24 Best Italian Restaurants in Gilbert

“Vito's Pizza & Italian Ristorante is a hit with both pizza and pasta lovers. The restaurant offers delicious food, including gluten-free pizza, and efficient, friendly service. Customers praise the tasty pizza, exceptional calamari, and generous servings, making it a great choice for both lunch and dinner.“

“North Italia is a restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. The atmosphere is great, and the service is attentive, with servers ensuring customers have everything they need. The food is delicious, with a wide variety of options to choose from, including tasty appetizers like meatballs and bruschetta, and main dishes like pesto chicken. While the restaurant can get busy, making a reservation is recommended. Overall, North Italia is a great spot for a night out with friends, offering a quality meal in a welcoming environment.“

“Crust Simply Italian Gilbert serves excellent, fresh food with a wide variety of menu options. The Spicy Garlic Knots are a highlight, though be aware they pack a punch. Save room for the Butter cake, a hands-down favorite dessert. The restaurant accommodates gluten-free and dairy-free dietary needs, with attentive service that elevates the dining experience.“

“Eatalio Pasta & Wine is a popular Italian restaurant in Gilbert, known for its delicious food and great service. The garlic bread and cheese raviolis with marinara sauce are standout dishes, as is the penne alla vodka with shrimp. Although it can be a bit pricey, customers feel that the quality of the food justifies the cost. The restaurant is also praised for its authentic preparation of pasta, with some customers noting that it is served al dente, as it should be. Overall, Eatalio is a highly recommended spot for anyone in the area seeking consistently good Italian food.“

“Postino East is a popular restaurant that consistently receives excellent reviews for its outstanding service and delightful dining experience. The staff, including Kiley, Garrett, and Logan, are praised for their attentiveness, patience, and friendly demeanor, ensuring a memorable visit for all guests. The restaurant offers a variety of menu items, including a Chef's Charcuterie board and a range of bruschetta options, all of which are described as fresh, light, and delicious. Postino East also features daily happy hour specials and a weekly board and bottle special, making it an attractive destination for both casual and special occasions. Customers highly recommend this establishment, noting its welcoming atmosphere and dog-friendly policy.“

“Brio Italian Grille offers a range of dishes, with the lamb chops and chicken Parmesan being mentioned as standouts. However, there was a complaint about the lamb chops not being prepared as described. The service is reported to be excellent, with servers Christopher and Daniel going above and beyond to provide great service. The atmosphere is also described as enjoyable. The restaurant is suitable for both couples and families.“

“Zappone's Italian Bistro is a recommended spot with accommodating staff and awesome food. Located in a shopping area with ample parking, it's kid-friendly too, offering high chairs and coloring sheets. Enjoy great deals during happy hour, with delicious appetizers, entrees, drinks, and desserts. The cozy setting and excellent service make for a pleasant dining experience, despite some dishes lacking in flavor consistency. The kitchen staff is praised, although some dishes could use a bit more seasoning. Overall, a promising place to visit for a satisfying meal and warm service.“

“By The Bucket Gilbert is a restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. The aromas from the kitchen are fantastic, making customers eager to try the spaghetti. The online ordering process is easy and convenient, and the friendly staff is more than willing to assist. The spaghetti is described as having amazing flavors, with a quality marinara sauce that is among the best. The portions are generous, and the meatballs are tasty with a good texture. The garlic bread is also praised as being delicious. Customers who have visited the cozy and affordable restaurant have been impressed with the food and service, and those who have ordered delivery have been equally satisfied. The owner's personal outreach to ensure customer satisfaction is a testament to their commitment to providing a great dining experience.“

“Buonos Pizza is a beloved spot in the valley, delivering on its promise of authentic New York-style pizza. With a rich history, the restaurant has maintained its quality over the years, serving up amazing pies that taste just as good as they did years ago. The staff goes above and beyond, providing excellent customer service and ensuring a pleasant dining experience. With its affordable prices and great lunch options, Buonos Pizza is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers.“

“Picazzo's Healthy Italian Kitchen Gilbert offers a varied menu with gluten-free and kid-friendly options. The salads are generously portioned, and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The restaurant has a nice ambiance, including a patio with sunscreens, misters, and heaters, and complementary mouthwash in the restrooms.“

“Vero Chicago Pizza offers a variety of delicious pizzas, including butter crust and thin crust options. Customers enjoy the chill vibe and friendly service at both locations. While some find the prices slightly higher, the quality and taste of the pizza make it worth it. The Chicago deep dish pizza is a definite highlight, with free parking available at both spots. A great spot for a casual and tasty pizza night out with friends or family.“

“Carrabba's Italian Grill offers delicious food, amazing service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether celebrating a special occasion or enjoying an early dinner with family, guests appreciate the generous portion sizes and kid-friendly options like penne Alfredo. The gluten-free pasta and Alfredo sauce are highly recommended. Catering services are also available, with attention to detail and on-time delivery making any event stress-free and enjoyable.“

