25 Best Sandwich Shops near Garden City Park

Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
2345 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park

Customers` Favorites

Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
My Philly Cheesesteak
Original Italian Sub
Subs by the Bag
Club Supreme
Roast Beef
Brownie
Cookie
Chips

“This team did a top notch job during the day of giving! The staff all had smiles beaming on their faces and they were so happy to be able to give back to the Special Olympics of NY! I loved my tuna sub Mike's Way -- it's my go-to sub!“

3.6 Good54 Reviews
Press 195 Sandwich Shop • $$
22 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre - 5.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Cauliflower with Blue Cheese Crumbles
Authentic Buffalo Wings
Kid's Grilled Cheese
Double Cooked Fries
Belgian Fries Frites
Slow Roasted Pork
Sweet Potato Fries
Fried Mozzarella
Belgian Fries
Brisket Knish

“I've only discovered Press two months ago, and I've already been there multiple times. The menu is very diverse, making it tough to make a decision. As a vegetarian, that's not always the case. The food is fresh and amazing ( the fries are ?!) Service is friendly.Press 195 is my new favorite choice!“

4.3 Superb108 Reviews
Louisiana Joe's Sandwich Shop • $
488 Merrick Rd, Oceanside - 6.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Andouille Mac & Cheese
Louisiana Roast Pork
Chopped Pork Panini
Macaroni and Cheese
Brisket Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Shrimp PO Boy
Chicken Gumbo
Cajun Fries
Pulled Pork

“Great taste of home for this New Orleans transplant. The crawfish etouffee and gumbo are delicious. The bread pudding is yummy too. There is a well stocked market adjacent to the ordering counter that has many basic groceries as well as prepared foods and regional specialties. Looking forward to trying more of their extensive menu.“

4.7 Superb40 Reviews
My Hero Sandwich Shop • $
1005 Jerusalem Ave, North Merrick - 6.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Club Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Chicken Cutlet with Mozzarella and Red Peppers
Chicken Club Sandwich
Chicken Cutlet Parm
Roast Beef Hero
Chicken Supreme
Meatball Parm
Potato Salad
Chicken Parm
All American

“My Hero, has been here forever, a staple of my highschool days.And they haven't missed a beat. This place rocks. Good food, friendly staff and now, better parking! That was the only downside, but it's fixed!Cash only, that's the only thing you have to know before coming “

4.4 Superb66 Reviews
BRENDOS American • $
82 Hillside Ave., Williston Park - 1.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Dip Hero
Chicken Wings
Chopped Cheese
Mac N Cheese
French Fries
TexMex
Philly

“I have been following this shop on Ig for a while and finally got around to trying it. Incan happily say I was not disappointed. I had the Jackpot with honey money mustard and my fiance had a chicken caesar wrap and we split drunken fries. All of it was delicious. Both of ours had plenty of chicken and taste. The fries were delicious and the vodka sauce was very good. Also tried the mac and cheese and it was good. Overall cant wait to go back and try more of the menu!“

4.4 Superb61 Reviews
Press 195 Sandwich Shop • $$
4011 Bell Blvd, Queens - 5.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Marinated Sliced Steak
Classic Pastrami Knish
Classic Buffalo Wings
Sandwiches and Fries
Guacamole and Salsa
Steak Sandwiches
Chicken Fingers
Chipotle Mayo
Belgian Fries
Classic Burger

“I've been coming here for years. Great casual outdoor area in the back when the weather is nice. Pretty extensive varied menu so no matter what you like, you'll definitely find something to eat here. My go-to is their #38, the steak with the mozzarella and sweet onion jam is not to be missed. Their fries are also amazing and served with your choice of sauces. Super friendly service here every time.“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
Pantano's Gourmet Uniondale Sandwich Shop • $
1150 Hempstead Tpke, Uniondale - 4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hangover Breakfast Hero
Buttermilk Pancakes
Philly Cheese Steak
Berry Pancakes
Regular Fries
French Toast
Cheesesteak
Panini
Gravy
Bagel

