42 Best Sandwich Shops in Omaha

“Loved this place! If you're a foodie, you will too. Carefully curated menu with signature fares and seasonal offerings, alike. We had the poutine fries, a couple of burgers and a featured grilled cheese with huckleberry jam-delicious! Our friends had the poutine burrito and other burgers, along with the crab and green fries. We don't eat shellfish, but they say it was delicious. We would definitely come here again when in town.“

“Admittedly I was skeptical this would be anything more than ordinary. But not only was I greeted immediately with a friendly and cordial welcome, the sandwich was also extremely delicious. The ingredients tasted very fresh and tasty. I would highly recommend this shop based on my experience.“

“I decided to stop in & get a couple of subs today for my sister & I for lunch one hot & one cold & must tell you that we are beyond satisfied 😋 This was a complete 180 from the time I ordered online last year & was very disappointed with what I received a small portion of tuna salad and not having all the ingredients either. I called to speak to a manager but she had left for the day already & explained what happened I called multiple times & after a week later I finally got ahold of her & she gave me attitude & was very rude & asked me if I had my receipt & if I ate the sandwich 😳 She wasn’t wanting to give me a refund but told her that her other manager already told me that they would & finally said she would put the credit back on my card which I received the next day. Big shout out to Kenny & his crew 🗣💯 The subs were delicious & filling. I am very impressed with the customer service & friendliness of the staff. Thank you & keep up the amazing work 🤩“

“Took the crew (2yrs old to 56) to Picklemans on Farnam in Omaha and was very pleasantly surprised. They had a little something for all of us. The staff was patient and very helpful. The restaurant was clean, the food was great and everyone working there was super friendly. Can't ask for more than that! I will definitely be back when I'm back in town.“

“I’ve always enjoyed Penn Station every single time. Nothing wrong with the food or the service. However, this time, instead of ordering full sized cookies, I decided to order the dozen bite sized cookies. But what I got instead was 3 cookies, cut into quarters. 👎🏼 I chose bite sized cookies for a reason. If I wanted full sized cookies cut down, I would’ve ordered full size cookies and cut them down.
Might seem like a small inconvenience, but they are not the same. Now I have a bunch of cookie pieces that will get hard quickly, rather than small individual cookies I can save for a few days.
The sandwich was still good. (As it should be, it was $15)“

“first time having it this will deff be my new spot! love love love them“

“I came in at 7/31 @ 7:08 PM. I got a Royal Turkey Sandwich for my client & a 12 in. Royal Treat on Asiago bread. Those two ladies made are sandwiches so good! Just got to say “Thank You”. Keep doing an excellent job on those sandwiches.“

“Absolutely phenomenal sandwiches. I've been there several times and it never disappoints. My favorite is the Red Baron.“

“Come in today with my mom and grandma and the pizza was delicious! My favorite buffalo chicken pizza. The service was great and quick. Our only complaint was it was absolutely FREEZING in there. Today it’s 27° out the thermostat here said it was 57°! Hard to visit with family when you’re frozen haha.“

“I was in a pickle today with my catering order being canceled without prior knowledge. I walked in to Potbelly and was greeted with kindness by Zane. I shared my predicament with another sandwich location and how I was in urgent need of 15 sandwiches. Zane, Jesse, Betty & Ian took care of me right away. They procured 2 sandwich boxes in under 20 minutes. I was able to make my meeting and take care of my customers without missing a beat. The team at Potbelly really went above and beyond. I greatly appreciate them and will certainly be back!!“

“First time at Jersey Mike’s today. The food was excellent. I was even more impressed with the manager. I did not catch his name but he pushed his employees to get orders right, and quick, was himself working hard and did so with a smile. He greeted every customer, played peek-a-boo with a baby and had cheerful conversations with regulars. All of this on a busy Sunday lunch rush. Jersey Mike’s you do not want to lose this gentleman! It’s obvious he cares. With as busy as they were the bathrooms were even clean and tidy“

“Sandwiches - great! Cookies - hit or miss; does Goodcents corporate want them super doughy in the middle? Needs a few more minutes of baking time!“

“I order a sandwich and tuna salad. The tuna salad was outstanding. Delivery was within 30 minutes which isn’t bad in Omaha. Most definitely recommend the Aksarben store.“

