35 Best Ice Cream Shops near Elma

“Great service and ice cream!“

“We went here for the first time today from Brantford Ontario. Everyone was so nice and the selections are amazing!!! You can pretty much get anything with ice cream you are craving. Anytime we come to Buffalo now in the season, we are going!“

“Best spot for ice cream !!“

“Sweet Jenny’s is a staple for our family. We never have a holiday table without chocolate from here. Teacher gifts are a must. Summer ice cream trips making memories! Everything here is amazing, including the owners. If your visiting the Buffalo area this place is a must see, we always bring out of towners here! Thanks for being such an awesome part of our community!“

“Ice cream locally made is off the charts DELICIOUS!!! Repeat customers for sure!!!“

“WOW!!! That’s what I have to say about this place! Such a gem went here for first time and got such nice guys taking our order as well as preparing it with nothing but smiles and awesome service! Great tasting ice cream too! Might want to add more seating somehow.. little hard to find a seat but we will SOO be back!!!!!!(and they had my hard to find fav flavor)!“

“The absolute BEST ice cream you will ever put in your mouth“

“We love Village Ice Cream! They're so friendly and helpful, ice cream is great, prices are good! I love that they have Perrys flavors not sold in stores.“

“Our favorite place to get 🍦! 😊“

“We could not have been more excited to have The Pink Cow Ice Cream Truck, our absolute favorite ice cream shop, be part of our wedding day! Having their truck there was such a fun and memorable addition, and our guests absolutely loved it. One of our favorite parts was being able to create customizable signature sundaes specifically for our wedding. It made the experience feel so personal and was such a fun way to incorporate one of our favorite places into our special day. Everything was absolutely delicious, and the truck was a huge hit with our guests! Hanna was absolutely amazing to work with from start to finish. She was incredibly kind, accommodating, and easy to communicate with, and we truly felt like she cared about making our day special. The entire experience was seamless, and we couldn’t have asked for a better vendor to be part of our celebration.

We already loved The Pink Cow, but having them be part of such an important day made us love them even more! ❤🍦 We cannot recommend them enough for any event, big or small. If you’re looking for a fun, delicious, and unique addition to your celebration, book The Pink Cow Ice Cream Truck—you won’t regret it!“

“We went last night to Kone king and had a great experience. On fridays we celebrate our son Felix and call it “Felix fridays” where we do something fun with him. Decided on Kone king last night. Our son ordered his ice cream and the staff clapped and celebrated “Felix friday” and the one worker said she had something special for Felix and it was a color changing spoon- to a 5 year old that was the coolest thing ever. I just wanna say thank you to the staff for really brightening Felix Friday for us, it made it a magical evening for our sweet boy. ♥️“

“I wanted to express my deepest gratitude to Kone King for coming to my rescue when I found myself in a bit of a pickle. After Charlap's bailed on me just two days before the event, I was feeling incredibly stressed and unsure of how to proceed. But then, like a superhero, you swooped in to save the day! Jennifer Johnson Hubert Metro Robert Realty“

“I have visited this place twice. Once last year during the 4th of July weekend (2025) and now today (July 4th weekend 2026), while visiting family. The place is great! A large variety of flavors and items. I would DEFINITELY recommend going there if you get a chance. Both times the staff were great.“

“My sister and I were traveling for my birthday to Niagara Falls, Canada from Ohio. A friend of mine, who grew up in Buffalo suggested if we had time to stop by and try the best sponge candy, so we DID! We also tried other delicious chocolates and AHmazing baklava. It did not disappoint!“

“Crumbl makes some of the best cookies around. They’re fresh, creative, and consistently delicious, with new flavors every week that make each visit fun. The only drawback is the price. The cookies are excellent, but they are far too pricy. I’d visit more often if they were a little more affordable.“

“Best spot for ice cream !!“

“I've always enjoyed everything I've ordered. So many flavors, so many toppings, so many options. It's great.“

“We love going to C’s! They have a variety of delicious ice cream flavors and their service is great! Even our puppy gives their pup cups 5 stars! 👍“

“No I don’t recommend French Road Dairy Queen. The workers are rude. Online says they’re open until 10 so my kids and I ride our bikes a couple miles to French road Dairy Queen looking for a tasty treat. On arrival the inside area is already closed at 9:45. Drive thru is open since they don’t have a walk up window like every other ice cream shop I figured I could get served at the drive thru window. NOPE. No ice cream for you they say like I’m in the Sienfeld episode The soup Nazi only it’s ice cream. My kids and I were so disappointed. The ride home was treacherous with no calories in our systems. We barely made it home Sincerely Disappointed customer“

“Usually really good, our order is always right, but sometimes it’s a group of young kids working that don’t really seem to care about whether you get your food/ice cream at a decent time or not. They tend to care more about being on their phones and listening to music/joking with each other than customer service but that seems to be pretty typical these days. Otherwise it’s been good“

“I love their Dilly bars and Buster bars!!♥️♥️♥️🤍🤍💙💙🎉🎊🎉🎊“

“Sponge Candy is to die for!!!! Loved my treat box the chocolate is unmatched👌🏽 Recommended to everyone.“

“Have stopped in and buying different treats here for years and still get plenty of new, sweet, surprises all the time. Everyone in the family love to come and pick their own sweet rewards. Love their milk-chocolate, orange, sponge candy! You can join their rewards system to earn points and get future discounts.“

“I love this, this is perfect. Putting aside that there's more Perry's flavors than any other ice cream shop I've seen, this place is AN ACTUAL TRAINCAR!! I thought it was just a name. There's tracks under it and everything.
The people are really cool and pleasant, and they have a cool train track toy off in the yard. Also there's a deer family, a mom and 2 fawns, just meandering around, eating grass, not running away from the people. This is a great place“

“was great ice cream and great service and great company!!“

“Yeah, I really like this place! The prices are definitely reasonable, which is a huge plus. Plus, they never skimp on the toppings; you always get a good amount. The staff is also super friendly and always makes you feel welcome. Honestly, it's a great spot for a quick and tasty meal.“

“Excellent chocolates. The coconut clusters, peanut clusters, sponge candy and different milk chocolate items are all incredible. Friendly and helpful staff. It’s relaxing and enjoyable to shop around the store. Perfect stop for holiday treats :)“

“Helpful staff, outdoor & indoor safe seating, lots of food & ice cream choices.“

“A great variety of shakes, ice creams ?etc.Great to visit on a very hot summer evening.Ice cream is very tasty.Totally family oriented, you can get your ice cream and sit around and eat, enjoy some fun time talking with family & friends.“

“yummy ice cream! let's you try before you buy so you know you will like it.“

“I had a dipped trust soft serve cone. The ice cream and dip were both great! It was busy, and I can understand why. Be aware, cash only, but there is an on-site ATM“

“Still the best! The flavor took me back to 1987 on Seneca St. Thank's for making the Chicken "Patty" sub like the old days!“

“BEST subs in WNY. They use all fresh meats and vegetables - tomatoes are fresh and bright red (other sub shops will bury unripe, yellow slices in under the mayo), lettuce is fresh iceberg and not shredded, rolls and meats are fresh. I pass 4 sub shops on my way to J & M’s on Transit Rd. You wait a bit too long for them to take your phone order but it’s worth the wait. Great staff!“

“Thank you to the kind person/employee that turned in my purse to the office. It’s great to know there are still kind and honest people in this world! It made my error in judgement a bit more bearable. Much appreciated! 😊“

“Awesome food get the mozzarella sticks!!“