50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Whitefish Bay

“food and service was good“

“Good food and environment“

“Excellent atmosphere, food and service.“

“Pricing is reasonable for seafood and food is delicious. Crab legs were AMAZING!“

“We've been going here since '91. Always a great experience. The Grouper basket is my go to meal. Delicious!“

“Upscale casual cozy restaurant with creative delicious food and cocktails. A very special place!“

“Nous adorons cet endroit, nous avons donc faite un détour pour y revenir. La nourriture est excellente et le service est sans reproche.“

“great customer service and the food was amazing“

“Excellent Food. the service and staff is out of this world, one of the best experiences I've had at a restaurant. Fabulous place everyone should experience. The staff is exceptional, not only our server but others came to talk and make sure we were enjoying our selves and the food. Highly recommend !!!“

“yum is all that needs to b said“

“Had to stop in last night with friends to try the nuggets and caviar and I could have eaten them all day. Absolutely delicious.
Everyone at our table loved the Caesar fries, genius idea.
The oysters were delicious and fresh and loved the fried capers on the deviled eggs.
The only disappointment was the lobster roll. That was the saddest lobster I have ever seen, dried out like it had been microwaved.
Our waitstaff forgot about us the end of meal check but otherwise was friendly and tried with the drink recommendations.
Despite the lobster, we'll be back again for more oysters and nuggets :) Thank you!“

“First time coming in, I live in the area I definitely was satisfied will be back!!! Food was good as well as customer service.“

“Stumbled upon this unique, marvelous place. Will definitely visit again. Sampled several items, all delish. Hubby said oysters were best he has had anywhere in the country! Fries were even delish, very crispy. Complimentary wine sampler to start, how nice. The espresso tini tinis were just the way we like them. Had to order seconds. Enjoy.“

“Went to The Capital Grille for a business dinner meeting and we both selected the restaurant week menu. The sea bass was excellent, food portions perfect. Unfortunately, my business guest's steak was served overcooked and dry. However I want to highlight a few important details...

1. A manager approached our table and apologized for a delay on our food - honestly we didn't even notice and the fact that she brought it to our attention was amazing!

2. When we expressed that the steak was overcooked and not the M.Well temp not only were they apologetic but the restaurant went above and beyond our expectations to take care of us!!

I LOVE Excellent customer service- in a world where customer service is lacking and not what it use to be , The Capital Grille refreshed my memory on exactly how Superb customer service looks and feels!! I Love this restaurant!!“

“Wonderful staff beautiful venue great bar and stunning views.“

“Excellent, excellent, excellent. 10/10 for everything except the owners. They are 12/10! Great food, absolutely welcoming and charming. Don’t be lolo like me and wait too long—head to Ono Kine Grindz wiki wiki! It was our Valentine’s Day date-I had the chicken/pork combo plate with carrot pineapple slaw and macaroni salad, my husband has the Hawaiian breakfast. Excellent all around—the POG juice leveled it up even more. I love this place, and I am gladly adding it to my favorites/must haves when we get visitors.“

“Yall 2 pizza puff combo don’t come with a drink yall slow & the girls yall got in there dum…..“

“delicious food, great service !“

“I went in kinda skeptical from all the mixed reviews, especially for the pizza but all my food was great. I ordered on Super Bowl sunday and my food was done really fast. The crust on my hand-tossed greek pizza was very good, even though it was a little strange to put jalapeños on a greek pizza, instead of banana peppers or pepperoncini. The wings were almost too tender but the buffalo sauce was better than expected. Maybe I’m an outlier on experiences but I was impressed.“

“The bartenders and whole staff are very welcoming! Food is always perfect. Love the spice!“

“Very, very delicious😋 I recommend anything on the menu. I’ve been there at least 10 times I like the parridilla.“

“Took the Hubster to celebrate his Father’s Day… Our French waitstaff, live music , ambience and our cuisine were all EXCEPTIONAL. #Datenight36Yrs“

“The food was hot and fresh but we did have to wait a bit. I'd suggest ordering ahead it seemed to be the trend. We tried the catfish, fried chicken, fries, and fried green tomatoes. Unfortunately, the fried green tomatoes were a bit disappointing and flavorless, but the rest of the meal was really good. The chicken and fish were crispy and juicy. Although the dining area didn't quite live up to our expectations, so we decided to take our food to go instead.“

“The best chicken parm I've ever had.“

“The food is good and alot of food.“

“The restaurant is small, so be sure to make reservations ahead of time in order to ensure a seat upon arrival. The chicken empanadas were great and so were the yucca fries. The entries had lots of flavor and the chicken was really tender. If the restaurant is full, be aware it might take longer to get your food.“

“Way better experience compared to last time. The 2 pc catfish dinner was so good a bit pricey though but I highly recommend❤️“

“Always come hungry! I always split a bag with someone. I enjoy their crab legs and shrimp. This time I ordered a bag of shrimp. It comes with potatos, corn, and a slice of corn bread. I always add broccoli and cauliflower. I also recommend getting a side of white rice as it pairs nicely w the seasoned butter sauce. Their cajun and everything sauces are yummy 😋“

“We showed up with two extra people than what our reservation was for. They quickly accommodated us. The waitress was good and efficient. The food was decent, good-sized portions.“

“This is my first time and it will not be my last time purchasing a crab boil With Cajun seasoning from this place I give them a 10 out of 10 even though they left out my eggs I ordered a special with the lobster tail, but they didn’t give me no eggs once I started eating it I couldn’t pull myself away to go back up there to get the eggs I Don’t stay too close to the restaurant. So despite not having the eggs, it was still good and I will be returning I was kinda mad about the eggs my boil was $52“

