New American Restaurants in Crested Butte, CO

“Wonderful food and great service. The Buffalo appetizer was amazing and everything we ordered exceeded expectations. Great atmosphere and menu options. Highly recommend.“

“THE best meal we had in Crested Butte this trip! Grounded in the owner’s great-grandmother’s sourdough starter (named “Trisha”, because OF COURSE), this woman-owned gem is deliciousness at every turn. From the sourdough with black garlic butter to the house-made pasta to the flatbreads and finally bread pudding, everything was PERFECTION - well balanced, indulgent, DELICIOUS. And the wait staff were awesome too (thanks, Abby!). Don’t miss this spot!“

“Just my unbiased opinion. Absolutely delicious!“

“Had a great experience at McGill’s in Crested Butte! The food was solid. Tried a bison burger for the first time and definitely did not disappoint! It had plenty of flavor and was a great choice.

The customer service was excellent. Our waiter was polite, outgoing, and attentive, which made the experience even better.

The restaurant stays pretty busy, so be prepared for around a 20–30 minute wait, especially during peak times. It seemed like a great spot for parties of around 4, and the atmosphere was welcoming and laid-back.

Overall, great food, great service, and a fun Crested Butte experience. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in town! 🍔🏔“

“What an incredible experience. We loved the ability to ski and ski out. The people were all really nice and the food was great. A hidden gem. We recommend definitely a bucket list item you should do. Compare to experiences at some of the other restaurants, we found the prices reasonable.“

“Had our wedding night dinner here after deciding to elope in Crested Butte October 2023. Fantastic place. Great food, cool vibes, amazing service.“

“Came here all the way from South Carolina to meet my grandpa, who lives in Crested Butte. Anyway, we decided to eat at this restaurant, our server was very funny and kind and had a great personality! We ordered the 2nd course fried chicken, the service was kind of slow but the chicken was worth the wait, it was fresh, juicy, and seasoned to perfection. I loved the sides that came with it, especially the cream corn. For desert, we had ice cream sandwiches which were just as good! My only complaint is the price!! It is very expensive and for just 2 people, we paid over 100 dollars for fried chicken! If you have the money, I definitely recommend this place but if you want a cheap budget meal, this place is definitely not for you.“