33 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bayville

SCOOP & COFFEE Ice Cream Shop • $
271 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Out of the Oven

“We love this establishment!!We have had various coffees, pastries & now ice cream!Cheesecake, chocolate and tiramisu ice cream was a delicious creamy treat.The pastries are so good that every bite makes you go “mmmmm!”Bayville is lucky to have you “

4.9 Superb46 Reviews
Krispy Mango Café & Bakeshop Bakery • $
21 Wall St, Huntington - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brownie Chocolate Rolled Ice Cream
Cookies & Cream Macaron
7 Chocolate Raspberry
Tiramisu Individual
The Cookie Monster
Chocolate Madness
Cookie Dough Shake
Raspberry Lemon
Vanilla Cupcake
Birthday Cake

“Krispy Mango Cafe's ice cream is a delightful blend of creamy texture and vibrant mango flavor. The smooth consistency and balanced sweetness make it a refreshing treat. The generous swirls of real strawberry puree add an authentic touch, creating a satisfying indulgence for ice cream enthusiasts.“

4.8 Superb119 Reviews
Crumbl - Port Washington Dessert • $
20 Soundview Market Pl Unit #7, Port Washington - 8.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Peanut Butter M&M
Lava Cake
Cookies

“These are all my cookies i have ever gotten from crumbl. They were all delicious. Cannot eat a whole cookie in one sitting tbh but that is not a bad thing at all! That means I can savor the cookie over a period of time woo! My favs from the times I've got crumbl were blueberry cheesecake, snickerdoodle cupcake, cannoli and cinnamon square! Many awesome and yummy flavors. The store is very clean and smells of fresh cookies. Yummmm“

4.7 Superb94 Reviews
Cups N' Cones of Old Greenwich Ice Cream Shop •
235 Sound Beach Ave, Old Greenwich - 8.32 miles

“We had the best time celebrating our son's 3rd birthday at Cups n' Cones! The location is perfect and Anna and her team could not have made it simpler. Besides the obvious perk of having ice cream and toppings for the kids, the space also gives you the opportunity to plan any other activities you like. We will definitely be back for future parties!“

4.8 Superb34 Reviews
COCO Confections and Coffee Ice Cream • $$
365 Glen Cove Ave, Sea Cliff - 6.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hand Painted Truffles

“The best chocolatier in the NY-metro area! Great array of unique and interesting flavors that one doesn't see anywhere else. You can tell they put their heart into their craft. I am eating art. Great for gifting, the recipients always love their treats. The staff are always very nice and helpful.“

4.9 Superb24 Reviews
Lucky Penguin Frozen Yogurt Bubble tea Ice Cream Shop • $
675 Glen Cove Ave, Glen Head - 6.47 miles

“I recently visited Lucky Penguin for the first time and had the pleasure of trying their matcha crepe, while my friend opted for the Ferrero Rocher rolled ice cream. Let me tell you, the matcha crepe was a revelation - it's easily one of the best I've ever had. Special thanks to the young man working there who recommended it to me; he really knows his stuff! The customer service was outstanding as well; they even gave me extra sauce topping for free. Yum! Lucky Penguin is a must-visit for dessert lovers.“

4.7 Superb30 Reviews
Alkemy Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop •
260 Main St, Huntington - 7.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Strawberry Ice Cream
S'Mores Signature Creation
Matcha Green Tea Signature
Ooey Gooey Butter Cake
Strawberry Sundae
Cookie Butter

“Best ice cream I’ve ever had? Best ice cream I’ve ever had. Flavors and textures were amazing. I had the Matcha Green Tea signature and my wife had a dark chocolate base with peanut butter mixed in. Both were awesome. Can't wait to come back!“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Sid's All American Hamburger • $
80 Glen Cove Ave, Glen Cove - 5.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheese Fries
Chicken Tenders
Buffalo Wings
Truffle Fries
Fried Chicken
French Fries
Cheesesteaks
Cajun Fries
Tater Tots
Hamburger

“Classic American food! Burger and fries. Sid’s is an ideal spot for a delicious burger with some Cajun-seasoned fries. Good customer service and I received my food fairly quickly.You don't need McDonald's when you have Sid’s. I do recommend trying their brownies as a finisher. I will return for more awesome food.“

