26 Best Sandwich Shops near Finleyville

“Cant go wrong here we stopped in for lunch and got a meatball hoagie with a chicken bacon ranch hoagie and tried the new foot long cookie, churo and pretzel. The cookie and churo were probably tied for being pretty good and the pretzel was ok“

“we stopped in cuz a friend said you guys made really good hoagie. I was Wrong , you guys make an awsome hoagie ! . I will be seeing yinnz alot from now on. thank you and I highly recommend“

“Food is fresh, tastes great and is absolutely delicious! Staff is exceptional! HIGHLY recommend“

“We visited your establishment for the first time last night, I insisted on finding a more gourmet tasting Italian hoagie and oh man did I find it. Your food is amazing BUT I apologize as I did not catch his name, the employee up front basically running your establishment WOW!! What a fabulous individual you have as the face of your business. I just want you to know that he is an absolute asset, the world needs many more of these kind of people. (Professional, knowledgeable, happy, all around wonderful person) THANK YOU! We will be back!“

“The people working at Jersey Mike's on Saturday evening, July 18 2020 went above and beyond for us. I placed an online order and on our way to get the order the vehicle we were driving in broke down. I called and explained the situation because I knew we wouldn't get there before close. The person I spoke with was so kind and assured me I could still get my order. Unfortunately, we weren't able to get there at all and when I called to explain and offer my order to the closing team, the person who answered was again so kind and offered to refund my order even though I had no intention of asking for that. It was just a nice gesture and the care they showed for our situation was amazing. I will make sure to order from them more often! Thanks guys!“

“The staff is excellent and very caring. They are the perfect business for that plaza, especially because it's near one of Allegheny Health Networks treatment centers. People that come and go from that plaza need love and a smile. Thank you for making our day when we come to eat. On top of the great service the food is always fresh and excellent. The store is always spotless.“

“I order from here all the time because the sandwiches are delicious! Today, they forgot the mayo and pepper relish on both of our sandwiches so they were very dry and boring. I like to order online to customize my sandwich but what's the point if they skip the ingredients you want to add??“

“From Michigan and had to experience the Sandwich..😊 Very good!!! Heading to a Steeler and Penguin games tomorrow and Tuesday.“

“It's a classic older family run restaurant. 1980's Pepsi menu boards, cheap prices, family owned, etc. The subs/hoagies are 100% over rated. Now the burgers, pizzas, fries, broccoli bites are worth it. They are priced well and taste pretty good. Have been there a few times to try their menu and can see going back.“

“First of all, those cookies were scrum diddly yum yum. My footlong sub was perfectly hand crafted by Karlee who is so incredibly kind and efficient!!! Although the time I spent in the clean and organized restaurant was short, she absolutely brightened my day! Give her a raise.“

“The best sandwiches around! The younger staff working are super fast and friendly with their service. Side note for my coleslaw lovers- it's amazing, none of that dry shredded cabbage it's saucey and chopped perfectly! Highly recommend the Audie.“

“The crew at the South Park Rd in Bethel Park closed 40 min early and was closed and dark at 7:40pm
I had to go to the McMurray Subway
The crew there made me a delicious meatball sub perfectly. This review is for the McMurray crew. They're 👍“

“Convenient and helpful. A great asset to the neighborhood“

“Primanti’s is rarely less than A+. Purists may defecate on pizza being on the menu these days, but this is a SOLID pie. Had a slice as a side to the sandwich and subsequently ordered a large to take home. They got the pizza right, at least in Bridgeville.“

“I had the freshest hoagie at this location this week and WOW, game changer. Thanks alot.“

“Ashley and Amanda swift and friendly service. They pivoted with grace when I decided I wanted to make my salad a sub halfway through the creation. I must say as an out of towner frequenting the Greater Pittsburgh ares the put Bethel and South Hills on the map and booked this spot as a place to return. Double AA's powering this Sunway with A1 service.“

“This is the best subway I have ever been to! Everything is so fresh and extremely clean. The owners are always so nice and welcoming. I have come twice with my 2.5 year and 8 month old and they are always so sweet to the kids and the woman has given my older one a free cookie twice which she really appreciates. I saw other customers come in and the owner remembered everyone’s order if they had been in before which I find super impressive. I highly recommend coming to this subway! I’ll be back!“

“I am somewhat new to the area and have been in this location twice. Yes it is more expensive than Subway but there is no comparison. I think if you are willing to spend the extra dollars you’ll be happy here. I know what $10 buys me at Subway. And they’ve been going downhill for years. I’d rather spend the extra money at Primo’s or just do without! The quality is much higher and ingredients seem a lot fresher. IMO. I don’t think you could go wrong with anything on menu. I usually skip the cheese but not here. Anything with turkey is lower in calories so I’ve only had that so far. A lot of women could probably get two meals out of the primo size sandwich if you get a small side. Their potato salad is different but very good. They were out of rice pudding today so they substituted dirty pudding. While I don’t need the extra sugar, it is very good! Store seems very clean as well. The saying ‘You get what you pay for’ applies here!“

“I was in on June 9th, 2022 and was waited on by a lovely woman named Carissa. I was unsure on what to order and she gave great recommendations on what sandwich to order. She suggested the chicken and bacon ranch, which was amazing. I never buy chips or a drink either but she was able to sell me on those too. If she’s not manager yet she needs to be. Stellar service!“

“We've been here a bunch over the years and the food is always good, and the service is good too, other than it feels like 1/3 times on mobile or called in orders, the order isn't quite correct. Nothing terrible just something like tomatoes added when no tomatoes are ordered“

“Had the Philly cheesesteak, was one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had. Highly recommend this jersey mikes it’s the best around.

Vegetarian options: There are veggie only subs

Parking: About 30 spots to park

Kid-friendliness: Kids are allowes in a very welcoming environment“

“Almost a hour to get food, others seated after us waited and served. Another table close by also complained of wait time. we were given the excuse that a large party came in ( not true) and large number of take outs (?). Not sure what type of meat tge burger was but was totally tasteless, took home and threw away. Most disappointing meal ever!! Jefferson Hills/Pleasant Hills“

“Went to the McKeesport Subway for the first time, since Glassport one is NEVER open and I am so glad I did

The service is phenomenal, the young man working has such a sunny disposition, very accommodating to what I wanted to order, very friendly and professional

The food they serve is very fresh, I will definitely revisit this location again. It will be my first choice instead of the one in my town. I do not think they care at all in Glassport

Parking: Parking lot is right off the Main Street. No issues getting in or out“

“Lov'in this Jimmy John's ~ AWESOME Spot ??.This was a late night visit. I love getting photos during off peak hours. Can you say fresh products. ✅?.

Parking: I feel like there is plenty of free parking available at this Jimmy John's ‼️?

Kid-friendliness: Like I said I visited in evening. The two guys working we're very kind and quick ?‼️?“

“This Subway is tucked away in the Caste Village strip mall. It may be a little hard to find but there is plenty of parking.The service was prompt and pretty fast. The employee had a rather thick accent and it was a little hard to understand her, but she was polite and accommodating.We ordered a Spicy Italian and a BMT sub; both were delicious and were made with fresh looking and tasting ingredients.Overall, it was a very good experience and I am sure that we will be back.“