50 Best Seafood Restaurants near New Castle

“Beautiful day and delicious meal were had at Latitudes today .“

“Fantastic Food, outstanding service, great dining room.“

“Architecture et design parfaits dans cette auberge élégante, chic et raffinée sur une île où absolument tout est beau et harmonieux. Les lits sont ultra-confortables et chaque chambre offre un intérieur spacieux et très élégant. À quelques pas de l'auberge, une superbe plage nous invite à la contemplation. Great Island Inn nous a offert des vacances de rêve, dans un lieu enchanteur et parfait à tout égard. C'est désormais notre rendez-vous annuel du mois de novembre. N'hésitez pas, réservez!“

“Levi was our server and he was incredible, on the ball, and funny, dinner was absolutely delicious and we’ll absolutely be back, I suggest to Umami roll, my partner got the buttermilk chicken, it was “outstanding”, the head chef Jeff is wildly talented and dinner was 10/10“

“oh wow... what a find! We were looking for a seafood restaurant when passing thru the area and the name caught our attention. We had an amazing dinner! We both chose the seafood fettuccine, which was heavenly - incredible pasta and sauce topped with succulent seafood. Desserts were lavender creme brulee and white chocolate cake...Holy cow! Dinner and service were both top-notch.. and we can't wait to return!“

“Kudos to the kitchen… best meal we’ve had in a long time!! Will be back soon!“

“The BEST place to get a lobster roll or fish tacos. I don’t think anything on the menu could disappoint 🥹 my new favorite restaurant. The staff is also incredible! Hard working and friendly.“

“We are here from out of town and stumbled upon this incredibly amazing spot! The seafood chowder is killer, THE BEST!!! Do yourself a favor stop in!“

“Just got back!!!! We Had both a cold and a hot lobster roll…and there was absolutely no skimping on the lobster!!! And 2 fluff chowders!!! Everything was so good and reasonably priced!!! We will be back!!“

“We went with a group of 7, having made reservations in advance. The food was excellent and service very good. We were able to bring a cake from outside in for a birthday celebration which our server brought to us ready to serve and sing! The Hospitality was excellent along with our dinners. I highly recommend Robert's and we always make it a point to go there whenever we have the chance! My only negative comment is the safety of the staircase to upstairs, railings on both sides are needed, an elevator would be better.“

“We had the shrimp chowder today and it was amazing! Never had a bad experience with this lovely gem! The service is great and the food is excellent.“

“Just there today. The Harbor side Cioppino is my favorite. My favorite restaurant.“

“The BEST roast beef I've ever had at a sub shoppe. I just wish that they delivered!!!“

“I work at the Moffatt-Ladd House across the street and have been meaning to come over and experience their menu, as we often have overlapping customers. Our host sat us right away, drinks were fabulous, and all the meals were absolutely amazing! (I had the caribbean grilled swordfish.) My mom had been here with her parents in college in the early 80s and clearly Casey is carrying the mantle well. Thank you especially to our server, Rachel!“

“great service amazing food“

“I have been eating there for years. I went the other night because I was craving scallops. I got my usual scallops and tried to substitute o-rings for fries. The girl told me it wasn't allowed. No substitutions. I was willing to pay for the upgrade. No go. I live in the area and there are a lot of other options which I'll be trying.“

“We booked the private dining area and had a great experience. Service was great and we were not rushed at all. Food and drinks were good and the overall booking process with Zoey was easy and transparent.“

“We’ve gone here for years. Always fast, friendly service. Clean and comfortable seating. Very reasonable prices.“

“Tonight I had a wonderful dinner with my husband I think the service was great and the food was delicious and I think the manager was so wonderful and very pleasant and I think the restaurant is a 5 star all the way. Thank u“

“Great food and always very friendly helpful staff.“

“This place got some very bad food reviews so even though a NE friend recommended it, I was apprehensive. Don't know what the complaints were about. Started with an order of mussels, perfectly fine. The lobster was good, give you an actual cracker to help u extract the meat. The service is partly self serve. The location is the big draw.“

“Just got back!!!! We Had both a cold and a hot lobster roll…and there was absolutely no skimping on the lobster!!! And 2 fluff chowders!!! Everything was so good and reasonably priced!!! We will be back!!“

“The best lobster roll I’ve ever had.“

“Everything- wonderful rooms, public areas, fantastic staff, and a chef whose food is TO DIE FOR! We just got home from 2 wonderful nights there a Christmas present from our daughter and her husband). We've been going there for 35 years and this stay was one of our very best! Bravi, SNI!“

