50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bayville

“I wish this establishment the best of luck. They have quality products. The store is sparkling clean.“

“My kids and I love their Ice Cream with fresh fruit.“

“Brown butter cookie dough is a must.“

“If you want a place to go eat with dirty hands this is the one! Bathroom is always closed but there’s an alley not too far away. You can tell management really cares about the customer experience when they keep the bathroom closed from customers. And they even have tables, that alone would be a health department violation(tables without a working bathroom) but who has time to call them anyway? I think the stuff here is delicious but it could also be the flavor from the last customer on the door handle so who knows?“

“Very nice cookies that taste splendid! However the staff could be a little more enthusiastic (referring to the ones that have worked there for a while, I get it can be tiring to put on a smiley face for each customer that walks in, but you are getting paid to do it and it makes their experience 10x better!). So, there are many new employees who are very welcoming and kind!“

“I recently bought the Earl Grey Tea and Berry Cornbread at my local Kroger store and was blown away! The richness and the flavor profiles were out of this world, especially the latter flavor of the two. It’s dangerous to know the Kroger store is only five minutes from my house. I’ll definitely be trying other flavors.“

“fresh buns and delicious dogs!“

“I recently bought the Earl Grey Tea and Berry Cornbread at my local Kroger store and was blown away! The richness and the flavor profiles were out of this world, especially the latter flavor of the two. It’s dangerous to know the Kroger store is only five minutes from my house. I’ll definitely be trying other flavors.“

“This 16 Handles location is always a great experience! The store is spotless, and the friendly staff create such a warm, welcoming environment-especially with kids. I really appreciate how clearly everything is labeled, from which toppings are kosher to what allergens are present, making it easy to eat here with confidence. Highly recommend!“

“Loved my candied nut popcorn !!! Ice cream is amazing too. And awesome customer service 👍🏼“

“TropiGlace is hands down the tastiest Ecuadorian ice cream spot in Stamford! The owner, Paola, is super friendly and welcoming, which makes the experience even better. I also had the BEST milkshake made by Silvia—absolutely delicious and perfectly done. Highly recommend this place for authentic flavors and great service!“

“***** (Five Star) Review - The hubby and I love the Hicksville Sweet Shop! It is such a warm and welcoming restaurant/ice cream shop – were everyone knows your name! We reserved a table for Valentines Day and had a wonderful meal consisting of crab cakes, fried shrimp, French fries, vegetables and, for dessert, fresh homemade strawberry shortcake – reservations are rarely needed! Homemade ice cream and chocolates are also delicious! I can honestly say I never had a bad meal at the Hicksville Sweet Shop! Thank you Eva, Phil, Harry, Walter, Alma, Jeannie & Clair❤️e!“

“delicious shaved ice, portion size, swag and value for the price. also a plus that it's located in a cute spot in sea cliff. you need to check this place out when open. only draw back is that it's a little slow to get things made. but it's worth the wait on a summer day.“

“Unique and fun experience! Delicious ice cream and friendly workers! Will definitely be back!! Coram location“

“Immaculate frozen yogurt store and friendly staff. They’re following strict Covid protocols. Great tasting yogurt too! 🍦“

“My friend and I stopped in late on a Saturday. The staff was super friendly and the milk and cookies flavor was delicious! I was also surprised to see that this store had one of my favorite flavors that I don't find often, in their freezers! (Churray for Churro, if anyone was curious- I highly recommend it) Also, the store was nicely decorated!“

“Cups N Cones is the best spot to head to after a long day on the way back from Tod’s, or just my go to place after dinner! Their fro-yo is so fresh, the overall atmosphere of the place is super super clean, and everyone in there is so friendly! I also LOVE that they use Longford’s ice cream products. Longford’s has THE BEST flavors and just such an amazing product!“

“I've been seeing the really good food posted on Social Media and finally made the 5 minute trek. I have to say the calzones and pizza were excellent! The calzones are enormous. Where looking forward to trying something different next time, and next time will be soon! ��“

