50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bayville

“I wish this establishment the best of luck. They have quality products. The store is sparkling clean.“

“If you want a place to go eat with dirty hands this is the one! Bathroom is always closed but there’s an alley not too far away. You can tell management really cares about the customer experience when they keep the bathroom closed from customers. And they even have tables, that alone would be a health department violation(tables without a working bathroom) but who has time to call them anyway? I think the stuff here is delicious but it could also be the flavor from the last customer on the door handle so who knows?“

“fresh buns and delicious dogs!“

“Decided on a late night sweet treat with my mother, we ended up here since it was open late at night. I ended up getting a pint of the Early Grey ice-cream. If you are a fan of Earl Grey you will absolutely love this. The ice-cream was smooth, creamy and just divine. Though there was a sign they had that states they only take tap payment so please keep that in mind.“

“Went to Crumbl for first time with nieces, Cookies delicious, pricey but worth it! Can’t go often but when you do, cookies delicious! Enjoy

Parking: Large shopping center, lots of parking.

Wheelchair accessibility: Single level and Handicap spots available.“

“To say I’m obsessed is an understatement - I LOVE this place! The shaved ice/ice cream combination is so delicious and refreshing - you have to try it! My favorite is the Tropical Sunset. My son also loves the $2 chocolate ice cream cone.“

“Unique and fun experience! Delicious ice cream and friendly workers! Will definitely be back!! Coram location“

“I have visited this store unexpectedly, and I must admit, the staff’s were very friendly and helpful, the atmosphere was very pleasant and extremely welcoming. This store is very tidy and make anyone feel they’re being treated right and they have a great selection of products to choose from.
Jason- Queens- NYC
Attorney- In- Fact!“

“The place has a pretty cool vibe and decent seating! But it’s really small in there, and when it’s busy, the line of people waiting unfortunately goes right in front of the frozen yogurt self serve area, blocking it completely. Not the biggest problem ever but it was just slightly annoying. I get it that it was just busy that day though. I do wish there were a couple more places for outside seating; I think there’s only one or two small benches.

Dietary restrictions: Non-dairy options.

Parking: It’s probably a tiny bit hard to find if you don’t know the area but behind the building there is a really big open parking lot, which is cool. I don’t completely remember the time restrictions on it though, sorry. There’s street parking but it’s usually full.“

“This place is so much fun for kids! Mine love watching the “smoke” cloud pour out, and the ice cream is always fantastic.

Kid-friendliness: The staff is always very sweet with my kids, and they love watching the ice cream be made.“

“Wonderful ice cream experience. I got the mint chip & it was delicious.“

“Tiny ice cream place that does their own take on ice cream sundaes and shaved ice, with tons of tropical flavors and a "sundae" that has fresh fruit and condensed milk on top. The ice cream quality is very high, the people are lovely and eager to help, the portions are huge, and the combination of ice cream and fruit is extremely refreshing.“

“i absolutely love this place. my friends and i go whenever we have the chance to. every worker there is so welcoming and friendly. Douglas, Ashlee and the manager Mike have created such a fun environment for all the kids that go after school. highly recommend going with friends and family, they are never scared to spark up a conversation! lovely place. lovely decoration!“

“Fresh and delicious. Will visit again“

“Fantastic from beginning to end! Walked in on a busy night, and was quickly greeted with a smile and positivity. The owner (i believe) was there helping her staff tend to the crowd.
I asked about private catering and she was super helpful and provided me with information during the rush as well. Couldn’t recommend it more, love Ben and Jerry’s and this location!“

“I drive 40 Minutes to huntington from my home for their delicious waffle cone and dulce de leche ice cream. This location is my most preffered we have here in the Island. It is very clean and the young ladies and gentlemen that work here are so kind and patient. It is and will always be a pleasure to come to Kilwins. You come once and will never stop coming !!!“

