“Had a party for My Aunt’s Carole 85th birthday party, John and the other guy provided us with great service along with the owner Linda with great flexibility with what we needed. Plenty of delicious food. I also wanna thank Linda with letting us have our own private room that made everything alot easier for us will definitely have another party in the future.“
“My wife and I stopped here for lunch after a train ride in from NYC, it was our first time at Reruns but won't be our last. It is a small, but friendly establishment - as the only non-regulars in the place it could have been uncomfortable, but Karen the bartender treated us like old friends. The owner/chef (didn't catch his name) was friendly, and a great guy. They told us (most of) the food is homemade. We had the French onion soup made by the owners wife (incredible), a buffalo chicken wrap with tots (very good sauce), a $19 lobster grilled cheese that tasted better than a $40 one elsewhere, and finally the clams over linguini (a special, I think). All of the food was delicious, they clearly take pride in their work. We had a couple beers (not sure the price) and finished off with an Irish coffee and a spiked hot chocolate - both were perfect. What an unexpected but 5 star experience. Amazing food, friendly staff, and friendly regulars (they had us cracking up the whole time). Don't let the small space, or divey vibes throw you off - Reruns is a gem and we can't wait to go back!“
“Best bar in West Haven. I mean if you are going to dance and pay for overpriced shots then no. This is not your place. If you are looking for a bar where everyone knows your name and the beer is always cold and served right then this is your place.“
“Great food! Amazing service! They have a lot of choices for sandwich and the best sandwiches I’ve ever tried! The people that work here are very nice and clean. The service is fast and along with the delicious sandwiches you can buy drinks and snacks to go along with them!??“
“For starters went with the garlic fondue. Bread was fresh and spongey and boy, if you love garlic (I do) the roasted garlic in this cheese is for you.Mom went with the Smash Patty Melt and in her words, "it was goooood." I stole a few of the onion straws and they were crispy and flavorful.Me, however, decided to mix it up with the Red Stag Bourbon Burger. Now, using a cherry bourbon to make a bbq sauce is unique, but not weird. Delicious, but not weird.However... This burger has cream cheese on it alongside it's caramelized onions, bacon and bbq sauce. Cream cheese on a burger? That's just weird enough for me to try and not be turned off by. Surprisingly, it didn't really give a cream cheese flavor but it definitely was unique and worth the chance.Next time, I'll try the Nona's chicken, which I wavered back and forth getting but wanted to add something out of the usual tonight and got what I was after!“
“I’m a longtime customer who comes in for breakfast occasionally. Decided to come in today before work on this “Fat Tuesday” I ordered a Mushroom and Cheese Omelette with a Side of Corned Beef Hash. Service is always great, attentive and friendly. Love the additional hours during the end of the week, open until 9:00pm. Never had a bad experience dining here at one of West Haven’s Best Restaurants !“
“I love this place! Papi is the sweetest and so is the lady that works there! I’ve been coming to this restaurant for about 15 years. Papi has seen my children grow from little kids to full grown adults!! Hidden Gem I tell you!! I recommend it 100% I promise, you will come back!! :)“
“First time doing karaoke with Jimmy D Productions here. We had an awesome time. The Philly Cheesesteak egg rolls were good, drinks were excellent, and the staff was amazing. The place was packed! A much better atmosphere than Offshore where Jimmy was previously. The sound in the room was also great. Looking forward to going back for Karaoke again.“
“Just went there . No one in front of me . I order 2 eggs scrambled with bacon and white toast . I’m there for about 10min , a guys comes in and says that they don’t have any sausage sandwiches made so they make him one in like 2min .. about 5min later the guys comes out of the back with 5 sandwiches for their pre made heater . Still nothing for me .. Like 5min later the guys comes out with food for another guy that ordered after me ! I waited for about 20min , I asked if mine was coming , the guy says “ oh he’s making it now “ wtf !! So I say give it to someone else and walk out !!! So pissed that I didn’t ask for my $$ back or anything .. just had to walk out !! Never going back“