50 Best American Restaurants near Garfield

“Hands down the best hole-in-the-wall restaurant I’ve ever been to! You walk into what feels like a cozy dive bar, but when you ask to sit in the dining room, they take you through the kitchen to the back—and wow, it’s like stepping into a hidden gem packed with memorabilia everywhere you look. I didn’t even know where to start taking it all in!

The owner personally went around to every table, greeting everyone and chatting with us about the history of the place—which alone deserves 10 stars. Every single dish we tried was absolutely fantastic. The baked clams were massive, and the garlic clams in that buttery garlic sauce? I could honestly drink it with a spoon. Then came the steaks—perfectly cooked, melt-in-your-mouth delicious.

To top it all off, the chef came out to greet everyone too and asked how everything was. It’s such a rare touch that made us feel like family, like we’d been regulars for years. And for the kids—there’s even a fun little scavenger hunt, which is such a cute idea!

If I could give Charlie Bloods 20 stars, I would. This place is full of heart, history, and seriously good food. Can’t wait to go back!“

“food and drinks were delicious and fun atmosphere“

“The food and service is excellent. It is always an enjoyable evening.“

“Very nice family friendly restaurant enjoyed their thin crust pizza 🍕 nice welcoming staff will come back to partake on the rest of their menu options George rudawsky“

“I walked into this small cafe without even thinking they had such a great variety of food… I WAS BLOWN AWAY!!!!!!! The pizza is fantastic, thin airy crispy crust … so delicious!!!

I ordered the drunken parm sandwich and it was made fresh, the breaded chicken was made right then not cold and frozen like other places.. they put the perfect amount of cheese and sauce .. it was crispy and not messy. The hero bread was delicious too! I cannot rave enough about this place!

It’s also very clean!“

“Leanne, is an exceptional server and always brings a big smile to the table, great Food, and atmosphere. Fun and friendly place.“

“Want to have a good food, drinks and vibes with great service. Well look no further, this is the spot right here. One of my favorite go to spot. If you haven't been here yet, you're missing out. Check them out.“

“everything everything everything“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I read a lot of bad reviews about this Applebee’s location, but I must say our experience was excellent! Despite being a large group, everything was amazing. Our waitress, Freddy, did an outstanding job — he double-checked our order, constantly made sure we had what we needed, and provided great service with a positive attitude the entire time. The manager was also very helpful and attentive.

I noticed all the staff working hard and providing great service, which made the atmosphere even better. Kudos to the manager and especially to Freddy for making our visit so enjoyable. I hope everyone who comes here has the same great experience. Thank you for the excellent service!“

“Loved every dish- fluke with black tea, mint and peach(who knew raw fish and fruit went so well together?), amazing grilled artichokes and grilled eggplant. Barely touched my pasta with preserved lemon because I was full, but it was delicious. My daughter’s burger was iconic. The Platonic ideal of hamburgers. Coffee was also delicious. If we had not made a plan to go to La Cabral for dessert and more coffee, I am sure dessert would have been equally excellent.Service was excellent and our waitress was knowledgeable and interested in the food.The fluke reminded me of the first time I went to USC in 1988. I had a plate with raw marinated tuna, raw salmon and raw scallops. The little heaps of fish were so pretty on the plate with their contrasting colors.“

“Every time we take a trip into the city, we make sure to visit the Cookshop. Love the staff. So friendly and they make the best margaritas! Jiro (sorry if I’m misspelling) is a great bartender.“

“Absolutely the best food in NYC we finally got a bar seat this past Saturday was in the city for pride we have been trying for years everything was spot on crysathenn salad, the stuffed flatbread and lasagna and cocoa tiramisu“

“I visited RH New York on a tough day. I had just flown in from Atlanta for a funeral, and I stopped in before heading back to the airport. Their kindness and hospitality genuinely lifted my spirits. Even though the restaurant was busy, they accommodated me quickly, and the service was exceptional. The lobster roll with caviar was delicious, but it was the warmth of the staff especially Fidy and Manager Salvatore that made my heart smile.“