“***** (Five Star) Review - The hubby and I love the Hicksville Sweet Shop! It is such a warm and welcoming restaurant/ice cream shop – were everyone knows your name! We reserved a table for Valentines Day and had a wonderful meal consisting of crab cakes, fried shrimp, French fries, vegetables and, for dessert, fresh homemade strawberry shortcake – reservations are rarely needed! Homemade ice cream and chocolates are also delicious! I can honestly say I never had a bad meal at the Hicksville Sweet Shop! Thank you Eva, Phil, Harry, Walter, Alma, Jeannie & Clair❤️e!“

“Il miglior gelato in tutta New York...“

“Highly recommended shop! I’m new to the North Shore and have been looking for a non-chain local coffee shop in the area. CoCo was recommended to me by a friend who raved about them and it does not disappoint. Terrence does not miss a single detail- from the quality of the coffee—to the matcha powder—to the innovative drink menu- to the hand-painted made in-house delicious chocolate truffles that fly off the shelves daily- to the warm and welcoming hip vibe that makes you feel like you’re sitting in a coffee shop in Greenwich Village. It’s also refreshing to see them support other small businesses in the area with an array of baked goods from St Rocco’s made especially for this store to fantastic local donuts. Great gift boxes filled with these heavenly chocolate bites are also available around the holidays. Easily one of my favorite gems I’ve discovered in the area so far (and yes, they blow away Karmic Grind).“

“Amazing. So incredibly fresh. We will be back.“

“The truffle fries were to die for and the burger was just the right size and delish!“

“Just stopped by here today because I really wanted some frozen yogurt. This was my first time going there as I am not from here. There are several tables inside with seating for up to 10 people.I wanted some frozen yogurt and was going to get the biggest container they had which was the 1.5 quart, but the guy at the counter warned me it would run me about $25 - $30 which was really expensive. That’s when he explained they charge by the ounce ($1.50/oz?) so the more I put in the container the more expensive it is.I settled for a 16oz container but didn’t fill it all the way up and it ran me about $13 after tax. It was really good and they had a good selection of toppings as well. I would definitely go back again.

Parking: There is a municipal parking lot across the street for a fee ($3/hr?) with ample parking.“

“Would be a 5 but there are no public bathrooms which seems sketchy to me because I thought all dine in establishmentts (they had seating prior to COVID) had to provide bathrooms. Prices compared to portions is insane but that's just the times we live in.“

“My wife and I were dining outdoors at a nearby restaurant, and we kept seeing people walking by with ice cream cones. My wife checked her smartphone and discovered there was this ice cream shop just past the restaurant. We enjoyed our meal, but we craved ice cream, so we had our dessert at Gofer's. I had a handmade waffle cone with chocolate and black raspberry chip ice creams. Very yummy! Gofers had soft serve ice cream, ice cream cakes, ice cream quarts to go, and more. It was a popular place on a Saturday evening. It's well worth a visit.“

“great shakes and and great ice creams with lots of flavors that I would highly recommend it. I wouldn't give it 5 stars because there's no seating as the whole indoor space is taken up by freezers. I think better stand up freezer to reduce floor space and make seating available would really improve the image of the place and for people who want to come there. I definitely want to have more of their shakes more often!“

“Some of the best frozen yogurt I've had, with so many toppings and options to choose from! The portions are also quite big. The line can get a bit long at more popular times (at night) and the shop itself is quite small so it is hard to fit all of its customers.“

“I love the products and the crew“

“Ice Cream Deliciousness!!!!“

“I've been seeing the really good food posted on Social Media and finally made the 5 minute trek. I have to say the calzones and pizza were excellent! The calzones are enormous. Where looking forward to trying something different next time, and next time will be soon! ��“

“Great place on a warm summer night for an array of cold, frozen treats. Don't forget that Wednesday's are bogo free ice cream sundaes. Very clean, great, quick and happy staff. Highly recommend!“

“Seriously the best ices and ice creams ever. They have douzaines of classic dessert and candy flavors which are better then the originals. It's pure and elevates your spirit up to the moon! Once a year, we travel to Long Island, New York and, we dream about Ralph's all year round, back in Canada. What we would do to have this here in our country.“

