Browse menus, reviews and photos of Bagels Restaurants near Holtsville.
Bagels · $
1018 Waverly Ave, Holtsville
“Local bagel house for fresh delicious rolls and bagels at genuinely affordable prices. Their everything bagel with scallion cream cheese was a standout to me. I'm a regular customer for buttered roll with coffee. Not a café or restaurant. Authentic and clean place.”
Deli · $
375 Boyle Road, Selden · 5.08 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I just ordered the Ballfield-Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Melted Swiss, Onion Rings, Russian dressing on Garlic Hero , It was the best Hero I have had in a long time. It was packed with Cutlets and was so filling I ate half then a few hours later ate the other half. I will def go back for another order soon.”
Bagels · $
25 Gibbs Rd, Coram · 5.87 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best Home Fries Ever! I get them with melted mozzarella and bacon in top! So good! My husband loves their breakfast sandwiches! The fact that I work next door is a bonus for sure! If you’ve never been here you’re missing out!”
Bagel shop · $
1055 Portion Road, Farmingville · 1.76 miles
“Absolutely loved this place. The bagels are exactly how a real bagel should be — fresh, perfectly textured, and packed with flavor. You can genuinely taste the quality in every ingredient they use. The staff was super friendly and welcoming too, which made the whole experience even better. Honestly, this is the kind of spot that ruins average bagels for you forever. Definitely coming back.”
Bagels · $
1198 Middle Country Rd, Selden · 3.29 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I have not been here in a long time. This bagel loving girl gives them a 10. Perfect crunch, seeds on both sides. The gentleman that helped us this morning along with the other staff were very friendly. I will definitely be back. Oh and the inside is cute..”
Bagel shop · $
2065 Middle Country Road, Centereach · 3.65 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I recently visited this delightful bagel shop and was thoroughly impressed! The bagel sandwiches and croissants were absolutely delicious. My son said it was the best bacon, egg and cheese sandwich he’s ever had. The staff is super friendly as well. I highly recommend this bagel shop!”
Bagels · $
1380 Montauk Highway, Oakdale · 6.85 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I gave five star review because I really do not go to this place but I was mortified by how dirty it was. It was disgustingly dirty. I don’t know if they just look at the place from the customers view. I would never eat there. They really need to clean that place up. They need a total overhaul in front that eating whatever’s in the back. It was worse than a dirty Chinese restaurant I’m sorry I threw my bagel out actually.”
Bagel shop · $
5507 Nesconset Highway Unit 14, Mount Sinai · 7.99 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We were visiting the area and decided to go here. The bagels were very fresh and our food was so good!! The staff was extremely nice and helpful, and even asked how much cream cheese we wanted on our bagel which i’ve never seen a place do. I definitely recommend!”
Deli · $
623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville · 1.3 miles
Customers’ favorites
“As soon as I walked in, I was immediately welcomed and helped very attentively. Amazing customer service and environment is very comforting. Store is very clean and upkept. And food is even better. I mean they have so many cool creations. Definitely recommend choosing this as your go-to bagel spot if you’re near by!”
Bagels · $
379 NY-25A, Rocky Point · 10.54 miles
“The best bagels by far on Long Island also I recommend all my fellow comics and friends to go and try the hero's!! Now you know how I became a fat jolly comedian!!”
Bagels · $
67 NY-111, Smithtown · 7.83 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Wish I knew about them sooner! !! I would have gone there for years! They should open one by us in kings park! !”
Bagel shop · $
1311 Middle Country Rd, Centereach · 3.36 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Brendel’s Bagels is hands down one of the best bagel spots around. The bagels are always fresh, soft on the inside, and perfectly crisp on the outside. Their breakfast sandwiches are delicious, made with quality ingredients, and always hit the spot. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the shop has a welcoming atmosphere that keeps you coming back. Whether you’re grabbing a classic bagel with cream cheese or a bacon, egg, and cheese, you can count on a great meal every time. If you’re looking for authentic New York-style bagels, Brendel’s Bagels is definitely worth a visit. Highly recommended!”
Bagel shop · $
2815 Middle Country Road, Lake Grove · 4.69 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Everything I’ve tried here has been amazing! They even make their own ice cream, which you definitely need to try. The staff are super friendly, and the owners are right there running the place themselves. It’s a true family business and honestly just perfect.”
Bakery · $
888 Johnson Avenue Suite 6058, Ronkonkoma · 4.12 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great fresh bagels and a wonderful spread of delicious Italian cookies. The rainbow cookie is my fav and it did not disappoint: sweet and the moisture was on point. Look forward to coming back when I’m in town! *just note this is a grab and go kinda bagel place. There’s no indoor or outdoor seating available.”
