50 Best Seafood Restaurants near West Allis

“Gyros Are Amazing As Well customer service is Excellent Clean Place SUPER REASONABLE PRICES MUST TRY TO BELIEVE“

“The restaurant is small, so be sure to make reservations ahead of time in order to ensure a seat upon arrival. The chicken empanadas were great and so were the yucca fries. The entries had lots of flavor and the chicken was really tender. If the restaurant is full, be aware it might take longer to get your food.“

“This was our 1st. time here and it certainly didn't disappoint! Atmosphere was really nice, cozy but still fun. Our waitress Eliza was super, checking on us but never pushy. She gave us some great recommendations that were absolutely delicious. We started with sharing a cup of corn and crab chowder, beet and goat cheese salad and sautéed crawfish with crossttini. Everything was fantastic, not to spicy hot just seasoned well. Main course was also great, steak and mashed potatoes....super tender and juicy steak came out exactly like we ordered...perfect meduim rare. That doesn't happen often. Also had the blacken salmon with asparagus and beans and rice. Again can't say enough it was delicious. Then to top the evening off we shared the beneignts with a fruit sauce. YUMMY Kudos to you all the chef and waite staff and Eliza for a great dining experience.“

“The best Chinese in the city so good. Amazing locally owned spot! Everything is delicious! You can't go wrong.“

“It you want great, authentic homemade Chinese food…….this is the place. Honestly, the best chicken fried rice you’ll ever eat, amongst everything else. Great family restaurant, they work so hard, remember their customers, and every single meal is made to perfection. Hadn’t been here in a while since we moved, we were lucky enough to be in the area and stopped in, amazing food as always. Give New No. 1 on 76th & Oklahoma Ave a try if you haven’t , no BS.“

“Excellent atmosphere, food and service.“

“Pricing is reasonable for seafood and food is delicious. Crab legs were AMAZING!“

“Upscale casual cozy restaurant with creative delicious food and cocktails. A very special place!“

“Fried zucchini and steaks are very good so is the spaghetti very friendly people“

“Overall experience was great. Started off with the fried calamari as an appetizer which was to die for and good portion. I had the filet mignon and my husband had the ribeye. Both steaks were cooked perfectly and tasted juicy and tender. We shared the asparagus and crab Mac and cheese for our sides. (Sides are portioned to be shareable). The sides were great as well. My only suggestion is providing clean plates for your sides since they are shareable. The steak comes on a plate covered in au jus which is delicious, but I didn't want to plate my mac n cheese on that plate and the bread plates were a little small. Not a big deal though! Service was great, ambiance was cozy. Highly recommend!“

“Nous adorons cet endroit, nous avons donc faite un détour pour y revenir. La nourriture est excellente et le service est sans reproche.“

“yum is all that needs to b said“

“1st time dining here. Had Imperial Cod,Plank Salmon and Sirloin with shrimp. Great plate presentation , excellent food taste and price. Our server Precious P. was best server we have had in along time. She was very attentive and knew the menu when asked about certain items. Will recommend to all.“

“The pork chop was excellent! I liked that it was served with Gnocchi and not rice or a normally cooked potato. I sampled a bourbon drink and it was so good. Too much sugar if you have diabetes like my partner. Haha“

“Amazing food any dish would be amazing and service is outsanding“

“First time coming in, I live in the area I definitely was satisfied will be back!!! Food was good as well as customer service.“

“Fantastic tasty food and great service!“

“We checked out Outlaw Oyster (located in Crafty Cow) after seeing a video about it by another food reviewer and decided to go during their late “Yappy Hour” (8:30–10 PM). The vibe was laid-back, the deals were great, and the food was definitely memorable.

We ordered the “Let’s Get It All” platter for $50, which included lobster claws with hot butter, smoked whitefish dip, shrimp cocktail, tinned fish with crackers and lemon crème, octopus aguachile, and Caesar fries. We also added on extra lobster claws, shrimp cocktail, and fries.

Highlights:
The smoked whitefish dip was unbelievably good, rich, flavorful, and something we’d absolutely come back for.

Caesar fries were completely addictive.

The tinned fish was so tasty we ended up buying two to take home.

And those tiny tinis… wow. The espresso and dirty martinis were easily some of the best we’ve ever had. The dirty martini especially stood out, super briny, garlicky, and just perfect. (We definitely had more than a few.)

Lowlight:
The lobster claws were unfortunately very overcooked, which was disappointing.