“It is so refreshing to know there is someone bilingual working at a busy place like this, if I am not mistaken she said her name was Kaylin. She took her time naming flavors to my father in Spanish which was so sweet. This location always has the nicest girls every time we go, I applaud the owners and the managers.“

“I genuinely had the best soft serve of my life at gophers. I imagine that all soft serve dreams of being gophers. I got the coconut swirl. It wasn’t that coconut-y but it was perfectly sweet and so refreshing. My dad got the dairy free sorbet also, the blue raspberry one. It was amazing!! I cannot wait to go again.“

“Recently tried the apple crumb and chocolate cream and they were absolutely delicious. Service was great. Highly recommend.“

“I recently visited Sunny Daes for the first time, and I was impressed by the quality of the ice cream. It was delicious and clearly made with care. However, the service didn't quite match up to the same standard. I understand that it can get busy, but it's important to maintain consistent and friendly customer service. Instead of feeling rushed to make a decision, a little more patience and attentiveness from the staff would greatly enhance the overall experience.“

“Great flavors that change from time to time. Always one that is sugar free, which is what I’m looking for. Several low fat options as well as dairy free! The consistency is always thick and creamy!! They also give you heaping sample cups to try the flavors too. 75 cents per ounce“

“Just got off the phone with Jared. His service is fantastic! Friendly, efficient, and a pleasure to work with!“

“Ordered a cappuccino blast and a mini cone cake. Both were amazing. The drink was very refreshing and not overwhelmingly sweet or heavy. The cake I got cookie dough and cookies and cream. My friends and family loved it.

Kid-friendliness: Kids love ice cream“

“It's Labor Day and there is only one girl working, with a steady stream of people.But she's a rockstar, super friendly and fast!Ralph's you're doing this poor girl wrong though, by not having someone else there too.*EditThis is a pretty funny, (passive aggressive?), reply. I get the problems, so good on you for working too. The accepting applications comment is awesome lol.Just recognize that girl with something! If it isn't extra pay for the holiday, or even if it is, give her some extra recognition.Good luck!“

“One thing I look for when judging how good a frozen yogurt is is the consistency and this place did a great job. All the machines were working properly and the store was clean. The flavors I liked were vanilla, Hershey chocolate kiss and peanut butter.“

“Delicious. Great cakes, pastry and cookies. Cafe not open now wholesale available Unbelievable breads Try it“

“The best carvel store in the area! All of the employees are so wonderful and accommodating with my family and especially my 4 year old daughter. Always have a smile on their face and all of their products are delicious!! They are a staple to the Port Chester and Greenwich communities. We are regulars for many, many years.“

“very good, always cools me down on a hot day, and you can almost always find a new flavor to try out due to their wide variety of choises, and flavors are also realy flavorful(idk a better word) and the little chunks of fruit they put in(for some flavors, not all) make it so good. Will keep coming back for more as the summer approaches!“

“This had been out number one spot for ice cream cakes. My family and I have been coming here for over a decade . Everyone always asks us where we bought our cake after a party . It is only cash only so be prepared before you go. Over 15 flavors to choose from, you won't be disappointed.“

“Been to this particular Carvel about 5 times.Delicious Ice Cream.Delicious Shakes!Excellent service.Clean Establishment.Good Prices.It’s nice to know I have a place where the product is excellent every time.Carvel - Old Country Road, Plainview, NY“

“I went here with my family to get a cake for my moms birthday. All the small cakes (which we wanted) were taken (as it was Easter). A very nice woman (I didn't catch her name) came to us and said that she would give us a cake for a lower price. Very very pleased with customer service. Would give more stars if I could.“

“We went for the first time, was a bit taken back with some pricing . We met the owner , he asked what was wrong , absolutely accommodating and concerned, checked it out and was a good guy . We wish him all the best and will be back ! Thanks for the great ice cream too!“

“Great ice cream and customer service!“

“The best place on Long Island for Ice Cream. The staff is super kind. I really appreciate how clean the place is. The flavor selection is out of this world.

Dietary restrictions: Staff is super conscious and aware dietary restrictions

Parking: Large spots, easy to get in and out of

Kid-friendliness: Super fun environment“