“So, if you are in the downtown Omaha area, and your hotel is wanting to charge you $20 for a lame breakfast buffet, I suggest going down to Manhattan's. I got the breakfast bowl and my daughter had the breakfast croissant sandwich. The bowl was $9 I believe and I could not finish it. My daughter said that was the best breakfast sandwich she had ever had. Either way, much better than the buffets at the hotel. I also got their hamburger for lunch. Quite tasty and the fries were awesome.“

“Great service, great food, very clean. Obviously popular because it got very busy after we were served,“

“Best salads in town! Nice size and price with fresh ingredients! I only go to 15th and Farnam location though! Sandwich’s and the pizza is good too!“

“Best sub sandwiches ever!!!!! Every sandwich is made fresh and served hot. My favorite is the BBQ Brisket and Cheddar.“

“Jenna or Jenny hopefully it’s one of the two she is such a nice and respectful server kind helpful really committed to customers making sure that the orders are perfect. Helped me with my DoorDash to get a five star give a5 star back promote her get more reviews excellent“

“This is the place you go to if you want the best fresh frys ever! The teriyaki chicken was really salty I'm never having it again! My girlfriend had the Philly cheesesteak she said it was amazing! I'm only getting one sandwich there, the BLT! I honestly think I just love the frys!“

“I visit this store a lot but my latest order was an absolutely terrible failure. I actually had 4 different problems with my order and the worst of it was a bug in my sandwich. Ordered a Deluxe original with no lettuce & tomato and they slopped so much of both on my sandwich. Both were wilted and had a rotten smell and ruined the entire order. On top of that failure, both of the sandwiches were supposed to be double meat but were not double meat at all and they also failed to include additional items in the bag that we ordered. I could go on and on about their failures but the bug in my sandwich says it all! Huge disappointment! MASSIVE FAILURE!“

“Chyn was excellent and delightful Actually talks to customers“

“I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS LOCATION FOR ANYONE! A 1/2 STAR REVIEW IS TOO GOOD FOR THEM! I called the north 40th street location and made a delivery order for lunch today. I ordered a Bootlegger club only meat and cheese on wheat. first off the delivery driver did not meet me on the floor I specified and I went from floor to floor to find him. I finally met him and received my order. upon opening I learned the sandwich was made incorrectly. The pit lettuce and mayo on it anyway. I called and was given to the manager. instead of trying to handle the situation calmly, she accused me of having an attitude, said it would be made the way I requested it and redelivered. The manager abruptly hung up the phone. I was called by the driver roughly 15 minutes later and went to the third floor to pick up the new sandwich. I gave the first one to a therapist downstairs and went back up to eat lunch. upon opening the sandwich, I learned it was not made as I requested either! It was gooped with mayo! It was already after 1:30pm at this point and I did not have time nor did I feel like calling that store again! I packaged it back up and gave it to another therapist downstairs (they paid me for both sandwiches). So instead of getting to eat lunch, I had to go without because the staff at this location have issues with listening. I GUESS WHEN YOU WORK AT A STORE THAT IS SURROUNDED BY VAPE/KRAYON/THC STORES, IT IS MORE IMPORTANT TO GET A VAPE, GET HIGH IN THC OR KRATOM, AND WORK AT A DELI Y DER THE INFLUENCE THAT IT IS TO DO THE JOB RIGHT AND MAKE FOOD AS REQUESTED BY A CUSTOMER!!!!!! THIS LOCATION GOT PAID BY ME FOR FOOD I WAS UNABLE TO ENJOY OR EAT! THIS LOCATION WILL NEVER GET BUSINESS FROM ME AGAIN!“

“Excellent service, I have been in the subway more than 3 times. The food is excellent, everything tastes fresh from the excuisit chicken, turkey, white American cheese, etc. If I am in the area, I definitely would choose, Subway to fast food restaurants, as Subway is extremely quick in making a variety of sandwiches.“

“I ordered online and they were out of a couple items, which they kept in touch with me about! I’m not all that picky so it didn’t bother me. What stuck out to me though is that the employee was very genuine and kind! I didn’t get his name but I hope he sees this!“

“Gotta love Jimmy John’s. The Italian Night Club (#9) and the JJ Gargantuan are my go-tos—can’t beat em. Add some jalapeño chips and it’s honestly one of the best quick lunches out there. Super fresh, always fast, and it just hits every time. Whether I’m in a hurry or just craving something good, Jimmy John’s always comes through. Def recommend!“

