50 Best Burger Restaurants near Rutherford

“This place man let me tell you phenomenal I love the staff so hardworking and awesome genuinely the best people EVER. The SECOND I came in the staff were welcoming me mad wit feel like home 🥹. The place clean my stomach full milkshakes are to die for.. Amazing restaurant you guys HAVE to try the chicken sammies“

“Jim dandy’s is a very good place to get a quick meal for cheap with a friendly staff making you feel comfortable“

“Larry was very courteous and professional throughout our visit. He was respectful and patient, especially knowing I was with two kids trying to decide what to order. When he took my order, he kindly asked if I would like to contribute to a charity by rounding up my total, which I appreciated. He also checked in with us during our meal to make sure everything was okay.

Overall, Larry provided excellent customer service and made our experience pleasant.“

“The young manager with the tattoos on her hands is a very fast and very friendly person. She is always so polite and quick when working, I usually see her working alone in the early mornings I go for my coffee. Recommend this place to everyone! The decorations inside this location are so beautiful!“

“New York-35th Amazing staff! Mia C was on top of everything. She was thoughtful and fast. She was excited for my son who was turning 10. So much food and make sure you get a shake.“

“Everything was incredible. Best burger, great service!“

“Great burger , Enjoyed true atmosphere right in the heart of the theatre district - 💯“

“awesome fresh and flavorful food with fast and friendly service.“

“Great food n environment rocks“

“chill vibe. great burgers. super cocktails. good service“

“I have been passing by this place for some time now. The moment I entered, I was already greeted with an unique accent by a lovely host. She is very polite, professional, and attentive to all patrons. Eager to finally try their George Motz's Fried Onion Burger (I'm an onion guy), I found myself happily and quietly eating it. The double patties makes it so juicy and filling! It is not greasy unlike other places. And the fried onions adds a bit more of the crips and flavor. The french fries are simple and always great when out of the fryer. The food was simple, but great! And that, sometimes, is all that is needed to make fill up that hunger. Also, the bathroom is clean and big. Definitely recommend coming here for breakfast, lunch or dinner!“

“The Best burguer i tasted 😍“

“I had such a wonderful experience at Royale. First it has an awesome bar and restaurant indoors and the space outdoors is beautifully decorated. I have celiac disease and they had the most delicious gluten free nachos (made on site) ever! They were perfect. I was so happy I could have them and they were excellent! Great atmosphere and food! Highly recommend when in the Village.“

“Stayed in NYC Hell’s Kitchen for 6 months for work and tried many different burger joint and this is by far the best i have had during my stay. The juiciest tastiest smash patties, best buns, incredible sauce. Friendly staff and atmosphere! Thank you Cubby’s!“

“its straight up 🔥. best burger and fries I've had in years“

“Great food, good service, good vibe!“

“The girl who served us… She needs to smile more. Her whole face brightens when she does.“

“If you are celiac and want a good burger in NYC, this is the place for you. Food here is amazing. We came here twice during our visit, takeout the first time, and ate at the restaurant the second.
I would suggest you to eat here, quality is high and hot food is always better, but this place is so good that even when it's cold at home is worth it. Very good burger, amazing popcorn chicken, sweet potato fries are a gem.“

“I live in basically the middle of nowhere. Most food I eat is relegated to home cooking or traveling several towns over if I ever want to eat out. I'm visiting the city for a weekend. Oh my god I didn't know we were at this level. Genuinely some of the greatest plant meat food I've ever had. It's honestly a crime against humanity I have to go back and live in a place where this doesn't exist. Updated from previous review on 2026-03-01“

“First time I went the sandwiches were really good.

Got the tropical island chicken sandwich which was juicy, and their burgers are juicy too.

The strawberry milkshake was pretty good as well.

However second time I went the sandwich wasn't as good as the first time.

Still recommend, its a nice burger place in the area.“

“My wife and I visited Handcraft Burgers and Brews for my birthday this past weekend. As soon as my wife opened the menu she knew that I was going to have to try the burger of the month which was a peanut butter and grape jelly topped hamburger with jalapenos, bacon and cheese. Admittedly I have never had peanut butter and jelly on a burger before but I figured I would try something new and see what all of the hype was about. Turns out, I loved it! Every bite was so flavorful and completely made my birthday lunch a worthwhile venture! We also tried the tater tots, because who doesn't love a good tater tot. We could have chosen from multiple dipping sauces but we decided to go with the garlic aioli and I am glad we did. I dipped each of my tater tots in the sauce and there was plenty for both of us to share. We were helped by Vanessa at the restaurant and she was very accommodating when I was having trouble using a coupon that I had for my birthday. All in all this was a wonderful choice for my birthday lunch and when we are in the area again I would definitely stop by and perhaps try the latest burger of the month along with some tater tots and garlic aioli dipping sauce of course!“