“I made a huge order because i was ordering for my office. The gentleman who helped me over the phone for my pick up order was very patient. I had three different orders with special instructions and all separate payments. Yes, i knew it was a lot. He kept his professionalism and grace. I walked into the restaurant and it was clean, smelled sanitized and things were neatly place and organized. As soon as i was greeted by a nice lady at the register when i told her my name my order was close by being prepared. The service was fast and friendly. The gentleman who helped me over the phone let me know we were waiting for my fries and he prepared a lemonade which went with the upgrade for one of my orders. While waiting for the fries we shared a nice small talk about the great service and he let me know getting the lemonade was a better deal than the can soda because the lemonade was 20 ounces and the van was 12 ounces. The staff was great! Now to the food. I tipped in the jar because it’s a great experience. It only got better when he helped me to my car. He placed the food neatly in my car. I started with my appetizer the mini crab cakes. You get five for $10.95. They were seasoned nicely to taste and perfectly baked outside batter. May have been imitation crab meat but hey they were good! The macaroni salad that came with my pastrami Mac melt wasn’t the best. They used rigatoni noodles instead of elbow and it was dry. The Mayo was at the bottom of the cup. I doctored that up and it was okay. But boyyyyy did the pastrami Mac melt melt my taste buds! Wow is all i can say! Temperature wise the food was hot and fresh. The taste of the pastrami was so delicious and savory it went perfectly with the type of bread that was used. The Mac was cheesy and also seasoned (i noticed the pepper) went so well with the meat! This melt is a must have if you like big flavor. This place is fantastic and i will always dine here. Thank you to the staff at Pantano’s for “loving to feed us!” Keep up the awesome work!“

4.2 Good68 Reviews
Roast Sandwich House Sandwich Shop •
238 W Jericho Turnpike, Syosset - 8.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Small Roasted Chicken Tortellini Soup
Crispy Eggplant Burrata Caprese
Crispy Eggplant Buratta Caprese
Sweet Potato Tater Tots
Housemade French Fries
Blackened Shrimp Cobb
Philly Cheese Steak
Cubano Sandwich
Roast Beef Melt
Italian Sub

“Solid sandwiches! I was so sad when Village Heros closed down and began my search yet again for that Soul-satisfying sandwich... Roast is in the running! Got the Cubano and the Country Fried Chicken sandwiches - so tasty!! Also enjoyed the house made fries - ordered two for two people but one order would have sufficed. Great portions! The only downside (very slight) would be the Mac and Cheese - not bad but not great. It was the only hiccup during the whole meal. Service was quite friendly and efficient; the seating area was clean and comfortable. Parking is easy and, if you have room for dessert, Ralph's is just a couple of steps away (during the warmer days).“

4.5 Superb32 Reviews
Blimpie Sandwich Shop • $
525 Old Country Rd, Westbury - 4.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Turkey and Cheese Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken
Italiano Blimp
Blimpie Best
Hoboken Hero
Pastrami

“It was my first time here, a friend recommended it due to the halal opinions available. When I walked in, I was greated right away. While I was looking at the menu the employees asked if I needed help and asked my needs and suggested the halal options. The selection wasn't grand but enough to not overwhelm me. In regards to the food it was par and I was pleased. In all services was amazing, food was good and atmosphere was peaceful.“

4.2 Good37 Reviews
Kitchen Kabaret Sandwich Shop • $
409 Glen Cove Rd, Roslyn Heights - 3.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cheesecake Y Fruit Tarts
Pepperoni Pizza with Pepper Flakes
Delicious Homemade Cupcakes
Steak Teriyaki on Lettuce
Strawberry Chocolates
Garlic Knot Sandwich
Roast Beef Sandwich
Chicken Pot Pies
Chicken Sandwich
Seafood Salad

“I'm giving it 4 stars, because I went in looking for lunch, not an additional 10 pounds! Hahaha the food was so good!!! And desert......stop it! I should bill you for the sugar coma I was left in, the cookies, canoli, puddings also so very good. This place is amazing, a whole lot of everything no matter what your taste buds are craving!“

3.9 Good71 Reviews
CJ's Cafe Sandwich Shop • $
177-15 Union Tpke, Fresh Meadows - 6.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pressed Home-Made Baked Chicken Sandwich Comes with Avocado Cheddar and Chipotle Sauce
Chicken Cutlet Lettuce Tomato N Chipotle Sauce

“Really good sandwiches, way better than any of the Subways in the area. I'm coming here from now on. Also love the smoothies. The best part is customer service, the lady at the counter was very friendly, and accommodating about my food allergies.“

4.5 Superb21 Reviews
Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint Sandwich Shop • $$
40-15 Bell Blvd, Queens - 5.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger Pizza Slice
Loaded Tater Tot Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Mac and Cheese Slice
Mac & Cheese Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Philly Bomber Sub
Lord of the Fries
Chicken Wings
Sandwich