What really stood out, though, was our server, Sugar Bear. She was absolutely outstanding, warm, funny, and super attentive. She genuinely made the whole experience feel special and memorable. When she found out about the overcooked lobster, she immediately apologized and went out of her way to try to make it right. Top-notch service.

Bonus tip: If you’re planning to go, check out the InKind app, they’re offering $30 off $100 right now, which made the night an even better deal.

We’d 100% go back, especially for the tinis, whitefish dip, and Caesar fries.

For more reviews, follow us on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok @gbdiningdykes“

“We come here regularly and love everything from the delicious food to the friendly staff & wonderful owners. I was raised in Kona & this feels like home. Casual atmosphere where you feel like family- but can leave your slippas on! And great island treats & gifts. March of 2025 they have a $10 the King Kamehameha Platter and it's a great way to sample all their dishes. my Favorites are the poké & CharSiu pork🌺“

“We stopped here on a work trip and loved it! The largest portions of seafood I’ve ever seen and delicious. This place is great for groups since the portions of the platters are very large. I’d recommend the large combo plate - it is definitely more than enough to share“

“Our waiter was LAUREN giver her a raise. She did that! She was so knowledgeable & made the dining an experience. Customer service A1. Thanks Lauren It was to celebrate a birthday & try definitely made it a whole experience. I was impressed ! If u r thinking of going def go“

“Wonderful staff beautiful venue great bar and stunning views.“

“This was everything I wanted it to be! They started us with a wine sipper which is so nice and also an amazing way to try new stuff. We got the espresso tini tinis which were SO delish and properly strong. We got one of each featured oyster- all fantastic and the aguachili was a great addition. The smoked trout plate was deliiiiiish and so satisfying. We also got the lobster sliders, smaller than expected but yummy. The Cesar fries are a worthwhile upgrade for sure. I got an extra dry dirty martini and it was perfect. Our waiter Emma was so helpful and kind and fun. We spent the whole dinner talking about how we can’t wait to come back!!!!“

“Yall 2 pizza puff combo don’t come with a drink yall slow & the girls yall got in there dum…..“

“delicious food, great service !“

“All you can eat sushi? C'mon! Who can say "no" to that!? And it's good too!“

“I went in kinda skeptical from all the mixed reviews, especially for the pizza but all my food was great. I ordered on Super Bowl sunday and my food was done really fast. The crust on my hand-tossed greek pizza was very good, even though it was a little strange to put jalapeños on a greek pizza, instead of banana peppers or pepperoncini. The wings were almost too tender but the buffalo sauce was better than expected. Maybe I’m an outlier on experiences but I was impressed.“

“Very, very delicious😋 I recommend anything on the menu. I’ve been there at least 10 times I like the parridilla.“

“Birthday dinner for my 8YO daughter. Shout out to the entire staff at Wonita Sushi Seafood and Bar. They were super patient with the kids, waiter was awesome and even brought an extra dessert after simply noticing my daughter looking with envy at her brothers choice. Then waiting for the bill, the host (manager/owner?) noticed the kids eyeballing the lobster tank and he pulled up a stool for them to get a better look. He explained to the kids the growth rate of lobsters and we explained it was my daughters birthday dinner. Walking to the car, he chased us into the parking lot and gave her a special birthday stuffed animal. I honestly don’t think I’ve ever been this impressed with service. Especially as it was just another day to them, we didn’t mention the bday until leaving. We had planned a different place that is closed on Mondays. Glad we tried Wonita. They left a very favorable impression on both kids and they both said they want all future birthdays at Wonita!!“

“We went for China Lights 2025 and it was wonderful! We bought the family four-pack for around $80 and drove 1:20 from near Chicago and it was totally worth it.
Very interactive. Lots of interesting prehistoric lights, enchanted forest, the zodiac, fish, dragons and crocodiles and a whole interactive area with swings, seesaws, dance floors, music interactions, a life tree, Halloween lights, pumpkins, games, bubbles and more.“

“Absolutely amazing, all around! Food, service, everything. Shrimp sweet and delicious. Scallops silky soft and smooth, seared great and so tasty! Bacon wrapped asparagus is killer good. Prime rib sandwich is pillow soft, so flavorful and satisfying. Great garlic and herb butter seasoning on everything. I had a nasty respiratory infection a couple months prior, hadn't been able to taste much of anything for over two months... until coming here. I could taste the amazing flavor cooked into all of our items for the first time since getting sick. This was probably about the most satisfying dining experience I've ever had. Love it and can't wait to go back!!!“

