Customers` Favorites
Customers` Favorites
“I respectfully cannot give O’Maddy less than five stars. My sister had her wedding here -hell- there’s even a drink named after my sister’s mother-in-law!
But do not worry, dear reviewer, though we are biased, we are honest.
Parking: Despite the limited parking, we happened to get a front row “princess parking” spot right in front of the building. If you don’t get as lucky as we are, there is more parking around the corner if you are willing to walk.
Atmosphere: the vibes are immaculate, as any cozy pub can be! Even more so because O’Maddy’s has big, open-air seating that looks right out onto the bay. As a girl from Oregon seeing a REAL beach (one that isn’t wild, freezing, and liable to kill you), I found it soothing to see the tropic, warm water. This evening, the Australia vs. US soccer game was on (the US won 2-0), and it would have been an amazing game to watch, but we just so happened to be seated at one of the only tables without access to a television. (This can be forgiven, though, since they were able to seat a party of 8 with no wait time.)
Food: the nephew gives his bun only to his hot dog 5/5 stars. He tried giving a thumbs up, but we are still learning that skill. Overall, the party was happy with their food. We unanimously agreed that the French fries are top tier, and all French fries need to taste and look like the ones from O’Maddys’. It’s not just greasy pub fare!
We love O’Maddys. Heck, I just flew 2k miles to eat there! I even walked away with a cool t-shirt.“
Customers` Favorites
“Four of us came for lunch; only one of our party ordered seafood, which is what they mostly have. That same person also was the only one to order an alcoholic drink. My pulled pork sandwich was a great disappointment. The pulled pork didn't even cover the bottom part of the bread, very skimpy serving. What there was good, but mostly it was the taste of the bread that I experienced. Service was slow. Didn't see many ordering meals as we did, but many did enjoy the bar the libations there. If you go for seafood, you will probably enjoy this restaurant. Fortunately, it wasn't hot yet.“
Customers` Favorites
“Have been curious about this restaurant and we finally gave it a try. The food was delicious and our waiter Jamie was awesome! They now have two loyal customers!“
Customers` Favorites
“75th Trip-Around-the-Sun for my husband. Party of 16 seated to celebrate. The birthday boy has the Mango Nut Crusted Grouper (Fresh Florida Grouper crusted with macadamia, pistachio, and walnuts with a Mango Beurre Blanc & coconut basmati rice.) The atmosphere was inviting - our locals enjoyed the signature dishes and the menu selections, and our out-of-town family was impressed the location, food and service.“
Customers` Favorites
“Great atmosphere Mahi Tacos exceptional lot of wait staff to help with your needs“
Customers` Favorites
“Really enjoyed the food..ask for Kelly. She did a great job and took the time to explain the difference between the menu items. Would recommend the Nachos. My kids fought me for them. It was my meal and even 1/2 was more than enough. Try it out!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Signature Smoked Wings (Delicious!) Smoked right out back at Mullet's daily. Try the Dry Rub, House Merman Sauce, Signature Dirté sauce, or Classic Buffalo. Served with house-made ranch or blue cheese.“
Customers` Favorites
“Tha clam chowder was perfect….hot till the last bite…..loaded with clams and potatoes. Thick and creamy and reasonable price. The fried clams were the tastiest ever. Perfectly fried, tender, flavorful, and a hearty portion and reasonable price.“
Customers` Favorites
“We ate here 2 nights while staying on the beach this week. The hummus and flatbread along with their house salad for a starter was sooo good. The coconut shrimp was good and the coconut curry snapper was the best fish I have ever tasted and I grew up in Florida. The dish is not sweet and the flavor is amazing along with fish cooked perfect. Don’t hesitate to eat here it was our best meal when in St Pete Beach. Thanks Snappers we will be back!“
Customers` Favorites
“Best Blackened Grouper Sandwich ever!! Onion Rings were also fantastic. Look forward to visiting again.“
Customers` Favorites
“Looking for seafood in St Pete Beach? This is the place. You will not be disappointed. Service was 5 stars, too. Lots of character and casual.“
Customers` Favorites
“Excellent food and service plus very affordable prices! The paella, shrimp+grits and shrimp+pasta were all delicious. However, it was the curry shrimp+rice and the ceviche that were the show stoppers. The curry sauce was absolutely incredible! And the trio of ceviche were so unique and delicious. Can’t wait to go back!“
Customers` Favorites
“Megan the Bartender is Awesome! Great Service! Great Drinks! I’m a local restaurant manager and I approve!! Thanks Megan!! You rock!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Amazing service and excellent food! Steph was an absolute pleasure to be served by!“
Customers` Favorites
“Only at happy hour , otherwise oysters are expensive“
Customers` Favorites
“Highly recommend this awesome local spot! The service was great, the food was amazing, and the prices were incredibly fair. The trout was only $15.95 and absolutely delicious, and the Mezzo Mezzo pasta was just as amazing. The crab looked so good that I'm already wishing I'd ordered it, but I was craving pasta! It's not right on the beach, but it's definitely worth the visit. Don't judge a book by its cover. This place is a hidden gem!“
Customers` Favorites
“Have loved this place for years….great reasonably priced food, quick friendly service and a great atmosphere! Go at least once a month.“
Customers` Favorites
“For a fish place, burgers are dam good 👍“
Customers` Favorites
“Went to Sup Crab great place great staff fantastic food yum prices reasonable. I love low country boil the spices were amazing, corn fresh good potatoes and hushpuppies. I am from east coast of Florida wish I had this place near my house. Yeah“
