36 Best Pizza Restaurants near Pennellville

“Great food! Excellent Baked Goods! Clean, orderly and fast excellent service from a very friendly owner! Love the decor! 46 years in business, so they have to be doing something right!“

“Highlights: 1st friendly staff !! 2nd watching the workers hustle!! They we all very attentive including the dishwasher. 3rd my order was read back to me. 4th watching a worker walk through the dining area asking each table if everything was to our likings. 5th OUR FOOD WAS AMAZING!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🍕“

“This was my first time ordering here & I am amazed by how nice the young man was that delivered our dinner. I’m not big on pizza - (I did take a bite of the kids & actually liked it) I ordered an antipasto with onions for myself and it was bigger and better than expected. Joe called to let me know that he forgot the onions ( I didn’t even realize 😂 it was so so good) & refunded the $1. We found our new favorite pizza place & can not wait to try the wings!!!!“

“We stopped for lunch as we were traveling through otw to Canada. This pizza is amazing!!! Highly recommend!“

“We just left Akropolis and the Gyros were amazing 👏 The lamb meat was so fresh, tasty, and tender. I am assuming the owners, they were the nicest people ever. Also, the restaurant was extremely clean! Thanks for meal ❤️❤️“

“Their pizza is one of the best in the area. The crust is so good I never leave any of it..Their wing are great as well. This is only our second time ordering but we are looking forward to exploring more of their menu. Definitely worth every penny and the service is fast and friendly.“

“The staff were great, they went out of their way to make sure my nieces birthday was special. Highly recommend them! Desi the owner was awesome!“

“Great pizza, wings and great service!“

“Great, friendly service. Excellent food stopped there almost every time I go that way I just don’t go that way that much.“

“Awesome Awesome Awesome Customer Service and great food! First time trying Luna Pizza! It was delicious!“

“I’ve been a loyal customer of Independent for several years, ordering for both parties and the occasional pizza night. I’ve tried many other places in the area, but nothing compares. The team consistently goes above and beyond, especially when I call to pre-order before opening hours, they always make it work. The pizza is, without a doubt, some of the best in the area. Prices are fair and reasonable, unlike many other places, and the staff and delivery drivers are always friendly and professional. I highly recommend them and will continue to be a regular customer.“

“I go out of my way to shop here and fuel up. The employees and owner are very friendly and helpful. They have just about everything that you may have forgotten to buy at the grocery store. Prices are reasonable and gas prices are comparable with the big chains.“

“My wife and I use to eat here a lot when we lived in Baldwinsville, NY. My wife has been eating cheese pizza with medium wing sauce on the side here since she was 14. Wings were perfectly cooked! Crispy but not too well done. The service is excellent. Everyone is friendly and helpful. I’ve never had a bad experience. It could use a deep cleaning in the dine in area. When ordering takeout in bville, Gino and joes will always be my first choice.“

“love their pizza. great staff and very kind, great customer service. the best fish. I have tried Atlantic, fish cove, and even the new place in big m mall no place beats twin trees fish for me“

“THE BEST !!!!! You bro hit me up !!!!“

“The pizza was good however I ordered garlic knots and there was no flavor to them whatsoever and were pretty dry. I ordered 10 knots and only ate one then threw the rest in the garbage since no one else in my family wanted to eat them. The mozzarella were nothing great and were somewhat soggy, it was giving they were heated up in the microwave.“

“The pizza is great but there’s this guy Mike there that I just go to stare at. He’s fine af.“

“We chose this restaurant to celebrate after our courthouse wedding, and it honestly couldn’t have been more perfect. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt special welcoming, and just the right place to soak in such an important day. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel celebrated without being over the top. Everyone was kind, attentive, and genuinely happy for us, which made the experience even more meaningful. The food was incredible as always. It felt like the perfect way to mark the start of our new chapter together. This will always be a special place for us. We come here for trivia and have built great relationships with the staff. We’re so grateful we chose to celebrate here and will definitely be back for anniversaries to come. Cecelia and Kevin Roskopf“