“Ice Cream Deliciousness!!!!“

“Fresh and delicious. Will visit again“

“Wonderful ice cream experience. I got the mint chip & it was delicious.“

“Their location has changed since the picture was posted. They’ve reopened nearby and introduced a variety of new flavors. My favorite has been the acai bowl, but you really can't go wrong with their cream or water ices. Their banana shake is just as delightful as any of their other specialty shakes and ice creams. I believe I visit them 3 to 4 times a week.“

“Wow! Alkemy Ice Cream is amazing! I def recommend trying it! And especially for a birthday party! My entire experience was fantastic! I stumbled upon Alkemy Ice cream while looking for something unique for a birthday and the owner Alan explained how they do birthday parties almost like a show AND make the dessert. They can host a party at the shop OR they can come to you! I was unsure how it would go but Alan was super friendly, answered all my questions throughly and assured me I would love it. I more than loved it! It was the best ever and we are still talking about it. They came to my house and put on a show for the kids that even they are still talking about how cool it was. It was like having a party and adding a surprise guest with a special science experiment show for additional entertainment that makes amazing unique dessert at the end! Each ice cream was perfectly made and was fresh! The toppings were all fresh as well. Watching the show was fascinating and the kids had so much fun learning. They continued to amaze guests as they made each ice cream right there. I wasn’t sure if each kid would be waiting a while but it didn’t take long to get all the kids ice cream after the show. They whipped it up fast and everyone got to pick toppings and have a perfectly made ice cream quickly. They didn’t need a lot of room and even cleaned up! I so happy to have found them and I will be having them come back again! Start to finish was a perfect experience. I highly recommend them!!!“

“Some of the kindest, most understanding people work here.

It's a Coldstone Creamery, you know what you're getting into.

But the staff is exceptional, we'd been here more than a few times and always had great ice-cream. My keys stopped working and me and my fiancé were locked out of our car late at night in sub 20 below weather. The manager attempted to help us open the car, gave us shelter, and was so kind and supportive. They moved a bench inside for us, checked in and offered so much. They took care of us in more ways than not after an already long and hard day.

Outside of being a good place to get ice cream, I think any locals should support these people as much as possible.“

“We stopped by Yogurt & Such today after my teenager kept seeing it all over social media, and it absolutely lived up to the hype! This independently owned yogurt shop was easy to find on the corner with convenient nearby parking, and we were greeted by a genuinely friendly staff from the moment we walked in.
The selection was impressive, with something for everyone, including sugar-free, fat-free, low-fat, and plenty of other flavor and topping combinations. I chose a swirl of the non-fat Angel Vanilla and Cappuccino topped with Heath Bar crumbles, while my daughter went with the Angel Vanilla layered with the highly recommended Strawberry Shortcake crumbles. Both were outstanding—fresh, incredibly smooth, creamy, and delicious without the heaviness (or calories) of traditional ice cream.
The portions were generous, the pricing was very fair, and it's easy to see why so many people recommend this place. They also offer a rewards program with each purchase, which is a nice bonus for future visits.
If you're looking for a frozen yogurt shop with fantastic flavors, endless topping options, friendly service, and excellent value, Yogurt & Such is absolutely worth the visit. We'll definitely be back!“

“Delicious frozen yogurt!🍦🍨“

“Ottimo 👏 lavoro . Gelato come in Italia“

“Great place on a warm summer night for an array of cold, frozen treats. Don't forget that Wednesday's are bogo free ice cream sundaes. Very clean, great, quick and happy staff. Highly recommend!“

“I teach at the local high school and we recently had Ralph’s cater our Junior Prom. They only required a few days advanced notice and provided a great price. Drop off and pick up was excellent; I had forgotten to ask for spoons and they went and picked them up for me!

In prior years, we’d paid 4x as much for an ice cream truck, but the kids liked the Ralph’s way more. They are great for individual orders but are also great for catering; give them a try!“

“The best carvel store in the area! All of the employees are so wonderful and accommodating with my family and especially my 4 year old daughter. Always have a smile on their face and all of their products are delicious!! They are a staple to the Port Chester and Greenwich communities. We are regulars for many, many years.“

“We ordered this custom ice cream cake for our Moana-themed first anniversary celebration, and it exceeded all of our expectations! The most incredible part is that this was a last-minute order placed the day before our event, and they still created something absolutely breathtaking.

