29 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mentor

1 Ice Cream On the Greens

4.7 Superb 167 Reviews

8957 Lakeshore Boulevard, Mentor

• Take-Out

“I reached out through Google. A very nice person talked to me until we could find an ice cream flavor which didn’t have gluten, milk, nor coconut oil/milk. They ordered “non dairy blue sky” as a new flavor because we as GF DF people couldn’t have any others. I mean, come on guys, this is the ultimate good customer service. My heart swells in gratitude for a fabulous summer thanks to them! It was our first season after being diagnosed with food sensitivities, and you made it so much better with the acquiring of the flavor + awesome portions!!! God bless!!!”

2 Crumbl

4.7 Superb 394 Reviews

9662 Mentor Avenue, Mentor

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Crumbl gets a solid 4.5/5 stars always. We usually dislike at least one of their flavors which is unfortunate but not enough to take away stars because we enjoy so many of them. The flavor we disliked recently was the root beer cookie and it's expensive to not like it but I go for my kids. They enjoy the experience.”

3 FroYo Twist Soft Serve & Bubble Tea

4.7 Superb 149 Reviews

7267 Center Street, Mentor

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“OMGGGG! The FROZEN YOGURT IS AMAZING!!! I HAVE TO GO AT LEAST TWICE A WEEK! Tart flavor is amazing, vanilla, strawberry, pistachio! All of them! I love adding gummy bears, coconut, nuts ..I put a lot of toppings on mines lol You will not regret going!”

4 East Coast Original Frozen Custard

4.1 Good 226 Reviews

7577 Mentor Avenue, Mentor

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Best frozen custard we’ve ever had—creamy goodness!!! The dipped waffle cone didn’t fail to impress either-plenty of thick chocolate on the rim. Will definitely be back!!!”

5 Café Panda

4.6 Superb 87 Reviews

7850 Mentor Avenue Suite 874, Mentor

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Tons of great things at the market. Food is super yummy. Royal mango parfait in the mall is a must!”

6 Del Monti's Italian Eats

4.7 Superb 18 Reviews

7850 Mentor Avenue Ste 356, Mentor

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Besides a family owned and ran business, Del Monti's has freshest and authentic Italian pizzas, gelato, pastries and more. The amount you get and the excellent service, is abundant, and the prices are amazingly low as well. Their Margherita Pizza, Meatball Sub, Chicken Parm Sub, Meatball Cup, Rigatoni, Gelato and Peach Iced Tea (Real Italian, even the Iced Tea), are the delicious items I have tried so far and absolutely love. Take a moment and go get a taste of Real Italian food from them, just in Mentor, up the road.”

7 Dairy Queen® / Orange Julius

3.7 Good 165 Reviews

7695 Lakeshore Boulevard, Mentor

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“I have been coming to this Dairy Queen since I was three and it's been a staple in Mentor on the lake and I just have to say they have been fantastic and the manager just did the kindest thing and I'm not going to explain why but she was awesome and I want everybody to know that they need to go there they're Putt-Putt courses awesome their ice cream is awesome their hot dogs and their pretzel sticks are awesome and the manager is so sweet you guys all need to go there and support this local establishment!”

8 DQ Grill & Chill Restaurant

3.1 Average 223 Reviews

9575 Diamond Centre Drive, Mentor

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“We thought we would try this DQ again because last time was not so good. Now that it has been taken over by a new owner we tried again. We did the drive thru and placed our order. One regular double with all that it comes with and one bacon double burger with lettuce, tomato and ketchup only. One large fry and a regular onion ring order. When we got to the window and paid we were told to pull ahead, it would be a little time. 10 minutes later we were headed home. Besides having to warm everything, the bacon double had lettuce, tomato, ketchup AND pickles, mayo,and onion! The regular double was made properly. So why the 10 minute wait for two regular menu item burgers we wondered? The fries seemed like they could have been cooked a little more but the onion rings were crunchy and very generous. After removing the unwanted additions from the bacon burger it was very tasty. The regular double was also tasty. We may try them again in the future because they were certainly better than our last visit with other owner but they need to get the order right and not take 10 minutes to get it wrong.”

9 Fairport Harbor Creamery

4.8 Superb 207 Reviews

202 High Street, Fairport Harbor · 7.04 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Vegan chocolate ice cream is perfection. Smooth, creamy, chocolately and dare I say better than dairy ice cream. It exceeded my expectations!”

10 Jerry's Dari-Pride

4.7 Superb 220 Reviews

30136 Euclid Avenue, Wickliffe · 7.17 miles

• Take-Out

“EXCELLENT!!! [Original] EXCELLENT!!!”

11 La Flor Michoacana Paleteria & Neveria

4.9 Superb 85 Reviews

1248 High Street Ste 4, Fairport Harbor · 6.2 miles

“Delicious!! Such an unexpected treat!”