“good place to work company has a talent for gettimg amazing quality lobsters“

“We had lunch at Frisbee’s Wharf and it was delightful. The food, service, and view were amazing.“

“Stopped in today for the first time and it won’t be the last. Great food, great vibe, great value and fabulous weight staff. Their lobster roll is a 10.“

“It’s been a ritual for me to get there at least once every summer since I moved away from the see coast.“

“Dockside is one of my favorite wedding venues to photograph! I've shot many weddings there and I've loved every one of them. The staff is top notch, the grounds are beautiful, and view is unmatched, and during your reception you'll probably be visited by a nosy great blue heron. He's popped up at most of the weddings I've shot there. There are so many wedding venues in Southern Maine, you probably can't do any better than Dockside.“

“My fiancé and I had to return for a second night, making it two nights in a row for the great seafood, service, and atmosphere! Cathy was phenomenal in the main dining room Thursday night & Michelle on the deck Friday night was delightful!! Lobster, scallops, clams, and everything were spectacular!!! We WILL be back!!!“

“Always great food and amazing friendly staff.“

“Wonderful old-school, Old-Maine place - "Lobsters in the Rough" like we used to have. Ambience - totally relaxed, right on the water. Food - Menu has good variety, the lobsters come in daily, cooked just right. The view across the river to Portsmouth is like no other, plus the river traffic and bridge openings, lobster boats, big ships, tugs, you name it. River breezes tend to keep things a little cooler. I'll be back.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Comfort food meets fine dining. Great atmosphere, service was great. The food was amazing. Will definitely be back !!!“

“Awesome place to see a band with the family“

“Best lobster roll and lobster bisque I have ever had!“

“Favorite Thai spot I’ve been to yet. I really appreciate how clean the food is and didn’t leave us feeling heavy and sluggish after. The flavor was amazing and the ambiance is nice for a dinner out with others.

10/10“

“great location, great views but wasn't impressed with the food. I had a 3 ounce lobster roll for $20+, they wanted $55 for a 6 ounce.😱 there was more roll then lobster and the roll was over toasted. The Cole slaw was right out of a bag and blah. The only good part was the blueberry margarita, but I think I overheard the employee say it was only 5%. They didn't offer whole lobster.🫤 Go for the view, maybe order a burger or hot dog.“

“Food was absolutely amazing. Service was fast and friendly. Views were amazing!!!!“

“great food at reasonable prices. excellent service.“

“Great view when sitting outside. The food was tasty but not to die for. My fries had good seasoning, but they were a tad cold. The crab cake sandwich had bacon on it and a great texture. Also, the waitress was friendly and prompt at serving us.“

“After 2 years of eating at the same restaurants I tried this place at the recommendation of one of my customers. The place is super clean and the staff was friendly. Most importantly the food was Phenomenal and portions were great.“

“Amazing food, great service and beautiful restaurant! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Best Seafood restaurant and great service! We will keep on coming back!“

“My 10-year-old wanted to go for dinner and he asked the host if we could sit by the window. We were told no even though there were several tables open. Asked for a manager and the manager told us no that's not how they do it. We left“

“Have been many times over the years, both to hotel and restaurant. Highly recommend and love that they empower their employees to support the communities they live and work in.“

“Just a quick note from someone who never writes reviews. Sitting at The Beach Plum with my three kiddos and so impressed and grateful for the wonderful service we’ve received here. We had a tiny issue with one meal which was immediately acknowledged and fixed tenfold. Two members of the team checked on us several times after to make sure we were doing okay and then sent us home with an extra meal for later on the house. My kids learned a great lesson on wonderful and kind customer service and The Beach Plum will continue to be a favorite spot for us! Thank you!!“

“The food is amazing, always super fresh and the flavors are incredible. We visit here twice a yearr and this is always a regular must stop for dinner while we are in town. I have found nothing compares to the quality, freshness, and flavor of the food they serve here. I have never been disappointed with anything I have ordered here. Highly recommended“

“My family recently booked a private function in the Eisenhower room at Lamies. Everything was truly exceptional. Michelle and her team went out of their way to guarantee that our extra large party was perfectly cared for. I highly recommend considering the Old Salt for your private functions. You won’t find better service.“

“Michael was wonderful at the bar. Extremely knowledgeable and a fun person to talk to while he is mixing drinks and teaching others.“

“The food is delicious, I have had the smash burger, the jambalaya and lasagna. The portions are big and the staff is so very friendly. I love going there.“