“Spinato's Pizzeria and Family Kitchen in Gilbert offers amazing Chicago-style pizza. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is great. Customers enjoy the cheezy garlic bread and antipasta salad, although parking can be an issue. The crunchy toast and fluffy inside of the garlic bread is a hit, but some find the pizza sauce too sweet. The restaurant is ideal for family gatherings, with fast and friendly service, and cold beer available.“

“Salerno's is a family-owned restaurant that offers a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service. The menu features a range of options, including pizzas, sandwiches, and pasta dishes. The small pizza is a popular choice, with reasonable prices and generous portions. The Italian roast beef sandwich is also a hit, with many customers taking leftovers home. The restaurant's unique pizza oven cooks pizzas with toppings buried under the cheese, allowing for a blend of flavors. The red sauce is also a standout, and the Italian beef and chick parm are favorite dishes among customers. Overall, Salerno's is a great choice for those looking for good food and a friendly atmosphere.“

“Venezia's New York Style Pizzeria in Gilbert is a popular spot for pizza and subs, known for its delicious taste and high-quality food. Favorites include their Buffalo Chicken Hero, Chicken Parm Hero, and Stromboli, which is said to be better than Hot Pockets. The restaurant also offers huge pizza slices, salads, and a welcoming environment with good music. There are plenty of parking spaces, and it is wheelchair accessible with a ramp. Kids will enjoy the large pizza slices, and vegetarian options are available through their salads.“

“Brooklyn V's Pizza offers delicious Italian dishes, including great baked ziti, cheese ravioli, and meatballs. The atmosphere is lively and fun, with live music on weekends, and the staff is friendly and helpful. The pizza is amazing, even impressing picky East Coast customers. Other popular items include garlic knots, fried mozzarella sticks, calzones, stromboli, and pizzas with unique toppings like pineapple and ham.“

“Oregano's is a popular restaurant known for its Rigatoni dish. The location is wheelchair accessible, making it convenient for families with strollers. Customers enjoy the Chicken Parmesan sandwich and find the food good overall, despite some changes in taste. The restaurant can accommodate large parties, although there may be a wait during peak times. Some diners mention being seated in a separate room, which can be noisy when larger groups are present. However, the staff is friendly and apologetic for any inconveniences. Oregano's remains a favorite spot for many families and individuals in the area, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.“

“Romeo's Euro Café serves incredibly fresh and delicious food in an authentic, original setting. The feta cheese salad dressing and pasta dishes are standouts, and the restaurant offers a wide range of choices to suit various tastes. While the bakery section may be a letdown, the excellent service and food make it a great spot for dinner. The atmosphere, attached to a folk art gift shop, may not appeal to everyone, but the food is sure to please.“

“Barro's Pizza is known for serving some of the best pizzas in Arizona, with hot and generously topped options. The wings are also a popular choice. The staff is friendly and helpful, although they may be slightly busy due to managing online orders. The restaurant is generally clean and offers vegetarian options, gluten-free crust, and a kid-friendly area with toys and Disney Jr. on TV. Wheelchair accessibility is convenient with a spacious interior. They occasionally close off seating areas a few hours before closing time.“

“Barro's Pizza offers a variety of delicious options, including an XL pizza and wings special perfect for families. With friendly service and lunch specials available, customers can enjoy a satisfying meal at a reasonable price. The pineapple and jalapeño pizza stands out as a fan-favorite, with the perfect balance of sweet and spicy flavors. Barro's consistently delivers high-quality food, making it a go-to spot for pizza lovers.“

“Marco's Pizza offers an exceptional customer service experience, with friendly staff members like Sam and Drew going above and beyond to ensure a wonderful visit. The restaurant also serves delicious food, particularly its pizzas. One reviewer raved about the Pepperoni Magnífico, which came with both regular and old world pepperoni, and praised the pizza's crunchy texture and flavorful toppings. Another favorite was the Pepperoni Pizzoli, which was devoured in its entirety. With its consistent flavor and quality, Marco's Pizza has earned a loyal customer who plans to return to try more menu options.“

“Which Wich offers a variety of delicious sandwiches like the Wicked, Philly, and Club, along with fresh and tasty fries. The self-service kiosk and friendly staff provide excellent service. However, some find the pricing to be high compared to other sub shops. Kids can enjoy meals with tokens for candy. For a more budget-friendly option, customers suggest visiting Jersey Mike's or eegees.“

“Sauce Pizza & Wine offers great food, fast service, and a friendly staff. The restaurant features a cozy patio, an Italian chop salad, and delicious Mac and Cheese with pulled chicken. The seasonal menu provides tasty surprises, and the staff goes above and beyond to provide exceptional customer service, even during busy times.“

“Fired Pie is a pizza place where you can build your own pizza with a thin dough crust. They offer options like the pesto chicken pizza, which is a popular choice. While some orders may have inconsistencies, the staff provides good service, and the general manager is often seen interacting with customers. Despite some imperfections, Fired Pie is a great spot for a quick and enjoyable meal.“