“This is an amazing choice for people in large groups and/or if you're just looking for good food. Customer service was amazing very grateful for the last minute seating. There was a group of 9 of us and they were super welcoming to all of us. I would recommend anyone who is hungry, eat here, you will not be disappointed.“

“Took the Hubster to celebrate his Father’s Day… Our French waitstaff, live music , ambience and our cuisine were all EXCEPTIONAL. #Datenight36Yrs“

“The food is good and alot of food.“

“The food was awesome great atmosphere!! Was happy we found it after turning down 3 others places to eat!! Would visit again if we come threw that town again!!“

“My wife and I had a wonderful date night AT Mallard“

“The best chicken parm I've ever had.“

“Great venue with unique selection of drinks and dishes.The romantic vibes are perfect for couples and casual dining. There is a dedicated parking lot for the restaurant too. Highly recommended!“

“Way better experience compared to last time. The 2 pc catfish dinner was so good a bit pricey though but I highly recommend❤️“

“Wow, what a great restaurant! The cozy bar area, great staff, wonderful food. I just moved to the area, and I'm looking very forward to becoming a regular.“

“One of the best New York Strips my husband has ever had. And for me, I had the tenderloin which was absolutely cooked to perfection and I also ordered a side scallop which was absolutely delicious! Way to go Jackson Grill! We WILL be back!“

“The food is delicious very well.I rated as a great place to go with family and friends.They have specials on beers now and then.And second, the food can be hot and spicy.If you like it or mild.
My waitress Tiffany was very polite and friendly, always check on us.Make sure we had everything we need.And if we didn't, she got it right away.“

“I always bring all my friends here. It's a nice hangout spot and the staff there make it even better. I recommend the volcano chicken 🐔 😋.“

“Celebrating Family, Friendship, Life, Champagne Dinner And 5 star Service At One Of Wauwatosa’s Finest Dining Destinations! 😋❤️“

“please keep up great food& service in 2025 hope your Allgood PALI“

“We didn’t try any of the seafood but gave the Vietnamese food a try… First off, super clean! Right off the bat, without trying the food, I knew that I’d come back based off this alone. When a place is clean, it makes worth it Second, our server, Liyah, sooo wonderful! Super attentive and very nice! Third, the food was good! Not the best pho/Vietnamese food I’ve had. but considering it’s not their main feature, it wasnt bad! The eggrolls were meh, definitely frozen. We will definitely be back again!“

“Finally tried the chicken and shrimp alfredo from many recommendations and it was 🔥 🔥 🔥 chicken was juicy and very saucy. Not many shrimp but enough. I will add broccoli next time and mushrooms if they have them. If you scared of a lil salt don’t order it. It wasn’t overly salty but for somebody who watches their salt intake might find an issue. My mild buffalo wings with the fries was on point per usual. I got a peach lemonade and it was good too. Again very sweet for somebody who can’t handle that don’t get it! I just added a little water to it when I got home. The ice machine wasn’t working so I added ice too. The restaurant was clean. I know they can be hit or miss but they was on point this day! Actually I never had a miss. If it’s a busy time of day like a lunch rush, the last hr before close or a weekend, just plan and call ahead if you can. I called ahead and got great food. My auntie said her plain whole wings didnt have any flavor but people usually go for the variety of flavors they offer so go up the street to jjs for plain wings. & you can sprinkles some seasoning on your own food right at the side counter. And when I came in there was someone at each register waiting to help customers. I know everybody won’t have a good experience but damn yall it’s not Coopers Hawk 🥩 but its good ghetto food lol.“

“I had sworn off of JJ's Chicken after my last experience but this new location for me is fantastic! The chicken is not oily. The meal was ready when we arrived. The fries were crispy just like I like them! You have a new customer with us.

Parking: Enough parking in the lot when we were there.“

“The service was warming. The young lady made sure we had everything we needed. She recognized it was my first time visiting their establishment. You could tell she had a relationship with their customers. Which says a lot. The fish was fresh and fried with a great golden coating. The pieces were a nice size not tiny and shriveled up. ???? We will be returning. We thank you for great service.Note: Don't allow the exterior to detour you from trying them out. It may not be fancy however everything was fresh and it didn't look dirty.

Parking: There is offstreet parking available.“