The owner’s wife stayed up late into the night pouring so much love, creativity, and heart into decorating this cake, and it truly showed in every detail. The tropical flowers, ocean waves, and Moana topper were beautifully crafted and perfectly matched our celebration.

Not only was the cake gorgeous, but it was also one of the most delicious ice cream cakes we’ve ever had. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about both how beautiful it looked and how amazing it tasted.

We are beyond grateful for the extra effort, care, and dedication they put into making our celebration so special. If you’re looking for a bakery that goes above and beyond and truly cares about its customers, I cannot recommend them enough. Thank you for making our anniversary unforgettable!“

“The truffle fries were to die for and the burger was just the right size and delish!“

“Great customer service! I talked to a girl named Emily on the phone about my cake order and she was super helpful, patient and kind! My cake was also super tasty and looked AMAZING!!! Definitely recommend the gofer cakes and the staff is truly amazing !“

“Great place to have a nice ice cream treat. The only little problem w this store is that when too many people are there the place to pay is too crowded. They should separate payment section and delivery section. Honestly some.of these entitled parents have no consideration where they are standing and just cut people off when paying. Other than that place is amazing and have lots on the menu.“

“Amazing. So incredibly fresh. We will be back.“

“They have false advertising on 10% on the wall and then refuse to give it. Otherwise they are fine“

“Would be a 5 but there are no public bathrooms which seems sketchy to me because I thought all dine in establishmentts (they had seating prior to COVID) had to provide bathrooms. Prices compared to portions is insane but that's just the times we live in.“

“Delicious cake, amazing staff - who dealt with my craziness on such short notice. Beautifully decorated and brought such a smile to my 16-year-old daughter's face (which isn't easy😉) Even the restaurant staff was impressed by the taste and texture of the cake. Can't wait to stop in again for a treat or to order another specialty cake.“

“great shakes and and great ice creams with lots of flavors that I would highly recommend it. I wouldn't give it 5 stars because there's no seating as the whole indoor space is taken up by freezers. I think better stand up freezer to reduce floor space and make seating available would really improve the image of the place and for people who want to come there. I definitely want to have more of their shakes more often!“

“Love the convenience of having this next door to Mario’s. The other Ralph’s is open seasonally and this one is open year round. Scott is wonderful and works with schools to do fundraisers and can also do school events where they bring their trailer and serve ices to the kids.“

“This is an awesome ice cream shop! I tried three different flavors but coconut chunk has been on my mind ever since I tried it. Once you try this stuff the gas station special will never cut it ever again. Great view from the parking lot too!“

“Their menu is the star here. I’ve learned a lot. There are so many flavors, styles & combinations that you’ll probably discover something you’ve never had before, every time. For real, they have fake flavoring but their stuff is tasty. Service can be quite slow, especially when you’re not the only one there (ha), but this place will get you coming back because it’s that good and fun. If you’re really itching, order a hot dog at Toxic Wings connected to it while you wait. Come with patience and optimism if required. Worth a visit.“

“Great ice cream and waffles . Cute shop . Very friendly workers . The vegan ice cream was so yummy“

“I love the products and the crew“

“Ice cream is amazing. Employees are super friendly, especially Andre. I love the vibe they have and how kind they are, I don’t understand any negative reviews. The ice cream and shakes are delicious. I think people in this mall and area just like complaining.“

“Seriously the best ices and ice creams ever. They have douzaines of classic dessert and candy flavors which are better then the originals. It's pure and elevates your spirit up to the moon! Once a year, we travel to Long Island, New York and, we dream about Ralph's all year round, back in Canada. What we would do to have this here in our country.“

“Constantino’s makes the perfect pizza. The ingredients are so fresh and the customer service experience is the cherry on top. We went for the soft opening a few weeks back and the atmosphere was so family oriented and welcoming. Some of the best pizza I have had! They have a bunch of different kinds but the grandma pizza and the plain pizza are out of this world! You have to try this place. Mike the owner is absolutely wonderful and knows what really good pizza is.“

“Just got off the phone with Jared. His service is fantastic! Friendly, efficient, and a pleasure to work with!“