50 Best American Restaurants near Hallam

1 Hallamshire Family Restaurant

4.6 Superb 347 Reviews

480 West Market Street, Hallam

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great tasting food. Good value for your money. Wonderful servers. Excellent kitchen staff. Place is always very clean. Great friendly atmosphere/ A lot of regular repeat customers. Owners/ management are the best- They run a first rate place!👍 - I've been a very satisfied customer for years! Check them out today!”

2 The First Post

4.8 Superb 429 Reviews

3691 E Market St, York · 2.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Today, had lunch at The First Post in York, PA. The place is nice and spacious, located on East Market Street. Our party of four shared a ravioli appetizer and had French Onion soup. Both were delicious!!! Easily the best French Onion soup I've eaten!!! For lunch, we each had something different. My Aunt had Salmon Salad. My wife had The Post Steak Sandwich with fries. Our son had the Blackened Shrimp Alfredo. I settled for.the Fish & Chips!! Each of us loved our meals - taking at least half home!! The portions were enormous!!! To wrap up, we decided on some dessert. My Aunt and wife had the Creme Brulee. My son and I had the Chocolate Reese Cake Tort. So good!!!! Service was phenomenal!! If in the York, PA area, you MUST stop in and eat up!!!”

3 Griddles malt shoppe

4.9 Superb 225 Reviews

315 Locust Street, Columbia · 5.71 miles

• Take-Out

“Waitress Tiffany was very nice along with the cook! Cute place to grab a bit to eat❤️ Keep up the good work!”

4 The Railroad House Inn

4.7 Superb 265 Reviews

280 West Front Street, Marietta · 4.1 miles

• Take-Out

“Our son's wedding reception was held here, and it was our first time visiting. I was being a bit nosy about the basement when a gentleman who worked there noticed and kindly asked if we’d like to take a peek. Thank you again — that small gesture showed how much you care about your visitors’ experience. During the reception, a family with three young kids started to get a little bored. That same gentleman came out with a basket of brand-new Matchbox cars and gave each child one. Wow! What a thoughtful and above-and-beyond thing to do. You truly helped make their day — and ours — even brighter. Thank you for your kindness and hospitality!”

5 Bully's Restaurant & Pub

4.7 Superb 211 Reviews

647 Union Street, Columbia · 6.13 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We visited Bullies Saturday evening, 4/9. For starters I had the mussels. Absolutely delicious. I'd go back just for them. My wife had bacon wrapped scallops. They were really good, also. For entrees I had the Kona tenderloin steak. It was perfectly cooked and fork tender. My only issue, it came out barely luke warm. Same for my French fries. I'd call them cold. The roasted brussel sprouts, which I was really anticipating, were tasty, but all but burned and only luke warm. Though I should have said something to the server, I didn't. My bad. My wife's meal, beef tenderloin tips, were perfectly cooked, hot and fork tender, with mushroom and onion gravy. They were on a bed of rice. Dessert was creme brulee and NY cheesecake. Both were very good. I was disappointed with the cheesecake slice, being about half the size of what I consider a normal sized slice. All in all, a tasty meal. I'd return, but in the future insist on a HOT meal, not luke warm.”

6 Mapa's Boli

4.8 Superb 75 Reviews

2535 South Queen Street, York · 7.58 miles

• Delivery

“I love their food and I love their location and the staff is awesome!”

7 Roosevelt Tavern

4.5 Superb 171 Reviews

50 North Penn Street, York · 7.7 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“One of York’s hidden gems! We have eaten here several times and have never had a bad meal. In my opinion, consistency is what will bring you back to a restaurant time and time again. The Roosevelt Tavern is definitely one of those places. Atmosphere is very nice, quiet with great music in the background where you can actually have a conversation while enjoying your meal. The owner/chef, Byron Kehr, is fantastic and extremely accomodating! Thank you, Byron, for always making sure you have the wine we like on hand for our visit!! Ann and Chantal”

8 Becky's Kitchen

4.7 Superb 81 Reviews

5188 E Prospect Rd, York · 4.44 miles

• Take-Out
• Drive-Through

“It was the first time we stopped at Becky's Kitchen. Loved all the old country antique decor and plants. They were very busy with take-out. No wonder. Everything was delicious. We especially loved the ham potpie. Other customers and staff were friendly. We plan on returning often.”