Bagels · $
650 Patchogue Road, Port Jefferson Station · 7.72 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Before we start, this amazing place closes at 2PM. The MOST Famous item is veggie cream cheese. I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND everything flagel, Jalapeño chedder bagel & everything egg bagel. I stopped in for a quick bite and ended up having one of the best fresh coffees of my life. I’m talking smooth, bold, and the kind of cup that makes you pause mid-sip just to appreciate it. Total standout. The full egg everything bagel with scallion cream cheese was exactly what you want on a good morning. Soft, warm, packed with flavor, and honestly just satisfying in every way. Simple, fresh, and done right. Great little spot, great energy, and even better breakfast. I’d go back in a heartbeat.”
Pizza · $
1699 Medford Ave, Medford · 2.26 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Been going to Joel's bagels forever! Rolando and family are such beautiful people, warm, welcoming, and funny. I moved to patchogue some years back and began the hunt for a good bagel spot. I walked in and couldn't believe how friendly everyone was. Instantly it became my #1 go-to. The food is tasty and the people treat you like family. Now I'm a few towns over and worth the trip back each and every time!”
Bagel shop · $
876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace · 7.58 miles
Customers’ favorites
“near where i work i think? gonna check it out!”
Bagels · $
Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station · 5.79 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Always have to stop by old town bagels when I’m passing through town! The owner and staff are very friendly and always working with a smile!! I got a few dozen bagels to share with my coworkers and was a big hit amongst the nurses :). Def will continue to come back for these bagels!!”
Bagels · $
1879 Lakeland Avenue, Ronkonkoma · 4.14 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Walking in the establishment, everything smells so fresh and delicious. Of course, it's going to be busy, so I advise calling ahead, as I did. They seem very organized, and I could see how it can be chaotic, but it's well worth the wait. Thank you for my breakfast.”
Deli · $
691 NY-25A, Miller Place · 9.55 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The Bagel sandwiches were delicious. Our order was forgotten about and we just watched people come and go. We finally asked someone to check on it and got the order. Worth the wait though! Delicious. Salt bagels on hand and delicious fresh lox. Yum”
Bagels · $
871 Montauk Highway, Bayport · 4.64 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious, made to order bagels, at a reasonable price. The shop was clean and well stocked. The staff was kind and efficient. I would highly recommend this bagel shop. We ordered egg and cheese bagels and they were delicious. You can customize it anyway you like and it comes with juice or coffee. There is no seating for eating in, but that was fine with us because we wanted to take our food to go.”
Deli · $
418 N Country Rd, St James · 7.77 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I absolutely love the attention to detail, the care and love of food that these chefs prepare. Love the surprise of not knowing what you get. They work with dietary restrictions.”
Bagels · $
1097 Smithtown Ave, Bohemia · 4.57 miles
Customers’ favorites
“hubby's in there now buying bagels and cream cheese”
Bagels · $
275 NY-25A #21, Miller Place · 9.29 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We've been going here for a long time n it's our ONLY go to spot for bagels. ALWAYS great n friendly service n delicious bagels. No matter what day or time their bagels are ALWAYS FRESH. We highly recommend BETTER ON A BAGEL in MILLER PLACE. Thank you Better On A Bagel crew. 💗🥯🥯🥯🥯”
Bagels · $
207 Middle Country Rd, Centereach · 3.76 miles
Customers’ favorites
“If you’re from the area, you already know. And if you’re not—let me put you on. JeJoJo Bagels is THAT spot. From the second you walk in, the vibe is welcoming, warm, and just real. It’s not one of those rushed, cramped places where you grab a bagel and run. There’s actually room to sit, chat, and enjoy—like the Sunday morning ritual we all deserve. And the food? Let’s talk about it. The bagels come out warm, fluffy inside with just the right crunch on the outside—the kind that makes you close your eyes for a second on the first bite. Whether you’re a classic bacon egg and cheese lover or you go rogue with lox and scallion cream cheese, every bite hits. The crew behind the counter? Terrific people. They know their regulars, keep things moving, and still manage to smile like they’re genuinely happy to be there. That energy matters. JeJoJo’s has officially become my Sunday morning cheat meal haven. I sit, sip my coffee, tear into a hot bagel, and let the world slow down for a minute. It’s more than a bagel shop—it’s a little pocket of comfort.”
Bagels · $
1360 Lakeland Avenue, Bohemia · 4.23 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Picked up bagels to take to Ohio with me and a sandwich for lunch the day for myself. Sandwich was delicious!! The bagels were a huge hit in Ohio, the kids especially loved the French Toast Bagel.”
