40 Best Seafood Restaurants near Mattituck

“My Wife and I live in Nesconset. We Frequent Love Lane throughout The Year. Ammiratis is a place we love ,super food , nice people. We will be back soon …..“

“Today I came to these places because a friend was invited to a wedding and I have to wait for her for several hours ?. I was hungry and I stopped by this Chinese food store. I live in Valley Stream And I have tried many Chinese food shops around NY and I can honestly say this is the best. The food was very tasty! Very well prepared, very fast service and excellent price, quantity and quality. They also have tables and they serve you directly there. I wish it was closer to my house.“

“In late June, we arrived for a late evening dinner. Other customers were finishing as we were seated. Our waitress who had an out sized personality, Sandra, greeted us warmly. It was our worry that the kitchen might be shutting down but we were assured that we could be accompanied even at the late hour. this concern was made even more complicated by my dietary restrictions that the chef met wonderfully . We enjoyed an excellent dinner, joined by our server, Sandra, who regaled us with tales of her family and the area. Sandra was a very experienced server. My wife, Denise, who was at the time undergoing chemotherapy, appreciated her warmth and sensitivity. All in all it was an excellent experience and we look forward to our next visit to Mattituck when we will certainly visit your wonderful restaurant again. Denise and John“

“Excellent casual seafood spot! Fresh, delicious and great selection! Service was excellent! Staff were outstanding! Loved this place! Well done, Jerry, Nicole et Al!!“

“The team at Cowfish went above and beyond to host our wedding. We spent the entire time completely in awe of the space and we are so grateful for the responsiveness, kindness, and care of everyone who helped make our day so special. Just stunned in the best way at the effort, details, and accommodation. It was more beautiful than we could have imagined. All of the food was delicious. We keep hearing how everyone especially loved the shrimp tempura passed app! We highly recommend going for event menu extras like oysters, clams, and other apps. The lawn space and outdoor bar area were beautiful and we were lucky to have amazing October weather on top of it. We recommend Cowfish for any event with their wonderful catering team, great food, and atmosphere!“

“If you haven't been to Captain Jack's yet... what are you waiting for?! Their food is phenomenal, everything is priced very fairly, the atmosphere is relaxing, and the service was wonderful!“

“Amazingly creative seafood and wonderful service made for a great birthday celebration! The lobster and shrimp shepherd’s pie was spectacular! This restaurant is outstanding!“

“Great place for a delicious steak.“

“Had the pleasure of eating at the Greenport location. Two of my HS girlfriends and myself on moderately busy on Sunday (1012/24) at about 5:30. A young waiter named Brian was our server. We first ordered drinks, mine was the margarita with the pomegranate swirl. So delicious!! Refreshing and frosty! We shared the Mexican Street corn and the three dips with chips, which were freshly made. So fabulous! So tasty. The salsa, guacamole and queso were just perfect, each different but delicious!! The corn was sweet and flavorful. I had three tacos in hard shells. Fried chicken, fried shrimp and the marinated steak. Each one was different and very fresh. My one friend, is a vegetarian and the other is gluten intolerant BUT! They each found many yummy choices! I’ve been trying to get to this restaurant for several years, and finally the planets aligned! Brian was well trained, patient and informative with a good humor. The interior is bright, festive and clean. So much food, I could not finish all of it. And!! the restroom was clean! You should be very proud of this business! We will be back! Thank you!!“

“Wow, for us to be seated party of four, to be expected on a Sunday afternoon. Ordered the swordfish and it was very good. Ordered the Keylime pie for dessert and it was not quite up to my expectations. Very creamy, but I am taste was lacking and the crust was a little overcooked that the experience was very good. I get back into the neighborhood I will stop again.“

“I want to rate this 3 stars out of 5. The food is amazing but customer service not that great. My family was in from out of state and wanted to get take out and I instantly thought about this place. my fiance got the food and came home and my order was missing the cheese on the burger. So, I unfortunately couldn't eat with my family and neither did my fiance because he had to eat his food while driving 20 minutes back to get my food fixed at the restaurant and then 20 minutes back. However, I would still recommend you guys to other people. I would just suggest checking your order before leaving“

