Bakeries near Amityville

the cheesecake spot Bakery • $
201 Broadway, Amityville

Customers` Favorites

Banana Puddin Cheesecake
Red Velvet

“Hands down the best cheesecake I ever had! Their coconut cheesecake is to die for! A little pricey but out of this world delicious 😋“

4.7 Superb23 Reviews
La Milagrosa Bakery Bakery • $
220 Broadway, Amityville

“Ordered empanadas for the fire department Santa run in Massapequa. Delicious and Anameli was very generous with price. Bakery is clean and staff is friendly !“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant Caribbean • $
777 Broadway, Amityville

Customers` Favorites

Curry Goat Rice and Peas and Steamed Vegetables
Hard Dough Bread
Cocktail Patties
Jerk Chicken
Oxtail Stew

“I have been coming here for years (2008) to get my spinach patties always served hot and fresh. Camille is always forthcoming and polite! She serves customers with warmth and diligence. She has a very good report with customers. Great place to go! Thanks Camille, for your five star service over all these years.“

2.7 Average36 Reviews
Little Candy Cake Dessert • $$
213 Broadway, Amityville
0 Na0 Reviews
Cream Espresso Bar & Bakery Bakery • $
2455 Jerusalem Ave, North Bellmore

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Mousse Cake
Strawberry Short Cake
Toasted Almond Eclair
Salted Caramel Cake
Oreo Mousse Cake
Chocolate Eclair
Plain Cheesecake
Birthday Cake
Tiramisu Cake
Carrot Cake

“Thank you for the most delicious bday cake on 4/13/25!“

4.9 Superb85 Reviews
Patsy's and Son Italian Bakery Bakery • $$
199 S Wellwood Ave, Lindenhurst

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake and Birthday Cupcakes
Rainbow Cookie
Baby Shower
Gingerbread
Tiramisu

“My husband so happy, he grow in Lindenhurst, he always miss patsy’s“

4.8 Superb100 Reviews
Uncle Joey’s Rainbow Explosion Bakery • $
451 Main St, Farmingdale

Customers` Favorites

Rainbow Cookie Brownie Chocolate Chip Cookie and Linzer
Rainbow Cookies Linzer Brownie & Chocolate Chip Cookie
Rainbow Black and White Cookie
Raspberry Cheesecake
Rainbow Cake

“Had them for the first time tonight when wife surprised me and the linzar tart cookie was the best one i have had in a very long time! Soft and loaded with fresh raspberry jelly! Also the donut my wife got was great! Very cool concept and will be back asap to try some other treats for us and the kids! Keep up the good work! 👌🏻😋🍰🍩🍪🧁🥮🌈“

4.9 Superb75 Reviews
Emilia's Bakehouse Bakery • $$
664 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville

Customers` Favorites

Mini Spanish Chorizo & Manchego Sandwich
Chocolate Chip Toasted Almond Scone
Roasted Chicken Empanada
Brooklyn Blackout Cake
Strawberry Shortcake
Pretzel Croissant
French Baguette
Unicorn Cake
Carrot Cake
Donut Cake

“I stopped in to Emilia’s Bakehouse Café on Walt Whitman Rd in Melville yesterday (they have another location in E. Northport) and boy, was I glad I did! I entered into a well-lit shop filled with pastries, scones, cookies, brownies, croissants, breads and quiches, etc. and was greeted with enthusiasm and a smile by 2 attractive young ladies. It was a great vibe just being there, very stress relieving. The chocolate brownie is perfection in texture and taste! The scones and peanut butter coconut power bites are delicious! Their organic Colombian coffee is the bomb, and you can get it with your favorite milk - for me it’s Oat Planet oat milk. Stop in, it’ll make your day! A feast for the eyes and tastebuds :)“

4.7 Superb126 Reviews
Duchess Cookies - Plainview Bakery • $
331 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview

Customers` Favorites

Strawberries N' Cream Energy Elixir
Blackberry Palmer Energy Elixir
Call Me a Nerd Energy Elixir
Oatmeal Apple Pie Cookie
Triple Chocolate Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Cookie Monster Cookie
Grape PB&J Cookie
Funfetti Cookie
Churro Cookie

“Met the owner....he is such a down to earth person. the cookies are amazing. I love ❤️ the two that I had and would definitely be getting some more for the holidays.“

4.7 Superb106 Reviews
Bread in Oven Bakery • $
13 W Marie St, Hicksville

Customers` Favorites

Tower Wedding Cake with Fresh
Fresh Flower Wedding Cake
Customized Birthday Cake
Customized Theme Cake
Gulab Jamun Pastries
Red Velvet Cup Cake
Butterscotch Pastry
Gulab Jamun Pastry
Dried Fruits Cake
Butter Cream Cake

“My wife was looking for a bakery who made eggless cakes and she stumbled upon this bakery by chance. She ordered a custom made gulab jamun flavored eggless cakes and. It was definitely one of the best cakes I had especially for my birthday. My folks also grabbed a few puffs - mixed vegetable and paneer puffs while they went to grab the cake. Those were spicy and delicious as well. We will be ordering regularly from this bakery moving forward. Definitely want to try all their different flavored items. Highly recommended!“

4.9 Superb62 Reviews