“Day of visit 1/15/2024 In the words of my very wise 7yr old "best day ever!" We really had such a great experience that day. And I certainly have the employees at Kraveit to thank for it. We got there just as they had opened, and only two pizzas were out. Seriously, we were there for a late breakfast haha. We were hungry and it was clear lol. My daughter wanted the Mac and cheese slice and ofcourse that wasn't out. When I asked how long it would take for them to make the pizzas, also, if they were going to make a Mac and cheese pie soon? Paul (the awesome Pizza maker) said which ones do you want? I'll make em now. WHAT!!! He knew we'd get a slice or two, but offered to make whichever ones we wanted next. We ordered the Mac-tastic, sweet devil, and, fuego chicken. My daughter described the Mac and cheese slice perfectly. She said "this is blowing my mind with goodness lol". It's really a gem of a slice. The chicken fuego was my personal favorite. Perfectly balanced and delicious. The sweet devil wasn't my favorite, but I see the appeal. Their garlic knots were perfect. And dont forget the krave-it soda! It's addictingly delicious. I also reccomend the fried oreoz for dessert. Now while we were waiting for the pizzas to be done, we got our own pizza making class. My daughter was elated, and the bursts of laughter and happiness wouldn't stop. Diana showed her how she put the sauces on, and answered all her questions. Paul explained the toppings on the slices, twirled the dough for her, and showed her how he sliced them. She must have said "best day ever" over 20 times. She was so happy she forgot the was hungry lol. I know how busy this place can be, and how they crank out the pizzas, so to take the time to answer a curious child's questions really speaks of Paul and Diana's character. I've been coming to Krave-it since my college days (when it opened). And I'm happy to say, that they've officially sealed themselves in the hearts of a 2nd generation. My kids will be here and in the words of my 7yr old "I will bring my kids here one day". Thank you Paul, Diana, and Krave-it for serving great food, and creating such an inclusive environment for families.“

3.8 Good84 Reviews

13
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
127-02 Merrick Blvd, Queens - 6.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sub Footlong
Black Forest Ham Sub Footlong
Steak & Cheese Salad
Spicy Italian Wrap
The Great Garlic
Subway Club
Cookies
Tuna

“I enjoyed eating here but I don't really eat cookies ? or cake ? except for special occasions. I highly recommend the Veggie delight with extra avocadoVegetarian options: Veggie delightDietary restrictions: They let me know if something has eggs or milk or any other meat byproducts since I have been a vegan since 1996 and vegetarian since 1990.“

4.4 Superb20 Reviews
Charleys Cheesesteaks and Wings Cheesesteaks •
362 Fulton Ave, Hempstead - 3.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cheesesteak Boxed Meal
Real Fruit Lemonade
Philly Cheesesteak
6 PC Classic Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Boneless Wings
Thai Chili
Fries

“Food - delicious and served hot, which is a big plus for me; ordered classic wings with Thai Chilli sauce, an order of boneless wings with mango habanero sauce and fries (all less than $25)Service - good; the young men held it downAtmosphere - small space, but nice and cleanParking: Small lot behind the building for all businesses...often packed, but wait 5mins or so and sometimes moving; drive slowly and carefully; people walk out into traffic or are sitting on the sides at times... interesting crowd.“

4.2 Good24 Reviews
Roast Sandwich House Sandwich Shop • $
100 Main St, Mineola - 1.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Housemade French Fries
Philly Cheese Steak
Roast Beef Melt

“Consistently good food: sandwiches and soups. Have been getting them for years. Have tried both Bethpage and mineola. Both have good food and quick service. Order ahead on their website to save on the bs fees from 3rd party nonsense. If there is a special that interests you, get it. Most let very room.“

3.9 Good38 Reviews
Superhero Deli Sandwich Shop • $
2431 Grand Ave, Bellmore - 8.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

2 Eggs on a Roll

“I was in the area yesterday and I was a little early for the studio I had rented for the day so we decided to stop in and get some food. The owner was very friendly and accommodating(which is an understatement), they made my order exactly how I wanted it and it was fast.I've passed by this place a few times and I know they're known for their heroes obviously. I'll be back in for my goto Italian hero which they call the Superman.P.S. Ignore that 2 star review I'm sure you can tell it was written by a Karen or whiney hipster.“

4.5 Superb15 Reviews

17
Blimpie

Blimpie Sandwich Shop • $
2375 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow - 6.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry Banana Smoothie
Peach Mango Smoothie
Extra Dressings
Sandwich
Salads
Turkey
Chips

