23 Best Sandwich Shops near New City

“I showed up here late at night 30 mins before closing. And before i went in i said awe these guys are probably going to be cleaning up and all mad that i comin in so late. But i walked in and a guy made me one of the best subway sandwiches i had ever had. And i know hes just pitting ingredients in there but it was the way he folded it. They always fold it wrong. They always put the meats in the center instead of on the side and it doesnt make it like a porportioned sandwich. But this guy placed those ingredients perfectly onto that bun. And he smiled and joked with me as he made the sandwich. And he deserves a raise if not 2. Go hit subway night shift on thursday at this location. My boy will hook you up“

“I recently discovered Benny's and a bit depressed I was late to the game. A great sandwich shop. To date I have had the Chilii Turkey, Thai Fried Chicken, and the Chimi Chimi Roast Beef. All are excellent. The Thai Fried Chicken would be best when you can sit down and enjoy it. Cool chip selection and beverages. Counter folks are super friendly as well. Sandwiches are like $15 but are built to share. Great place I will frequently visit now.“

“The best food I've ever had.“

“We visited the Nanuet NY location on Saturday 11/19/22. We were helped by both Anthony & Darryl. I would really like to extend a thank you to both those gentlemen on such wonderful service. We stopped in quick to order 4 sandwiches then visit with family, we had just driven about 2.5 hrs prior to coming into the store so where pretty cranky. The store was packed and these 2, as well as the other 3 team members, serviced everyone with smiles and thank yous. We walked out with smiles on our faces laughing. Please take a moment to recognize these 2 for incredible service. I did sent this to the corporate office as well, I do hope these 2 gentlemen are singled out for going above and beyond.“

“3/23 another delicious dinner from Ikes! chicken parm sandwich. plenty for the two of us. Everything from salads, wings, sandwiches are delicious! service is fast and friendly. recently I have had delivery and the food arrived fast and hot. The hot roast beef sandwich is sooooo good!“

“We where visiting the area from Tampa FL and wanted some good sandwiches and came across them searching online. It was worth it. Ordering system with touchscreen super user friendly and easy to pay without human interaction. Sandwiches and burgers made fast and exactly as ordered. Fries were steamy and crispy. Clean friendly environment.“

“This is the best subway store I’ve ever been to! It has everything you want as a customer: delicious and fresh food, very clean, and VERY friendly and professional staff. They inform you of meal deals, so you pay less and get more. 10/10 highly recommend supporting this business!“

“This was quite literally the best sandwich, I've ever had. Period. EXAGGERATING??? TRY IT YOURSELF. THE BRISKET CAROLINA. The brisket is wonderfully tender, flavor packed slaw, and sweet on the tongue bbq. I will stop in here every time I pass by.“

“great sandwiches terrific people who there and Frankie...!!“

“Clean Sandwich made fresh to order Staff was helpful, polite and friendly Delicious sandwich“

“great service. awesome chicken cheese steak 😊😊😊😊“

“I was on and out of town visit when I dropped by the store. The sandwich I usually get consists of vegetables only: spinach, cucumber, tomatoes, olives and banana peppers. Many stores act as if the spinach is just a topping rather than the base of the sandwich. This shop made the sandwich nicely. I had no complaints. They staff was also very patient while I signed into the subway app as I had forgotten my password and it took more time than usual. Overall, it was a very pleasant experience.“

“I can’t say enough good things about Primo Hoagies! The sandwiches are always fresh, generously filled, and packed with flavor. The rolls are perfectly crusty on the outside and soft on the inside you can tell they use quality ingredients. My go-to is the ham salami and provolone but honestly, you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu.
The staff is friendly, quick, and always gets the order right, even when it’s busy. You can tell they take pride in what they do. Whether you’re grabbing lunch on the go or catering for a crowd, Primo Hoagies never disappoints. Highly recommend!“

“The manager and crew are so welcoming, polite and friendly. Sandwiches were delicious!! The place itself was immaculate. Will definitely be coming back. My first Jersey Mike’s experience was in Nanuet and because of the rude manager I would rather drive further to Stonypoint where the energy is positive.“

“I got there just as they were about to close and they still made me a hot lunch, that alone would have been worth 5 stars to me. But wow that was the best chicken parm hero Iv had in Rockland in the 5 years Iv been working down here. Thank you!“

“I think this place is the only cleanest restaurant in rockland county. Every time I visit, the place is spotless and I appreciate the employees ALWAYS switching out their gloves after EACH customer AND transaction. The employees are also very quick and nice.“

“I order Buffalo wings and they never put any sauce on them just dry wings fix your wings cheapskates“

“Very good, excellent sandwich 🥪...“

“I got a sub there yesterday afternoon and I swear the kid made it in literally a minute and it was great.“

“Always sliced fresh. Toppings piled high. Attentive service. Better than the other sub chain stores.“

“I’m visiting from VT and I kept hearing about how VT doesn’t know how to make bagels. These are AMAZING!!! And the variety of the cream cheese are out of this world! We went back twice. I highly recommend.“

“The food is So So good! The Teas are exquisite! The atmosphere is so warm and charming! The owner is so humble and gracious! The staff is so kind and attentive! I visit Kathleen's Tea Room whenever I am in Peekskill. I Highly recommend this establishment!“