12 Mmm...Yummy

4.7 Superb 72 Reviews

76 South Park Place, Painesville · 6.39 miles

“The Dubai chocolate crepes are insanely good! This is such a cute little place. Highly recommend!”

13 CP's Cooler Homemade Ice Cream & Treats

4.5 Superb 210 Reviews

32433 Vine Street, Willowick · 6.28 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“best place ever. all the unique flavors are spot on 😎”

14 Kirtland Creamery

4.5 Superb 167 Reviews

9304 Chillicothe Road, Kirtland · 3.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Ice cream was amazing!! Honestly best i ever had! But the people there kept just starring us, like if they had never seen a Mexican before, i felt uncomfortable while eating my ice cream😔 didnt feel comfortable at all”

15 Little Mountain Creamery

4.5 Superb 85 Reviews

7872 Crile Road, Concord · 5.24 miles

“First time. it was fantastic! We will be back!”

16 Crumbl

4.7 Superb 277 Reviews

1241 SOM Ctr Road, Mayfield Heights · 10.9 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I love this store. Everything that comes out of it is delicious. The staff is amazing , always courteous and friendly. I usually do preorders and it’s always ready or just about ready when I get there. Couldn’t be happier with this Crumbl store!!”

17 Catonas

4.6 Superb 27 Reviews

2000 North Ridge Road, Painesville · 9.12 miles

• Delivery

“Catered pur wedding and the food was absolutely amazing. Got many compliments and inquiries from our guests about who catered our food! Couldn't have asked for more in anyway! Wonderful experience and we will definitely be using for all our future events! Thank you Tami!!”

18 Blu Bee Cafe

4.7 Superb 147 Reviews

1493 Mentor Avenue, Painesville · 4.07 miles

• Delivery

“Delicious desserts and great atmosphere ☕️🍰”

19 Crumbl

4.6 Superb 280 Reviews

36001 Euclid Avenue Unit 2, Willoughby · 5.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I love this location but at certain times of the day. During the day the customer service is on point!!! But evening / night it’s trash. The younger employees be needing home training before they get a job because their customer service sucks. But anywho during the day, I love this location and the cookies!”

20 Valley Villa Custard

4.2 Good 87 Reviews

8200 Mayfield Road, Chesterland · 9.94 miles

“Valley Villa is one of those rare ice cream places that has truly perfected the Turtle Sunday, as well as many, many more. My favorite part about Valley Villa Custard has been the new renovations and evolving menu, always coming up with innovations in the industry with a strong staff to support. Bravo Valley Villa, best of luck this Summer.”

21 East Coast Custard

4.2 Good 176 Reviews

6 Fairfield Road, Painesville · 3.41 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“love the chocolate or vanilla custard. you can see it being made while standing in line”

22 Angelo's Pizzeria & Ice Cream

4.2 Good 239 Reviews

8162 Euclid Chardon Road, Kirtland · 5.72 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We stop here every time we’re in the area for pizza and ice cream and have always left happy and with full bellies. Love the decor, prompt service, and excellent food. Worth a stop for any family on their way back from Lakefarm Park, Holden, or apple picking.”

23 JoJo’s Creamery

4.0 Good 123 Reviews

38700 OH-283, Willoughby · 3.52 miles

“We got our daughter an ice cream birthday cake. It was amazing and everyone thought it was delicious.”

24 Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

4.0 Good 126 Reviews

1249 SOM Ctr Road, Mayfield Heights · 10.91 miles

• Delivery

“Go see Reid and Shayla ASAP”

25 Dairy Queen

3.9 Good 135 Reviews

2008 Mentor Avenue, Painesville · 3.12 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Quick drive through service. great food, friendly employees.”

26 Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

4.3 Superb 274 Reviews

34600 Euclid Avenue, Willoughby · 6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“The custom cakes here are incredible. I had my daughter’s “camping” theme bday cake made here. She really wanted an ice cream cake, but I wasn’t sure if DQ was going to be able to do the design I wanted. I brought my ideas, photos and accessories. And let me tell you! The service I received from Belinda was better than some high end bakeries I’ve used for other events. She was so detail oriented and made sure everything was just how I wanted it, even following up with text reminders and questions. And the design was THE ABSOLUTE CUTEST!!! So happy with my experience here and very impressed !”

27 Sweet Street

4.2 Good 46 Reviews

29348 Euclid Avenue, Wickliffe · 8.03 miles

• Take-Out

“great pies!!! will be placing another order!!!!”

28 Dairy Queen / Orange Julius

4.2 Good 102 Reviews

108 Wilson Mills Road, Chardon · 8.84 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Great staff and great ice cream. Always a wonderful experience!”

29 Fire & Ice

4.2 Good 109 Reviews

970 Riverside Drive, Painesville · 7.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“absolutely disgusting. peppers soggy,pizza soggy,coney dogs soggy..sauce was suppose to be on the side..never ever again”