9 Corner Cabinet

4.6 Superb 79 Reviews

34 West Philadelphia Street, York · 7.23 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Lovely I love this place I”

10 Marietta Tavern On Market

4.4 Superb 200 Reviews

324 West Market Street, Marietta · 4.16 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Be careful if going here. It looks like they are having real issues with trouble makers, which can happen with any tavern along the river. About 10 days ago they confronted a person outside who refused to pay. That guy pulled a gun on the employee and threatened to shoot them in the head. Look online, you'll see the news story. We went there with another couple anyway for supper aware of the situation that possibly the management wasn't able to keep the trouble out of the place. Within minutes Courtney had our drinks at the table and placed our food orders ... and then some white trash at the bar left out a super loud screech or whistle looking for attention. It was bad. Then he did it again a few minutes later and left. One more time and I'd have gotten involved. The owner needs to hire some beefy enforcement right now to keep a handle on this or the place is going to get a reputation like the Bainbridge Inn as a good place to raise hell and start a fight. NOT date night atmosphere.”

11 Great American Saloon

4.4 Superb 176 Reviews

20 Dairyland Square, Red Lion · 7.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had the most incredible dinner this evening with Bri as our waitress. She was so personable, so engaging with our daughter, and had great recommendations! Food and drinks were great per usual — crab cakes and scallops always hit!”

12 Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen

4.3 Superb 590 Reviews

1340 Toronita Street, York · 6.74 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Overall service was great, waitress was good, service was good food was good. Ordered a spinach/cheese appetizer to go, was bagged ready to go but when we opened it 1 1/2 inch of dip ! N a small bowl with a half of a large bag of chips already opened, we only needed about 4 chips to eat it”

13 Shank's Tavern

4.8 Superb 215 Reviews

36 South Waterford Avenue, Marietta · 4.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Been to Shanks quite a few times. We moved about 25 min away a little over a year ago and this place doesn’t disappoint. Every time we order drinks and food it’s been solidly consistent. This past Sunday we went for drinks and food at happy hour. 6 dollar Bloodys and 4 dollar pickle shots is a steal and of course I had 2 Bloodys. My wife and I went with the special for food. Bacon egg and cheese on potato bun with a sriracha maple glaze. The star of the show though is always Andi. She’s an amazing bartender. Whenever we go there ( we have to sit at the bar ) and she’s there. We are in for a good time. Keep doing what your doing and we will keep coming back”

14 Central Family Restaurant

4.3 Superb 288 Reviews

400 North George Street, York · 7.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Fantastic”

15 Rivertowne Restaurant & Bar

4.3 Superb 218 Reviews

960 Hellam Street, Wrightsville · 3.41 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We go a few times a month. Always good food. Always good service. Will be back. Thank you!”

16 Rockfish Public House

4.6 Superb 422 Reviews

110 North George Street, York · 7.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“my mom and i had a great time here and their mojitos were really great and i would rate this restaurant 10stars”

17 Hinkle's Restaurant

4.3 Superb 178 Reviews

261 Locust St, Columbia · 5.67 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We were just here for the first time. Very good first impression. Excellent food and service! Will definitely come back!”

18 Lion's Pride Restaurant

4.3 Superb 172 Reviews

20 Dairyland Square, Red Lion · 7.65 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best around!”

19 Black Olive Family Diner

4.6 Superb 402 Reviews

1506 Lancaster Avenue, Columbia · 6.76 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They Have the best chicken Caesar salad!”

20 Creekside Cafe

4.3 Superb 90 Reviews

1519 Habecker Road, Columbia · 7.12 miles

• Delivery

“Terrific food!! Great service!”

21 Harvey's Main Street BBQ

4.6 Superb 312 Reviews

304 East Main Street, Mount Joy · 9.2 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent food. Certainly recommend this place. First time here, definitely coming again!”

