31 Best Pizza Restaurants near Thiensville

“Delicious pizza. Ordered thin crust custom. Crunchy crust. Delicious giant pieces of sausage. Super cheesy. A ton of hot sauces to choose from to put on top. Sprecher root beer in stock. Great customer service and atmosphere. Clean and cozy.“

“Super happy to have returned to Old Germantown restaurant for the third time and first time inside the restaurant. Farm Fresh means extra work, planning and focus on ingredients. Forget instant gratification found in drive through's and fast food mass production-delivery. This is a family run throw back offering awesome craft beers made onsite and many creative personal pizza's. Just like the thousands of small craft breweries throughout the west, sometimes ale/beer types run out, you get to venture to other tastes! If you want some lager canned weeks ago designed for college kids on spring break, this is not a place for you. If you are in a hurry and long ago forgot what restaurant atmosphere is, this is not a place for you. If you need a large backlit sign to find the driveway (like main street America looks today), this is not a place for you. Here is a challenge, find the restaurant without your GPS!Last night we tried the "Milwaukee" pizza and if you grew up in Southeastern Wisconsin you know what a "Milwaukee" pizza should taste and look like. They nailed it and I get the left overs today! Regarding the Ale; I was a taste tester for a global Milwaukee beer company, have traveled the Western hemisphere trying ales and beers all over. The ales here are excellent.If you get an opportunity I highly recommend Old Germantown, enjoy!“

“This is by far the best pizza! You must order the deep dish. Even people that typically do not like deep dish love this one! The crust tastes like my grandma's beer bread she used to make. The ingredients are fresh and they are not stingy with their toppings. I even had my friend's mom (from Italy) dine with me there and she said it was exceptionally good. She said the sausage is excellent. It's a small, cozy place. A great place to dine with friends. The bartenders are always friendly. (You order at the bar and they tell you when your order is up.) My latest visit was recently. We drove from the airport, all the way to Tomaso's in the snow to enjoy their pizza, (we even ordered a par bake to take home) then drive an hour back home.“

“5/1 Update: I just wanted to follow up on my 3 star review from 2 weeks ago. I upvoted to 5 stars due to my experience today. Assistant Manager, Ty, was very friendly and courteous, and went out of the way to make sure I had a good customer experience after running out of one of the toppings I ordered. That was much appreciated. And as I noted earlier the pizza was fantastic, the best Toppers pizza I’ve ever had. Thank you, Ty!Previous review:Nice staff working the front, however, when I initially called I was told they couldn’t handle the request, that it should have gone through the call center. After further explanation, they said they would take my order. Lo and behold, when I picked up my order, it was that same staff member who took my order who also rang me up. I didn’t know the staff at our local Toppers shouldn’t be taking orders? Hmm. Not to mention, they seemed otherwise engaged with another staff member, on a very slooow night.Note: I’ve only had really good experiences at this location up until tonight and the pizza is as good as ever.“

“this was my first visit to Ivee's! the food was very good and the staff was attentive. I have been a customer for a good many years to the Sawmill and Odyssey restaurants and Ivee's by far exceeds their standards! I hope they take their business away as they deserve it! Thank you!“

“Ordered pizza, lasagna, and garlic bread for a small gathering at our house. Staff was very helpful in helping us figure out how much we would need, and getting things ordered (especially, Sam). Everything was hot, ready on time, and enjoyed by all… especially the lasagna/garlic bread. Even the small bit of leftovers we had the next day was delish ?? ??“

“Visiting Cedarburg Wisconsin for the first time today our group really lucked out in finding Sal's pizzeria. After being turned down at a few local spots for not having reservations we continued down main steet in hopes of finding someplace good for breakfast. After a few minutes walking downtown we crossed the street where the familiar smell of fresh baked pizza permeated the air. After a short discussion the group decided I should go inside first to check if they had enough room for the six of us and see if they made gluten free pizza. The answer was yes to both so we decided to give it a try and man are we glad we did! The six of us, all pizza snobs from Chicago had to agree Sal's makes an exceptionally good pie, literally among the best pizza any of us ever tasted. What makes admitting this so hard is the fact Sal's pizza is New York style, a hard pill to swallow for anyone from the Windy City. But hey, anything as good as Sal's needs to be celebrated so that's why we've decided to surrender this battle in the Pizza wars and share this amazing gem with the world.Mangiare“

“Some of the best Italian food I've ever had in my life. And I frequently go back to New York, which arguably is known for Italian food. The atmosphere is wonderful. The owner is usually there and he's a steel trap of memory. He knows who we are you feel like family when you go in there. Did I mention it's the best Italian food I've had in a while. If you haven't tried it you have to try it even if it's just grabbing a pizza to go.“