“The food was excellent the best Chophouse we’ve ever been to. 🔥🔥🔥🔥“

“Great venue with unique selection of drinks and dishes.The romantic vibes are perfect for couples and casual dining. There is a dedicated parking lot for the restaurant too. Highly recommended!“

“One of the best New York Strips my husband has ever had. And for me, I had the tenderloin which was absolutely cooked to perfection and I also ordered a side scallop which was absolutely delicious! Way to go Jackson Grill! We WILL be back!“

“The service was warming. The young lady made sure we had everything we needed. She recognized it was my first time visiting their establishment. You could tell she had a relationship with their customers. Which says a lot. The fish was fresh and fried with a great golden coating. The pieces were a nice size not tiny and shriveled up. ???? We will be returning. We thank you for great service.Note: Don't allow the exterior to detour you from trying them out. It may not be fancy however everything was fresh and it didn't look dirty.

Parking: There is offstreet parking available.“

“I honestly cannot say ENOUGH great things about Gold Rush Chicken! They’re an amazing crew with fantastic food & service! I’ve been ordering from them for over 30 years & it honestly has only gotten better!! They’re South Side Royalty as far as our family is concerned!! We LOVE Gold Rush Chicken!!“

“I had sworn off of JJ's Chicken after my last experience but this new location for me is fantastic! The chicken is not oily. The meal was ready when we arrived. The fries were crispy just like I like them! You have a new customer with us.

Parking: Enough parking in the lot when we were there.“

“The blackened mahi mahi tacos and the old bay fries were so good! And we love Val, our bartender. ❤️“

“The best chicken I've had in the whole state of Wisconsin is in Milwaukee . JJ s chicken is worth trying because once you try it..it will be a regular place you eat I promise. Chicken that makes your mouth water.. awesome thank you jhs“

“Celebrating Family, Friendship, Life, Champagne Dinner And 5 star Service At One Of Wauwatosa’s Finest Dining Destinations! 😋❤️“

“I always bring all my friends here. It's a nice hangout spot and the staff there make it even better. I recommend the volcano chicken 🐔 😋.“

“Had the poutine (extra gravy). Lemme tell ya, �YUM“

“Super Taco is owned by my former employee Lupe . She worked so hard for us now she has her own restaurant! The tacos are amazing! And even has burgers and Philly cheese steaks! Highly recommend for some tasty and very affordable food!“

“Finally tried the chicken and shrimp alfredo from many recommendations and it was 🔥 🔥 🔥 chicken was juicy and very saucy. Not many shrimp but enough. I will add broccoli next time and mushrooms if they have them. If you scared of a lil salt don’t order it. It wasn’t overly salty but for somebody who watches their salt intake might find an issue. My mild buffalo wings with the fries was on point per usual. I got a peach lemonade and it was good too. Again very sweet for somebody who can’t handle that don’t get it! I just added a little water to it when I got home. The ice machine wasn’t working so I added ice too. The restaurant was clean. I know they can be hit or miss but they was on point this day! Actually I never had a miss. If it’s a busy time of day like a lunch rush, the last hr before close or a weekend, just plan and call ahead if you can. I called ahead and got great food. My auntie said her plain whole wings didnt have any flavor but people usually go for the variety of flavors they offer so go up the street to jjs for plain wings. & you can sprinkles some seasoning on your own food right at the side counter. And when I came in there was someone at each register waiting to help customers. I know everybody won’t have a good experience but damn yall it’s not Coopers Hawk 🥩 but its good ghetto food lol.“

“I always enjoyed Tu Casa. The food is good and the service is excellent. The only issue is that we both asked for no rice and beans with our dinners. So, instead of charging us the dinner price we got À la carte price, three tacos without rice and beans $2-3 more expensive than the dinner. Two chimis with a side of sour cream and a side of guac and no rice and beans…you guessed it $6-7 more than the dinner. Including two $4.50 glasses of ice tea our lunch was $48.42, unfortunate.“

“This was our 1st. time here and it certainly didn't disappoint! Atmosphere was really nice, cozy but still fun. Our waitress Eliza was super, checking on us but never pushy. She gave us some great recommendations that were absolutely delicious. We started with sharing a cup of corn and crab chowder, beet and goat cheese salad and sautéed crawfish with crossttini. Everything was fantastic, not to spicy hot just seasoned well. Main course was also great, steak and mashed potatoes....super tender and juicy steak came out exactly like we ordered...perfect meduim rare. That doesn't happen often. Also had the blacken salmon with asparagus and beans and rice. Again can't say enough it was delicious. Then to top the evening off we shared the beneignts with a fruit sauce. YUMMY Kudos to you all the chef and waite staff and Eliza for a great dining experience.“

“Best fried clams and Bloody Mary on the planet“

“I had an exceptional experience at this restaurant! The service was fabulous and the food was on point. I highly recommend this establishment for anyone looking for a great meal and wonderful atmosphere. It's definitely one of the best restaurants in town!“

“Food was excellent, service, very efficient and attentive by Sadee and her serving partner. The interior is nouveau rustic and complimented the menu nicely! Celebrated our 35th Wedding Anniversary!“

“Limited menu and hours but EXCELLENT Pizza and very reasonable prices. A nice quiet bar.“

“Finally checked this place out and it did not disappoint. Everything that we ordered was amazing and full of flavor. Service and atmosphere were great too. Reasonable pricing. If you haven’t gone yet, here’s your sign to go.“