Jimmy John's in Waukesha

“Today I ordered the Gyro and had it delivered. It was delicious! The only negative is that it was 25$ for a awful tasting soda that had a weird aftertaste, a pickle and a small Gyro. Even tho it was very delicious, it was also underwhelming for the price. I was unable to pick up, if I did pick it up, I think it would eliminate some cost and I would have been more satisfied. My husband could easily eat 3 of these Gyros, at that cost there is NO WAY.“

“I placed a pickup order to this location last month (March 14th) for a party and had the unfortunate luck to have someone else take my 3 thirty-piece party boxes + 3 custom sandwiches instead of their own catering order.

Thankfully, I had placed the pickup time about 45 minutes before the party started, so there was enough time for the staff to remake the order while also keeping up with regular lunch orders that came in. I'm very grateful for their quick and efficient work, thanks to them I was only a few minutes late with the food! Everything was well made and I didn't hear any complaints.

I would definitely consider ordering from here again if I needed to cater for a large group, though it would be nice in the future if larger orders like this one were kept closer to the staff and were verified before handing off so someone else doesn't end up in the same situation as this one!

Thanks again to the staff for making a stressful situation much easier to handle!“