“Classic for pre-or post Broadway fare!“

“Uma experiência fantástica, com ótima música! Fui do Brasil a Nova York para conhecer! Show!!“

“nice service,,🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰😍💪💪🤳🤳🤳🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶🤝“

“What a treat to stumble upon Parker & Quinn! It was an intimate atmosphere and a perfect night for me and my 10-year-old daughter. The kids’ menu was so good (the pasta was homemade and so delicious that I had to enjoy a few bites!), and my margarita flatbread was incredible. Great service from our server and another gentleman (the manager?) who came over multiple times to check on us. I highly recommend you check this out if you’re looking for something away from the hustle and bustle and generic nature of Timed Square. Chef’s kiss!“

“A great place to get a top-notch burger-Add avocado! Cocktails were great and it has a delightful atmosphere. Really great service concept-more than one person assists with the table-our waiter wasn't as chipper as the others but would def recommend! Host was fantastic!“

“Best lunch I’ve had. My taste buds were delighted. Every single dish was amazing and the portions are so generous I couldn’t put my fork down. Wow the monkey bread melted in my mouth, the wedge salad was delicious with so much bacon and the mushrooms with the crispy onions omg! Plus it’s so pretty and cool! Service was tops and it was packed. I haven’t been there in 20 years and it was full of nostalgia. Sat in the bar area which is cozy but the dining room is gorgeous. Gee how neat, the original phone booths with numbers on the wall of local NYC establishments. Score this restaurant you will be happy!“

“Fabulous and gluten free. great selection, service, atmosphere and very close to MSG!“

“❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“Fabulous experience last night here for a quick fun trip to the city. Perfect pre-show spot if seeing anything at Lincoln Center, as we were. Team from hostess, to manager Shay, who was checking on all guests periodically, in addition to our fabulous server Tijana were wonderful and so friendly. The food did not disappoint either! Great menu, and reasonable prices for the amazing quantity you get- not to mention the quality. We went for the filet with the cacio e Pepe ravioli and there really aren’t enough adjectives to describe how delicious it was - perfection!! In addition the garlic babel, pepperoni cups, meatballs, antipasto wedge and MOST mind-blowing lemon cheesecake were all sublime!! Great job and can’t wait to get back to try the other amazing dishes we saw delivered all around us.“

“So beautiful and so delicious!!“

“Great time! Food was delish!“

“Blown away by interior design, topped with finger-licking food, friendly service, and such a well crafted drinks!“

“Great food, good service, good vibe!“

“This Manhattan diner was neat and clean, and the food was definitely good. The staff was friendly, but one downside was that they charged for refills on small cups, which felt a bit pricey. Overall, a solid spot for a tasty meal if you’re in the area, just be aware of the extra charges, they will try to be sneaky.“

“We lived in nyc for 30 years. Recently moved to DE. God only knows how much we miss the nyc culture. Nothing holds a candle to it. Thank you Aaron for such a delightful lunch today at your restaurant. Best Manhattan I’ve had in a long long time! You were so attentive and accommodating. Service the best! Thank the kitchen for the great food also! Will be back soon with our nephew and his spouse!“

“Had a great late breakfast complete with Mimosas and Alfie’s Amber Ale- all served by our awesome bartender Niamh from Ireland!!!“

“Honestly one of the best restaurants I have ever been to. Not only were the ingredients fresh, but the preparation was nothing short of perfect. Great atmosphere & vibe. Will definitely be returning very soon.“

“Wonderful experience! Amazing Apps & Steak / Side. Great cocktails. Beautifully put together & appointed cozy bar & restaurant. Most importantly - the staff is amazing. Mike A was an outstanding server. It all started with a warm welcome by the Maitre D, a great conversation with the Hostess, and then an amazing experience by Mike & the serving staff. The soft shell crab & shrimp cocktail appetizers were exceptional. And we had the 30 oz porterhouse steak to share. Cooked to perfection. Finally, the steak sauce that is prepared at your table is epic. Highly, highly recommend!! Be informed - it does get loud in there when full of customers. Still can't wait to to go back!“

