34 Best American Restaurants near Smithville

“We decided to stop in on our way down to Wooster. We had lunch and then treated our ourselves to their ice cream. Everything was extremely fresh and tasty and the staff was exceptional!! Definitely a great find! The best part is that it’s family owned! Highly recommend!!“

“Been there many times over the years. Always a treat. Beats a noisy Sports Bar any day !“

“My husband and I ate at the Ugly Duck last Friday. Let me tell you it was so good. The mushrooms for our appetizer and an absolutely delicious pizza were spot on. Our server was friendly and very attentive. We'll definitely be back.“

“Great food and great service! The prices were decent for the amount of food that you get! We will be back!“

“We booked TJ's to cater for our wedding and we were absolutely blown away! Their customer service is beyond stellar and their service was outstanding. We had our guests choose between the Lemon Basil Chicken and Manicotti and multiple guests said it was the best food they've ever had at a wedding! Rachel went above and beyond to help make sure our day went smoothly and that my husband and I were taken care of at all times! Their staff was so kind. Everything about our experience with TJ's was so awesome and I would recommend them to every couple looking for a wedding caterer!“

“Such great food, I got the Lackawanna and white bread toast. Very filling and delicious!“

“Very friendly staff! Ian was a blast!!! Thank goodness he mentioned they use peanut oil due to allergies! The cook was great as well, sorry I didn’t catch her name. Place was very clean and the food was beyond amazing!!!
We ordered a chicken teriyaki sub and a cheesesteak and fries.“

“Tried the pork watermelon tacos today at the food truck festival. the food was unbelievably delicious. Unfortunately, the girl working the window taking orders was unbelievably rude and her service were enough to not want to go back. I hope that in the future, they change the service approach as the food was amazing.“

“I went there today for the first time, I've read the reviews, some good and some not so good. But I had a great meal and my friend did too. Plenty of food, our server Ricky was wonderful, one of the best servers I've ever had. Everyone was very friendly. The place was very clean and a nice atmosphere. I would definitely go again.“

“Had an amazing time. After working 40 hours in the past 3 days, I was so hungry, drained, and I'm still in my work clothes. My waitress Cy is amazing at her job. Very professional, attentive, kind, and polite. 11/10 customer service Cy!“

“Passing through Wooster and tried Farmer Boy for breakfast based on their Google reviews. My wife and I both had omelets and they were delicious! Their shredded hash browns were very tasty as well. Great food, decent prices, awesome service, and a clean comfortable atmosphere make Farmer Boy a gem; we will be back as we have family in the area.“

“Mother's Day Brunch was a very pleasant experience. Delicious food, prompt courteous attentive service. We were seated near the kitchen and it was such a please to watch the choreographed interaction within the kitchen, the chef was very much in charge, very verbal and there was also non verbal communication amongst the staff. You could tell they had worked together for a while. I could not express how enjoyable the meal and experience was. You can see than the owners put an emphasis on training and the staff enjoyed working there.“

“Food was so-so. Loaded baked potato was good.
Salad was very small/skimpy.
Steak was really not quality, especially for a ribeye. Would have not said anything except that my companion and I had ordered ours medium and they were way overdone.
Mentioned to waitress who got Manager, who got us new ones, including new sides. There were many apologies from both. I couldn't have asked for a better resolution.
Waitress was great throughout, and manager truly cared.
Will be back!“

“Lisa showed us to our table and went out of her to find my husband a cushion for his back. Colleen waited on us, and she was pleasant and knowledgeable. Drinks were good, and I had the best fish sandwich I have had in years. My hubby enjoyed his mussels, and the beet salad we split was fresh and well balanced. We drove from Medina, and we will not hesitate to return to this laidback, well run cafe. Besides, I need to save room for dessert!“

“Stopped here for supper. WOW!!! Nice atmosphere. Food Very Good. Waitress made sure our glasses were filled and checked on us several times. Well worth the money. Will be going back there.“

“The team from Old Carolina Barbecue Company were at our venue again last night and as usual provided stellar service. This was the second time this summer. In June catering was provided by Joseph, Gavin, Chase and Abby, and last night we had Tanner, Shannon, Chase and Abby. Both times they were timely, efficient and professional, and also added extra services like moving things around to serve appetizers outside, cutting and serving multiple cakes and leaving the kitchen spotless! All these things from a venue's perspective are so important. From the guests' perspective, of course, is the question "was the food good?" Yes it was! So good! They received many compliments. Great job guys! Thanks again!“