4.4 Superb63 Reviews
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
375 Greenwich Ave, Greenwich - 8.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Marionberry Cheesecake
Black Cherry Chip

“David was the best and he gave a great experience as it was my first time there. Omg the vanilla and strawberry ice cream I love . Thank you so much David we will definitely return because of your great customer serviceVegetarian options: Love“

4.4 Superb59 Reviews
Bonanza Stand of Oyster Bay Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
25 Shore Ave, Oyster Bay - 2.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Dog with Sauerkraut
Coconut Ice Cream
Italian Ice
Onion Rings
Cheese Dog
Chili Dog
Fries

“Cash only. Been going to Bonanza’s my entire life, every time we’re in the area, we stop by. Fresh lemon Italian ice is the classic but other flavors are lovely as well. Hot dogs are simple and delicious.Kid-friendliness: There are picnic benches in back. Great for when the kids want to eat their ices immediately.“

4.6 Superb29 Reviews
Sea Cliff Shave Ice Ice Cream Shop •
247 Sea Cliff Ave, Sea Cliff - 6.1 miles

“Charming neighborhood with the friendliest locals I’ve ever encountered in NY. It’s a beautiful drive here from Queens and randomly found a place that serves Hawaiian style shaved ice. It was delicious and I ordered the tropical shaved ice. The staff were very helpful, environment is clean and plenty of parking. I’m definitely going back to try more of their flavors/toppings!“

4.9 Superb17 Reviews
Smallcakes Syosset Bakery • $$
339 Jackson Ave, Syosset - 7.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pink Vanilla

“Best cupcakes I've ever had. The pink vanilla are classic vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream and are my favorite. They are very soft and moist. They stay fresh for a few days after I buy them. Friendly staff and clean store. They make very cute cupcakes for all holidays. Highly recommend.“

4.6 Superb27 Reviews
Bona Bona Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
10 Westchester Ave, Port Chester - 8.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Brownie Ice Cream Bona Style
Vegan Strawberry Ice Cream

“Pink Pink and Pink It's a very cute ice cream shop with a cute girlie atmosphere.We were there for a birthday party. You can have a birthday party in one area or the store. Sprinkle time looked fun. Tried roasted pistachio ice cream with marshmallows. The combination was good, but marshmallow was a bit too sweet for my taste, so I'd get it without next time. It's a bit pricey but it's an experience.“

4.3 Superb53 Reviews
TropiGlace Ice Cream Shop •
864 Cove Rd, Stamford - 9.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fruit Salad
Shaved Ice

“I had their version of a Cholado. It was really good, the different combinations of fruit were great, the topping of the Leche condesada added an amazing touch, and when the shaved ice melts it add for a great drink or iceeParking: Right next to pizza restaurant“

4.6 Superb21 Reviews
Piazza Pizza Pizza • $
520 Milton Rd, Rye - 7.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken Fingers
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings

“FANTASTIC PIZZA. EVEN BETTER SERVICE. I don’t normally write reviews, but these guys absolutely deserve one. I can’t believe I’ve been missing out on Pizza Piazza my whole life, I’ve lived in the area for 20+ years, and now I wish I could have those 20 years back. If only there were more spots like this around that truly cared about the quality of their food, and the experience of their customers. The gentlemen behind the counter made me feel like ive been one of their most loyal customers for years. I will be returning to try more items from their menu very soon! Or I might just get more pizza since it was that good!“

4.4 Superb32 Reviews
Hicksville Sweet Shop Ice Cream Shop • $
75 S Broadway, Hicksville - 10.08 miles

“What a beautiful place! Delicious food, great variety and famtadrict service! Our waitress was kind and attentive.It was me, my husband and 3 kids. The food came out fast (if you have kids to know how important that is). As soon as we sat down she gave us coffee. We were well taken care of here, I can't wait to come back and try lunch.“

4.7 Superb15 Reviews
YOLO Yogurt & Desserts- Frozen Yogurt, Crepe, Gelato, Acai Bowls and more... Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
1355 Old Northern Blvd, Roslyn - 8.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Frozen Yogurt
Frozen Yogurt Cake
Gelato Options
Crepes