“Ordered lunch for delivery and had a great first-timer experience. Ordering flow was easy and intuitive, food arrived quickly with great packaging and labeling. Sandwiches were great (New Yorker and Ham/Cheese Melt) and sides were equally good. Generous portions of everything. Drinks were carefully packaged and very well-prepared. A new go-to for lunch!“

“Have loved Charley's sandwiches for years! Such a shame this is the last one left in the Omaha metro.
Had another great philly with fresh fries just today. Service was good and the meal was put together well. Hope to return soon!“

“2/7/25 Friday lunch rush. These 2 employees were there by THEMSELVES running this whole place. Trying to do online orders and help all the customers in line. Even though there was probably 10 people waiting in line, this younger man (20’s?) was being very patient with his older co-worker who seemed to be just learning the job. They were both very professional and were trying to go as fast as they could. I would have lost it, but these guys kept their cool. Very nice to see. I was impressed!“

“FINALLY, I can get ranch dressing at Jimmy John's. OK, it's "Kickin' ranch", but it's still ranch! Good job JJs! Now how about some pickle chips to put ON my sandwich?“

“I LOVE Jimmy Johns, but it legitimately bugs me, that EVERY TIME I add mayo packets to my order, they NEVER pay attention and add them! This is the 3rd time this has happened to me. :(“

“The last time I went to subway it was swamped. I have to give it to the sandwich artist behind the counter. There was a panicked bone in their body. No they simply simply assured us our wait would not be long . Then went about whipping our orders together lightning fast. I like a person who stays positive even when it looks like they are faced with the impossible task. This guy deserved a raise!“

“Love the #5's and the number 9's they are the Best !!!“

“Ordered delivery multiple times from this location, and the driver, Veronica, is amazing and super fast. Faster than freaky fast. Every time she delivers to my work, it makes my day so much better. She definitely deserves a raise and promotion to delivery manager if not already one. Love this woman.“

“We got 4 orders of cookies to celebrate a coworkers birthday (they're her favorite type of cookies). We tried the oatmeal raisin, chocolate chip, raspberry cheesecake and white chocolate macadamia nut.All the cookies were soft and delicious ?“

“Ordered ahead for a late dinner after my daughter’s soccer game. Everything was ready on time, and everything was accurate and neatly packed. Staff was very kind and polite, always a plus for our family of 6! Great dinner after an evening game :-)“

“Just picked up my order...best sandwich ive had in a really long time! Fresh high quality ingrediants. Worth every penny! This location is also top notch. Fast, friendly and they handle your order with care. Facility is really clean. Highly recommend!“

“The best! Every time I brought my family here it is always top quality service and food.“

“Service was exceptional. Made an order through the app & completely forget about transport situation. Made a phone call & the person who picked it up managed to changed pick up time. I would be ok if my sandwiches were made earlier & waiting to be pick up; however to my surprise I was given a freshly made sandwiches.Foods tasted the same but the service/atmosphere on this location is excellent. Thank you!“

“The food is good☺️ and tasty I left my first review the first time I went today 2-22-24 and had a kicking chicken taste great just be careful as the sandwich is tasty fresh and the peppers are a little juicy you want more to the owners next time I stop by I take pictures so people can see how nice a place you have.“

“Leo and Amia are the MVPs! They always make sure our night hospital staff are fed, especially since the cafeteria is closed when night shift arrives. They go above and beyond, staying literally until the last person is done ordering, not closing early. Thank you both for your patience and understanding! It means the world to have people that help you while you're helping others! I'm soo thankful you're here! @Subway they both are exceptional in everyday, particularly in quality and customer service!“

“Picture doesn’t do my sandwich justice. I got the cubano. I get the sliced wheat bread, because I don’t like the French bread. The sandwich is only showing one half, but it comes full. It was fresh and it was made how a sandwich should be made, no skimping out here! I won’t mind spending $13 on lunch (if you get a combo, sandwiches are cheaper by themselves), because at least you’ll get a quality meal for it being a fast sub place.“

“My wife and I were in a hotel near Eppley Airport in Omaha, to attend her father's funeral. As we were traveling with our two dogs, dining was a bit of a problem. It's been a long time since we had Subway sandwiches, but there was one within walking distance of our hotel and the sandwiches we're really great and provided a convenient meal or two a day.“