40 Best Pizza Restaurants in Erie

“We have had pizza (and other things) from here…. Both times: AMAZING!! My husband and I vote: best pizza in Erie! Another perk- staff is so friendly! Yumm! 💯🍕“

“All of the food I have tried is amazing ? ?pie is always on point and love trying all the flavors!“

“This grocery is like art work....the best grocery store I have ever seen in my life... I need to come visit home more for this store 😊“

“9.20.24 While traveling around the US from our home in CO, we stopped at the Erie store. Wow, it is outstanding. The quality, selection, variety of prepared meals and OMG the bakery. In addition the store design is attractive, staff is friendly and the store and restrooms are spotless. Other stores could learn a thing or two about how a grocery store experience should be. I ask you, have you ever seen parking spaces reserved for expecting moms, or flowered in the man’s bathroom. Golly I love it!!“

“Literally been eating Patti's since I was 2!!! Everytime I come home, 1st thing I do is Order!!! Still as Great as it was when I was a baby!!! So Happy U remain a Staple of Erie!!!!!“

“After working a 14-hour day, we picked up Donatos for dinner. Unfortunately, the 3 orders of wings were missing from the order. The manager went out of his way to fix the situation. He had the wings delivered to us- way out of their normal delivery area. The food was great. Customer service was top notch. Kudos to the Harborcreek Donatos!“

“I love ippa pizza their pizza and calzones are awesome. The only issue I have is on a weekday when I go to order And door dash says they are closed. I don't know if it is a staffing issue and they can't keep up or can't open at all. I like their food when I can get it.“

“I work in the activities department for Soldiers' and Sailors' Home and this evening we were very pleased with our outing at Maria's Pizza. Not only did their diverse menu hit the spot for many picky eaters, but it also provided a great family atmosphere. The staff was very kind and courteous, respectful of our Veterans and they served us with perfect time, especially since our crowd is typically not known to be very patient and/or have short attention spans. The pricing was well within budget, giving our residents the ability to splurge and go wild on a smorgasbord of deliciousness. Thank you so much for the amazing experience! This is not the last time we see Maria's!“

“it is the best Pizza anywhere. 🍕 And it is reasonably priced.“

“excellent Burger. excellent fries. just went there on a whim and had an excellent lunch. the staff was nice and friendly. and the owner came out and talked with us too. Great experience will go back!“

“This place has the best gluten-free pizza with a vegan cheese available All you have to do is specify that your gluten-free and they'll use a separate pan so good amazing people and amazing pizza“

“have always loved this place and will still recommend it. the dough is amazing. and the best thing on the menu is the Hawaiian pizza (did you know they put bacon on it BACON) today I was not impressed. got the Italian combo calzone. the lady accidentally put it in as a Italian combo sub. I waited twice the time for it...will not be getting it again. I thought it would be ham salami and pepperoni, with sauce and cheese. no just ham salami and cheese.amd then the meats where hug pieces making it hards to eat. a little disappointed that I waited twice the time for them to fix it but then I got charged 4 dollars difference. looking at the menu there's only a 2.50 difference. will still recommend but will only get what I know now.“

“This is my favorite place to get pizza in Erie. The prices are reasonable and the pizza is cooked to perfection. There was one time we were given a different pizza than we ordered, but it was actually delicious. Hoping they add a cook's choice option. Could be fun!“

“Food is amazing and staff is great. Love the new location wine and spirits.“

“Amazing Stromboli’s and Pizza!! Highly recommended!!“

“I used to order every friday when I lived in town. it's been a couple years since I've gone and still hands down the best wings in Erie. man have I missed these wings“

“they don't lie when they say edge to edge toppings!“

“Wow !! Everything I have ordered has been delivered and amazing !! Highly recommend“

“We love BLAZE! Decided to come after the movies and the ingredients were fresh and my son enjoyed the high rise dough. The team was friendly and made our pies with specificity. But most of all, the rewards are worth it! I got 50% off and a free pizza with my flames🔥 🔥. I just wish there was a second location on the east side of Erie.“

“I absolutely love this place.
I run a local motel and i push them business EVERY time anyone asks where they should order from.
The woman that runs this establishment is AMAZING. She answers the phone, cooks and she has even delivered a few times.
This place is a gem.
The food is absolutely phenomenal. Tried just about everything on the menu, throughout the years. Its all quality ingredients and its extremely consistent.
If you go into the place, be prepared for an optical illusion. The place is 20x the size of what it looks like from the outside. And, they have great decor.
I am an absolute fan of Stevo's“

“LOVE THE FOOD! We normally get take out, but the staff has always been friendly. Homestyle spaghetti is awesome, nice thick noodles cooked perfectly, with great meatballs and sauce. Subs are tasty, and Big! And Valerio's manages to keep their prices reasonable for the quality and portion size of the food! Both locations rock; would definitely recommend.“