“This place is amazing, highly recommend, A+ for everything 🥰💕“

“We frequently get the Garlic Pizza for the office. Always a big hit!“

“Bryce, the district manager made this experience phenomenal! Had placed an order online for this location through google maps and the online order went to Liverpools. Upon being informed at this location, Bryce overheard and stepped up to personally take care of the issue by canceling, reordering and fastracking my order for a quick, satisfying experience. Highly recommend Bryce and his team they all did an amazing job. 🤙🏼🏆👏🏼“

“Crispy crust yet just the right thickness and soft in the middle. Really great pizza. First time we had it. The buffalo chicken wings were absolutely perfect too. Great service and they brought these great big delicious garlic rolls out at the beginning lol. We left stuffed and happy with leftovers for tomorrow. Thank you.“

“Food was great, will be back!“

“Such a great place! The owner is a really great guy and so helpful to all his customers! A great warm inviting place to enjoy family and friends ! Food is fantastic!“

“The service was incredible, the food was delicious, the atmosphere was ethereal, our server was both caring and hilarious, the owner actually came out to make sure everything was too our liking, and the prices were unbelievably low. I couldn’t recommend it more. Did I mention how great the food was?“

“I haven't been able to get here in a while. I don't know who the cook is, she was not here the last time i was here. But today August 21, 2022, i just had one of the best breakfasts i have ev“

“Lock One Distillery in Phoenix, NY was an amazing experience, the service was excellent and they even gave us a nice Christmas gift and let us sample anything we wanted to try. We went for their Monday wing night, and the 50-cent wings were delicious!!! The drinks were also 10/10, our favorites were the butter beer and the Four sons toasted coconut, we will be back to try more things we were recommended.

Huge shoutout to Jim, who was incredibly friendly and took great care of us. He really made the experience even better. We’ll definitely be back and highly recommend checking this place out!“

“🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 5-Star Experience! A massive thank you to Average Joe's Beernasium for making our surprise Bachelorette Party truly unforgettable! From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was electric. Food: Absolutely delicious and budget-friendly! Every bite was a delight. Drinks: Crafted to perfection—each one better than the last. Live Band: Phenomenal performance that had us dancing non-stop for three hours! It felt like we were reliving our college days. We genuinely didn't want the night to end. The combination of great food, fantastic music, and an incredible atmosphere made it a night to remember. We'll definitely be returning—for the vibes, the tunes, and especially the food. Already planning our next pizza night with takeout from here!“

“Had Sandy as our waitress today ! Only waitress there and she was amazing. She works harder than any one I’ve seen and she’s 74! Shoutout to sandy at the Cicero Pizza Hut!!“

“Domino’s Pizza is a familiar go‑to for delivery when you want something quick and satisfying without spending a lot. The ordering process was straightforward and the delivery arrived within the estimated window. The pizza itself was decent — the crust was crisp at the edges and toppings were generous for the price point — but it didn’t quite stand out compared to other local pizza places I’ve tried. Some slices were a bit unevenly cooked, and the sauce could have had more seasoning.“

“Reds Palermo market, on the past you could go rent your favorite movie from the Reds Video and get a pizza and wings from the market. Well now there's no videos for rent but they still have pizza, wings, Gas, Beer, Cigarettes. All the small things as a quick stop convenience store. May God Bless You and keep you in his loving Grace..“

“Got a chance to order today after waiting a bit after they first opened ,and was not disappointed, pizza was great , definitely will be ordering again“

“This place hits the spot every time. Honestly I’m a tough critic but I’ve never had bad pizza or wings here. We go to this location specifically because of the quality of their chicken wings, as most other pizza places are skimping out with cheap chicken that tastes horrible. This place does not sacrifice quality for cost, and you get what you pay for. Pizza and wings are fresh and great, quick and friendly service and always craving this place. Thank you!“

“Wow! The Chicken Riggies were incredible- I did order standard and they had the perfect kick. Had plenty of chicken and slivers of cherry peppers- loved this. Thank you for a delicious dinner that was also my lunch. Thank you, chef. I’ll be back and will order these again next time. Recommended, great service at the bar- the Genny Citrus Pils was also perfection.“