22 McCleary's Pub

4.5 Superb 645 Reviews

130 West Front Street, Marietta · 4.32 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We were at McCleary’s today when a storm came through and knocked out the power. The staff was great! They were friendly, flexible, helpful, and all-around great. They joked and filled water and checked on everyone. It’s easy to offer great service/food under normal circumstances, but these folks knocked it out of the park under really bad conditions. Bravo. This is why I love McCleary’s.”

23 John Wright Restaurant

4.2 Good 464 Reviews

234 North Front Street, Wrightsville · 4.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“About a year ago, I went to John Wright Restaurant for Sunday brunch with a group of friends. I didn’t know what to expect, but the moment I arrived, I was struck by the beautiful waterfront scenery and the stunning, rustic building. Inside, that old-world charm blends perfectly with an upscale dining vibe, giving the place a truly special and unique energy. The brunch was absolutely delicious—so many options, including my personal favorite, eggs Benedict. Fast forward to last night: I stopped in for happy hour with a friend, and we grabbed seats at the bar. It was surprisingly comfortable and not overcrowded at all. The two bartenders were fantastic—warm, funny, and attentive. And the cocktails… OH MY GOSH. Just try them. You’ll thank me later! We ordered the calamari and crab risotto small plates, and they were so good that we immediately ordered a second round of the exact same thing. From a relaxed Sunday brunch, to after-work apps and cocktails, to a special dinner out—John Wright Restaurant gets a solid 10/10 from me. 🍽️”

24 Conewago Inn

4.2 Good 355 Reviews

3480 York Haven Rd, Manchester · 8.04 miles

• Delivery

“Burgers were top notch. Chicken tortellini soup was way too salty last week.”

25 Iron Horse York

4.2 Good 269 Reviews

1 West Market Street, York · 7.18 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Went on a busy Friday night but hostess was able to accommodate myself and two daughters. I was in a rush and was pleasantly surprised by the speed of service by the wait staff and kitchen. Everyone was pleasant, food was excellent (kids had burgers and fries and I had the chicken sandwich). Had a long drive home and we arrived at 7:15 and left by 7:50 with full bellies, fun atmosphere, great staff… which was ideal! Highly recommended!”

26 Beanie's Bar & Grill

4.5 Superb 373 Reviews

78 West Main Street, Mount Joy · 8.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Beanie’s delivers exactly what a local bar & grill should: bold portions and punchy flavor. The Volcano Burger was a full send. Juicy patty, onion rings stacked high, jalapeños, salsa and ranch. A punch full of flavor. The Southwest Chipotle wings had that smoky heat balance dialed in. Not just spice for shock value — actual flavor layered in. The patty melt leaned classic comfort with a side of fries. Nothing over the top. It was perfect, and seasoned beautifully. The mild wings over fries (Monday deal win) proved you can still get a solid meal for just $10. The nachos? Exactly what you want. Cheese, jalapeños, taco meat onions, salsa and sour cream. Atmosphere-wise, it feels local in the best way — relaxed on one side, bar going on the other. Perfect mix for introverts and extroverts. This is the kind of spot that builds community through food and friends. Sincerely , Full Effect Eats ❤️🍽️”

27 Dairyland Family Restaurant

3.9 Good 26 Reviews

5 Dairyland Square, Red Lion · 7.66 miles

“Pleasant Asmus fear great service always a good time with good people”

28 LettUsKnow

4.8 Superb 87 Reviews

22 South George Street, York · 7.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“If You Dont Know about this place... you REALLY should go!”

29 Round the Clock Diner

4.4 Superb 639 Reviews

222 Arsenal Road, York · 6.68 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The mushroom burger was delicious 😋”

30 Jim & Nena's Pizzeria

4.6 Superb 147 Reviews

2535 South Queen Street, York · 7.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I cannot even begin to express how grateful we are for the kindness and exceptional service provided by Jim & Nena's. After a failed delivery with GrubHub it was much needed!! They were patient with GrubHub and my husband as all 3 worked together in rectifying the situation (which was no fault of the restaurant). They not only offered to deliver our order themselves (so we could stop dealing with GrubHub), but also gave us an additional pizza!! Ps. The bacon cheese fries were LOADED in cheese & bacon & they were absolutely delicious. We will certainly be stopping here more often (rather than ordering through GrubHub).”

