42 Best American Restaurants in Rehoboth Beach

“I had a great experience at the Rehoboth Applebees. My server Paul was very friendly, knowledgeable and anticipated our every need.Food was very good“

“This place is amazing. The service is excellent everyone is so friendly and the food was amazing! The gravy is definitely homemade the homefries are crispy and the waffles are so light and fluffy! 15 out of 10 would recommend!“

“Yummy breakfast and servers are very friendly. Would recommend.“

“Incredible atmosphere and ambience, perfect for a romantic night out. The dishes are flavorful, colorful and balanced to be pleasant yet impactful. 10/10 recommend!“

“I loved Cracker Barrel for years. Always something new on the menu, but I can always get my old favorites also. You know what you're getting when you go in for a meal there. Very pleasant environment and very clean bathrooms. The staff is always prompt and courteous.“

“Wonderful gracious hosts! The gnocchi is absolutely amazing and the best espresso martini I have ever had!“

“My sister in law recommended and we went on our anniversary eve and had a spectacular time. The food was excellent and the waiter, Antonio, felt like a long lost friend. As we were leaving, Bob the owner made a point of coming over and saying hello and chatting. Prior, As we were sitting at our table and enjoying our time and a wonderful drink, we noticed that Bob knew everyone that came in. We felt “left out” but by the time we left we felt like family. It doesn’t hurt that the food was really really good. We went on a Monday and they had a steak frites special as well as a filet special. The steaks were perfectly cooked and the sides were extremely well prepared. I almost don’t want to recommend because I want this wonderful place all to myself. Thanks to all and we will be back! Enjoy. We also met Christy who was as nice as the rest of the group. You cannot go wrong here.“

“Amazing service from the moment we walked in the door. First time visiting. Loved the set up of the restaurant and bar area. Food was delicious, awesome beer selection (amazing seasonal craft brews) and service was outstanding! Thank you, Roman & Noel! We’ll be back!“

“the best breakfast around. they make the best and freshest blueberry pancakes. bacon. ham srambled. eggs and sunnyside up eggs. We ate there every morning we were here.

Kid-friendliness: my son is autistic and Amy handled him well. very friendly“

“Michy’s is just outstanding. Michelle, Richard, and Vivian with their team have delivered consistent great service, food, and hospitality since 2014. We highly recommend for your special or casual great experience in Rehoboth!“

“Flavors, textures, cooking technique better than a 5 Star restaurant. Everything on the menu is Amazing. Their homemade sauces are like nothing I have ever tasted before and I am quite the Foodie! My favorite is the Thai Chili Shrimp Taco, I can't order tacos from anywhere else. They truly have spoiled me. The owners are wonderful people and talented chefs! I purposely drive to Rehoboth to do my grocery shopping so I can order dinner once a week from First State!!! It is a must Go-To!!!“

“My favorite spot at the beach. Great food and wine. Awesome service and atmosphere.“

“Fantastic food at a great price and sizzle hot plates to keep food warm We will be back 👍👍“

“Was there 5/15/2024….our dinner was delicious and George could not have been nicer! Love this gem there are lots of good resorts restaurants but this is special it’s not themed cookie cutter like those !!! The food is exceptionally good great sauces and the decor is elegant!!! Ty for making our special dinner out a great experience don’t change a thing!!💕“

“Everything delicious. Chocolate chip cookies best ever. Tiramisu and cheesecake so good. Nice staff. Can’t wait to come back here!“

“Delish loved the servers and bartenders great food“

“Wow! I’ve been here before but I got something different this time and I am blown away. The Day boat Scallop dish is fabulous. The flavor mix of the scallop, squash, bacon, miso, honey, beet and more is incredible. Worth every penny. Our waiter was fabulous as well his name is Justin. I will definitely be back. I may have a new favorite dish in Rehoboth after eating here tonight.“

“Happy hour drink specials and 1/2 price apps, freshly prepared and not frozen. We were in for the burger night special, not only a great value but delish! Very attentive table service, overall a great experience!“

“Amazing dinner and best Manhattan ever!! Great service and we definitely recommend for a very special night out.“

“Hung out with my family there and the vibe and drinks were great!“

“Amazingly consistently great food, the best happy hour at the beach and amazing staff. In the atrium, entertainment is excellent.“