“That Blimpie's in East Meadow is our favorite one they always make the sandwiches really good.. I put a couple of receipts up one of them was $39.04 another one was $15.19 now the third one I'm about to put up is $22.77 $35.80 somebody has to go to math class because if you add up those four receipts what is the answer ???“

4 Good26 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
2756 Sunrise Hwy, Bellmore - 8.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Cheesesteak
Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
Roast Beef and Provolone
Turkey and Provolone
The Original Italian
Stickball Special
Subs by the Box
Club Supreme

“Bellmore store is great! The owner, Mitch Cohen is absolutely the most helpful and patient of anyone you could ask to deal with. He spent almost an hour on the phone, helping me navigate ordering on the app which for some reason I was having an ordering problem. Happy one that works there is helpful and the sandwiches are great.“

3.9 Good31 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop •
180 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville - 7.25 miles

“Best gluten-free lunch option!The staff is super attentive to a gluten allergy and follow higher than average operating procedures to ensure no cross contamination occurs (changing gloves, using mayo from the bottle vs. the container, etc.). Staff is also very helpful and efficient.“

3.6 Good62 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
988 Hempstead Tpke, Uniondale - 3.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mike's Chicken Philly
Turkey and Provolone
Chips & Drinks
Tuna Sub
Wrap

“First time trying jersey mikes ! 10/10 amazing I definitely enjoyed every bite and will definitely be getting this more often ! Best subs everything is so fresh and tasty , being that it was my first time here I didn’t realize they didn’t take bills over 50-100 dollars and it was all I had and I was ready to go get change and come back and the girl that helped assist in making my sandwich was so nice she took the 50 I had so we can make the purchase she did let me know she would try to help me and she did ! What a friendly and nice gesture of her I’m so mad I didn’t get her name to add in this review. I can say the staff is very nice and pleasant! Def check them out“

3.7 Good41 Reviews
MMM That's A Wrap Sandwich Shop • $
45-52 Bell Blvd, Queens - 5.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mango Mania Smoothie
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Southern Quesadilla
Balboa Wrap

“Very good and healthy love the decorations. Their best rap is the number 11 the logo burrito wrap and it really is so good. I got the chicken Caesar wrap which it was good as well but the Caesar dressing is definitely store-bought which makes me not like it as much but my boyfriend got the loco burrito and I ate half of his and I feel happy!“

3.7 Good36 Reviews

22
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
219-25 N Conduit Ave, Jamaica - 7.11 miles

“Lovely trip on the train even tho I missed the right train the shuttle bus driver that takes me to E-train stop was great I must also congratulate him and a passenger who help me through the rest of my journey and I reached home in safety. Thanks J train Etrain and team“

3.9 Good15 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $$
202 Glen Cove Rd, Carle Place - 2.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Original Italian Extra Meat and Cheese
Chicken Philly Cheese Steak
Roast Beef and Provolone
Big Kahuna Cheese Steak
Chipotle Cheese Steak
Buffalo Chicken

“It's a sandwich shop. I gave it five stars in comparison to similar places such as subway. You can find better at worse at a deli but this is convenient, especially when traveling. Very consistent from store to store throughout the tri-state area at least.“

3.5 Good43 Reviews

24
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
358B Broadway Food Court Store No 200, Hicksville - 7.22 miles
3.6 Good27 Reviews

25
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
205-12 Northern Blvd, Auburndale - 6.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken & Bacon Ranch Footlong Pro Double Protein
Rotisserie-Style Chicken Footlong Regular Sub
Oven Roasted Turkey & Ham 6 Inch Regular Sub
The Outlaw Footlong Pro Double Protein
Footlong Sandwiches and Personal Pizza
Steak & Cheese Footlong Regular Sub
Grilled Chicken 6 Inch Regular Sub
Ham & Cheese Melt Footlong Melt
Ham & Cheese Melt 6 Inch Melt
Black Forest Ham Sandwich

“As far as a chain for Subway this is by far the cleanest and nicest one to dine in New York city even the floor was kept clean. I love it because it has parking space because I had to go out of my way to come here, the nearby subway doesn't look as clean. Compliment on the lady working there presenting her smiles to customers which is rare in NY. The store supervisor was proactively resolving the register system issue. Subway has long been having problems with their POS. Good to know they are the only one in the area that accepts national coupon/gift cards properly while most other Subways I been to just straight out refused to accept them.“

3.5 Good36 Reviews
Loading...
map Map