“always enough toppings, staff is great but they need to upgrade the use of credit and or debit cards so you can leave a tip for the staff. they only have a tip jar for cash. I for one do not carry cash most of the time anymore due to a lot of businesses can be cashless. i wish he/they would update. As i am told it is not a difficult process to change over“

“Gave this spot a try. Ordered a large pepperoni, basil, and garlic extra thin. And a small pepperoni and black olive thin crust. Also ordered garlic bread with marinara sauce. First let me say. Their thin crust is basically hand tossed and the extra thin is a thicker version of a thin crust pizza. Both pizzas graded out to be about a 6.2/10. The cook on them was good. Not undercooked like many chain places do. The sauce is zesty with little to no sweetness. We preferred the sweeter sauce at Demarinis. But if you like a zestier sauce, you will most likely prefer Pepinos. Pizza was a tad greasy. Basil was dried basil, and not fresh unfortunately. But overall, I’d choose this place over any chain. The garlic bread and marinara was a bit confusing. They forgot the marinara unfortunately. So we just got the bread. The garlic bread looks to be French bread with sesame seeds on the bottom. Definitely different as the bitterness of the sesame doesn’t really mix well the buttery flavor of the garlic. 3.5/10 on the bread. Not my favorite, but not my least favorite. 6/10 overall experience.“

“December 23rd, my family had our Family Christmas party here. Great time. I also came here for the Friday fish fry. Great catfish, very delicious. Excellent customer service and staff. Great venue for a party, delicious food and great price.“

“I’ve been ordering from Chicken Man/Gianelli’s for over 30 years. My parents got it when I was a kid and I have been ordering since for my family! Great food for a reasonable price, which is not easy to find as much! But definitely great food and service!“

“Highly recommend!The delivery on March 3rd around 6 pm, was on time and the delivery driver was incredibly courteous and professional. I wish we had gotten his name so we could let his manager know we both really appreciated such great service.'The Worx' pizza was absolutely delicious. The hand tossed crust was perfect and all the toppings were even better than anticipated.The whole experience was great, thank you, and we'll be ordering from your restaurant again!“

“This is my first time ordering from there and the food was quite delicious. I ordered the large cheese and sausage pizza and enjoyed the taste And firmness of the cheese and toppings on the crust. So many times pizza toppings slide all over and this was Enjoyable to open the box and see everything in place. We also ordered the garlic Parmesan boneless wings and those were by far the best tasting Boneless wings I have ever had. The wings are moist and flavorful. I could order the wings solely as a meal and be totally satisfied. I will definitely order from them again. I just wish I was a bit closer to their location but they were able to get the pizza to me on the east side with no problem. Delivery driver was super also.“

“I have been coming here for over 30 years and they have never disappointed me. I love that they are fresh and bake the pizza to perfection so that the crust isn't doughy or burnt. I wish that they opened a little earlier so I can have it at lunchtime, but I will take them being open in the evening because it's always been like this and I would assume that this is what continues to make their service great as well as their food. I will continue to patron small business. That is a historical part of the city.“

“An excellent fast casual dining experience. I was promptly greeted and asked if there was any particular pizza I would like on the buffet, which they made a priority to get in the oven quickly. All the items on the buffet were fresh and rotated out in a timely manner despite it being a Tuesday afternoon between lunch and dinner. The pizza was of a high quality. The store was clean and the atmosphere was pleasant. As an added bonus they offered nacho cheese in addition to the usual marinara to accompany bread/cheese sticks. I highly recommend this buffet to any pizza lover.“

“This establishment was very professional, I enjoyed how great the employees spent their hard time working on my meal! I will be sure to come back next time I am in the taste buds for some delicious toppers pizza ?!!! I also want to specially give a thanks to my favorite employee, Meearah Cornelius!! Thank you Toppers!!!!“

“Support local, this is your place! I am a pizza fanatic and definitely wasn't disappointed here. They have many other options as well with great specials at a great price. Family owned, what else could you ask for? There's a reason they have been in business so long. Don't drive by, stop in and grab some good eats!“

“Stopped in recently for the first time and had the crispy chicken sandwich. It was the best chicken sandwich I have ever had. Crispy, juicy and hot - served on a toasted brioche bun with fresh lettuce, tomato and a creamy mayonnaise. The Kettle Chips were perfect. Good price and great service. You can tell they care about what they do. Looking forward to trying the meatball sub.“

