50 Best Seafood Restaurants in St. Augustine

“Loved our dinner tonight! We ordered the Salt and Pepper Ahi Tuna Salad. Excellent. Our waiter was Eddie who was the perfect waiter!!! Highly recommend!“

“Had a good meal and a real nice server Mary M.“

“Located in the heart of historic St. Augustine, Catch 27 is a dining experience that perfectly reflects the charm and coastal spirit of Florida’s 27th state. From the moment you arrive, you can feel the care and passion they put into their food and atmosphere.

What truly sets Catch 27 apart is their dedication to fresh, locally sourced seafood. Everything on the menu is prepared from scratch using seasonal ingredients and local produce — and you can taste the difference in every bite. Their fish, shrimp, and clams are caught in Florida waters and delivered daily, ensuring the freshest flavors possible. The rotating selection keeps things exciting too — from snapper and sheepshead to mahi-mahi, triggerfish, flounder, and black drum, there’s always something new to try.

Whether you're a seafood lover or prefer something from land, there's a dish here for everyone. Each plate is crafted with genuine care, beautifully presented, and full of vibrant, coastal-fresh flavor. The staff is warm and welcoming, creating an inviting dining experience that feels uniquely local and wonderfully memorable.

If you're exploring St. Augustine or simply craving honest, delicious Florida-sourced seafood, Catch 27 is an absolute must-visit. Fresh, thoughtful, and unforgettable — this restaurant truly captures the essence of Florida dining!“

“Ordered shrimp and grits... $21 for a large spoon of grits and not sure what was mixed in the gravy , and 5 small shrimp.. Awful tasting and not enough for even a small kid. So disgusted. Granddaughter got chicken po boy she said was good. I sure wouldn't choose this place for seafood..“

“Last evening we had a delightful and delicious dinner. Rum pour was generous. JJ was our outstanding and friendly waitress. She made our dinner special with her attentiveness. We will continue to return to this gem and hope JJ is our waitress again.“

“We happened to find Poppy’s on Trip Advisor and boy were we delighted. The atmosphere is authentic, food is exceptional and friendly staff. Would highly recommend.“

“One of the best in area.“

“Food was all very fast, and freshly made! Such a unique concept on serving too - all on a board which was definitely more enjoyable for our family!! Food was delicious and fresh (went for brunch). Family friendly as well. Definitely a hidden gem!“

“Made a special trip to st Augustine on Memorial Day just to check out DJs. Extremely nice staff, and phenomenal fried clams. Had Both a cold and hot lobster roll, and a shrimp roll. I have to say I preferred the cold lobster roll over the hot, they were both very different so to try to compare the two isn’t fair. The cold one is so flavorful with some seasonings. The hot one was also good with just butter. The shrimp roll was also great! Because they were closing for the week they didn’t have any full bellies which is why I made the trip. But it’s okay because we will def be going back to eat!! Highly recommend“

“The ambience was just right, the service top notch and the food was amazing“

“The best fried shrimp! I drive 140 miles to eat here!“

“Our Christmas Eve dinner was spectacular once again! I have used OBBC several times and each and every time all of our guests LOVE the food! Thank you! 🫶🏼“

“Tiktok Bullrider726. Started with Gator, it was absolutely phenomenal! Then had the calamari, crab burger and crab legs, everything was cooked perfectly 👌 The datil sauce was so incredible, bought a couple jars of it. The staff was friendly and answered all our questions. 1st trip in, will not be the last!“

“What a gem St Augustine has in its’ midst! We recently visited the fine establishment after reading previous reviews and was overwhelmed by the kindness and expertise of the owner! We were novices and had never prepared blue crab before. Instead of being annoyed at our lack of knowledge, he explained at great length and in easy to understand detail, how to prepare his delicious crab in several different ways. We served up a delightful, delicious meal that evening! The seafood was exceptional! He and his small business is a real asset to the community! You won’t be disappointed!!!!“

“We visited Grouper Shack a couple of weeks ago. It was our first visit and we definitely have added it to our restaurants to have dinner. Know that you order first then find a seat. Food was served on paper baskets, but it did take away from the delicious food!“

“Thursday nights Casa Maya is the go to for our group.. Chase at the bar and Edwin playing amazing guitar..“

“Service was awesome! Vinny“

“We had dinner at Elkhouse Eatery and were so very pleased with the service and food. Wonderful presentation and delivery. It's a must try when your in town.“