“I ordered pizza from here no employee was wearing gloves using hands without gloves i asked the guy up front to make sure please wear gloves for my pizza he gave me attitude and the girl white shirt she wear short was giving me attitude I came home open this box found little hear please start wearing gloves or at least wash hands before touching food i would never ever come here again. I’m really upset“

“I get my deli every 2 weeks,I always get the sand.pepp,hard salami,some prov,cheese,yellow american,some mozz,occasionally some roast beast,call it in on Saturday b4 10 am,save 1.00 per lb per item,meat is cut nice and thin,cheese as well,best place to get your deli on,I've used garys so many many times,I don't have to leave a name,dude knows who placed it ,names on the bag,didn't give him my name,m paying close to 5 a lb when the Walmart is charging 8-9 per lb,um yeah no brainer,plus when I pick up my order,there is always something tasty too take home,12 in sub rolls,6 in a bag,really fresh,7 bucks dang“

“We walked over to Connies for food and ice cream last night with our 2 kids for the first time after moving to the neighborhood last fall. The girls working were great! We loved the pizza and ice cream special! Pizza empanadas were also awesome!“

“This place has the best gluten-free pizza with a vegan cheese available All you have to do is specify that your gluten-free and they'll use a separate pan so good amazing people and amazing pizza“

“Small dining room, but service was fast and friendly. The food is amazingly good and in large portions. Almost two meals for the price of one. The loaded potato soup that came with the dinner was rich and creamy. We had the lasagna and chicken Alfredo and both were exceptional. A must order is the cheesy garlic bread. Hard to beat. You have to try, will enjoy.“

“I absolutely Love Sbarro The workers at this location are Wonderful Thank You 😊🍕🍕❤️“

“friendly staff and great food. reasonable prices as well. Would recommend the burger and quesadilla's. we traveled from Michigan and went to MA and ME trying to find good food and this ended up being our favorite.“

“I think the stupid sign on top of the car should be a lick and stick on the front and back windshield alot more stylish 😎.
And if your really into delivery you could always customize your car and promote Domino's 😉 😀 😄“

“Highly recommend!!! It was clean and the staff were friendly, always checking up on the party throwers to make sure the kids were comfortable and entertained. Was amazed at the ability for kids to play games by swiping your wrist bands instead of inserting coins. Very affordable…“

“Most incredible French Onion Soup I have EVER tasted. And I order French onion soup every time I’m at a new place that serves it. There is no recipe or establishment that can compare with the soup I had at the Beechwood Inn. It was a mission of mine to find the best French onion soup and after 25 years of searching, I can honestly say mission complete.
My son had the Big Wood burger and couldn’t say enough positive things about it.
We grabbed a cherry cheesecake desserts to go. It was also fabulous and you could tell it was homemade with its thick, buttery, graham cracker crust.
Loved the homestyle rustic ambience of both the dining and bar area. The murals/wood carvings are quite unique and add to the country home cooking feel.
Service was quick and friendly.
The total meal was quite inexpensive.
The only thing that disappointed me had nothing to do with the Beechwood inn, but the fact that none of the local Erie visitor guides even mentioned the existence of this place. Shame on them for not listing this hidden gem of a local business.“

“Great spot for delicious affordable food. Thanks guys!“

“We had them cater our retirement party at our home last evening. The food was amazing, as always! We ordered, chicken, bbq pork, rigatoni, and meatballs. All of our guests raved about the food! Over the years we have used Teresa’s for all our big events. John does an amazing job, and the quality of the food is top notch! Thank you again!
Dean & Lisa Coburn“

“I signed up on the app and, every year, get a free cookie on my birthday. Plus, you can save up dough points for free pizza!! It smells amazing in there with all their fresh ingredients. Staff are friendly and welcoming. Lots of great deals on the app. They food cooks fast for a delicious meal. I highly recommend you won't be sorry.

Vegetarian options: They have lots of vegetables to choose from for you're pizza. There garlic knots are garlicky deliciousness.

Kid-friendliness: They have cheese pizza, desert, and sides you're little one is sure to love.“

“Absolutely amazing food and service I will 100% be back one of the best pizzas I have ever had. crispy, fluffy and buttery crust and the sauce is delicious.“

“I’ve never met better people than you guys! You guys are working Christmas Eve and while some may be bitter - you both are the exact opposite and are what Christmas is all about! Thank you Amanda and Robert for amazing customer service. I wish you nothing but the best.“

“Reagan our waitress was so nice and took great care of us Our food was very good We will definitely eat here again when we are in town“

“Mama Mia's is our favorite Pizza. It has a chewy crust and delicious sauce. Friendly service and reasonably priced too!“

“Great local bar woth great people and great music!“

“Ordered the meat lovers large pizza for 50% off and I have to honestly say it was one of the best pizza's I have ever had. The best topping was the Italian Sausage which really gave the pizza some extra flavor. The amount of toppings was good and the end of the crust was not too big. Sometimes you buy a pizza and 1/4th of it is raised crust that most people don't eat. Excellent pizza and service. 5 stars.“