27 Best Sandwich Shops near Sellersburg

“This is the absolute BEST subway anywhere around. Sandwiches are always loaded and perfect. The people there are always polite and hard working. It's always clean. They put every other subway to shame. I wish I could give them more than 5 stars“

“They are fast, friendly and the food is fantastic!“

“Staff is always friendly. Food is always delicious. Great place to grab a sandwich“

“Just wanted to give a shout out to the two gentlemen who served me thursday sept 24th. I had some bad news so wasnt gonna be able to cook dinner. Walked in trying to grab some sandwiches. These gentle were so accommodating to all my sandwiches which needed this and not that. They ended up making me laugh and i bought a cookie. That really cheered me up to see smiling faces through their masks. Thanks carol greenwood. Loyal customer. Highly recommend their subs!!“

“Not sure if it was the steak or sinus drainage but something about it didn't jive with me. The staff at the store however was upbeat and really seemed to have a good work life chemistry that makes rough customer facing jobs more bearable. Whatever you're doing to cultivate that sort of atmosphere, I'd encourage more of it.“

“I would go out on a limb and say you will not receive better customer service from nicer people anywhere in the food industry! The food is always great and the service is always fantastic. Wonderful group of people in there. Truly a highlight of my day“

“Good food, affordable, and friendly staff.“

“Never had Jersey Mike's before. I really liked it. Staff was friendly, service was timely. I dined in and dining area was clean. I got the Chipotle chicken Philly. Bread was soft and fresh, chicken was tender. I will definitely stop again next time I am in the area! I wish there was a location near me.“

“I live in Louisville but I am Jeffersonville often because my mother lives here. And this Subway is the absolute Best location between Indiana and Louisville. It’s always clean, food is always fresh and very single young person that works in there has excellent customer service and is genuinely kind.“

“Great. Sandy is the best.

Vegetarian options: Variety

Dietary restrictions: Variety

Parking: With Kroger's

Kid-friendliness: Very

Wheelchair accessibility: Parking“

“We expected to have a typical Subway lunch while visiting Louisville but ended up extremely impressed by the two young people working. The lady with red braids was patient, kind, and prepared excellent sandwiches. She took the time to chat for a few moments and shared that she chooses to make her job fun. Both people working in the dining room were cleaning. We enjoyed our meal and walked to the door. The young man said, “Miss! You forgot something!” I had accidentally left my wallet on the chair. I’m incredibly thankful for his honesty and kindness. Subway is incredibly blessed to have these two employees. Date and time visited: Feb 3rd, 3:30 pm.“

“The way the crew from thus store greets you when you first come in is heart warming. It took me by surprise. You don't get thus kind of appreciating these day's. If your ever having a bad day stop at the Jimmy John's and by the time you leave you definitely have a smile on your face. SHOUT OUT TO THIS TEAM AND A BIG SHOUT OUT TO THE MANAGER. YOU CREW IS A REFLECTION OF MANAGEMENT. KEEP UP.THE GOOD WORK“

“When I walked in I was greeted with a huge smile and such sweet attitude. The person making my sandwich named Cali did such a great job. Didn’t smash my sandwich and didn’t rush me one bit. One of the nicest workers and best subway experience I’ve ever had. I WILL BE COMING BACK“

“My favorite place to eat lunch. Very clean and love the staff.“

“The people that own and operate this location are super hard workers and extremely good at customer service. Today I placed an order through the subway app and a small mistake was made. The second it was brought to their attention they immediately went above and beyond to correct the oversight and tried giving me a free sandwich and cookie. I thanked them for their generosity and was quickly on my way.“

“Very friendly service. Counter angent engaged young kids and took time to ensure they understood menu options and got what they wanted. Also made sure our coupon was applied without any hesitation. Multiple employees checked on us while we ate; service makes good atmosphere.“

“Best JJohns in town. Staff is outstanding. Delivery is fast and incredibly polite.“

“I went in for lunch on 01/21/2025 the 2 young ladies that were working was so amazing and polite. They seem to love their job and had a smile on their face when they were talking. Lots of eye contact and just great overall experience. You do not see young people: teenagers greeting and being happy to be working to often. If you want that type of service go to this Subway. I am driving across town 🚗 to get my wrap #45 all because of the experience. Great job ladies👏🏽👏🏽💪🏾👊🏾🫶🏽“

“Love some McCallisters. I always get the King Club but my kid will eat everything on the menu. Healthy and delicious.“

“My wife just ordered from here for lunch. Got home and opened my sandwich and it was wrong. My wife called and they gladly delivered me the correct sandwich. I am leaving a 5-star review because of their excellent customer service. I don't know of too many restaurants that would have offered that. The person my wife spoke to on the phone was understanding and professional as well as the delivery driver. My order: Beach Club #12, what I received was a beach club with no bread. I have to admit that I ate some of the turkey and tomatoes from the wrong sandwich due to being on lunch break. We come to this location a lot and from this experience I will continue to support this location. Thank you again.“

“I’m so glad I decided to give Penn Station one more chance! After having a few disappointing experiences at the State Street location, I was hesitant, but since I had an appointment in Jeffersonville, I figured I’d stop in.
​I am so happy I did! This location completely restored my hope in the chain. The food was absolutely spot on, the service was incredibly friendly, and the entire store was noticeably clean and well-maintained.
​Kudos to the management and the entire team here for running such a tight ship. It’s clear they care about quality and customer experience. I’ll definitely be back to this location!“

“Great Service tonight! 10/10“

“I think the owner and his family were serving us last time we went there. The sandwiches had generous amounts of ingredients, the service was friendly and competent. We liked our sandwiches. Nice clean restrooms too. Earlier times there, we also had the displeasure of dealing with the "rude girl". Hopefully she is no longer working there.“

“The gentleman that made our sandwiches was absolutely wonderful I think his name was Dean. Very nice and made suggestions on some chips as hubby and I could not decide which to get. Then due to store being slow for a few moments he came out to clean up our after lunch as we were just visiting.“

“I usually go in and get a sandwich for my elderly friend, so I got a sandwich as well Plus they sell their yesterday's bread for $0.50 a loaf which is a 16-in .
That bread is excellent to bring home cut it in half and make two good sandwiches out of each 50 cent loaf.“

“When I was in your store today, an employee immediately came to assist me and was very kind. She was about 5'4 she was a young woman whose name was rubbed away on the name tag. She was very sweet and service was really nice.“

“I just had a great customer service experience at this store. I did a mobile order and arrived just a few minutes before 10:30 the door was open and everyone was working hard and prepping for the day. They made my order really quickly and I was on my way.“