“We come to St Augustine several times a year with our dogs. This is always our #1 restaurant and eat there a few times each trip. Staff is super friendly and the food is delicious. Would give it a 10 our of 10!“

“Amazing place. Will definitely be back“

“Beautiful sunset views! The tuna was excellent! great atmosphere The bartender was very knowledgeable about wines and had visited the vineyard of the wine choice we made. Good price points on the wine as well as the food. Definitely, will be back. Smiles, D“

“Kara was an excellent waitress always friendly always gives good recommendations. Excellent even in suggestion of bar drinks and willing to go the extra mile to make the customer happy.🩷“

“I have to be honest and say I can remember when this location was a Greek restaurant in the late 70's, and it's been transformed many times. The decor is cool. Very large space with inside and outdoor seating. Very many cool drink options, but no draft beer. I did settle for an IPA in a can. The fish dip was awesome and it came with some yummy raw veggies. A worthwhile visit.“

“A big shout out to the 2 managers working Sat. They were kind, friendly & helpful. Not something you experience much any more. These ladies deserve a RAISE. Good luck with Nursing school. Travel Nurse Theresa from SC 😁🏝“

“Had a WONDERFUL experience with Tyler our waiter this past weekend. Great atmosphere, friendliness and the food was some of the beat you could ask for!“

“We had no prior knowledge of Blackfly. We chose it because it was close to our rental.  We smiled as soon as we walked in the side door leading to the bar area and everybody seemed to be enjoying themselves. The further we entered the very well decorated restaurant the more we knew we had made a good choice.  To us, the best reason to visit St. Augustine is dining at the Blackfly!  We went all out and had drinks,  appetizers, their version of Coquille St. Jacques and their Chilli lime shrimp. Both were delicious and cooked to perfection with exceptional sauces. Main course was a Chef's Special which was baked shrimps, scallops over a bed of thai noodles and a sauce to die for.  I had the bone in Pork chop cooked medium rare and it was delicious.  Blackfly has a vast selection of wines in their wine cellar and we enjoyed a nice Honig sauvignon blanc.   Kudos to Matt, our server, who throughout the evening gave us the right amount of attention and space to relax for our entire dining experience.  The food was so good and well prepared that I was compelled to go to the kitchen to thank the staff and gave a large tip for the kitchen staff . Our evening at Blackfly was the highlight of our trip.  Thank you Vaughn and staff, you have an outstanding establishment.“

“Great Place to eat. Staff and food here is fantastic!“

“We both agreed this was our best food during our trip to Florida, and possibly the best seafood we’ve ever had. We got fried oysters, fried shrimp, blackened shrimp, fried gator tail, and crab legs between the two of us. Absolutely delicious and the drinks were great too! Everything was priced well, and the view if you eat outside is amazing. We saw a mama duck with 10 ducklings! And a beautiful sunset over the lake in the back. The inside had a singer who sounded great! Overall a wonderful experience.“

“Ordered food from there yesterday and it was amazing! The jerk chicken quesadilla was outstanding and the three taco combo was phenomenal! BBQ super tender. Shrimp - super fresh. Highly, highly recommend. Was enough for two meals!“

“The best service and quality. The very best fried shrimp and special sauce in SA. We've been eating there for years and still have no desire to eat elsewhere. It's our go-to place. Love It !!!“

“I recommend O.C. White's for the service. I followed Corey the bartender over from his previous gig. He is always johnny on the spot with your food and drinks and ALWAYS hilarious. Stop by and get your favorite libation and a dose of Corey's personality!“

“The host was very sweet and welcoming. Our server was knowledgeable and attentive. Food was delicious and large portions. I had the Mediterranean pasta that was hot to the last bite and had delicious flavor. My server recommended the Dirty banana frozen drink. It was amazing= an adult milkshake. Sunset was gorgeous.“

“This is one of the very best Sushi restaurants that i have ever eaten at. The service was spectacular and the selection of sushi and sashimi was stupendous. I have eaten in many Sushi restaurants and I have to say this is by far my favorite . Whenever we are in St. Augustine I know we will eat there again. My husband, who does not like sushi, also loved the food he was able to get.“

