and twin 6 week olds. Staff was so great! They were happy to see us all, instead of annoyed we were there.“

“We had Landrey as our server and she was phenomenal!! She is the sweetest! If you go and she's working, definitely request her! Lizzy is also amazing. She wasn't our server but she still took care of us as if she was. I love this place!“

“My sisters and I went to eat last night for the first time, definitely going back! The food was fantastic, the owner and his waitress were so kind and such lovely people. The ribs fell off the bone and the sides were delicious. So yummy!“

“Our first time here! Very enjoyable and lots to pick from. Great service! Yummy special dessert.“

“We've been coming here for yrs especially on Fridays we switch between the ayce fish dinners to the he-man breakfast, and the girls that are waitresses are always cheerful and delightful, the food is always delicious and reasonable priced its a local favorite and I also recommend the fried mushrooms, you won't be disappointed sincerely The Puchalski's“

“Let's start with our server Cheryl so friendly and made sure we had everything we needed. From the white french dressing to the new Cider chicken with caramelized onions and a perfectly cooked ribeye it was all delicious! Hubby had to have a piece of cheesecake w/ freshly made raspberry puree, he had to end up sharing...it was sooo good.“

“Great food , great prices , beautiful building inside and out !! Must try“

“Tried them for dinner for the first time yesterday. Freaking Amazing! There was magic in that hummus!“

“First time in… everything was amazing !! Our server (David), our drinks and meals - all outstanding!! Can’t wait to come back!“

“The staff was FANTASTIC!!! Amber (our waitress) was so quick and friendly!!“

“I visited Jane’s today for the first time. Had Coney and Macaroni salad. The food was amazing. I ordered Macaroni Salad to go and was disappointed when I went to eat it and it was a tiny salad dressing cup and not the portion size I had for “

“We come out every Wednesday for trivia and a good meal! But our server Nicole makes it the best!! We get her every week and she’s the best ever! Definitely our favorite server ever!!“

“Beers & beers & lots more beers.. If you want liquor; they have that too!!“

“They allow patrons and staff to tamper with food and throw food. charge different prices then rerings to takes the extra $2“

“We had a great dinner tonight and lots of fun with our server, Susan. We had the Crab Rangoon Pizza (special), Halibut (special), and Blackened Chicken Risotto. We had a Peanut Butter Bomb for dessert (always delicious). There were two of us. We ate a lot. It had been a while since our last visit and we're glad we gave them another shot.“

“Truly an authentic, legitimate, professional establishment that delivers exactly upon what it promises in a measured and classy way. Many places over promise and under deliver or focus on more on schtick than substance, not 91. If you desire something higher end they have you covered, if you are in the mood for more casual they have your back too. & It's the little things that can impress you also.

For example they cut the greens in their Caesar Salad to an appropriate size such that they are easily placed upon your fork and don't cascade all over the place while you're trying to enjoy them during dinner conversations either by needing to macerate them yourself or look like a heifer calf trying to eat from a bale of long stemmed alfalfa hay.

Great wine list (Tuesday specials appreciated), maybe the Craft Beer list could use a little "bump" but you can walk across the parking lot for that if really a priority. The Old Fashions are spot on and well crafted also.

Great communication from the staff and management also, exceedingly great service without being in your grill all the time.

Thanks for being a part of the community.“

“We visited on Mothers day. I had the cheesy potato and smoked sausage breakfast. Everything was delicious, the cheesy potatoes pairs perfectly with smoked sausage. Generous portions and fast friendy service. Samantha's really does have fabulous big breakfast meals!“

“Their food is Amazing, good size portions.“

“It was delicious!!! First time!!! Just tried the chicken sandwich!!!! Definitely will be back!!!“

“OH Culver's! It's better than Wendy's. It was born from Wisconsin. It's a midwestern popular joint. The concrete mixers are the best frozen custard I've had from a fast food place. Yes, it's better than Dairy Queen. The crinkle fries are better than Raising cane's. The spicy chicken sandwich is better than Wendy's. There is veggie burger option. And cheese curds. The butter burgers are fresh never frozen meat and they are smashed on the grill. You can order a triple bacon deluxe. There are also chicken tenders, Culver's root beer float, and their fish are not frozen. They flour them and put it in the fryer. They also have salads. Many options. Culver’s has very high standards, quality, and clean place. The front of the house brings the food to you in the dining room. Wow what a casual fast food place.“

“Great soup and the best burgers around!“

“I have been visiting this diner for over 10 years. I do not know one person's name! I love fresh food, so I come back over and over. There was one young lady highschooler she stands out of all my visits. The kids call it the senior citizens Cafe. They are not rude, just not personable. Food is usually great. They do have flies, especially in the corner booth near the window, the same side as the cash register in the opposite corner, so avoid that seat.

Kid-friendliness: The patrons love behaved little children and tolerate unbehaved ones. The diner welcomes all

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a section more open for wheelchairs may struggle in restroom and entrance if wider chair“

“I ate here about a month ago after visiting the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Their prices were so reasonable, and the staff was very friendly. I will eat here again if I'm ever in the area again. Loved it“

“Best Wings and Ribs … Ever“

“Great local family doing great things in Tallmadge! Great food!“

“Super Awesome Breakfast!! GREAT SERVICE!! Fantastic Prices!! You need to come here!!!“

“So delicious! Great staff!“

“My husband and I recently, 5/21/2023, stopped in for lunch. The food we ordered [Breaded AZ Cauliflower, Salad Steak & Blue, Soup Potato Lovers Bowl & 10 Wings] were all amazing!!! Want to give a shout out to our server Grier. Thank your for our very pleasant experience and excellent customer service! Grier, was very friendly, helpful, informative & attentive, without being over-bearing. Keep up the great work. We will be back and request you as a server!“

“Tried this place on referral from nearby motel and an appetizer discount -GLAD WE DID. Business is modern style pub/bar. Wait staff Sava could not have been more attentive or helpful. Wife & I split the Chicken Little sandwich; could easily have shared amongst 3 persons -HUGE.“

“Great food fast service. Steak and eggs was good steak was tender“

“Went here for date night and had the best experience. Kara, our waitress was phenomenal. She had great conversations with us and gave excellent menu recommendations. All of the staff was very friendly when arriving and departing. We will definitely come back, thank you Kara!!“

“This place is great! I would highly recommend it!!“

“My family really enjoyed ourselves today at Mission Bbq. The food was so delicious and the staff was beyond friendly and welcoming. We definitely found a new family favorite spot!“