“Just stopped by here today because I really wanted some frozen yogurt. This was my first time going there as I am not from here. There are several tables inside with seating for up to 10 people.I wanted some frozen yogurt and was going to get the biggest container they had which was the 1.5 quart, but the guy at the counter warned me it would run me about $25 - $30 which was really expensive. That’s when he explained they charge by the ounce ($1.50/oz?) so the more I put in the container the more expensive it is.I settled for a 16oz container but didn’t fill it all the way up and it ran me about $13 after tax. It was really good and they had a good selection of toppings as well. I would definitely go back again.Parking: There is a municipal parking lot across the street for a fee ($3/hr?) with ample parking.“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
MilkyWays Ice Cream & Cereal Bar Ice Cream Shop •
22 Clinton Ave, Huntington - 7.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Silly Rabbit Special Swirl

“This was our first time here, as soon as you walk in you are greeted and welcomed with a warm smile. Shout out to the two young men working this Wednesday night !!!!! They were very professional, very passionate, very friendly & understanding. Great hospitality overall. Will be coming back ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

4.3 Superb35 Reviews
Constantino’s Pizza & Ice Cream Pizza • $
699 West Putnam Avenue, Greenwich - 8.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Homemade Garlic Knots
Margherita Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Chicken Roll
Lil Michael

“We went for the first time, was a bit taken back with some pricing . We met the owner , he asked what was wrong , absolutely accommodating and concerned, checked it out and was a good guy . We wish him all the best and will be back ! Thanks for the great ice cream too!“

4.1 Good74 Reviews
Paleteria Fernandez Ice Cream Shop • $
119 N Main St, Port Chester - 8.19 miles

“This place is top tier. Hands down the best paletas I've ever had anywhere in the USA. The prices are great and their milk flavors are my absolute favorite. You can't go wrong with the cookies and cream flavor if you're new here but coconut and passion fruit are probably my favorites. The place isn't fancy by any means but don't let that stop you from stepping in. They have lots of flavors and a bunch of Mexican "street food" style snacks.“

4.3 Superb26 Reviews

21
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
130 Manetto Hill Rd, Plainview - 10.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rainbow Sprinkles
Chocolate Crunch
Hot Fudge Sundae

“Would be a 5 but there are no public bathrooms which seems sketchy to me because I thought all dine in establishmentts (they had seating prior to COVID) had to provide bathrooms. Prices compared to portions is insane but that's just the times we live in.“

4.6 Superb13 Reviews
Baskin-Robbins Ice Cream Shop • $
100 N Broadway, Hicksville - 9.82 miles

“I went here with my family to get a cake for my moms birthday. All the small cakes (which we wanted) were taken (as it was Easter). A very nice woman (I didn't catch her name) came to us and said that she would give us a cake for a lower price. Very very pleased with customer service. Would give more stars if I could.“

4.3 Superb22 Reviews
La Fenice Cafe • $$
315 Greenwich Ave, Greenwich - 8.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cannoli
Cookies

“A really nice Italian gelato/baked goods place. We stopped in about 20 minutes before closing and we're lucky enough to sit in their small eating area and enjoy a pana cotta and some other baked goods we took home. Initially I wanted some gelato but after seeing the baked goods I switched. They have lots of options and the next time in the area we will go back for dessert, maybe gelato.“

4.3 Superb18 Reviews
Sundae Donuts Huntington Dessert • $
377 New York Ave, Huntington - 7.63 miles

“Best donuts I've had on Long Island. Found them at Citi field and checked out their Huntington location. Friendly staff, fun flavors, great place for Instagram pictures. And they have kids birthday parties. Will definitely be bringing the family back!“

4 Good62 Reviews
Kilwin's Huntington Village Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
293 Main St, Huntington - 7.52 miles

“Ice cream is delicious. Good variety of flavors- I can get something new everytime I'm here. Their caramel apples are amazing, definitely try them at least once. All the staff here are very nice. They have a Huntington specific flavor which I find so cute!“

