50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Rye Brook

“Amazing, great tasting food....restaurant quality! Ordered catering for our Easter celebration and everything from BelleFair Kitchen was just perfect! Easy to order, great delivery service and again delicious food! Will definitely use again and highly recommend!“

“All the stuff is nice and friendly“

“I’ve been there 5 times. Never had a bad experience. The food is amazing, the staff is friendly and price is reasonable. Perfect match! My favorite restaurant in Westchester.“

“Good food good service. I will definitely visit again.“

“5 Stars - Highly recommend.“

“The first pie I had from John at Fenice was the Detroit Red...which Tony picked up for me last week when i was at work...i finished the whole pie by just after midnight...but I had to go for the regular NY Cheese pie fresh from the oven. We scored one of the two tables there and were able to decide which of the other slices to bring home...it was like a pizza candy store. We didn't finish our pie so brought home two slices, and I wanted to try John's sicilian, I couldn't leave there without a Detroit Red slice and Tony wanted the multi cheese white pizza...every pizza we tried was perfect! something about the dough. The sauce. The cheese. The dough for the Sicilian and the Detroit Red was light and perfectly crunchy on the bottom. Flavor out of this world. We drove from White Plains just to try Pizza Fenice. worth the trip.“

“Mario's Metro Pizza is hands down the best pizzaria in New Rochelle; and I have tried them all as a New Ro long time resident. I am a pizza aficionado and their pizza has only the top ingredient. Their cheese and sauce is amazing.
Also, the owner is incredibly welcoming and kind. This guy is 1st class.
I highly recommend you give this pizzaria a try.“

“Food is number one but engaged and present owners set the tone in this buzzing north stamford market/deli. Fresh, generous, creative sandwiches, cool specials and the secret weapon is top notch pizza. The cha cha cha breakfast burrito might just be the morning winner too. Keep it up guys and we will remain regulars!“

“Great NY Pizza. We have fresh pie, Excellent“

“Fantastic pizza! Super-friendly staff. Only complaint, music way too loud.“

“Nice little place. Pizza and Calzone both were very good“

“GET THE KALE CEASAR SALAD!!! I love their pizza but I go for the salad. This restaurant has such a great atmosphere and their menu is very accommodating. Everything on the menu is delicious and if you are strong enough to leave room for dessert, you will be extremely happy. Their cookie and their brownie come in a cast iron skillet and tase homemade and the ice cream and whipped cream make it even more delicious.“

“My go to spot fresh delish and hot“

“Absolutely loved our experience here tonight! I am unsure of the hostesses name but she was a doll and clearly had everything running so smoothly. As walk-ins we were even able to pick where we wanted to sit. Juan was our waiter who was such a gem, so attentive but also did not rush us at all. We got the baked clams, veal Marsala and the gnocchi special which were excellent. The manager also came over to say hello which felt very personable. We can’t wait to come back!“

“We visited Luca’s Pizza for the second time today, and once again everything was amazing. Both times we ordered a large pizza and pasta, and the pasta was perfectly al dente each visit.

This time we also tried a cannoli that was filled fresh to order, and it was phenomenal. The staff is incredibly professional while still making the experience feel warm and personal. You can tell they truly care about their food and their customers. We will definitely be back in the summer for the tiramisu!“

“Great meal tonight, pizza was perfect…. Wings were tasty !!“

“Without a doubt, NY Pizza Co. is the best pizzeria in Harrison. The pizza is always fresh, with a crispy authentic New York–style crust and a delicious flavorful sauce. The service is outstanding, the staff is friendly, and the atmosphere makes you feel at home. Every time I visit, the food exceeds my expectations. I highly recommend their pizzas, pasta, and wings. If you’re in Harrison and want real New York–style pizza, this is the place to go.”“

“Food was delicious!! highly recommend!!“

“awesome food,great portions and prices wonderful owners go there you wont regret it“

“Silvio’s did a wonderful job feeding my wife’s family for her 80th birthday. Thank you for everything. All her cousins, sisters, brother, son, granddaughter and spouses had plenty to say about the food - All pleased. The servers were great. Everyone was so responsive to our needs. The cake from Artuso was great and we had plenty for the next day. I’ve been sweating this birthday for the last year snd you did not let me down!“

“Stopped in there with 8 wild kids and the staff was so gracious and kind and helpful to all of us. The pizza came out fast and let me tell you that was one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. Kids were armwrestling for the last slice. We will go back soon even though we don't live close. Go there or order out, you won't be disappointed

Kid-friendliness: We took up every chair in the restaurant, we were even offered to put all tables together. Our kids were loud and annoying, whiny and hungry and yet the staff was so nice!“

“One of the best pizzerias in all of Westchester County you will not be disappointed all of the flavors of every item on the menu will melt in your mouth. Great job guys. I would recommend seeing this place.“

“I've been seeing the really good food posted on Social Media and finally made the 5 minute trek. I have to say the calzones and pizza were excellent! The calzones are enormous. Where looking forward to trying something different next time, and next time will be soon! ��“

“awesome pizza, awesome crew“

“Great place, great people, great food!“

“Pizza was delicious! Pie size is great for just one person, and fries were great too! This is my first time trying this pizza shop and never knew this pizza joint even existed, now this will definitely be the spot to order some delicious pizza🍕😋😁“

