50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elm Grove

“Juan our server did a great job. Excellent service and the food was delicious“

“Good service, friendly atmosphere and excellent food quality.“

“I had ordered a pizza last night from Alphonso‘s and I thought it was the absolute worst pizza I ever had when it arrived at my house. It was almost burnt. I called and complained to the manager. He said he would do everything he could to make it up to me. So I stopped in today and they gave me a pizza and one of their sandwiches and I haven’t had the sandwich yet because I’m too full from the pizza, it was a night and day difference From yesterday to today. It was excellent.“

“Had the fish tonight, it was very good. Fish and fries were hot, and we had this delivered. I was a customer many yrs. ago, and the quality and service is still #1. Thank you...“

“January 16, 2026. Just had a wonderful experience at Balistreri’s. There were 4 of us having the BEST PIZZA EVER! This is our go to pizza joint…all the way from North Carolina🤣🤣 (a joke). But my review is mainly regarding our awesome waiter, Ricardo! He was so pleasant and fun and played along with our joke! He showed that he truly enjoyed his job….what a joy!“

“I absolutely love Ann’s! Pizza, fettuccine, lasagna are all delicious. Last night I had Ann’s penne with chicken and it’s my new favorite! Our waiter, Logan, was amazing also! Definitely a must check out!“

“Great pizza, great staff, beautiful space.“

“Have been coming to Organ Piper since it opened in the 70's. Great food, friendly staff, wonderful service, fabulous entertainment for the price of a pizza. You can't go wrong here.“

“The best pizza ever! Friendly staff and the best food.“

“Best Pickup and Delivery place for Fried Chicken. Always hot and moist, never dried out. Always do pickup since only live a few minutes away.“

“Totally been missing out! All the flavors of the fresh ingredients, omgeee.🤯🥰🤤 Pear salad with the green goddess, focaccia w/ranch (fresh dill), highly recommended; glad they exceeded my expectations as we tried a new place for dinner after a long productive Saturday 🙌 (wayyy better than closed down MOD in Tosa😉)“

“The People are so friendly.The food is so Delicious.literally the freshest bread in town!!“

“Excellent food. But not the greatest customer service experience. I’d recommend sitting in the bar area or further back. We were seated in the front by the garage door. We had to eat with our coats on it was so cold. We asked to be moved, we even said we’d wait. They would not accommodate us. Bartender was awesome! Server not so great!“

“Jimano's is one of my all time favorite thin crust pizzas. The crust is always thin and crispy, sauced to the edges with the most delicious sauce, loaded with toppings, and baked to perfection. My go to pizza is the Pepperoni Deluxe add sausage and extra sauce. The bread sticks are also very addictive. And on top of it all Bill and his staff do a phenomenal job. If you haven't been here you are missing out. Wednesday it's also half price any one pizza which is a crazy deal! So happy to finally have a Jimano's in Wisconsin!“

“We got our 1st pizza from Cataro’s Pizza last night at 11:15pm after seeing the band Without Annette at Da Bar nearby. We were hungry so we searched pizza open late near me. That’s how we found this amazing pizza. The owner had closed the dining room early because business has been so slow but he offered to make us one to go. It was so good! I highly recommend this place. We’ll definitely be back!“

“We ordered for the first time yesterday at Brothers Gyro & Pizza. The Pizza was the best pizza we had ever eaten. Best crust, best sauce, plenty of cheese and toppings. Perfect! Brother's will be a go to for us for pizza and I can't wait to try the gyro. ❤️“

“I'm a big fan of your chicken and macho nachos. Plus it's always a nice perk that you provide your customers with free popcorn. :)“

“This is our favorite pizza in Milwaukee. The crust is great and they don't skimp on toppings. Lots of cheese too!“

“I will just say (1) thing…… THE BEST THIN CRUST PIZZA we’ve had in years!!!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Concert night + your crew = perfection! 🎶🍻 Dinner was chef’s kiss 👌 — delicious food with a great variety, and those monthly specials? We look forward to them like kids waiting for dessert! 😋✨ The barmaids? Top notch. Friendly, fast, and fun — they keep the good vibes (and the drinks) flowing 🍹💃. And let’s talk about those shuttle drivers… absolute legends! 🚐💨 They got us back from Miller High Life in a downpour like it was a sunny stroll. From the moment we walked in to the second we hopped off the shuttle, everything was smooth, welcoming, and a blast. You’ve got a dream team — can’t wait for the next round! 🙌🎉“

“The best pizza and excellent service. Family favorite.“

“Always great deep dish pizza here! Will come back forever!“

“The food was delicious, the service was phenomenal, and MJ, one of the owner's was so welcoming and gracious. Would highly recommend!“

“Hands down the best pizza 🍕 I just love that packer pizza“

“Most awesome pizza ever they have the best Italian sausage on the pizza. The cheesy bread is also great. Their wings are good. Their pepperoni pizza is awesome. Customer service and staff are really really nice. No complaints at all if you have trouble getting through there a small place for pick up and delivery in carry out so just keep trying they’re worth every second..“