Customers` Favorites
“First time trying great food and staff!“
Customers` Favorites
“We were in SPB this past week. Rick’s was a couple blocks away. Went there for breakfast and supper and every time, the food was awesome! Service was top notch. Such a fun little place to go. We’ll definitely hit them up next time we’re up there.“
Customers` Favorites
“Such a gorgeous view on the water! We just had appetizers shrimp cocktail but they were delicious! Valerie the bartender couldn’t have been any nicer! We had a great time! Can’t wait to go back!“
Customers` Favorites
“Great breakfasts and freidnly staffs“
Customers` Favorites
“My favorite spot I am there every Thursday or Friday one or other maybe both that’s the chill spot“
Customers` Favorites
“Yummy fish nuggets! Friendly staff!“
Customers` Favorites
“We dined on Easter Sunday 2025 and experienced the most fabulous food, atmosphere, and service!“
Customers` Favorites
“Great atmosphere & dining experience for my birthday.“
Customers` Favorites
“It was delicious, service excellent, and is good to know that master chef John Berrocal is there helping this amazing restaurant“
Customers` Favorites
“Great Food & Service, Love the bang bang Shrimp and you can have it with chicken as well. The salads we had were great and no problem with special request.This Bonefish was extremely clean and service was quick. Very friendly staff and greets you upon arrival. I will definitely be back to this location.“
Customers` Favorites
“Food very nice but we felt very rushed. Salads came out before the appetizer and we had only 2 bites from our dinner when the server asked us if we wanted desert…“
“Their Grouper Sandwich melts in your mouth like butter! It’s the best I’ve EVER had and I’m a local.“
Customers` Favorites
“What a wonderful find , Great Food , Great Service and the location is Beautiful . Good Music playing and we’ll definitely be Back , with the drive .“
Customers` Favorites
“Had lunch at Crabby Bill's today. Blackened grouper sandwich was fresh and tasty, onion rings were just right, and our waiter, Jaxon, was excellent. Always enjoy Crabby Bill's when we're in Florida.“
Customers` Favorites
“4 of 5 Star review Came to Florida for my bachelorette trip and chose this place as the place I wanted to have a “nice dinner.” We had a reservation at 8pm. The bar messed up 2 of our 5 drinks, which the waitress had remade and apologized saying the got a rush. All the food (conch platter, seafood pasta, crab legs, 4oz filet, and fresh vegetable pasta) was yummy and came old hot and well seasoned, though the steak was overcooked (ordered medium) Would have been 5 stars, but our waitress took 40 minutes to simply get us our checks and run our cards😅“
Customers` Favorites
“We enjoy the service, food, drinks and atmosphere! Love the margarita in paradise, really enjoy the breakfast and Eddie is always a great waiter!“
Customers` Favorites
“very good food not over seasoned“
Customers` Favorites
“I love the Wharf, but I am frustrated that they stopped serving tater tots, because the fries they have now are horrible. They have no flavor and are soggy or over crunchy. Please bring back the tater tots or get some different fries to serve with the meals! I’m getting tired of eating slaw or paying an extra $8 for onion rings!!“
Customers` Favorites
“soooo good! loved looking out at the water while I ate my yummy coconut shrimp & scrumptious ceasar salad. it was so good I ordered a meal to go! joe, the bartender was very attentive & makes good drinks. if I'm in St Petersburg again, I will definitely be back!“
Customers` Favorites
“The Food Is ALWAYS Good &The Service Is Great‼️“
Customers` Favorites
“Wow what a great meal we had tonight. The hostess Donna and wait staff were great. Food was off the hook.“
Customers` Favorites
“Lovely experience will definitely go again“
Customers` Favorites
“I visited on March 25th around 5:30. Waitress had a scour on her face the whole time. Tipped her well never bothered to say thank you the food was good but I refuse to spend my money where I'm not appreciated.“
Customers` Favorites
“I DO recommend the Casual Clam but PLEASE change the Bloody Mart mix! The 7's Bloody Mary SUCKS!“
Customers` Favorites
“The owner is very friendly the food is light and not a heavy buttery seasoning. It’s more like a boil with butter on the side. I enjoyed my snowcrab sausage, potatoes and shrimp. The only thing I would add is little more spice, but other than that, I enjoyed my food.“
Customers` Favorites
“Great food and staff was extremely helpful“
Customers` Favorites
“Seafood is hot, fresh, delicious and affordable. Great flavors, and the garlic butter is my favorite.“
Customers` Favorites
“Love it!! Convenient, fresh and delicious poke bowls. Clean easy beach atmosphere.“
Customers` Favorites
“My wife and I arrived on Saturday, Nov. 22, 2025 at 2:30 and found the place empty except for an older couple (like us) sitting at the bar which we sat at as well. We were greeted by Kalen who was bartender/waiter and was happy to share the history of his family restaurant. We have been displaced New Englanders for close to ten years and know good seafood and UNTIL TODAY was convinced it was never going to be found in Florida! We ordered two beers after taste testing four or five of their micro brews. Ordered two Clam Chowders , a Clam Basket (with bellies, which are non-existent in Florida), and a Lobster Roll, (Maine Style, which means "cold") and one of their famous Maine Whoopie Pies all for under a hundred dollars! FLORIDA , IF YOU WANT TO TASTE WHAT REAL SEAFOOD SHOULD TASTE LIKE....THIS IS THE PLACE! It is not an easy place to find but we will be back with all our New England friends that is for sure!“
Customers` Favorites
“{{restaurant.reviews}}“
Loading...
“I am anxious to try this restaurant. I heard they have a new server who is the best!!!,“