36 Best Pizza Restaurants in Peoria

“Dinner was great and our service was fabulous! Pumpkin ale was de-lish!! 🎃 Thank you Courtney H!! 😃“

“Pizza is yummy and sandwich’s are delicious! You will feel like family when you are there. Thank you for supporting Liberty Lions.“

“The Calzone is excellent. We ate there three times in the span of a couple of weeks while in AZ“

“Alright so finally tried this place, definitely different since it's In a liquor store however the pizza was actually very good I'm used to new York style this style is a little different but I think I like it better. The wings are huge!! I think they are baked so healthier than fried but not as goood. I definitely taste a certian flavor on the food from the way they cook it and its really good. I will be back!“

“We live local and frequent ballpark pizza all the time. it’s a bicycle ride for our kids to come visit and get a slice of pizza, and the Wife and I will jump on our scooters for date night and have dinner and beers there. The staff is always extremely welcoming, the food is amazing, we love their wings, and I think I’ve had every sandwich on the menu and they’re all fantastic. The chicken Parmesan is one of my favorites. Did I mention the wings? I absolutely love their boneless wings. It’s a great local business support with amazing food and great customer service.“

“We stopped on our way home from the dog groomer in the area because it was close and convenient to our errands. It turned out to be very quick and convenient. A friendly pizza maker took our order and explained the deals that Pappa Murphy's offers. The owner was also on site and showed us the process to sign up. We've always enjoyed the pizza and the fact it gets prepared your way (half and half) and can be ready later when you are. We will visit again and recommend this store to you.“

“Great food & friendly staff … we went after it was featured on Good Morning Arizona TV program“

“I stopped in while I was in the area for Sunday Breakfast. What a great decision. Great food. Waitress, Shandra, was very knowledgeable, fun and efficient. I’ll definitely be returning!“

“AMAZING pizza!! Everything was spot on and service was great!! Definitely my place to go.“

“5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

This place is a true mom-and-pop gem! The pizza is top-notch—crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and perfectly melted cheese—but the real surprise? The buffalo wings. Absolutely incredible! Perfectly crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and tossed in a sauce that hits the perfect balance of tangy, spicy, and savory.

You can tell everything is made with care and quality ingredients. The staff are friendly and make you feel right at home, like you’ve been coming there for years.

If you’re in the mood for great pizza and some of the best wings around, this is the place to go. Support local—you won’t regret it!“

“You all did it, great job. You can taste the food quality, pizza ingredients are obviously top quality and fresh, the wings slide right off the bone, perfect. Wish we would have tried this place years ago, you really gotta get your name out there. All I'm saying is, Tailgaters lost a customer today, for good. Tailgaters service is rude, ignores you, and doesn't care; food is mediocre at best. Uncle Sams, fast, friendly, delicious. You just got a new regular.“

“Hands down the best tasting Calazone I've had in Arizona. Nice friendly staff. Can't wait to sample more delicious items.“

“Went again today, new server Zeb waited on us, exceptional human being. Did a great job, made one minor error and CLAIMED IT, didn’t try to blame anyone else and totally the kind of person you want waiting on you and working for your business! Three cheers for integrity in the year 2025, who’d a thunk it?!!? Thanks again Zeb for taking care of us, see you guys again soon!

Awesome family owned (and staffed) pizza and pasta with exceptional service, great food and reasonable prices! Have never left there disappointed, but always taking some of my food home, because the portions are great and well worth reheating the next day!“

“manager, Tracy, not very friendly or nice. had to have blown someone to get that position, on her knees!!!“

“So much fun.🤩 I like how you don’t have to carry around all those tickets anymore. It all goes on the card or bracelet“

“First timer here !! My family and I just picked up our first order. and it was so delicious!!! The pizza was perfect, my family liked the bacon pizza the most but I enjoyed the pepperoni. The wings are delicious !!! We have found our new favorite pizza shop.. I almost forgot the staff is so kind. The restaurant is super clean and welcoming.“

“Yummmm…enough said! Keep it up❣️“

“CJ is a young man that has made customer service his art? He was prompt and always asked if we required more. I would definitely refer this young man to host all future parties. Private Room was nice but the location not so much, we were in the back where we could not see Our Guests or Children playing otherwise a very nice place.“

“BEST FOOD EVER!! I love the people there and the food is so good. I come here very often and I’m never disappointed. I definitely recommend and I wish everyone could try it.“

“The pasta and meatballs were good. It was a big portion. Nice and thick sauce. I like the atmosphere. The girl that waited on me was working the whole place and made it look easy. This place should appreciate her.

I ordered a cannoli, it was pretty good.“

“2 out of last 3 orders from this location have turned out to be a nightmare. Missing order..or mixed up order..maddening. Can't really blame employees..last nite..both employees. That's right dinner hour, Monday nite football, and only two very young girls who were totally overwhelmed. I know it's hard to find and retain employees but if this store owner wants to stay in business he better figure it out soon.“

“Price went up alot. Look on the website and it wasn't the same as what they quoted. Love the pizza and wings but won't order again. Over $60 Dollars for a XL pizza with 2 toppings and 24 wings.“

“Best Pizza I Have Ever Had & The Only Pizza I Will Eat.. Best Flavor, Very Fresh & Friendly Staff..Best At Everything!! I give them a 10++“

“Our first visit...won't be our last, for sure! The best mussels this side of the Mississippi!!! Amazing, authentic bolognese...and the texture of the pasta, WOW!! Our waitress, Courtney, was outstanding...from carefully explaining specials to the attention she gave our party of 6 throughout dinner!💜“

“Just had the deep dish Chicago style pizza and it's the best I've had around Sun City and even in town it was done so well tasted great would recommend to anyone that wants it deep dish Chicago style pizza“

“Awesome wings!!!! Lexi D is an amazing, professional server.“

“Fox News just ate in New York at Grimaldi’s! I miss this pizza. I live in west Texas & none yet!“

“Never knew they had a place that listens to what you want make it in front of you and give you directions how to cook it at home don’t even need to use your pizza pan’s they provide it and makes it a easy clean up after your done
And they said they will accept Ebt cards for anyone that has it not just the hot meal only one
5 star place they look but out for every single budget type“

“We ordered white pizza today for the first time ; it was delicious. Thick , chewy crust , plenty of cheese ; very good . We definitely will be getting it again“

“Best hot wings e v e r!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“Best hot wings e v e r!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“Pizza is always fresh and warm, service is quick and efficient, every employee we’ve encountered is always friendly (but usually busy!) without a lot of extra chit chat.

Ordering on the app makes it easy and our order is always ready on time. This location is small but clean and we will keep coming back!
Tasty food and well-run from start to finish.“

“great waitress, food and neighborhood atmosphere“

“manager Christina is awesome. alwayd handles every situation with a smile and ease. we have gone many times, but fundraiser nights are so busy tonight was by far the most people I've ever seen in there and the most with a fundraiser. they did games and blew through the line like nothing. the oven pumped out everything they put in. and those workers moved some pies tonight. good food. great service so proud of our local PPP!“

“Michelle I think her name was. Rock star for sure! Tons of orders flowing in and she is rocking it solo on a holiday. Whomever runs this location should be ashamed of themselves leaving her there by herself. I am a manager and would never leave my people alone like that. Doesn’t even matter the pay. But 5 stars to her!!!“

“I love Barro's pizza its NOT greasy at all and the crust is not hard its more of a soft crust like bread sticks.“