“Absolutely a gem. I love there pizza and appetizers, and all of it. Great place. Never disappointed. I came across this place on my son's baseball weekend tournament. And I'm from milwaukee and use to eat at lil Demarinis on kk in bayview. They have closed down for several yrs now. But when I seen the name. I had to stop. And man. I was amazed. Way better than that trash at Dom& Phil Demarinis. By far.They are A rated in my book and best believe I'm super picky. I'm have Italian and half Puerto Rican. So I know best of both worlds. Pizza is to die for. Wish the opened at 11am like they do on Fridays, more days of the week though. Because I'm a union hvac tech and when I'm in the area on calls. I want a pizza . But can't unless it's friday“

“Our family loves Rosati’s. If you enjoy pizza you will definitely have to visit. The golden rule is the sauce and crust define the pie. They have nailed it. Great customer service and smiling faces welcome all. I have not tried other menu items but I would be inclined to say they have to be just as tasty as the pizza. Great job guys for staying consistent.“

“The deep dish pizza is really great!!We arrived fairly early in the evening so it wasn't very busy, but it was still fairly loud due to hard surfaces in the restaurant. (Not too loud, just enough that it's noticeable.)We sat in a booth and put our order in at the bar. Food was delivered to us and everything was really good. We will definitely be going back... And we will try to bring friends or family members!“

“Friendly staff great food. Had wings the garlic parm and the Thai chili, both were delicious but we were craving spicy. We decided to order the irie heat....YUM! You won't be disappointed if you like spicy it's smoky and peppery. It doesn't last forever so you can enjoy more. We told the gentleman who brought the food out we loved it and he said he had something hotter called the scary Larry sauce. We were thrilled, we dipped a bit of the garlic parm since it's so mild and I took a baby bite and was fine. My husband was sweating and tearing. Go check it out“

“My friend and I went for a quick lunch Saturday around 12:30. The server immediately told us food may take a longer than usual since she was the only one working. With that said, we received amazing service and the food came out quickly. Our server Christina was professional and very attentive despite being the only server. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“Great Service Great Soulfood(Every 4th Sunday with the exception of how a Holidays might fall).I might say durning Soulfood Sunday The Hall is kid friendly durning the hours of 2pm to 530pm You will need to bring your own seating for the little ones if neededWonderful Event space with outdoor heated space available AsWell!The Everyday kitchen food is Top Tier!!Most Importantly the ratio to adult beverage in a cup Is ? Respectful“

“A great addition to Bayshore. I've been here several times since they opened and the pizza is very good! They have a nice cocktail menu- and the space is causal and fun. Date night appropriate, or just hanging out- it fits the bill. My favorite pizza is the Cadillac and it's even good the next day cold!“

“Everything you'd expect when dining at a quality Italian restaurant in Mequon, yet pretty well-priced. According to the bill, our server at table 31 last night was a young guy named "Alexander N" whom was really pleasant and well trained. If management reads these he deserves an attaboy.“

“Brandon was great. He took the order and made the pizza. He was very attentive and courteous. I was hesitant to order from this location after reading some of reviews. I’m glad I took a chance. The pizza was great and the wings were excellent. I’d 100% recommend coming here again. This is the pizza I miss every time I visit Milwaukee (traveling from Georgia).“

“If you have not tried this place yet, shame on you! This is an absolute must try! The pizza was phenomenal! Absolutely fantastic pizza! The wings tasted really good and tender, but in my opinion were missing a lot of sauce. Idk, maybe it's just me, but I like having more than bare minimum sauce on my wings. I will be sure to ask for extra sauce on my wings next time.“

“I hadn't ordered Little Ceasars in years, and it was at 8:40PM that I placed an order for pick up. Luckily, they said they could provide the food within 15 minutes, just before closing.I didn't understand that the lobby closes at 8:30PM until I read a small sign in the window. But, when I pulled into the drive thru, they were very fast and polite. I was even able to ask for additional dipping sauce at the window, and it was of no inconvenience to them. The food was fresh, and so very delicious, ever since I ordered, I've been craving even more. Unfortunately, I don't live that close and so I can't order often, but I would recommend their food. Fresh, delicious, relatively inexpensive, and the people are absolutely polite.“

“I love ordering from this store! 9/10 I get exactly what I order (I order here a lot ?) things happen it’s never a deal breaker for me even being pregnant. Sometimes a forgotten soda, they always come back with it or do a refund! I’ve never had to wait an hour or more for my order and I’m super happy they changed the point exchange! I’ll be cashing in soon ? so excited to try the new pepperoni stuffed breadsticks! Thanks everyone!“