15 Best Seafood Restaurants near Chincoteague Island

“Our first time to Chincoteague and camping at Yogi. My husband was told we had to try Capt Zach’s well let’s just say we were not disappointed one bit. The freshest seafood I have had in along time. Our Waitress Valerie was very nice and attentive. If you go just know to go early. You will have a slight wait but you won’t be disappointed for sure. 10/10 will be back and it will be worth the 2 hr drive.“

“This place has always been really good. I was a little disappointed. The inside was just filled with flies. I'm sure it was probably just the time of year but it did disappoint me from O'Neil.
The outside tiki bar is amazing and the sunsets that you can see there are off the chart. It is a good place to try“

“Friendly atmosphere. Fried scallops, perfection! Frisco taco … yum! Awesome experience!“

“We have been to Ray's many times over the years & it has always been a nice experience. Tonight was the WORST service we have ever had. On top of that, the stuffed shrimp was overcooked & only 4 shrimp for $35. For the amount of $ spent, it was highly disappointing all-around.“

“Best cocktails and mixed drinks by Dillon! Very clean and friendly.“

“YOU DON'T GET FISH FRESHER THAN THIS,RIGHT OFF THE BOAT. GREAT PRICES.Red, his son Andy, everyone are pleasant and helpful.As Andy was getting my fish he informed me CRABBING season starts MARCH 17, Bushels 1/2 bushels, whatever you need.“

“we won’t go back“

“The stuffed shrimp is simply delicious. Everyone there is no nice and friendly! My favorite drink there is a chocolate martini!“

“Angela! Aka tons of FUN! IS AWESOME! Super fun and friendly service and great food!! Big thank you again to Angela,Rebecca and George, excellent team to have at the bar.They made my Wife and I feel very comfortable from the first moment we interacted 😉“

“We spent the weekend in Chincoteague for our 65th anniversary. On Saturday we ate lunch and dinner at Bill's. My husband had oysters for lunch and flounder for dinner and was pleased with both selections. I had shrimp for lunch and the fried seafood platter for dinner. They shrimp for both meals were very small and did not have a lot of taste. The clam chowder that was included with my dinner was delicious. The rest of the seafood was average. For sides we had the Granny Smith apple cold slaw and red mashed potatoes with cheddar and hamhocks. Both were absolutely scrumptious. Our cocktails were great, as was the service! We made reservations for dinner. The restaurant filled up quickly but there seemed to be adequate staff. All the staff we encountered were very friendly. We would go back again.“

“I love the tea from here its the best on the island!“

“Great food! Great service! Awesome experience! We will be back soon!“

“We had a wonderful dinner for our anniversary very good service and friendly will come again“

“Food is good, albeit a little expensive (it's a marina after all). I really enjoyed the crab soup (order this!) and the fish and chips were delicious. Dessert was an unexpectedly tasty surprise. The drinks are a little cloying, so be prepared for syrupy sweetness if you're ordering one of the house cocktails. Overall a lovely restaurant.“

“The Pearl was an excellent experience overall. The atmosphere was welcoming, the staff was friendly and attentive, and the prime rib was absolutely amazing—tender, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. Definitely a great spot to stop if passing near Chincoteague Island, and I’ll be coming back.“