31 Kickin' Kadilaks Bar and Grill

4.5 Superb 230 Reviews

17 South Front Street, York Haven · 9.28 miles

• Take-Out

“It was my first time coming here with my girlfriend and let me tell you, it's refreshing to still find a good dive bar. We drove over 50 minutes to come here and it was well worth it. The food was great, our server was very pleasant, and overall I enjoyed the atmosphere. We especially loved the french fries and we couldn't believe how affordable the prices were.”

32 Bube's Brewery and the Catacombs

4.1 Good 537 Reviews

102 North Market Street, Mount Joy · 9.13 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Ate in the catacombs last night. I am a huge foodie and was looking forward to the atmosphere of the restaurant. It did not disappoint. Jack, our server was great, the food and drinks were amazing. Overall an excellent experience, we will return!”

33 Gus's - Mt Joy

4.4 Superb 405 Reviews

1050 West Main Street, Mount Joy · 8.62 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Desserts are fantastic! A must have! We went back to get something out of the dessert case another day.”

34 White Rose Bar & Grill

4.3 Superb 492 Reviews

48 North Beaver Street, York · 7.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I'm a Yorker. But hadn't frequented the white rose after they went to a more upscale setting, my old high school homie suggested we go there and after we got seated I found out his out of town visit was for a death in his family that he assumed I knew about but I did not... now your staff being as great as you guys are and the food made this bad personal experience for us very nice otherwise, and it made me feel I may visit again sometime for lunch and a cold 🍺”

35 Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar

4.3 Superb 460 Reviews

2151 South Queen Street, York · 6.71 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We went on 2/8/25. Staying at the Hampton inn for a dance comp. Our waiter, unfortunately l, didn’t catch his name was absolutely AMAZING! More people kept getting added to our party, he, without hesitation, added more tables and chairs. He took our orders and separated the checks without us even asking. He just really went above and beyond and was amazing! I hope he gets the recognition he deserves! Thank you again! Food and drinks were 10/10!”

36 LongHorn Steakhouse

4.3 Superb 411 Reviews

2901 Concord Road, York · 3.7 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Came here for my Daughters Birthday around 2 so we could beat the “traffic”, plus there was 7 of us! Trista, our server, was at the table and ready to go. Not pushy but timed, she managed the timing for the whole meal. Was so pleasant, never missed a beat. Glasses were always full and Trista even remembered my daughter’s Birthday Treat. We had a mixture of food stuffs, like having the shrimp appetizer for my entree, Burgers, Rivs and of course, steak! There was no rush to get us out of the table ( we would not do that as a simple courtesy to others waiting) but the time there was nice, not a lot of “noise” and did I mention Trista?”

37 Crimson American Grill

4.3 Superb 393 Reviews

1839 South Queen Street, York · 6.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The Best Steaks and seafood in town. Don’t forget the rice pudding for dessert.”

38 Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

4.0 Good 671 Reviews

236 Pauline Drive, York · 6.51 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Little rough in the beginning, BUT ...Sam n Rabbit made up for it, plus pleasant waitress, Sabrina . Definitely worth the wait and we will be back.”

39 Union Station Grill

4.3 Superb 317 Reviews

173 South 4th Street, Columbia · 5.87 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Found this gem by accident. Our server was great… wish I could remember her name Devon…something with a D. Food and service were both great!! We’re going back so we can try the other things on the menu.”

40 The Manchester Diner

4.3 Superb 311 Reviews

4302 North George Street Extension, Manchester · 6.97 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“An update... .look at the that meal!!! I ordered the roast beef sandwich with fries... omg. With a small soda still less than the garbage food... and the same price for more. What is stopping you from eating here. Sooooo delicious 😋 I don't understand why anybody would want to go to a fast food restaurant and get garbage ingredients making Corporate America richer when you can go to a family Diner and have better quality food hot and fast. The amount of time that it takes you to sit in the Drive-Thru you can order burger and fries at this little local spot run over to the dollar store to get whatever you need and then come back and it's all ready for you to eat if you get a cheeseburger deluxe with french fries it's the same price that you would be paying with a bigger burger and fresher vegetables then at a fast food restaurant!!! I have eaten here for breakfast and lunch multiple times over the years. I like going Saturday mornings with my co-workers just to sit down and have conversation and to relax. I wish they still had the dividers up between the booths that's the only reason why I gave it a four stars for atmosphere. It does get crowded on Saturdays so maybe you might want to do it Friday morning breakfast like my supervisors. breakfasts are excellent and affordable I can't share any pictures because I already ate it”