“6/2025 This time we ordered bowls for pickup, the ponzu glass noodles are so good, we also got spinach, chipotle chicken, balsamic mushrooms, garlic broccoli, and the chimichurri sauce. We loved it so much that we got it 2 days in a row! Dedicated gluten free for anyone who can’t have gluten! 5/2025 Employees were super friendly! We had smoothies and cheesecake, both were great. Will be back to try the bowls!“

“I had the pleasure of dining with my children this evening at Big Fish for Valentines Day our server Brooke was absolutely amazing she was attentive and focused on my children's wants and needs . The Food was amazing and the service was great 💪“

“Hung out with my family there and the vibe and drinks were great!“

“Very happy with the experience here. Went in at 11:58 am to get lunch and experienced the noon playing of the National Anthem, which was done with a great deal of care and reverence. I didn't know about that, and I was glad to be there for it.

Food is excellent. Terrific value for the price, great portion sizes of quality BBQ. I had the brisket sandwich, but got a bunch of sides (green beans, collard greens, baked beans, and Cole slaw, as well as cornbread) and all were outstanding.

When we got back to our house to eat, the rest of our family smelled and tasted the food, and then insisted we get it for dinner. Next day leftovers were even better. (Get the pulled pork, save some, make nachos tomorrow. You're welcome.)

The service was even better. Even while busy, they were friendly. One error was made and they immediately made it right. Will absolutely return.“

“it is one of the best experiences u could have. Great staff great food all around just awesome“

“waitress was so nice. food was very good and sat us a nice romantic table as requested. love the bar to, We sat down by the fireplace and the bar tender was very accommodating and made delicious drinks“

“Had a wonderful brunch today for 17 ladies and we couldn't speak more highly of the atmosphere, the service, delicious food and awesome drinks! We had a blast. Thank you, Rigby's!!“

“Great food awesome drinks and awesome live music!!!“

“We went to Iron Hill today, Feb 16. The food was excellent, the service was great, and the manager was so wonderful. He saw that we were trying the beer and brought over samples he thought we might like. We had such a great experience that we took home several packs of beer and a growler. Thank you for an enjoyable evening. Best in a long time!!“

“Food and drinks were delicious !! 🤤“

“There’s no sub like it in Sussex County Delaware. We got an Italian with prosciutto, it was packed full,fresh and delicious. And the rolls are out of this world. Five star.“

“Your grill cheese sandwich is out of this world, perhaps adding tomato soup to the menu would put this lunch time favorite over the top! Love your place!“

“I went there shortly after it first opened, excellent burger.“

“Delish loved the servers and bartenders great food“

“My Wife and I ate their this morning 8/8. We had a very friendly and hardworking young lady as our Waitress her name is Adelia. She made sure everything was fine during our Breakfast. Which by the way it was delicious.. We had the $6.00 pancakes. Our bill was only $17.00 . We will be back“

“We had lunch to day and very much enjoyed the experience, and wish to say how helpful and friendly our waitress was. Her name is Pamela K.“

“Grotto Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers! The moment you walk in, you're greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for a great meal. Their signature swirl pizza is not only unique but incredibly delicious, with a perfect blend of tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and a crispy crust that hits all the right notes. The menu offers a wide variety of options, from classic favorites to creative specialty pizzas, ensuring there's something for everyone.

The staff at Grotto Pizza are friendly and efficient, making the dining experience even better. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or ordering for delivery, the quality is consistently top-notch. It’s a great spot for families, friends, or anyone craving a satisfying, flavorful pizza. Five stars!“

“So I spotted this place while we were on our way back from the beach to our hotel. We went for Friday night karaoke with DJ Ice and it was a blast! The food is great and well priced. The staff are friendly. My partner and I had such a great time we had to come back Saturday as well for karaoke again and brought their mom along too! This place is definitely now a staple for us when we do our yearly vacation!“

“Tonight we dined at the Crab House and had Lila as our waitress. She was polite and we received amazing service! We will continue to dine here each summer during our vacation. The food was excellent! Especially the Lobster Roll!“

“Awesome wings great service Kyle is the best bartender in Rehoboth“

“Margs were great!!!! Staff very friendly and food delish! We will be back“