“East End Clambake catered my daughter’s and my mother’s joint birthday party in my backyard in July. I cannot describe how amazing and wonderful they were every step of the way. We ended up renting chairs and tables as well as went with the The East End Lobster Bake package, with fried chicken (the only catered who offered this as an addition to lobster!) Patricia coordinated everything and really made it so very easy. I can’t remember the two women who came to the event along with the chef but they really out themselves, our 60 guests were truly delighted and the food was incredible. No one left hungry, that is for sure!!!! They really know how to run a smooth operation and all of the staff were so lovely to work with. They are absolutely the best!!!!“

“Great food and Views!! Always fun to sit at the bar before dinner!!“

“The bartender Shawn was the best. Such a hustling guy he was able to handle the entire bar on his own and it was full. I will go back when I'm in town. The folks next to me had chicken sandwiches, one grilled and one fried. They said they were excellent. A nice spot on the water, but unfortunately it was raining otherwise deck seating would be awesome.“

“The food was very delicious!! The view was absolutely beautiful too! Also, the staff are very friendly. It was very windy that night and a staff member brought out a blanket for me as she saw I was cold. Highly recommend!“

“The food is excellent! The rum punch is to die for! The ambiance is great“

“If I need to buy some fresh seafood 🦞 this is only place I go if I am working in that area Always fresh“

“Lobster roll was so fresh and delicious.“

“Great day in Riverhead we stopped in for lunch. Very cool place the bartender was so nice“

“The food is wonderful here!“

“Great food and atmosphere“

“Food is fabulous. Anyone with a gluten allergy or sensitivity this is your place. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable and I love the atmosphere. Can’t wait for our next visit.“

“May 30, 2024. I had a delicious prime rib dinner at lunch. It is so hard these days to. find one that is tender and juicy but this fit the bill. Friendly staff and friendly patrons.“

“Rooms are immaculate and kept up every day. I stay here for business and will only stay here now.“

“awesome atmosphere, awesome owner, awesome menu!“

“great seafood always fresh caught“

“enjoyed a delicious dinner, great service by Sandra but did not like the staffs attire. Felt like I was in a barn or stable“

“Great place for a delicious steak.“

“Good times always! Great atmosphere! ⚓️“

“Food was good. The host was great and so was the waitress.“

“Wonderful place to eat off the beaten path. The food was delicious. And the server was friendly and helpful when deciding what to order. He recommended the proper portions for sharing instead of maximizing the bill and his tip. The water views were spectacular. And the atmosphere was relaxed. I would certainly going there again.“

“Always great food, service and atmosphere!“

“The food is amazing and the staff is incredible. We had a blast there last evening. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Great service and live music“

“Great food service & amazing Dirty martinis!!!“

“Really Italian food! Homemade pasta! U should go ❤️“

“Looking for a good meal at a reasonable price in Southampton? Wait no longer!! This is primarily a fish market, but they have a take-out kitchen that prepares all sorts of great meals. The fish and chips (house made chips, not fries) with Cole slaw was a steal at its price as were the clam strips. A full range of typical fried/broiled seafood items are also available. The fresh fish looks great and they have enough grocery items so a quick seafood dinner can be made with the fish you just bought, as well a sauces and chowders. Has moved to the top of my list for places not to miss in town.“

“Good times always! Great atmosphere! ⚓️“

“It’s outdated, the food isn’t high quality, but it’s a Southampton institution. That being said, my husband and I went on a date night we’re we ordered one slice of pizza from 10 places from Wainscott to Hampton bays and Paul’s had the best slice. A bottle of Caesar dressing is always in the fridge. Don’t come here expecting much from the regular menu, and staff is always rotating so service is iffy. Stick with the pizza and you won’t be disappointed“