Bagel shop · $
15-5 Bennetts Road, Setauket- East Setauket · 8.7 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Highly recommend the catering package - made my holiday very easy and enjoyable! Ordering was easy, food was delicious, and pickup was a breeze. Everybody was very happy and not salty, greasy, or heavy!!!”
Bagels · $
331 NY-25A Suite 10, Mount Sinai · 8.3 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I've come here over a handful of times now, and have been very satisfied each time! The bagels are soft and flavorful, as well as their cream cheese. The cold salads are good too, but could maybe use a little more flavor/vegetables. Extremely friendly and attentive staff. Bagels Your Way has definitely become my new go-to bagel spot!”
Bagels · $
1941 Middle Country Rd, Centereach · 3.57 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The best place for bagels and food!!! The friendliest staff!!!!”
Deli · $
4960 Nesconset Highway, Port Jefferson Station · 7.21 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Can’t wait to go back for some more delicious menu items!”
Bagels
10 Keyland Court, Bohemia · 3.75 miles
“I lived in Sayville, not far from Always Bagels. In fact passed right by it eeveryday on my way to work and never knew it was there. Now I live in Maine and ask any New Yorker what the miss most and New York bagels will be in the top 3. Here in Bridgton ME we found my favorite pumpernickel bagel at Food City. WOW, a GREAT BAGEL!!! Shared how these bagel were as good as the best bagels I had on Long Island, NY. Complimented Food City on their Great bagels. Never thinking to look at the label...Bohemia, NY. LONG ISLAND BAGELS!!! THE BEST!!! The thing I missed most is right here in my quaint Maine town. THANK YOU ALWAYS BAGELS...YOU ARE TRULY THE BEST BAGELS!!!”
Bagels · $
145 Smithtown Blvd # 1, Nesconset · 6.08 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My family has been getting breakfast from this place ever since we’ve moved here 8 years ago and almost everything we’ve got were delicious. The bagels are soft and warm, you could choose from all different types of cream cheese and the breakfast sandwiches are amazing. I would highly recommend the Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich which is my favorite item and it’s unbelievable. I definitely recommend going here and you’ll most likely not be disappointed.”
Deli · $
2140 Pond Road, Ronkonkoma · 4.04 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Large variety of food. Great breakfast! Coffee is delish! Comfy place to eat in and watch TV during lunch. Nice people too! Give em a try !!!!”
Deli · $
85 East Main Street, Patchogue · 3.81 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best bagels in town. Baked fresh daily. Always a pleasant experience”
Bagel shop · $
217 North Main Street, Sayville · 5.57 miles
Customers’ favorites
“BEST BAGEL "DELI" IN AREA . FRESH FOOD, POLITE STAFF. LARGE VARITY OF CHICKEN SALDS PLUS BURGER PLATTERS AS WELL. FRESH MADE SALADS AND THE BEST HOME FRIES ANYWHERE !!!”
Bagels · $
187 Middle Country Road, Middle Island · 5.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This place has been around for a long time its convenient food is good for the most part employees are respectful, however there is to much talking among themselves which causes continuous asking customer of their order, you cant multi-task they should not work there, chit chat is ok with customers or employees but full blown conversation while you need to wait to be ask what you want and then ask again what you said become fustrating, for the most part I have only had good service but with that said improvement would be appreciated,”
Deli · $
350 E Main St, East Patchogue · 4.06 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My daughter recommended this place said it looked interesting. The food is unbelievably good. The bodega food is exceptional as well as the pizza that is well above most of the places in that area. Pizza in Patchogue is a little tough to find good quality. On top of that The service is fantastic always served with a smile and great attitude.”
Bagels · $
705 Medford Ave ste a, East Patchogue · 2.55 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Bagel Patch in Medford, CT, holds such a special place in my husband's heart—it's the bagel spot he grew up with, where his dad would always pick up fresh bagels on the weekends. We made sure to stop by over Easter weekend to keep the tradition alive, and it did not disappoint! The bagels were just as delicious as he remembered—fresh, perfectly chewy, and full of that classic flavor. It was such a sweet and nostalgic experience, and a reminder that sometimes the best places are the ones tied to the best memories.”
Deli · $
4540 Sunrise Hwy South Service Road, Oakdale · 5.55 miles
“Here's a review of Bagel Hero in Oakdale, NY based on My experience: Bagel Hero - A Heroic Breakfast Experience! If you're looking for a reliably good breakfast in Oakdale, Bagel Hero seems to hit the mark! You had a fantastic experience with their Hungry Man Hero, getting it just the way you like it. It's always a win when a place nails specific requests, and they clearly did with your order: toasted on both sides, perfectly runny over-easy eggs, and that extra kick of raw onions. Beyond the customized order, I highlighted a few key things that make Bagel Hero stand out. Silvia helped me, quick and easy service is a huge plus, especially when you're looking to grab a bite on the go. And knowing it's a clean place definitely adds to the appeal. It sounds like Bagel Hero earned a loyal customer with this visit! What other breakfast spots in Oakdale have you tried?”