“7 people crew from the fortune society we where on 34th street donating jackets and sleeping bags to the homeless and walked to 42street Applebee's restaurant and got amazing service and the food was done and served quick amazing manager Mr Vernon and our waitress Sydney took super care of us if in nyc you must visit this grand restaurant 😀“

“We had our annual holiday dinner with friends on 12/21/25. We were a party of 9. The service was fantastic. Tiernan was our server and he and the team were exceptional. Great cocktails and menu recommendations. Friendly and attentive without being intrusive at all. We will definitely be back.“

“Cosy atmosphere, great food and friendly people.“

“Creative take on Mediterranean food Fantastic“

“Today was my first time visiting West Bank Café, and I had the best experience ever! The staff and service were fantastic, and the owner greeted us as soon as we arrived. It’s in a great location, right in the heart of Manhattan. There’s even a parking garage next to the restaurant, which is perfect if you’re a commuter. I would definitely eat here again. Best wishes to Tom and Michael ...bravo! 👏“

“Fantastic service, fantastic food, fantastic atmosphere“

“My dining experience was exemplary. I had my Thanksgiving feast in style! I did notice they had a prix fixe and an ala carte. I checked the items I wanted from the prix fixe on the ala carte and the ala carte was $20 cheaper ($95 vs $115). When I ordered I said ala carte please. Than I did explain the price difference to my server. I was not sure she was surprised but that $20 savings became her tip. Bon Apetite.“

“My dining experience was exemplary. I had my Thanksgiving feast in style! I did notice they had a prix fixe and an ala carte. I checked the items I wanted from the prix fixe on the ala carte and the ala carte was $20 cheaper ($95 vs $115). When I ordered I said ala carte please. Than I did explain the price difference to my server. I was not sure she was surprised but that $20 savings became her tip. Bon Apetite.“

“Had a few hours to kill before my flight at EWR. Looked up restaurants near the airport, found this and I’m so glad I did. Friendly staff, delicious Beyond Burger wrap w sweet potato tots, and a deeeeelish freshly made strawberry lemonade. Highly recommend! I’m keeping this place in my fav saves. If I’m ever back in Newark NJ I’m def stopping back. That drink was so perfect for the hot day!“

“The most incredible meal I have ever had. Thank you.“

“Went 1st time today for my Birthday - it was GREAT!💙👍“

“We were in from out of town, staying in New Jersey as our home base for day trips into NYC. On our first night we drove to Hamilton Park to take in views of the skyline, and then were looking for a place to eat with our two nieces. We found Fork Hill Kitchen and are so glad we did. We did not have reservations, but arriving around 5:30, they were able to accommodate our party of 4 and seat us right away. The food, drinks, ambiance, and service were all top notch. The gentleman that showed us to our seat was charming and when he found out we were in from out of town, he chatted with us for a bit, and made us feel so welcome. We each got a different dessert and everyone raved about theirs. Just a really lovely, cozy, welcoming place, with delicious food. Thanks for a great first night of our magical December NYC trip!“

“Everything was outstandingly delicious!!!“

“Incredible food and cool vibe🎼🍷😎“

“Crystal was an amazing server. Was efficient and engaging. I enjoy having servers like Crystal because they create a great dinning experience.“

“乾式熟成牛肉讚人均消費約NT$2500“

“It was a wonderful evening. Celia was excellent and very attentive. We were there for my daughter‘s birthday. They acknowledged it, wished her happy birthday,and even had a birthday card on the table. 😁 we dined on bake oysters, snapper,  and Nonna‘s meatballs. “

“Had a wonderful evening at this rooftop restaurant! Food & drinks were on point ! The views alone are worth the visit, especially as the sun sets and the city lights come alive. The atmosphere was relaxed but still felt special, with cozy seating and string lights that made it feel warm and inviting! We’ll be back !“

“Finally able to visit and so happy I did. My drink, Dutch Revival, is my new favorite cocktail. The winter flatbread was delicious. Loved the vibe and hospitality.“