“The BEST food!!!! I have eaten here twice and have gotten the shrimp and grits both times. The best I have ever had!!!! This time we got dessert too…peanut butter and chocolate pie and salted caramel cheesecake. I could have eaten my weight in both! We have been home for a day and I am ready craving it all and can’t wait to go back!! Also love the quiet atmosphere and the view of the water. My husband got the prime rib and he said it was delicious.“

“What a great place. Food was wonderful and authentic and the service was excellent. So glad we went.“

“We went for a birthday celebration. The ambiance is wonderful, there is a pianist that played beautifully. The food was delicious with a new twist on traditional dishes. We had the cheese antipasto and for main the swordfish and branzino . Perfectly portioned - not over sized and gluttonous. Very sophisticated vibe. Absolutely delicious! Highly recommend.“

“My husband and I live in Palm coast and when we make the trip to St. Augustine, this place is always a must! We’ve been a few times now and each time they are so friendly and fast with the service. I really appreciate how child-friendly they are, they always treat our toddler with such kindness and patience. One time that we went they even brought him out a dessert of ice cream! They are the best and so is the food. The buffets they have during the week are always hot, fresh and tasty as well.“

“Great Service and atmosphere loved the food. Will be back soon“

“We have gone to La Cocina over the last 25 years at 3 locations. This is the most scenic location. The food and service, as always, was impeccable. I had the Filet, my wife the shrimp. Absolutely wonderful.“

“The food is the best! Always consistently good, fresh and the portions are plenty to fill you up, and definitely NOT stingy on the protein. My favorite is the Tropical tacos, with salsa is to die for! Owners are on site daily and always make you feel welcome 😊“

“Best fried shrimp I've had in awhile and I'm a Floridian! Staff was great. This is a dog friendly business, too. We'll be back!“

“Just thought I was gonna go into this little joint. I was pretty fooled when I stepped in to a totally different atmosphere, a place where all the locals come, and it was packed, sat at the bar Andrew the bartender took care of us. He was amazing. He was on top of his game. Nothing unusual for him whatever he suggested was excellent service excellent food excellent wine excellent I drank sangria from Spain so did everybody else in the place? It’s my new go to it’s a hidden gem and I really thought this was just a joint and didn’t know if I was actually gonna eat here but was T fooled thank you so much guys for your food and service will bring all my friends and family to you.“

“Purple Olive never disappoints, offers a diverse menu of deliciously executed dishes, great staff and reasonably priced. Fortunately, we made reservations for opening night at new location and the food was stellar! The renovations are lovely and bar area warm and inviting. We started with a shared crab cake appetizer and pleasantly surprised. For our entrees we ordered the Mahi encrusted in macadamia nuts with a mango rum butter over jasmine rice with wok stir fried vegetables and the Korean style short rib with same rice and veg set up. No room for dessert this time, but if you haven’t tried their chocolate gateau please do, you will not regret. Kudos to Chef Peter and his staff.“

“Great spot for food and then go outside to the back patio and enjoy great music and atmosphere“

“My wife and I came here for our 31st anniversary. A highly rated restaurant. My meal, steak bowl, was very tasty. The steak was tuff. Over cooked I think. My wife had a fish meal. I forget which. She was very disappointed in the taste and quality of her meal. I have NEVER see my wife complain about a meal before. When our waitress (she was great!) Asked how the meal was my wife told her. Later a woman, not a lady, came to our table concerning our dissatisfaction. She seemed to be insulted and left in a huff. Normally a dissatisfied customer is given a discount or a free dessert. Something. Nothing was offered. What should have been an enjoyable dining experience for Saint Augustine residents celebrating their anniversary was left lacking. 🤢“

“From the drinks to dessert everything was perfect. Once again, our dinner was fabulous! Steve had the filet, was outstanding. I had the tuna tartare stack, amazing! We shared the chocolate molten cake which was delicious, can’t find the appropriate word to describe because it was the BEST we have ever had. This is our favorite restaurant.“

“Ashley took such good care of our family! We each got something different (kids Alfredo, kids spaghetti and meatball, lasagna, & chicken Marsala and dessert-gelato for the kids and bread pudding for my husband & I to share) everything was amazing! Thank for for giving us a wonderful wedding anniversary dinner 💞 we have been to this location a few times and it’s never been a disappointment!“

“Always an amazingly delicious experience. Excellent seafood and creative Italian dishes plus fantastic desserts such as the Limoncello cake. The live music adds to the chic atmosphere. Highly recommend!“