41 Hurricane Pizza Grill

4.3 Superb 301 Reviews

4031 Columbia Avenue, Columbia · 7.84 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“went there for lunch ,we were greeted by great waitress and the food was outstanding their specials were great ànd very reasonable and their bar drink special was great going to go there more offen!”

42 Golden Crust Pizza & Taproom

4.3 Superb 278 Reviews

59 E Broadway, Red Lion · 7.15 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had Tiffany as our server, she is absolutely a fantastic person who took excellent care of us. Highly recommended! Food and service were top notch.”

43 Alley Oops Sports Bar & Grill

4.5 Superb 59 Reviews

1945 South Queen Street, York · 6.7 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is not just a bar. Kelly made us feel like we had been old friends. I cannot say enough about the delicious food. The lunch menu is out of this world. I would tell you if you are looking for great food and a place go to Alley Oops Sports Bar & Grill is where to go. I will definitely do the hour drive and come back again to try the crab cakes that Kelly suggested. 👍”

44 M&m Mini Market 2

4.8 Superb 27 Reviews

381 West Philadelphia Street, York · 7.69 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“omg I fell in love with this place while furloughed and found them on grub hub. the tripleta and Cuban is to die for!!!”

45 Red Lion Corner Café

4.3 Superb 187 Reviews

601 Lombard Road, Red Lion · 6.38 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Everyone there is so friendly, respectful and welcoming. They treat you like family. They are so accommodating. We held our daughter and son-in-law’s 25th Anniversary there and they were absolutely amazing. The food was absolutely delicious. We strongly recommend you visit them for we know that you won’t be disappointed.”

46 First Capital Dispensing Co

4.7 Superb 25 Reviews

57 North Pershing Avenue, York · 7.38 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Original music hub of York pa ! Supporting artists for 30 plus years ! Dark and dirty bar!”

47 Pizza Town USA

4.3 Superb 151 Reviews

50 West Maple Street, East Prospect · 4.92 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“they have the greatest subs around and the people are amazing I love them!”

48 Hennigan's Restaurant And Bar

3.8 Good 177 Reviews

1990 West Main Street, Mount Joy · 8.92 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“my waitress was outstanding! she was so pleasant. I will definitely be looking for her the next time. The food was delicious. it was my grandsons 16th birthday and everything was perfect.”

49 3rd Base

4.3 Superb 131 Reviews

512 North George Street, York · 7.16 miles

• Delivery

“This was the first time that my wife and I ordered from 3rd Base, and while all we ordered was a Cheeseburger Sub and an order of fries, let me tell you that our dining room was eerily silent for 5-10 minutes as we both were so impressed and surprised at how damn good our meal was, that we didn't talk, share, or otherwise allow any outside interference as we thoroughly enjoyed our meal. To me, the food is quintessentially some of the best Central Pennsylvania comfort food around and we are thrilled that the menu prices for burgers, subs, and appetizers were lower than expected, even though the quality and quantity of the portions were well above average. We have definitely found our new favorite go-to spot.”

50 Infusions Bake Shop

4.6 Superb 17 Reviews

432 Old Market Street, Mount Joy · 9.26 miles

• Take-Out

“I came with a group of 15 for high tea & we all left full & happy. Just happened to be Mardi Gras today, so it was definitely New Orleans style food. Both the service & food were wonderful especially considering it was all done by high school students. An instructor circulated around the dining room & spoke with us for awhile. He said he didn't have much to do because the students were working pretty much on their own at this point. We are planning to come back in the fall for a different type of menu. We all live 30-45 minutes away, but if I lived closer I would be a regular customer at their bakery.”