Sandwich Shops near Elkhart Lake

“Lunch is always fantastic! Staff are always the Best! Thank you!“

“Love ordering on the app for pick up, but have also eaten there. Are for sandwiches were made as we asked and all the ingredients were fresh. The sub bread was fresh and tasty. Staff is always friendly and efficient. My family tends to order from here at least a few times a month.“

“I was very excited when this Cousins opened in Plymouth. We have always gone to the 1 off Taylor Dr in Sheboygan. I can't put my finger on the reason but the Plymouth Cousins just isn't as good as the 1 in on Taylor Dr. In Sheboygan. But they'll do in a pinch. We ordered 3 large subs & my sub was wrong. Everyone else's was fine.“

“Excellence“

“I am an ambulance driver and I came in on my lunch break as I was going through town. The young girl behind the counter was dealing with a disgruntled customer and a lobby full of customers . She handled herself so professionally. The customer was rude and disrespectful for no reason. So koodoos to the girl working alone on Sun March 8 2026 around 5pm in Kiel for standing your ground and being super professional. You rock!! Also my sub was absolutely delicious 😋“