“Just had a Christmas Party catered by Zody’s Mike and his staff did an incredible job in the food preparation and delivery Everyone raved about the quality of the food Was asked many times about the caterer’s Thanks Mike and all of your dedicated staff Happy Holidays to all Joe Conetta“

“Believe the hype! This place is the real deal. Pizza is crazy flavorful with perfectly cooked crust. No floppy nonsense. Owner is cool and makes a great pie. Worth driving to. If you live close by, you're blessed! This🍕🍕🍕 is🔥🔥🔥!!!“

“Picked up a nice pep pie and garlic knots today and wasn't disappointed!“

“I've had pizza all over, and in my opinion no one makes a more delicious plain cheese pie than Pleasantville Pizza.“

“Great pizza,great service friendly staff👍“

“On the recommendation of my son-in-law, a chef, I ordered pizza and appetizers for my party, and I was so thrilled with everything. I placed the order with the owner Benny, and he worked with me to place a perfect order. Thank you so much for everything! Lorraine Rufo“

“Great NY pizza with lots or little add ons.“

“Love Riko’s! Nice Atmosphere, Delicious Food The Best Thin Crust Pizza, Outstanding Appetizers, Full Bar With Specialties Drinks & Healthy Salads! Desserts Straight From Italy!“

“Ordered(takeout) a plain cheese and a side of house salad just to try them out. Pizza came out well and salad was of good quality greens. I will be going back and dine-in to try fresh out of the oven pizza next time.
(Newer posting Dec. 2025)
This time, I took my family of 6 to dine in at the place. As soon as we walked in, a middle age looking female staff or the owner(I’m not sure) started directing me where to sit & calling me “Hey buddy!…)
To me this is not acceptable but I decided to ignore it as we were in a holiday mood. She took our order and forgot a couple of our drinks. As we waited and waited.. finally we flagged her over to ask about our drinks. That’s when she brought the drinks over, no apologies. By this time our holiday spirits begin to wind down. The place is small and there weren’t that many people inside as there were a lot more people picking up their foods. She never came back to check on us during our time. I know that we weren’t eating at a fancy 4 star restaurant but eating pizza and salads but we felt pretty disappointed for their dine in experience and for that I am taking off 2 stars each in service and the atmosphere.“

“I had a cobb wrap and I haven't had a big delicious, fresh sandwich like it in a LONG time! This place is a bit more $$ but worth it considering the quality you get! Heck you could eat half and save half and that's your savings right there! I DON'T work there either!
I just wanted to go outta my way to write reviews when these quality places exit to get the word out. Good lunch sandwich, that's all I know.“

“My coworkers and I always get a large hot honey old fashioned pizza with hot peppers and hot honey and they always do an amazing job. They also make a great penne alla vodka , amazing garlic bread etc , at Micheal’s they cater to your preferences. I don’t eat pork or beef and they have always gone that extra mile to make sure im covered. If it’s from Micheal’s I’m sure it’s good! Def 10/10! The food is great and so is the service ! They are the best!“

“First time to try Papa G's and very pleased. Great pepperoni pizza (crust not too thick or too thin) and cheese sticks (excellent cheese!) We'll be back when we're in the area. 😎“

“Stamford Hospital crew orders from here all the time and food is always great. Today besides sending amazing food these guys helped with our tiny budget and feed ICU staff. THANK YOU Arcuris and Jammie for stepping up in such a difficult time for all of us ❤❤❤“

“Su personal es Muy amable la pizza 🍕 es deliciosa!!!“

“fast and friendly service“

“Greatest pizza by far in the Stamford region! I see A lot of complaints about rudeness! closest thing to NY Pizza and service! great food great people. Miss the cute Pizza Girl though she always made me smile! once again Good Food the margarita pizza my fav and the chicken salad LOVE IT!“

“Absolutely delicious…. We loved everything we ordered. The Angry Pie takes pizza to the next level.“

“the atmosphere was amazing, the staff was pleasant and very personable, the food was delicious and desert the chocolate bomb I believe that's the name was the perfect ending to a wonderful service also the waitress helped me pick out a non-alcoholic drink cucumber something I'm horrible with names that's why I haven't mentioned theirs because they definitely gave it I'm just horrible with remembering anyway....if you're in Stamford area go there you'll meet them tell them Emma sent you you won't regret it I live in New Jersey and will go back“

“Nice people and nice food“

“Delicious large cheese pizza with sausage. Moist, fresh , and delicious . Happy I tried your pizza. Will definitely reorder. Best wishes in your new place.“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“We ordered a custom pizza with less cheese and extra crispy crust and it was made to absolute perfection. The balance of flavors was spot-on and the crispy texture gave it that satisfying crunch with every bite. It's clear they paid attention to the details of our order. One of the best custom pizzas we’ve had in a long time.“

“When there last year, the manicotti was great.“

“Italian Pavilion Pizzeria is the best place in White Plains for a sausage calzone. The calzone was tender, savory, meaty, and perfectly spiced. The Italian sausage was cooked to perfection, the mozzarella had the ideal gooey stretch, and the crust was crispy with just the right bake time. The marinara sauce added great flavor. The staff were clean, orderly, and very helpful. Also an excellent spot for pizza and pasta. Spacious restaurant with plenty of room for large parties and conveniently located near stores.“