4.1 Good30 Reviews
La Fenice Of Rye Cafe • $
3 Purdy Ave, Rye - 8.18 miles

“Discovered this place when searching for gelato in the area and could not be more impressed with the amazing selection of pastries, gelato, and even crepes. The lady behind the counter recognize us since the first time we visited. Very personal and warm atmosphere. It's our dessert spot forever now.“

4.2 Good17 Reviews

27
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
210 Wall St, Huntington - 7.5 miles

“Our go-to, but recently a new employee (or manager? A woman we hadn't seen before) has been giving the WORST scoop - literally half of what the other employees give, making it a total rip and a disappointing experience. Please correct this ASAP or we'll be finding a new location!“

4 Good17 Reviews
Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Shop • $$
298 Main St, Huntington - 7.53 miles

“Walk in door no one there except for one worker, no hello, ice cream good, one table very wobbly needs to be fix before someone gets hurt, and do not like store that change 4 percent for a credit card it should be be add in the price already,“

3.9 Good28 Reviews
Stellina Bakery & Cafe Bakery • $
14 Cold Spring Rd, Syosset - 6.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cake Selection
Tiramisu Cake
Birthday Cake
Milhojas
Gelato

“We had a cake ordered , actually two cakes for my two kids bdays on two occasions . Bakery has amazing choices of fillings and options . Both my kids had the pictures they wanted to replicate and Dylan and her team exceeded our expectations on presentation and taste price was also good ! It’s my go to place ! Highly recommend! Thanks again for making my kids birthday an amazing event! Also ordered cakes for smaller occasions ! Amazing flavours !“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Ralph's Italian Ices Ice Cream Shop • $
292 Main St, Port Washington - 8.97 miles

“It's Labor Day and there is only one girl working, with a steady stream of people.But she's a rockstar, super friendly and fast!Ralph's you're doing this poor girl wrong though, by not having someone else there too.*EditThis is a pretty funny, (passive aggressive?), reply. I get the problems, so good on you for working too. The accepting applications comment is awesome lol.Just recognize that girl with something! If it isn't extra pay for the holiday, or even if it is, give her some extra recognition.Good luck!“

4.2 Good9 Reviews
Gofer Ice Cream Greenwich Ice Cream Shop • $
522 E Putnam Ave, Greenwich - 8.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Soft Serve Pint
Ice Cream Cakes
Specialty Cones
Premium Soft

“I genuinely had the best soft serve of my life at gophers. I imagine that all soft serve dreams of being gophers. I got the coconut swirl. It wasn’t that coconut-y but it was perfectly sweet and so refreshing. My dad got the dairy free sorbet also, the blue raspberry one. It was amazing!! I cannot wait to go again.“

3.9 Good15 Reviews

32
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
2 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay - 3.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Soft Serve Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sundae
Birthday Cake

“BEST carvel!!!! Customer service is so nice, atmosphere is peaceful and everyone is so attentive. Just to point out, please respect all of the employees. I get that they’re only teenagers, but they’re better than some of the rest. Don’t get mad at some stupid simple mistake, they’re just doing their job.“

3.8 Good22 Reviews

33
TCBY

TCBY Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
10 Washington Ave, Plainview - 10.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Honey Greek Vanilla
Frozen Yogurt

“This is an update from a few weeks ago at the TCBY in Plainview NY . ( see pix) "Pride Card" ? I questioned what is that? Seems in Plainview at the beginning of school year at Plainview schools, the cards are sold to be used at local places where savings apply. 15% off Soft Serve yogurt and different places have other specials with this card. The Pride is town pride honoring local stores and shops. On the wall were 3 circles of First. They do not use powered mix for their frozen yogurts, they have a signature flavor and 40 year celebrations have Arkansas opening their first TCBY. (see pix) They have an allergy poster as well for public awareness. I did buy this time small chocolate chip cookies with vanilla yogurt in them from the freezer section for about 8 dollars. There were other items in there as well. (note these items are not discounted from the Pride Card. As noted by the man worker who helped me and took my order. Note : As previously mentioned, the entrance to this little shopping center is on Washington Avenue off of Manetto Hill Road.“

3.9 Good12 Reviews
Loading...
map Map