8 Best American Restaurants near Milton

“Had a great experience tonight thanks to Kaitlyn! The restaurant was extremely busy and they were clearly dealing with a difficult night, including being short on a few items and supplies, but Kaitlyn handled everything incredibly well.

We had a large family group and she stayed friendly, attentive and positive the entire time. She kept checking on us, made sure we were comfortable, explained what was happening, and did everything she could to accommodate us despite how overwhelmed the restaurant was.

You can really tell when someone genuinely cares about doing a good job, especially when things aren’t going smoothly around them. Kaitlyn was fantastic and deserves some recognition for how she handled tonight. Thank you!“

“Great time tonight out at East Side Mario’s. A big part of that was our fantastic service. From top to bottom, everyone who checked on our table was great but our main server Shay was super. Keep up the great work. Will definitely recommend.“

“1 was there on vacation with daughter and grandkids, and visited the restaurant because the food looked delicious, and it was but my grand daughter got sick that evening continuous vomiting and stomach and had to rushed to Urgent care after spending $300 on the meal which wasn't a problem, the wrong order was brought out first I was very disappointed, Don't know if I would visit again( I really don't think the shrimp were cooked correctly.“

“Best place to go for Karaoke on thursday nights! Always a great vibe and such a fun group of people“

“What a fabulous place for lunch!!! Our server was sweet and professional, competent and not intrusive.

We opted for the soup and salad and it did not disappoint!!! We would highly recommend this place any time you are downtown Milton!“

“July 3, 2026

The food at this location was genuinely good, and I would gladly give it a positive review based on my experience.

However, customer reviews should be earned—not rewarded. Offering a free item in exchange for a 5-star review undermines the credibility of online ratings, even when the food and service deserve praise.

Ask customers for honest feedback—not five stars. Let quality earn the rating, not the reward.

Thanks“

“Went in late night, because they're supposed to be open 24 hours. Girl at the counter said they only do online and phone orders at this time (about 245am). I asked for clarification that if I go out to my car and use my phone to order something, then it's ok but not with me standing right there. She said that was correct. "Open" sign was on, door was unlocked and there was food. I left because it wasn't worth the silliness.“

“best wings and pizza deal 😋“