10 Best Ice Cream Shops in Sandusky

“Stopped here on the way back to Michigan from Cedar Point. If you have never been to Tofts, you really need to experience it!! So many choices from ice cream to milkshakes to malts, to sundaes. Portion sizes are extremely generous (a single scoop is actually 4 scoops). It was crowded when we were there but the line moved quickly. The staff was extremely nice and my family had a wonderful experience. I will definitely be back.“

“This is my favorite go to spot it’s delicious and clean and staff is friendly. The only thing I would change is that they’d open up another store in vermilion/amherst so we could enjoy it more often. I feel like it would thrive this way considering there’s no other froyo near by! Might be something to look into.“

“Crazy awesome portion sizes and even better service plus a huge range of flavors = must stop every time we are in town!!“

“I tried this place by chance on a trip as I live a few counties over. I got two flurries for my toddler and me and it was roughly $11. I thought that was a bit steep, but listen… there HUGE! And they were delicious. I got a strawberry cheesecake and loved it. The workers were nice and considering how busy the drive through was (seems to be super popular), they prepped our order really fast. They do accept card. They have seating on a covered patio. I didn’t see any hard scoop options but I may have just not noticed it. Only two complaints are that it’s close to the road, which if you have a small one isn’t ideal… also the patio needed cleaned better. Because of the debris there were so many bees that we had to go eat in the car. These are typical issues for ice cream stands though, minor problems. Definitely can see why this location seems so popular.“

“Golly Gee is my go to to get my blue goo fix. Nothing can compare! Flavorburst is an understatement, it will take your taste buds on a wild ride. Blue goo addiction aside, Golly Gee has a wonderful staff and delicious menu. They use quality items in all of their eats and treats and I couldn’t recommend them enough. A MUST visit for a treat from your wildest dreams.“

“We stopped while we were on vacation and it was amazing!! Staff was super nice and everything tasted amazing. We will definitely stop again the next time we are in Sandusky.“

“Food was excellent and service was great! Highly recommend.“

“I haven't been here in over 2 decades, since I lived in the area, basically. And their ice cream did NOT disappoint. We all ordered a different flavor and tried each other's as well. We enjoyed them all! I know I got the Brown Bourbon Truffle Butter, my husband got Superman, my youngest daughter got Strawberry Cheesecake, my eldest daughter decided she'd rather have a BTS poster ??‍♀️?, and my son got Strawberry. Can't wait to try some Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake, Buckeye, Coconut Almond, Peach Raspberry or a Taco next time ? Service was fast and friendly. It was very clean inside the building. There are benches along the farthest wall from where you choose your flavor. But no other seating. Plenty of seating out front though. And plenty of parking too. They sell souvenirs like hats and visors for $15, calendars for $4.50, bobbleheads for $8 and shirts for between $17, $26 and $35 depending on the style. They also sell grocery items like milk and bread, but I'm not sure about prices for souvenirs or groceries. Bathroom was very clean.“

“On the way from Cedar Point last night. You could tell the staff was tired, but they just smiled and made sure all the orders were filled. Great location. Great crew.“

“Usually a quick stop for some good food en route for Cedar Point. The pricing is very competitive for full meals and dessert, which I definitely appreciate if I’m picking up for a number of people. Over the years, I really can’t think of any egregious mistakes. It may not be as quick as some fast food chains, but it is far more satisfying.I have just had the best experience ordering a birthday ice cream cake there. Pics will be posted if it is allowed.“