50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cudahy

“Ordered for dinner tonight. When went to pick up they were just putting it in the oven. She was so apologetic about getting busy and falling behind. She gave us a free appetizer because we had to wait a little longer. Than she even brought it out to the car. Definitely ordering again.“

“This was our first time eating here. We would constantly see people walking out with to go containers so we thought we'd check it out. WOW was I glad we did. Food was amazing. Probably some of the best food I've had in Cudahy. John was super awesome and the place was real fun and a relaxed atmosphere. Will definitely be back again.“

“BIG shoutout to Papa Luigi's Pizza - Cudahy !!! Our 6th grade Basketball team had some time to spare in between games this afternoon and were HUNGRY after playing two already. I called for a last minute reservation for our group of about 25. They seamlessly set up our tables and set us up with their pizza buffet-which included pizzas, salads and mostaccioli! We all left happy, the boys with hi-fives from staff as well! Thanks so much for the quick service with a smile! #gowestbendspartans“

“Great wings, awsome staff“

“Good service, friendly atmosphere and excellent food quality.“

“Great pizza. The crust is crisp. Service was very good, too.“

“I've been dining here for over 30 years. I recommend 🤔everything 🥰 every single time has been pure epicurean bliss.. Bon Appetite to 🫵and thanks again 🥰“

“The pizza is AMAZING!! We tried several pizzas but my favorite was the Tin Widow, deep dish and we added the meatballs! So good!!! AND their customer service is awesome! Love it!!“

“Very good buffalo chicken wrap, beer was cold, and the staff was awesome!“

“Best Pizza I have had in a long time. new go-to place for sure. All staff wonderful!“

“Great pizza! Great atmosphere, great employees“

“Excellent food. But not the greatest customer service experience. I’d recommend sitting in the bar area or further back. We were seated in the front by the garage door. We had to eat with our coats on it was so cold. We asked to be moved, we even said we’d wait. They would not accommodate us. Bartender was awesome! Server not so great!“

“amazing lasagna and friendly atmosphere and people“

“I will just say (1) thing…… THE BEST THIN CRUST PIZZA we’ve had in years!!!“

“My food was absolutely delicious. I went for brunch and ordered the El Mexicano Bowl. I highly recommend this place. It’s nice to see a great restaurant finally take over the old Trocadero building.“

“I’ve been looking for a good place that has wraps and I just ordered myself a buffalo chicken wrap with french fries and the fries are delightfully seasoned and the wrap is very filling and one of the best chicken wraps I’ve ever had. I will definitely be coming back here to try other things on the menu !“

“Love the sourdough pizza, it offers something unique out of all of the options for pizza in Milwaukee! Try the garlic Parmesan bites and the pizza of the month!“

“Best Pickup and Delivery place for Fried Chicken. Always hot and moist, never dried out. Always do pickup since only live a few minutes away.“

“First time going after seeing an instagram post - so glad we tried it out! Pizza: we tried the club banger and the Mac & cheese. Wished the hot honey sauce was hotter but overall, both were great! Apps: tried the crab Rangoon spring rolls and the stuffed cheese bread. Both were a bit pricey ($13 and $12) for what they were. Still tasty! Service: amazing! We had 2 kids with us and all of the staff were so warm and friendly! Overall - so great! I’d recommend and plan to go back!“

“Me and my boyfriend ordered a pizza and birthday stix tonight around 11pm. Our order's estimated arrival time was 11:41-11:51. We were super hungry so when the food wasn't here at 12am we called to see whats going on. The guy we talked to was super nice and without any hesitation gave us $10 off our order. Then he explained it was only him and the driver in the store and they got hit really hard with orders (he said they received about 15 orders around the same time.) Working in food service ourselves, we completely understood the situation. The pizza arrived about 10 mins later and the food was warm and delicious. The driver also dropped off a pint of free ice cream and a brownie for the wait. We were very surprised with the service.“

“Everything we had was delicious- cannot wait to go back!!!“

“Excellent pizza pies! The crust is light, crispy, and thin, with just a touch of chewiness. Vegetarian and vegan friendly options are abundant and delicious. The pesto sauce is fantastic, I recommend it with sausage, artichoke hearts, and garlic.
The Green Hawaii is my favorite specialty pizza.
Stop in or get it delivered. Be sure to go straight to the website and order, don't use third party apps like Postmates and such. Support local business.