“Doughnuts are super yummy! And the milkshakes are soooo good!“

“I had a great burger and fries for lunch here today, and Maria was a wonderful server! Highly recommend this restaurant and will definitely be back the next time I come to the city to see a show.“

“Food 3.75/5
Value 3/5

After hearing all the hype around Gotham Burger, we went in with high expectations. It wasn’t bad by any means, but it also wasn’t the best burger I’ve had in NYC. Personally, I’d still choose 7th Street.“

“We visited this restaurant and ordered a cheeseburger with fries and a drink, along with the chicken sliders. The food tasted average, but the fries were good. The restaurant serves halal meals and is conveniently located near Times Square. The price of the meal was around $12“

“Uno de los mejores Bares del Mundo“

“This spot used to be a diner and Superiority Burger totally carries the legacy forward with the paper daily specials and slices of pearl pie in the refrigerated case.

That said, the menu here is unlike any restaurant anywhere. Honestly we didn’t even really know what we were ordering but the side of cabbage, fries, yuba sandwich and panelle were mind-blowing. Super wild flavors. Service was phenomenal.

I’m hooked. The pearl pie with fresh passion fruit was amazing.“

“Best service and affordable Price!“

“The burgers were absolutely delicious. However the staff seemed a little bit disgruntled today. Maybe it was just a bad day but it kind of affected me. I'll give it another shot though. Once again the hamburgers are very good french fries tasty atmosphere was wonderful.“

“Polecamy dla nas niesamowite przeżycie i wyprawa do NYC .Jedzenie Pyszne, bardzo duże porcję w eleganckim wydaniu .Polecam każdemu kto będzie w NYC aby odwodzić to miejsce 🥰“

“Is a nice environment an good food“

“Great food n environment rocks“

“Great burger, not too big and crinkle cut fries. Perfect.“

“Me encantan las hamburguesas y el servicio es rápido y excelente“

“Great food n environment rocks“

“Mashed Burgers is a must for smash burger fans. The burgers are thin, crispy around the edges, and packed with flavor, with that perfect griddle sear that makes smash burgers so good. Simple menu, well-executed food, and consistently satisfying. If you’re craving a no-nonsense burger done right, this is the spot 🍔🔥“

“Was in the area and decided to try this place out. So happy we did, it was aaaamazing!!! Great variety menu, we had the jojo burger and the mushroom burger with an order of fries. Everything was super hot and fresh and delicious. It was super clean and I believe the man there was JoJo himself, he was extremely attentive, friendly and even brought our food over to us. Will definitely be coming back to this place. Wish I lived closer lol“

“Some of the best burgers and staff. Delicious fries. What a great environment inside. My family highly suggests bun buddies“

“Most delicious burger and great service!“

“Amazing food and especially amazing service. Perfect spot for a late night get-together with friends to grab a very enjoyable bite. If you’re lucky, you’ll get yourself caught up in an honest, heart to heart conversation with some of the nicest workers you’ll meet.“

“Had à great brunch at PJ and so appreciate our fabulous server Fabiola! She was GREAT!!!!“

“Decided to stop in after a tour visit to Montclair University and receiving a gift card for Christmas. Everything was delicious. We ordered brisket fries,cheese fries, smash patty melt, Montclair Blue Burger, build your own burger and 3 shakes. Everything was amazing including the burger buns (fluffy and airy). I wish they were closer to us, Old Bridge could definitely use a really good burger place.“

“Hamburguesas deliciosas y las papas con salsa de queso!!!!“

“"Corner Bistro isn't just a bar; it’s the West Village’s North Star. A true Manhattan icon, it remains a masterclass in the art of never changing while the rest of the city chases trends. Between the legendary Bistro Burger and the cold McSorley’s, it’s the soulful, juicy heartbeat of the community. It’s history on a paper plate—unpretentious, timeless, and exactly what New York is supposed to feel like." Next Step: "Would you like to see the current menu or check for peak wait times?"“

“So I just had iftaar with their tikka paratha roll that I had got last Sunday evening. It just tasted so good even though I ate it cold straight from the fridge. 😊 It didn't taste as good when I had ordered it on site. Then, without me even asking for anything, they remade it and gave it to me to take it home with me even though I had told them I was full. 😊😊 The largest portions I have ever seen anywhere, good food, clean, best interior and decor, excellent service. I have yet to see a BETTER or even equally nice place in NYC. 🤍 Jo baat hay. Food makes/breaks the mood.“

“Great food n environment rocks“

“I really enjoyed this place. It has some retro charm. It even had a Photos booth and the food was good. The desserts were amazing. Largest milkshake I’ve ever seen in person and the staff was really nice and friendly and Alfredo the manager was really good guy.“

“Great food n environment rocks“

“Elk burger was delicious! Fries and onion rings were also great! Had takeaway and a couple of cocktails prior to food arriving which were also really good! Served by Javier G from Chile.. He was great and so were all the other staff too! Really good atmosphere and would definitely go back!“