“Awesome food and great service. Taylor was wonderful and made our dinner enjoyable.“

“The food was good and the staff were very friendly and nice. I should now because I am ten:)“

“Enjoyed their service and meal“

“Definitely a great place to eat! Food is amazing and the staff are wonderful!“

“delicious food as we love it as blesses this restaurant as friendly ... rates 10 .“

“Stopped by for lunch today as a last day of school celebration! Ordered burgers and a sub. Delicious! Excellent and friendly service.“

“I stopped by Bishops this afternoon for a late lunch/early dinner. I had been craving their onion rings for quite some time but had been reluctant to stop; we ordered from there about a year ago and didn't have a great experience with the quality of food.
So today, I decided to give it another try under the new ownership. I'm so glad I did!
I was promptly seated by a friendly staff member. My server was very quick to take my drink and food order. I decided on a grilled chicken sandwich, coleslaw, and half & half (half fries, half onion rings). It took all but 10 mins for the food to come out fresh and piping hot. I must say, the chicken sandwich was so good and flavorful. The best part is, the onion rings were just as I remembered them from when I was a kid and Bishops was located on Cleveland Road. The only negative thing (and I do mean ONLY) is that the fries were a little heavily seasoned, which was very salty. However, in their defense, I forgot to ask them not to add any salt to anything.

Overall, this was a great choice. I left satisfied with both the food and the cost of my meal. I'm so happy that the onion rings turned out as good as they were originally. I will definitely be back!“

“Great food! Clean! our server was fantastic! Good prices!“

“The Funnel Fries are my favorite! 5/5“

“I ate at Bob Evans today 6/28/23 about 5 pm. When i got there it didnt look to crowded. They had one server a guy, I didn't get his name, he told me but I forģot Within 5 minutes 4 more couples and a party of 5 came it. He was awesome, he had everyone taken care of and kept checking on everybody. He will go places, he is great with the public. Thanks again young man.“

“Atmosphere, food, service a great experience. Husband and I went for a nice dinner and this place was exactly what we wanted. Recommend and will go back on our next Amish Country trip.“

“We had not been to an Applebee's in many years and they honestly did an amazing job and the food was incredible. We had a gift card and decided to stop in for a quick bite to eat and definitely glad we did the burgers there are amazing and my girlfriend got the back and cheese with with some honey pepper chicken tenders on top and it was absolutely phenomenal. Our server also did a great job especially considered they were very busy that day.“

“Great Girls Breakfast! Fun time!“

“Steak was cooked wrong but that was the only issue with our food and they made it right for us. Building definitely needs an update as most Red Lobsters do. Service was excellent our server Alexis was fantastic and very friendly and helpful!!!“

“I recently ordered a 7.5" Cheese Steak Deluxe Hero Sub, a Small Fresh Cut Fry, and a Small Mr. Pibb / Dr. Pepper. It was all pretty great. I would order these items again. It was prepared and handed off quickly. I particularly liked the rather nostalgic artwork / photos framed on the walls.“

“Stopped in to have lunch and the food was AMAZING!!! Our waitress was also very nice definitely recommend this place we will be back 🙂👍“

“Overall this restaurant brings a calm, community style atmosphere. Service is generally satisfactory, and the food is made as it should be. If there is any issue with your food just ask them to correct it and there shouldn't be any issue. I hate to say that its plain jane, but sometimes thats what you want for consistency.“

“The was good but definitely could have been better. I had the chips and salsa as a starter. The salsa was good, and the chips were fresh. I was here on Thursday for their BOGO Boneless Wings. I ordered a 10 piece giving me a total of 20 wings, so I chose 4 different sauces. I had the Nashville Hot, Mango Habanero, Carribean Jerk, and Spicy Garlic. The wings were decent size and all very flavorful. The one issue was that some of the wings weren't coated that well in sauce and had areas with no sauce on them, I choose not to complain after all they should know how to properly coat the wings. My server Tonya was great she was very attentive and made sure my drink was full and I had everything I needed.“