“Came in late night and they were clearly overwhelmed but didn’t show it to the customers. It was all in the faces tho! Josh gave some of the best customer service which was very much neeeed after the day I had. He shared with me his frustration from the day as I did the same, and he proceeded to give me a pick me up as well as some great food. Thanks Josh for making my night. I hope you do great in life knowing you did a small deed for a stranger“

“Love love love love their fish fries. Service is excellent. The bartenders are great and if you see a bad review, just ignore it cause it’s not true.“

“They love to do business and love a friend over a foe“

“Even though the Pewaukee location is closer to my house, I order from the Menomonee Falls restaurant because the food and service I much much beter.“

“Ok, first time trying this place today. Lemme just say, this place is clean, friendly staff and nice atmosphere!. Had the lunch buffet, was top notch. I love a good salad bar with a lot of fixings, they even have extras like pasta, potato salad and more….the pizza was so good! The crunch and toppings that come to the edge of crust, spot on! Definitely will be back and highly recommend!“

“Great discovery of a great pizza place!“

“Best 🍕 I ever had. Pickup or delivery only. Ready in 30 minutes. To die for garlic bread 🍞 The employees are so sweet, cheerful and polite. I'm disabled and they helped open the door for me and then another employee outside noticed and carried my stuff to the car.“

“Yesterday I Had My Son 1st Birthday Party There(My 1st Party Booked There) and it was a great experience. Great Customer Service, Party Host(Marisha) The Party Supervisor (Haley) Rock. They were both Awesome, Thank You Ladies Both For Helping My Son Birthday Even More Perfect 🥰🤗

UPDATE: 12-06-2025 staff is not the same as before. Different faces, different services from 5 years ago. Also the bathrooms are disgusting!!!! I hate seen this after eating from here…. I have a photo but it’s not allowing me to upload it. Lucky them“

“Love their pizzas been eating here since I was a kid!“

“Cannot say enough about the food, the staff and the ambiance. Whether it is pregame, post-game, special night out, day drinking and dining or late night cocktails and dinner after a late flight this place never, ever disappoints. Its been that way for years and hope it never changes.“

“I love FireBirds Hot chicken !!!“

“Fantastic pizza - always - hot, delicious, done the way you like it - near the 'hood' and on-time - small place - but thin crust is on FIRE!!!!!! Awesome - recommended highly by those that tried it - many times.“

“When I arrive for my food, everyone always has a smile on their face and the greetings are always warm. The employees never have an issue helping me save money by adding my food to a deal.
Would recommend the 11.99 2 or more deals for best value!

Vegetarian options: As far as I know, there are 2 specialty vegan pizzas along with enough vegan friendly items to make your own concoction.
They also offer vegan chicken strips for those that don't want to eat wings. They have caulipower crust as well (only medium pizzas tho for caulipower crust) as well as vegan free ranch/garlic butter.“

“Has been my family pizza place for as long as I can remember. Love the food, servers, and atmosphere. Seriously. My dad comes for the salad and my mom and I for the garlic cheese bread. Pizza crust is out of this world good and the homemade sausage… we occasionally get other things like lasagna or fish fry, and while we have never been disappointed, we always come back for the pizza.“

“😍I recommend this place to everyone to enjoy the food they have. delicious tasty and fresh 🫶🏻👍“

“What a great space! Hosted a birthday party and was great to see everyone found a game (or 5) to enjoy. Exciting to see all of the young people (and old 🤭) off of their phones and talking with each other.“

“Lunch date was amazing! Vibes, food and beautiful atmosphere!“

“After moving here four years ago, I had given up hope of finding a place with genuinely decent baked fish. I finally found it here! The food is excellent, and the staff is absolutely amazing.

I've had Anjalesa twice now, and she has been wonderful—truly exceptional service.

If I could complain about one thing, it's the consistent lack of salad. I've come three Fridays now, and every time, the salad is completely gone, which is the only side I can have. They can't have one of the best ranches and not carry enough salad that they run out every Friday I've been here! I end up paying full price but leave with no side.

I hope the management sees this and addresses the salad stock, because otherwise, this place is a huge winner.“

“Expected some run of the mill bar food but WOW!! For the price this is an EXCEPTIONAL quality dinner. I'm ordering from them many many more times! Delicious.“

“Love these pizzas and the service!“

“Am from out of town and ordered via grubhub. I kept getting notices that it was being delayed so I called the restaurant and spoke with Amanda. Not only did she resolve my issue but she herself delivered the food. Awesome customer service. I highly recommend them. The pizza was delicious! It really hit the spot.“

“One of the top 5 pizzas in Milwaukee.“

“everyone there is always very friendly. we love eating there“

“This was our first time ordering. We’ll definitely order again! We loved everything about our pizza, the crust, the sausage, the sauce. There was just the right amount of sauce and cheese. We really enjoyed it!“

“Food is great. Italian sub hot or cold... amazing. Nickle nuggets AMAZING.
CREW very hit or miss. Mostly a miss. Just in almost 2 weeks ago. We ordered salad... no silverware after we asked for 8 minutes. Ordered a 2 liter of soda asked for it 3 times.... 30 min later I got it.... yes 10 min after the food came out.
I think I will try delivery.“