Dietary restrictions: 2 dairy free cheese options available,“

“What an amazing spot! I had the California and Caprese pizza slices today, and they were delicious! The crust was fantastic, and the ingredients tasted super fresh. As soon as I walked in, I was warmly greeted by everyone. They have such an incredible selection that I couldn’t choose just one, so I got two! I’m so glad I decided to give it a try today, and I can’t wait to come back for more! It’s really a lovely place with delicious food and wonderful people!“

“I’ve been meaning to try Santino’s for years. We picked up two pizzas, the giant meatball, and tiramisu. Everything was perfect! So delicious!“

“I ordered fried chicken never disappoints MMM juicy OMG the best flavor Pizza WOW best I've had fries everything sooooooo yummy y'all have to try“

“First time here. There will definitely be a second, third, fourth and so on!“

“The best pizza ever! Friendly staff and the best food.“

“The food is still amazing after so many years. The owner Luchia is a hard working woman. It has a hometown feeling like breaking bread with family. Anna the waitress was fun,and gave great service. The Ravioli are My Favorites. A must stop if you are in the Area. Thanks Luchia for the Wonderful time,and food. Very Blessed.“

“Best flat pizza in the area!“

“Me and my family love this place! We come here for pizza at least once a week now 👌👌 Best pizza place in town!“

“best pizza in Milwaukee! always have to get when visiting!“

“They love to do business and love a friend over a foe“

“The owner and staff are just amazing…they continually ask and promoted to be great….thank you so much“

“I stopped in to grab a few drinks with some friends and had an amazing time. The bartender Matt was friendly and funny. He made a very delicious espresso martini. If you happen to come here please try one! Everyone here seemed really happy and bubbly. The vibe was great and i had an awesome sunday funday!“

“Very friendly and fast. Clean place. Food is great“

“Great gluten free pizza and really great service from the staff from the moment we walked in.“

“I had to stop going to Taco Bell (R.I.P.) because it sucks so bad now and this was the only other thing open at midnight. Not bad at all. I recommend the triple bread sticks with 5-6 containers of garlic butter dipping sauce and 2 or more (trust me) of the triple chocolate brownies. The employees here are great too.“

“Just ate here with my girlfriend's and it was very good. service was excellent and food was delicious! Adding some pics“

“We got our 1st pizza from Cataro’s Pizza last night at 11:15pm after seeing the band Without Annette at Da Bar nearby. We were hungry so we searched pizza open late near me. That’s how we found this amazing pizza. The owner had closed the dining room early because business has been so slow but he offered to make us one to go. It was so good! I highly recommend this place. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Recently stumbled across Karina's looking for a non-chain delivery option, and I'm so happy we did. We've ordered multiple times since and it's always been delivered quickly and still warm. We've tried many different pizzas and all have been amazing! Highly recommend“

“Cannot say enough about the food, the staff and the ambiance. Whether it is pregame, post-game, special night out, day drinking and dining or late night cocktails and dinner after a late flight this place never, ever disappoints. Its been that way for years and hope it never changes.“

“We held our Wedding Welcome Party at MobCraft Beer the night before our big day. Elise was so fun, professional, and organized throughout the entire process. Elise was helpful in providing her recommendations for serving sizes based on our guest count and provided us with plenty of options based on her experiences! I would recommend MobCraft to anyone for their event because there are many options for where your event can be all within the brewery, plus overall its an amazing environment. We chose the Game Room, because we wanted our group to have its own space but we still wanted to be apart of the breweries atmosphere with the other customers. We also used the in-house catering MobCraft provided and it was delicious! Again, Elise was great to work with and it turned into such a fun night! Highly Recommend!!“

“Great gluten free pizza and really great service from the staff from the moment we walked in.“

“All they have for food is all they need for food: pizza. They have classic and modern cabinets + enough pinball, skee ball, and hoops games to keep you entertained. Plays are $0.25/player for every game, but they have specials that lower the cost per play even further. Great for small and large parties alike

Vegetarian options: Mona Lisa is a margarita pizza

Dietary restrictions: They have ciders and seltzer, but I do wish they had more rice beers

Parking: More reliable parking is on N Jackson

Kid-friendliness: The bar is strictly 21+

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramps to main floor. I believe there's an elevator to the second floor“

“Next time you want to eat a pizza in MKE definitely recommend considering those joint! This is a small business where all of the staff are passionate about what they do and excited to help their guests. The atmosphere is cozy, with tons of outdoor space. The vibes are great, the decor is great, and attention to detail is off the charts. From the menu to the decor to the staff, everything was carefully crafted and considered.

Beyond all of that, the pizza is both wood fired and “fire” - it’s a good pizza. Try it out!!!“

“Been going there since the late 60s and have never had o bad pizza,“

“It was great until I got home they forgot to give me my breadsticks. I called them, and all they could do was when I came again, they would give them to me for free, of course, they're gonna be free, I paid for them. Lol, you would think they would give me something else for free, but no, they just said the next time I came in, they would give me the 2 that I bought for free. Lol, that right there wasn't good customer service. I feel like I had to drive all the way back. Waste my gas for my 2 Breadsticks that I paid for that they forgot they could at least gave me something else, but no, they didn't.

Parking: It's a big parking lot“

“😍I recommend this place to everyone to enjoy the food they have. delicious tasty and fresh 🫶🏻👍“

“Great discovery of a great pizza place!“

“I ordered 21 wings and a pizza ragin pepperoni. I appreciate one of your workers making sure my order was cooked and prepared properly. Cynthia is a great employee to your team she makes sure you have plates and napkins and she smiles to make you feel good you order from there. The store was clean and welcoming from the employees. Thanks toppers“