Bagels · $
2690 NY-112, Medford · 2.47 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The employees are always delightful and willing to go above and beyond in order to satisfy our taste buds! We have been here a couple of times and our breakfast/lunch sandwiches never disappoint! I hate drinking coffee from bagel stores because it always tastes watered down but this one always exceeds my expectations, definitely a must visit!”
Bagels · $
90 Railroad Avenue Suite 107, Ronkonkoma · 3.21 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My father and I go here every other weekend when we wash clothes and it's always such a pleasure! The warm friendly and loving people behind the cover always light up and make us feel so at home. And the food!!!!! So delicious!!! The woman at the register also always writes these cute like smiley faces on our coffee lid. They're such a nice part of the community!”
Bagel shop · $
394 Sunrise Hwy South Service Road, Patchogue · 2.86 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I called to order a chicken salad wrap, not realizing they were closing within the next 15 minutes! (I only realized the closing time after placing my order over the phone and then seeing the hours online rifht afted.) I try never to do that because I've made that mistake in the past (not here; at other delis or bagel shops) and in return experienced bad customer service... again, not at Toasted Bagel, but elsewhere. I get it! People want to clean and get home. But, that wasn't the case at all here - when I called without realizing they were almost closing, the woman was still so pleasant taking my order. And when I came to pick up, it was evident they were closing up... and yet still, they were so welcoming, kind, and provided the same great customer service that I usually get when I stop in here. Not to mention my food was delicious as usual. So often we tolerate grumpy staff at other places and brush it off, but having employees who are as kind and welcoming as they are to me (and my 6 month old son) meant a lot to me. My husband has the same customer service experience when he goes in there as well. While the food is good, the quality of their kind staff is what keeps us coming back. Thank you so much!”
Bagels · $
271 Rte 25A, Mt Sinai · 8.19 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great Food, Great Service, The Staff is Great, There's Welcoming Atmosphere that is Family Oriented which is what you would expect from a Family Owned Business. They're involved with numerous Charities from coats and toys for the needy, to Cancer Research, for our Men and Women in the Armed Services. They donate to local hospitals events and fundraisers. I've tried Bagel Stores from Miller Place to Stony Brook, from Coram to Port Jeff, including other Strathmore's and by far Strathmore of Mount Sinai has been the best.”
Bagels · $
372 North Main Street, Sayville · 5.16 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I ordered egg salad, lox spread and scallion cream cheese with a dozen bagels for the office. Everything was delicious and fresh. The new owner Sabira is so friendly and really makes sure you are being taken care of. The bagel store is so clean and they are really organized. We are so happy to have such a great place for bagels in town!!”
Bagels · $
1365-1384 Rte 25A, Setauket- East Setauket · 8.19 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I’ve been getting bagels here since the early 2000s. Their bagels are my favorite, tighter and denser than a lot of other places in the area, which I prefer. Their bagel sandwiches are delicious.Coffee could be stronger and hotter though, and it’s more expensive than the competition. I remember when the bagel sandwiches were like 5+ dollars, now they’re almost 11. I realize everything in the area has gone up, though, so it is what it is.”
Bagels · $
1716 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia · 7.14 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The works bagel with garlic & herb is perfection. ❤️”
Bagels · $
4641 Sunrise Hwy, Bohemia · 5.53 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The Breakfast egg and cheese sandwich on a jalepeno bagel was really good and I came back a 2nd time before leaving New York /New Jersey”
Deli · $
159 NY-25A Suite 1, Miller Place · 9.01 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Bagel Lovers, Take Note! 🥯 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 for food. Just had an amazing takeout experience at Miller Place Bagels and Deli in Miller Place, NY. Their “Looong I-Lander” bagel---Egg Everything, bacon, egg, cheese, salt, pepper, and ketchup, the bagel was great. The owner’s friendly banter made my quick visit even better. Fast service, easy parking, and seriously tasty food. I’ll definitely be back for more! If you’re in the area and craving a real NY bagel, don’t miss this spot!”
Bagels · $
1073 Main Street, Holbrook · 1.69 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best bagels in Suffolk County! Great prices and awesome service!”
Bagels · $
852 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island · 7.18 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Just had for my first time and actually leaving a review. PHENOMENAL. BLT was gigantic and perfectly done. Salad - build your own and price can’t be beat with the freshest ingredients. Seriously top notch”